3 ms·
Perhaps the post is alluding to some different use of statistics than I'm used to - but isn't it normal to view a certain set of outcomes as a sample from some
by e12e 11y ago
Perhaps the post is alluding to some different use of statistics than I'm used to - but isn't it normal to view a certain set of outcomes as a sample from some larger population, and not as eg: a sequence. In the case of a given coin, and a controlled sequence of flips, we can ask different questions, like what is the probability of heads following heads vs, heads following tails? (Eg: when a certain experimenter flips the coin, do the side that is up at the start of the experiment affect the outcome? Will someone that mechanically flips a coin 10s or 100s of times in a row end up with such a similar mechanical motion that the coin tends to spin approximately the same number of times from "flip" until it lands?).
I think the author mixes up the mental models involved, when mixing "throwing away information", "sequence" and "a (typical) fair coin" and "a (typical) unfair coin".
There's this coin, this sequence, and those typical fair/unfair coins.
In as much as I've been able to grasp anything about proper statistics, it's the idea that without some idea of the population and sample type (eg: can we expect a Poisson distribution?) -- most modern statistics makes no sense. And one can look at things differently. Just like Newtonian physics is correct at the same time as quantum physics is correct (most of the time). But sometimes we need to change our theoretical model to be more precise (quantum) in order to predict and model behaviour mathematically.
- stdbrouw 11y agoA sequence corresponds to multiple draws from that population, and a statistic (number of successes / number of draws) is a summarization of those draws in a single number. The author isn't really arguing that a binomial distribution is not the right way to model this problem, but that the way frequentist statistics weighs the evidence is faulty. Edit: although, actually, you're right that the author does at one point say "Why should all sequences containing exactly 12 heads be treated the same?" but then goes on to model everything with the binomial distribution anyway.
- lottin 11y agoSince each draw is independent from each other (I don't think anyone disputes that), the order is irrelevant. You want to think about it as a set, not as a sequence.