8 ms·
The Serial Swatter
- tomtoise 11y agoI feel like this will always be an issue, due to the heavy militarization of local police. When any swatting could be a real incident, I suppose they have no choice but to go in with guns drawn and ready for anything.
- tehwebguy 11y agoThis kid DDoSed our site last year (League of Legends fan convention, http://www.summonerscon.com http://www.summonerscon.com). I wondered what had happened to him.
- TaylorSwift 11y agoAccording to the article, he is serving juvenile. "In July, a judge sentenced him to 16 months in youth jail, with credit for time served while awaiting trial. He is scheduled to be released in March, at age 18."
- DanBC 11y ago> and from a police point of view, it’s better to ‘‘respond high and then downgrade’’ They're saying increased risk of killing innocent people = ok, which is a sub-optimal approach when you look at the thousand or so people shot and killed by US police each year.
- golergka 11y agoTo be fair, there are innocent lives on both sides of the equation. This article only describes one side of it. A week later someone will post a story about how 911 never responds to calls in Detroit, and the comments will have the opposite message. It's easy to say what should and should not be done in each individual case. It's hard to build a bureaucratic system that intelligently evaluates each case with all information available and consistently makes high-quality decisions.
- detaro 11y agoIt would be really interesting to see the data supporting this: how often has a high response turned out to be the likely correct approach, how often has to "low" response gotten people killed? Sadly I don't think this kind of stuff is tracked on a larger scale.
- onewaystreet 11y agoThe argument for the "show of force" tactic is that a show of force can prevent the use of force because the suspect is too stunned to act.
- DanBC 11y agoWhere "stunned" means "shot and killed within 6 seconds of the officer arriving"? http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-34918231 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-34918231
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dibujante 11y agoWell, flip the response around - respond low and then upgrade. It's possible that this would lead to less death overall. But it would also mean that any situation requiring escalation would probably indicate such through the death of a police officer. Would you want to be the sacrificial officer who knocks on the door to find out if the situation is worth escalating? The overall numbers might work out better in that case, but the whole "someone will definitely die" factor is a big psychological hurdle.
- mikeash 11y agoI don't want to be a police officer at all, but for those who are, "put your life on the line for others" is pretty much the job description. By all means, we should minimize their risk as much as is reasonable. But when you get to the end of what's reasonable, you have to accept that they're still going to be at risk, because that's what the job is.
- Zigurd 11y agoThe US has unusually aggressive police, with tactics and doctrine that result in far too much shooting and killing compared to other advanced nations. Yet those other places don't get lots of dead police. Maybe there is a way to do this without "responding high?"
- dibujante 11y agoYou're missing my point; I'm not arguing in favor of responding high, but instead pointing out that responding high is more psychologically comfortable than its numerical consequences would otherwise indicate.
- fenomas 11y agoThe whole thing smells like a system that can't deal with bogus inputs. It's understandable that police want to prepare for the worst, but surely it's a "trust but verify" kind of situation. A swat team that charges in, guns drawn, even without any sign of a threat seems like a fire department that turns on the hoses before they've seen smoke or flame. Then of course, after the police work out a response plan that can cope with bad inputs, step 2 is they need to tell everyone about it. The expectation that cops will point ten guns at anyone you ask them to is the reason swatting is a thing at all.
- peter303 11y agoI guess the kid was a sociopath- the one one in twenty or so who dont give an eff about anyone else. Some anonymous posters are sociopaths.
- caseysoftware 11y ago> Around 6:30 a.m., her father jostled her awake and said she needed to come downstairs. When she got to the top of the steps, she saw her family’s living room ‘‘covered in cops.’’ There were at least five officers in riot gear, guns drawn. They had bulletproof vests and pads and helmets with visors. This line doesn't make sense. If officers showed up in SWAT/riot gear, they wouldn't let anyone leave their presence unsupervised, especially if someone else was in the house. SWAT only goes in for situations where they believe violence is imminent. Therefore they go room to room to clear/gather everyone, make sure potential victims are secured, and that no one is armed. If her/NYT's description is accurate, they broke procedure and put themselves and any possible victims at extreme risk. Are there any third party or police reports of this event?
