6 ms·
Sugar reduction: from evidence into action
- awjr 11y ago"Actions to take" section: 1. Reduce and rebalance the number and type of price promotions in all retail outlets including supermarkets and convenience stores and the out of home sector (including restaurants, cafes and takeaways) 2. Significantly reduce opportunities to market and advertise high sugar food and drink products to children and adults across all media including digital platforms and through sponsorship 3. The setting of a clear definition for high sugar foods to aid with actions 1 and 2 above. Currently the only regulatory framework for doing this is via the Ofcom nutrient profiling model, which would benefit from being reviewed and strengthened 4. Introduction of a broad, structured and transparently monitored programme of gradual sugar reduction in everyday food and drink products, combined with reductions in portion size 5. Introduction of a price increase of a minimum of 10-20% on high sugar products through the use of a tax or levy such as on full sugar soft drinks, based on the emerging evidence of the impact of such measures in other countries 6. Adopt, implement and monitor the government buying standards for food and catering services (GBSF) across the public sector, including national and local government and the NHS to ensure provision and sale of healthier food and drinks in hospitals, leisure centres etc 7. Ensure that accredited training in diet and health is routinely delivered to all of those who have opportunities to influence food choices in the catering, fitness and leisure sectors and others within local authorities 8. Continue to raise awareness of concerns around sugar levels in the diet to the public as well as health professionals, employers, the food industry etc, encourage action to reduce intakes and provide practical steps to help people lower their own and their families sugar intake
- awjr 11y agoA "sugar tax" is not a bad idea if it is ringfenced to creating a healthier environment and funding NHS obesity-related treatments. The problem is that this type of tax will be subsumed within general taxation.
- puttyaccount 11y agowhat about a "healthy food tax" ringfenced for funding the costs of end of life care for people with longer life expectancy??
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- sdoering 11y ago<sarcasm>Isn't this a very cynical pov? On the same grounds I could argue for trolls to be euthanized instead of feed. </sarcasm>
- belorn 11y agoYes, Minister made a similar joke that people who died from smoking tobacco are doing society a favor by limiting the need to spend money on elderly care and pensions.
- stevetrewick 11y agoExcept it's not a joke, it's probably true [0] : Research by the Institute of Economic Affairs argues that a tax on fatty food could actually increase the burden on the health system and unfairly penalise the poor. Dr Barrie Craven from the Department for Education at the University of Newcastle, who co-wrote the IEA report, said: "It is commonly assumed that obese people are a disproportionate burden on the NHS. "By 56, the obese are the most expensive but not over their lifetime. "We have to remember that the obese and smokers tend to die earlier and the healthy incur very expensive 24 hour care later in life for diseases such as dementia." [0] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/9359212/Obese-and-smokers-less-of-a-burden-on-the-NHS-than-the-healthy-who-live-longer-report.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/9359212/Obese-an...
- pm215 11y agoWhy do you think it is important that the use of the tax be ringfenced? My view would be that the aim of the tax would be to nudge people into changing their behaviours, and it will do this whether the resulting income goes into funding obesity related treatments or just into the general taxation pot. Also, hypothecation doesn't really seem to me to rise above the level of a PR labelling exercise -- if sugar tax income is all spent on NHS obesity programmes, then the government will simply reduce the amount of NHS funding from the general pot correspondingly. Further, you get awkward effects if peoples' behaviour really does change where obesity programmes could end up underfunded because the sugar tax income falls. Better to just fund them to the right level from the general pot, I think.
- stevetrewick 11y agoI'm not in favour of such a tax, but even if I were I would object to much of that. 1 through 4 and 6 through 8 fall somewhere on a spectrum from redundant to positively Orwellian.
- jbob2000 11y agoWhat the hell? Educating people on healthy eating is Orwellian? How...
- stevetrewick 11y agoIt isn't. Manipulating 60+ million people's choice architecture (as per e.g. 7) on the other hand certainly is. YMMV but either way it's still redundant if adding a tax as a market correction functions as expected. If it doesn't, there isn't a market solution so the tax is redundant. And if there turns out to be no negative externalities as per the IEA, then the whole thing is just one big Orwellian exercise in public health authoritarianism. But don't concern yourself, it's for your own good and won't someone think of the children ?
