27 ms·
I've taught at two colleges and based on my (purely) anecdotal experiences and attention to the climate, I'd say that the number of students and faculty interes
by jseliger 11y ago
I've taught at two colleges and based on my (purely) anecdotal experiences and attention to the climate, I'd say that the number of students and faculty interested in stifling or censoring ideas is small but also very, very noisy. They also have no sense of humor and college administrators as a group have no sense of humor or perspective, and they're chronically worried about accusations of indifference or insensitivity (which are themselves as good as convictions). There is a strong economic and career incentive for administrators to take everything seriously and to keep their heads down as much as possible.
Brew this up and one gets a majority of students who are reasonable but a small minority who drive all the discourse.
I don't teach at Yale and have never taught at Yale or schools with similar cultures, so I can't speak to the environment there, but William Deresiewicz did, and his book Excellent Sheep: The Miseducation of the American Elite and the Way to a Meaningful Life came out of that and I recommend it. His book A Jane Austen Education (http://jakeseliger.com/tag/a-jane-austen-education-how-six-novels-taught-me-about-love/ http://jakeseliger.com/tag/a-jane-austen-education-how-six-n...) is also very good, even for someone like me who does not love Jane Austen.
Edit: Also, almost all of the censorship calls and nasty behavior / comments came from students on the left. Vox's "I'm a liberal professor, and my liberal students terrify me" (http://www.vox.com/2015/6/3/8706323/college-professor-afraid http://www.vox.com/2015/6/3/8706323/college-professor-afraid) is congruent with my experiences.
- douche 11y agoYup, that parallels my experience pretty closely, as an undergraduate at an Ivy League college that was in the news recently. There might have been about a hundred people on campus that were actively interested in protesting things (what things?, all the things). For the most part, everybody else is there to go to class, learn, do their own thing, and drink too much beer on the weekends/Wednesdays/Mondays, etc. This vocal, seemingly-permanently-aggrieved small subset of the population seemed to stir up almost all of the controversy, and seemed hell-bent on ruining everybody else's good time at every opportunity. Increasingly, they seem to be succeeding; I'm glad I graduated when I did.
- mrtron 11y agoThis might be the first time I have seen someone from an Ivy league college not mention the name (intentionally). Why not just say X/Y/Z?
- elbigbad 11y agoI don't think specifying exactly which school, or even which "group of three" schools is really germane to the point being made. Probably "Ivy League" wasn't even especially relevant, but is a way to quickly state what probably was relevant, a "top school."
- LanceH 11y agoDon't they say that it is always Penn when they don't mention the school?
- douche 11y agoIt's not something I like to trumpet out. I dealt with enough toolbags at said institution of higher learning who tended to have little personality beyond exclaiming how they got a 2400 on the SAT, that they were the valedictorian of their class, how hard corporate recruiting was, and how sick it was that they got that internship at McKinsey, or Bridgewater. Also white-trash Yankee hillbillies are rare enough at these sorts of places that I might as well give up any pretenses of online anonymity if I said specifically which one it was.
- 7402 11y agoIt's not uncommon for people who went to Harvard to avoid mentioning it right away, because of the way it can derail conversations or create weird expectations. (It's sometimes referrred to as, "Dropping the H-bomb.") [1] http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2012/05/28/not_easy_for_harvard_grads_to_say_they_went_there/ http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2012... [2] https://www.quora.com/Why-do-people-who-went-to-Harvard-sometimes-say-I-went-to-school-in-Boston-when-asked-where-they-went-to-college https://www.quora.com/Why-do-people-who-went-to-Harvard-some...
- MollyR 11y ago
- ashark 11y ago> His book A Jane Austen Education is also very good, even for someone like me who does not love Jane Austen. Off topic, but you might try Persuasion if you haven't. I've attempted the others but been unable to get past the all-caps-bold-with-flashing-lights SMUG plastered over every page, save for in Emma, which was an excellent first 2/3 of a tragedy ruined by the last 1/3 in which it... isn't a tragedy. Persuasion, though, is snappy and enjoyable, IMO.
- kelukelugames 11y agoWhich ideas do they want to censor? Edit: I'm looking for specific examples. Otherwise we are just feigning outrage. I had an ex co-worker who confided in me that he doesn't like gay people. I was very happy that he couldn't say that in public.
- masterleep 11y agoThe no-good verybad wrongthink ideas, of course. What are you, some kind of dissident?
- lexcorvus 11y agoThey want to censor what might be called secular heresy—anything that questions the reigning "mainstream" (progressive) orthodoxy.