- tacojuan 11y agoIf you watch enough swattings (most are streamed via twitch.tv and wind up on youtube) you'll see they typically have a sheriff follow the obviously unarmed, unharmed, and generally confused victims around the house.
- caseysoftware 11y agoNo, most are not streamed via Twitch. A tiny percentage are. In fact, we will never hear of most of them unless someone is killed. Further, read the paragraph and my quoted portion again. She says her father woke her up and she didn't see cops until she saw into the living room. Therefore, there was no sheriff with him.
- onewaystreet 11y agoThe SWAT team likely rushed in, saw that there was no threat and then let the father go upstairs. And her account doesn't say if her father came up alone or not.
- jgrahamc 11y agoMany of the comments here about about the SWAT teams and militarization of the US police force, but the story I read is that this guy (and others) went after women gamers because of their gender. Just the other day a woman programmer told me of some of the threats and abuse she'd suffered essentially because she's a programmer, a woman and has a public profile. I find this so depressing.
- karmacondon 11y agoMy first thought in response to your comment was "Well, most jerks are men". But I was reading about Berkson's Paradox [1] earlier and I think it might apply here. There's probably an even distribution of bad behavior between both men and women, but the selection bias in programming and technology limits the sample so that it skews towards males who behave badly. This doesn't add much to your comment, other than offering a potential explanation as to why women in technology can have a hard time. Unfortunately I don't see a solution to the problem either. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkson%27s_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berkson%27s_paradox
- maroonblazer 11y agoPerhaps I'm misreading Berkson's Paradox but I'm not sure that explains all of it. We know men engage in risk-seeking behaviors more-so than women, in aggregate. Couple that with teenage men/boys being more likely to be socially isolated and all the other factors associated with the adolescent/pubescent lifestage (hormones raging, identity issues, etc) - again, in aggregate - it's easy to see why you'd get more males than females engaging in this kind of behavior.
- dahart 11y ago> There's probably an even distribution of bad behavior between both men and women... We're talking about sexual harassment, not just jerks or any old "bad behavior". There is not an even distribution of sexual harassment. http://news.msu.edu/media/documents/2011/03/1205ff7b-5b6c-40ab-ac78-9356422cd451.pdf http://news.msu.edu/media/documents/2011/03/1205ff7b-5b6c-40... http://www.aware.org.sg/training/wsh-site/14-statistics/ http://www.aware.org.sg/training/wsh-site/14-statistics/
- WeAllDieByBan 11y agoThis is just a Sybil attack. Also, this is NY Times cherry picking for the sake of election year narratives.
- jMyles 11y agoIt seems to me that the fault lies entirely with the state. If it is violently intruding people's homes on the basis of this sort of report - which ends up being false - then obviously it needs to change the nature of what evidence can be regarded as sufficient cause to do this. After all, say-so alone isn't supposed to be sufficient evidence to conduct a search. From the 4th amendment: > The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized. (emphasis mine)
- onewaystreet 11y agoSWAT is only called in when there is an imminent threat. The problem is that the swatters can make up whatever story they need to. There's no good way for the SWAT team to actually confirm the story without going in.
- jMyles 11y ago> There's no good way for the SWAT team to actually confirm the story without going in. I don't think I agree, especially as communications technology matures. On its face, this "hostage with gun to the head" story needs to be regarded with enormous skepticism, just because of how rare it actually is.
- awalton 11y agoWhen someone says they're robbing a bank, they send in the SWAT team, but the first thing they do is set a perimeter and try to make contact with the people inside. Zero of these incidents that I've read about have tried to make any contact with people inside. They just break down the door and invade the house, guns drawn, smoke grenades in cribs, whatever it takes to make entry. I have no idea why it isn't protocol to have a hostage negotiator ring the house, given that's how they'd respond to several other classes of incident, but my guess is that's what happens when you pay for BearCats and bullet-resist vests instead of councilors and negotiators.