- puttyaccount 11y agoNote that sugar consumption has been falling since the 1970s in the UK. Strangely this "evidence" is not mentioned.
- awjr 11y agoNote that our environment has changed significantly since the 1970s, with a propensity for many people to go from A to B by car and generally exercise less. I see a sugar tax as a way of creating a fund to enable councils to implement healthy travel options (protected cycle to school networks, discounted public transport, public transport networks) and mitigate the cost of obesity-related diseases to the NHS.
- elthran 11y agoExcept it won't - it will end up in the general taxation pool, and spent on anything, including foreign aid, unemployment, defense
- SmellyGeekBoy 11y agoGod forbid we get healthier as a nation and help those less fortunate than us at the same time!
- puttyaccount 11y agowhy introduce a financial penalty on sugar consumption itself if it is not a major factor in rising obesity and other health problems?
- 7952 11y agoI agree that this would be a good use of new funds. But perhaps a deeper problem is that these areas are so underfunded as it is. We treat road transport as "essential infrastructure" whilst provision for healthy options are treated as an expensive luxury.
- mseebach 11y agoPublic transport isn't a "healthy travel option". This just goes to support the worry of another commenter that this will just go into the general taxation pool to support various programs that may or may not have anything to do with sugar and/or health.
- ectoplasm 11y agoWe stopped buying raw sugar as well as things with added sugar at the grocery store. We also stopped buying juice and obvious junk food like potato chips. We still buy whole milk and bacon and cheese and pasta. It was hard at first, but we still have sugar in various forms around the home to use on occasion. We're buying more fruit now too, but eat less than it takes to make the juice we eliminated. We're losing about one pound per week, with no change in activity levels. So that's crudely about 500 calories per day, each. We have sweet things for social reasons, or to celebrate. The trick is just to avoid buying them so you can't eat them when you get hungry. Once we get down to our target weights I imagine we'll buy more. It's really quite shocking when you stop buying sugar, just how many of your usual purchases you end up putting back on the shelf.
- awjr 11y agoSugar is an odd substance. It's made up of glucose and fructose. Glucose tells your body to store fat and "use me" while your liver is converting the fructose to fat.
- david-given 11y agoAt least where I come from, domestic use sugar is almost entirely sucrose. Glucose and fructose are available but they're very much specialist products (for baking, jam-making, etc). They're certainly not something you put into tea.
- awjr 11y agoSucrose breaks down into glucose and fructose. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sucrose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sucrose
- yvdriess 11y agosucrose is an 50/50 glucose/fructose combination: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sucrose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sucrose But yeah, it's all sucrose except for 'dextro energy' (glucose==grape sugar) or baking.
- 11y ago
- gabemart 11y ago> The Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition (SACN) > has concluded that the recommended average population > maximum intake of sugar should be halved: it should > not exceed 5% of total dietary energy. If we say that an average man has nutritional requirements of 2500kcal per day, then these recommendations imply he should not consume more than 125kcal of sugar per day, which is 31.25 grams of sugar. A ~350ml can of Coke contains 39 grams of sugar [1]. A ~600ml 'Vitamin water' drink has 31 grams of sugar. A single McDonalds 'McFlurry' dessert has 64 grams of sugar [2]. Even something 'healthy' like a 250ml 'pomegranates, blueberries & acai' smoothie from 'innocent drinks' has 35 grams of sugar [4]. I guess my point is that we want people to reduce their sugar intake to recommended levels, there needs to be a sea change in what's seen as a normal diet. No one thinks that a 'McFlurry' is a health food, but in my experience they're not seen as a huge indulgence, despite being more than two-days worth of sugar-allowance for an average man, and more for an average woman. [1] http://www.coca-colaproductfacts.com/en/coca-cola-products/coca-cola/ [2] http://www.mcdonalds.com/us/en/food/product_nutrition.dessertsshakes.3832.mcflurry-with-oreo-cookies-12-fl-oz-cup.html [3] http://vitaminwater.com/files/vitaminwater_2014_NutritionFacts.pdf [4] https://www.innocentdrinks.co.uk/things-we-make/our-smoothies/smoothies/pomegranates-blueberries-acai
- IanCal 11y agoIs that total sugar or "added/free" sugar? Because for a 2000kcal diet, that'd be about 100kcal of sugar or ~25 grams. That's equivalent to a single NLEA serving of apple. https://www.nutritionix.com/i/usda/apple-1-nlea-serving/513fceb475b8dbbc21000f8f https://www.nutritionix.com/i/usda/apple-1-nlea-serving/513f...