- ffn 11y agoWell according to that Vox article about that liberal prof who got censored (and links therein) linked by the parent comment, the following things: 1. works of Edward Said 2. works of Mark Twain 3. works of Upton Sinclar 4. works of Maureen Tkacik 5. Ovid's Metamorphoses 6. The movie Avengers 7. Debates about abortion 8. Some "Afrobeat" band that had too many white people in it 9. Some male professor who was "creepy" at a conference 10. Asking harassment victims for proof And if I recall correctly from pop culture several months back: 11. The comedic act of Jerry Seinfeld 12. The comedic act of Chris Rock
- 11y ago
- gohrt 11y agoIt's more precise to say that the majority are apathetic than reasonable. Apathetic folks are just easier to deal with / ignore.
- nickbauman 11y agoThe problem with "balancing viewpoints" argument is that it isn't based on a critical ethos and so it cannot progress on the basis of logos. You can have a "balanced viewpoint" and still have debates about "whether the moon is made of the body of Vince Foster or not." There are certain ideas that just don't belong in a university setting because they are bunk and this has nothing to do with diversity of opinion. It similar to the bogus fair and balanced media argument. News reporting is about reporting the facts as they lead logically so that if anyone would perform the work of the journalist they would arrive at similar conclusions regardless of their perspective or polity. It's very much like the scientific method. Focusing on opinion diversity is a red herring.
- jon-wood 11y agoThank you, you've summed up the question of balanced journalism far better than I ever could. The current approach of sticking someone with an opposite opinion on the news, even if that opinion is clearly utter horseshit, really gets to me, but I wasn't able to properly describe why.
- cespare 11y agoBTW the name for this is "false balance". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_balance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_balance
- jgord 11y ago..thanks, this thought anti-pattern has become a cultural virus - having a name helps combat it.
- jimbokun 11y agoHowever, I think the approach of sticking someone with an opposite opinion, then tearing their argument apart with debate, insightful questions, or merciless satire are wonderful approaches to dealing with this problem. Stewart and Colbert, of course, mastered this art in the U.S., and many British journalists seem to have a knack for it as well.
- cm2187 11y agoa liberal tea party?
- kps 11y ago> Also, almost all of the censorship calls and nasty behavior / > comments came from students on the left. Almost all nasty behavior / comments come from the dominant subgroup, which in this context is the left.
- dragontamer 11y agoAgreed. This happens on both sides almost all the time. In this context, it is the left for sure. But I can imagine plenty of situations where it happens on the right in practice.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>Edit: Also, almost all of the censorship calls and nasty behavior / comments came from students on the left. Vox's "I'm a liberal professor, and my liberal students terrify me" (http://www.vox.com/2015/6/3/8706323/college-professor-afraid http://www.vox.com/2015/6/3/8706323/college-professor-afraid) is congruent with my experiences. I've read that article. At least in the article, the only student ever to actually cause trouble in-class was right-wing, and accused the professor of being a Communist because he doesn't blame the 2008 Global Financial Crisis on black people taking mortgages they couldn't pay. The professor's administration also knew this charge of Communism was utter bullshit. That doesn't sound to me like the problem is a left-wing regime of censorship and extremism.
- frotak 11y agoIn the article Haidt makes it clear that he sensed the shift in the academic community and adjusted his patterns of teaching accordingly. Each example he cites subsequently involve those with a moral liberal or left-leaning set of ideas.
- eli_gottlieb 11y agoI don't see any more subsequent examples. He appears to cite other people who claim to have data showing there's a "social justice problem", but if his citations have such data, he doesn't present it.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I don't see any more subsequent examples. There's a fairly non-specific, second-hand example regarding a student which made complaints with an unspecified basis about offensive writings of Mark Twain and Edward Said that preceded the non-renewal of a (different) adjunct professor's contract, which the author relates resulted in the author expunging anything they thought might be perceived as offensive from their syllabus (the author doesn't explain how they "saw" this scenario unfold, and given the usual confidential nature of such contracting decisions, it seems unlikely as someone who was neither the subject nor the decision-maker that the author had the full picture of the discussions or the reason for the decision.) Everything else is the description of the author's fears about what might happen, and repeating non-specific generalities from other sources. So, there is one vague subsequent example, but nothing in it actually specifies the basis of the offense and ties it into anything left/liberal (or right/conservative, for that matter). I've seen both left- and right-origin complaints about both Twain and Said (in the latter case, often the exact same complaint, of his perceived-by-some anti-Semitism.)
- iamsohungry 11y ago> They also have no sense of humor and college administrators as a group have no sense of humor or perspective, and they're chronically worried about accusations of indifference or insensitivity (which are themselves as good as convictions). I don't think this is where I want to draw the argument. If someone makes an insensitive joke, it's true that the social justice movement often reacts disproportionately, but I'm not that worried about people's right to make insensitive jokes. I'm much more worried about the people who are sharing opinions that are perfectly reasonable and necessary to the public discourse and are being squashed. Erika Christakis presented a reasoned argument at Yale for free speech, and people were calling for her and her husband to resign. This isn't a matter of lacking a sense of humor, this is an active campaign to forcibly silence discussion.