- sdoering 11y agoSorry to say that, but WTF? Having read this account, I can hardly believe such people (creatures? idiots? Lost for words right now.) exist. Even knowing, this is a one in a million/billion case, I really do not understand how someone could do things like this. I totally understand how a system can be exploited. I even can acknowledge on an intellectual level the "hack" of the system. But playing with lives destroying innocent (mostly girls in this case, but the gender/age do not matter if people are terrorized imho) people, is clearly something I will never be able to understand. And then only serving what - some 16 month in juvenile. Sorry, but that should not be right as well. This is no punishment, this does not deter others, imho. And this does also not help the guy in any way. Why can't he be made tu at least also undergo therapy: > His description of the pleasure he gets from causing humiliation and harm ... is suggestive of quite significant emerging psychopathic traits. No, he will run free, nine month after his sentence. Having written that much on him, I am still shaking my head in disbelieve.
- GFischer 11y agoI really wish he'd get some psychological or psychatric treatment, or even psychiatric internment. Much more suitable and helpful than more incarceration.
- masklinn 11y ago> Even knowing, this is a one in a million/billion case, I really do not understand how someone could do things like this. Definitely not billion, there have been tons of cases in the US alone[0]. See http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/05/teen-pleads-guilty-to-23-charges-of-swatting-harassing-online-game-rivals/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/05/teen-pleads-guilt... for an other fine case earlier this year. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatting#Notable_cases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swatting#Notable_cases note that the section is called "notable cases" it is not an exhaustive list by any stretch of imagination
- bigguy4u 11y agoWhen you walk into an anonymous message board and the first thing you declare is your gender, you shouldn't be surprised when other people think you are attention whoring. Tits or gtfo is the perfect counter, since you want to a special snowflake, then we will treat you as your polar opposite - a generic bag of skin and meat worth nothing but a masturbation aid. Downvote all you like. The truth hurts doesn't it?
- Frondo 11y agoI will reply before your comment disappears into oblivion (which it will and should): No, no, a thousand times no, because there is nothing wrong with being a woman. Everyone's gender, man, woman, or however they see it, is part of what makes them a human being. It makes up a part of your identity whether you're conscious of it or not. Announcing your gender is no more "attention whoring" (itself an awful, loaded phrase) than announcing that you're a student, that you're a teenager, that you're old, that you drive a Chevelle, whatever. That people will attack you simply for being a woman reflects wholly on them, and how awful they are as people (or possibly, to be charitable, just immature and ignorant about the world). Your defense of that is shameful, and you should take time to reflect on your world view, because it will not serve you well as you move through life.
- bigguy4u 11y agoNice straw man. If 4chan is made up of 99% females and I go in there and declare that I am male. I would expect nothing less. The fact is, you think they are being specialed out because they are women, no, they are being attacked by trying curry favours because they are different. They are not being attacked for being different, they are attacked for exploiting their differences. It is the same with people who use tripcodes to standout from the mob. The fact that you are no understanding of the 4chan dynamic and come here to lecture about 4chan culture is a bit rich.
- anon4 11y agoPsst. This is the "usual" anonymous 4chan account, made after anonymous was overtaken by a cumguzzling shitstain and had its password changed. Use this, don't suffer bad karma.
- jackgavigan 11y ago> The F.B.I. doesn’t keep statistics on swatting incidents; a bureau spokeswoman says it is still working out which part of the F.B.I. should handle swatting investigations, because the crime ‘‘crosses so many of our delineated thresholds for who handles what.’’ This is pretty shocking. Speaks to an unreasonable level of bureaucracy and/or a lack of internal cooperation (not to mention common sense) at the FBI.