- yummyfajitas 11y agoThey should probably just copy whatever we've been doing in the US. Our sugar consumption has been falling since the late 90's. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CUsIUgdVAAA-pu3.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CUsIUgdVAAA-pu3.jpg (Obesity has continually increased, however.)
- xentronium 11y agoDoes that chart include the corn syrup and other substitutes?
- yummyfajitas 11y agoYes. Jozan also just posted a link to a more detailed breakdown: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/39/US_Sweetener_consumption%2C_1966_to_2013.svg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/39/US_Sweet...
- jozan 11y agoHFCS article [0] on Wikipedia has a bit more detailed graph [0] about sugar usage in comparison with other sweeteners (high fructose corn syrup etc.) in the US. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_fructose_corn_syrup https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_fructose_corn_syrup [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/39/US_Sweetener_consumption%2C_1966_to_2013.svg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/39/US_Sweet...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- yvdriess 11y agoAverage consumption at least. It's still the poorer layers of society who suffer the most obesity problems, so it would be interesting to see a graph of their average consumption. The highly-refined super-sugary foods are typically the cheap stuff, so intuitively a sugar-tax and advertising ban should help target those most vulnerable to obesity.
- odiroot 11y ago
- duncan_bayne 11y agoWhat a surprise: a Government-appointed committee recommends increasing taxes.
- kspaans 11y agoIt's a specific consumption tax. It's not like they are proposing a 2% hike on income tax.
- duncan_bayne 11y agoEven worse - in addition to it being more tax, it's in a form that disproportionately harms poor people.
- Legogris 11y agoIf making more nutritionally balanced foods cheaper relatively to foods with a lot of associated health problems is taken as "harm", then yes.
- rustynails 11y agoIf a family is struggling financially, a sugar tax could easily push them over the edge. This strikes me as an increase in taxes for the poor as the impact relative to their income (as a %) would be significantly higher. So, the financial strain and stress would likely offset any benefit from reduced sugar for the poor. There were good posts about people on the poverty line on HN yesterday as a case in point.
- kspaans 11y agoIf the tax is restricted to "high sugar soft drinks"[0] do you still think that there wouldn't be alternatives for a struggling family to purchase? 0 - https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/470173/Annexe_2._Fiscal_evidence_review.pdf https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachm...
- baldfat 11y agoI don't drink, smoke nor do any type drugs (caffeine exempted). I am addicted to soda! I have gotten better but for a good 12 years I bet I drank 1.5 gallons of soda a day. I am down to 1 gallon a week or less. Hard to beat this consumption of sugar.
- noondip 11y agoTry substituting sugary drinks with a serving or several of whole fruit.
- sjwright 11y agoOne idea is to unceremoniously slam down a glass of water before you drink the sugary drink. Don't use sugar water to quench a thirst.
- baldfat 11y agoI drink 32 oz of water in the morning and 40 oz of tea before lunch.
- odiroot 11y agoWhy not drink diet/zero versions of your soda then?
- noondip 11y agoOne good reason to avoid "diet" soda is they contain artificial sweeteners, such as aspartame, which encourage sugar craving and sugar dependence - the opposite effect desired by the parent. Source: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2892765/pdf/yjbm_83_2_101.pdf http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2892765/pdf/yjbm...
- odiroot 11y agoIt's still better than drinking the "normal" versions.
- Shivetya 11y agoStill not convinced reducing sugar is going to stop childhood or adult obesity. The large part of it is simply because food is too convenient. With many foods having no preparation requirements it becomes easy for food to fill idle time. The easiest route to reducing over eating of foods that don't complement a sedentary diet would be to restrict food assistance programs. Instead of just saying "No" to certain purchases it should instead reward specific food type purchases. You could put a punitive value on some allowed but not good for you foods in necessary but rewarding good choices is better than punishing bad. Still their 25g is less than one ounce... how do you do that on a normal day?
- d_theorist 11y agoWhy can't they just leave us alone?
- vamur 11y agoMore bureaucracy. If they really wanted to decrease sugar usage, they could require poison labels on fruits, and any product with more than 5 grams of sugar, as well as any ads for these products.