5 ms·
A Historic Day for the World of Competitive Rubik’s Cube Solving
- callesgg 11y agoI assume the time depends very much on the initial state.
- baddox 11y agoI wonder how they set the initial state. I think it's fairly easy to calculate the minimum number of moves required to solve from a given state, so you'd think they would control for this.
- rusbus 11y agoMost states can be solved in around 21 moves by the best computer algorithms, but the fastest humans usually solve it in significantly more.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- atom-morgan 11y agoThe initial state is a random computer generated scramble. It's easy to calculate if you have a computer but it isn't easy when you have to do it in your head.
- harryh 11y agoIt is, in fact, not easy at all to calculate that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God%27s_algorithm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/God%27s_algorithm (There isn't as much info as there should be on that Wikipedia page but it was an open area of research for decades.)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- baddox 11y agoIsn't it though? I thought the hard part was proving the minimum number of moves that can solve all possible initial states. Korf's algorithm and several subsequent improvements seem to be able to find the minimum number of moves to solve any given initial state.
- harryh 11y agoA yes. You are correct. Finding minimum # of moves from a single state = not so hard. Finding the worst possible state (the state where the minimum # of moves is a maximum) = pretty hard, though now solved.
- rusbus 11y agoThere are standard randomized scrambles generated for competitions. Most competitions use some subset of 12 solves and take the average, although this appears to be the single solve record.
- brainburn 11y agoAgreed. More interesting is the variant where people try to solve a cube in as few moves as possible.
- atom-morgan 11y agoSpeedcuber here: each competitor starts with the same initial state for each solve in their best of X. Yes, there is some luck involved but it's distributed equally.
- orblivion 11y agoPer competition though, not across competitions, which is relevant WRT world records.
- mannykannot 11y agoYes - the fact that the record was broken twice in this one competition suggests that its particular initial state should be analyzed for solvability before we assume that we have entered 'a new chapter for speedcubing.'
- level3 11y agoThe two records were actually on different scrambles (i.e. different initial states). It's one thing if there was a particular scramble that everyone was solving faster than usual, but that wasn't the case here.
- atom-morgan 11y agoWell, yeah. You can't account for everything. Traditional sports don't consider elevation, air quality, wind, etc.
- hyperpape 11y agoTo an extent. Road race world records are only valid if they fall within certain limits of elevation change. You can run slightly downhill, but can't descend 500 meters. Ditto for tailwinds, I believe.
- mihaifm 11y agoWind speed is accounted for in athletics. Records won't get validated if there is a strong tail wind.
- iraphael 11y agoSort of, technically, no state needs more than 20 moves to be solved (but finding that optimal solution is kinda hard for humans). So while luck can play a part (i.e.: you may get a configuration that only requires three moves), it's much more a matter of skill to find those 15, 20, 23 moves. http://www.cube20.org/ http://www.cube20.org/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yF2J39Xny4Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yF2J39Xny4Q
- bpicolo 11y agoThe strategies humans use to solve it are not nearly so optimal in terms of number of moves. More like 50-100 for a typical solve.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mathgenius 11y agoRubik's cube always gets me thinking about group theory. Eg. http://www.gap-system.org/Doc/Examples/rubik.html http://www.gap-system.org/Doc/Examples/rubik.html
- zuck9 11y agoRelevant TED Ed video: https://youtu.be/FW2Hvs5WaRY https://youtu.be/FW2Hvs5WaRY
- phjesusthatguy3 11y agoThe video embeds on this story say they're stopped because I have Do Not Track set on my browser. They imply that if I do watch the videos, it's my own damn fault if I get tracked. So thanks for reminding me to never visit medium.com, I guess.
- guipsp 11y agoThe videos are on youtube. If you visit youtube you WILL get tracked
- mutagen 11y agoThe video embeds are YouTube videos in iframes. Medium is showing that warning in accord with their Do Not Track policy: https://medium.com/policy/how-we-handle-do-not-track-requests-on-medium-f2b4b4fb7c5e#.aqxs9d7tn https://medium.com/policy/how-we-handle-do-not-track-request... So you can blame Google / YouTube for their tracking, or blame the content creator for inserting the YouTube videos into their piece. Medium is just the messenger here.
- sambe 11y agoThis refers to the hosting site (YouTube), not medium.com. They are advising you that whilst they are observing the policy, YouTube is not. See https://medium.com/policy/how-we-handle-do-not-track-requests-on-medium-f2b4b4fb7c5e#.j43fho4d2 https://medium.com/policy/how-we-handle-do-not-track-request...
- lambda 11y agoHmm? This is Medium doing a reasonable thing. They comply with Do Not Track, but people can embed videos on sites that do not comply. Here they do a reasonable thing, and show a message to people with "Do Not Track" enabled, letting them know that they can still click through and see the video, but the site they are directing you towards might track you. Medium is just a blog hosting platform, as far as I know they don't control the content that gets posted. What would you prefer they do; not allow embedding YouTube videos? Not warn you that the linked content tracks you?
- zuck9 11y agoThis happened with the 2x2 cube too, 3 world records in the same competition: https://www.worldcubeassociation.org/results/events.php?eventId=222®ionId=&years=&show=100%2BPersons&single=Single https://www.worldcubeassociation.org/results/events.php?even... (Trentin Open 2011) The scramble was too easy, required only 4 moves.
- jpiabrantes 11y agoThe human reaction time is about 0.1 seconds. They shouldn't use a manual chronometer to measure these results 4.9+/-0.1 is the difference between a world record and a good score.
- level3 11y agoI believe WCA officially uses StackMats for the timing. Timer starts when you lift your hands from the touch pads and stops when you return them to the pads. This isn't perfect either but it doesn't rely on someone else's reaction time.
- bpicolo 11y agoCorrect.
- raldi 11y agoThe guy with the stopwatch isn't the official timer. He's just duplicating the job for fun / backup.
- sandworm101 11y agoThere is a point at which the elites of any activity become so proficient that meaningful differences between them disappear. Competitions are then won based on factors seemingly outside the nature of the activity. These rubik solvers seem to be at a point. Looking at the comments on this thread few talk of the actual solving. Most are concerned with the circumstances of the competition, I think because most here realize the differences between competitors are so slight that one must look to the competition rather than the competitive act to determine validity. So I offer this alternative:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5Zi054Fa5k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B5Zi054Fa5k By increasing the underlying difficulty of the task to the point that even the elites make many mistakes during competition, the focus returns to the underlying skill. And:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOilnrGrKsY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOilnrGrKsY
- level3 11y agoFew comments are about the solving because few commenters are actually cubers. If you look at discussions of this on actual cubing forums, then you'll see that the differences between competitors are actually significant. Edit: As a direct example of competitors making mistakes, Etter's 4.9s solve could actually have been trivially improved if he had done a U instead of U' U' U' on the 2nd pair.
- dudus 11y agoWRs of people solving Rubik's cubes with their feet is a thing these days. These seem much more skill based. https://youtu.be/DDWdSWfUAeo https://youtu.be/DDWdSWfUAeo
- jonahx 11y agoIt looks like he picks it up and examines it for a while, then puts it down. The timed solving starts only when he picks it up again -- is this correct? Is there a time limit to the examination stage?
- rosstex 11y ago15 seconds