- dragontamer 11y agoCross-state crimes have always been a major issue for law enforcement. You would think that the local SWAT team would investigate, except most SWAT teams are only county based. All of the calls for "small local government" come to bite us in the ass when a punk from California calls a SWAT team in Ohio. Lets presume a simple VPN setup here: California Punk buys VPN in Switzerland, creates a Google Voice Account for Ohio, makes a phone call to 911 through Google Voice in Ohio. SWAT Team eventually realizes they've been tricked, but then they have no authority in the next county over... let alone California. They call the FBI and hand the case over to them... but now what? The phone call was probably anonymized and tracing the caller id leads to a fake Google Voice account that was accessed from Switzerland. All of a sudden you need to pull an international team in to deal with the issue. Remember, each step of the way is a set of laws that we, the people, have wrapped the FBI with Red Tape in. What powers do the FBI have to trace phone calls? Was it legal for them to look at the IP traffic? Each of these steps are double-checked by lawyers in the FBI. An FBI Agent who specializes in domestic phone calls (and what he is legally allowed to do in the investigation) suddenly finds himself looking at VOIP traffic from Google, and no longer understands the legal landscape his is operating in. So he has to pass the job onto another department. Eventually, the FBI will build teams of people who understand the legal landscape across a typical SWAT attack, and have agents who can maneuver through the sea of red tape. Considering how much "Hacker News" posts about "OFMG, GOVMENT SPY ON US" like every damn day, is it surprising to see the red tape that the political opinion has caused?
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoConsidering how much "Hacker News" posts about "OFMG, GOVMENT SPY ON US" like every damn day, is it surprising to see the red tape that the political opinion has caused? Absolutely. This is all the fault of the anti-surveillance lobby, and nothing to do with the fact that separate political jurisdictions get to exercise their own autonomous decision making or anything stupid like that.
- skybrian 11y agoI'm wondering if a reliable caller ID that gives a rough geographical source of the call would prevent most swatting. A supposedly local emergency call that actually comes from a different country should be considered suspicious. Seems like there are some loopholes to be closed?
- CaptSpify 11y agoThe problem, I think, is that there does need to be a way to "anonymously" report suspicious activity. Imagine a legit call, where the "callee" is known by the "suspicious person". I agree that there's room for improvement/checking, but not sure how to reconcile the two.
- skybrian 11y agoNot sure what you mean since the emergency responders can keep the source of the call confidential. In any case, exact location isn't necessary. It doesn't make sense to treat a local call and a call from somewhere in Canada the same. Most swatting attempts are from far away, so having some indication of location would make it harder to do damage. Also, most calls to 911 are not anonymous - they automatically get caller id even for blocked numbers. It's just that there are some loopholes.
- btown 11y agoAs other commenters have noted, it is possible to buy local area code numbers for use on Google Voice. Very difficult to distinguish a swatter from a true resident of the area.
- hooloovoo_zoo 11y agoIs there really no information in the signal that would tell you what protocols were used to encode / transmit the call?
- someguydave 11y ago
- vinceguidry 11y agoKid's lucky, there are big dogs out there he could have angered. Parts where I used to live, you don't rely on the cops to solve your problems for you. I could have easily seen a truckful of guys driving up to Canada to beat the God back into him. Some guys are really protective of their daughters.
- Animats 11y agoWe need more detailed caller ID info to help stop this. At the point where a VoIP system connects to the PSTN, the ID of the VoIP system should be passed forward along with the usual CLID info. When that info reaches a PSAP, it should be displayed with a warning that the CLID info may be bogus and comes from (name of VoIP system). This would make it much harder to spoof the calling location. That info is usually available in logs at the PSTN gateway, but often not for long, because the logs aren't kept long.[1] But it's not passed forward to the PSAP. It should be. [1] http://www.911.gov/pdf/PublicSafetyInfo-Swatting-may2015.pdf http://www.911.gov/pdf/PublicSafetyInfo-Swatting-may2015.pdf
- kawera 11y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10625418 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10625418