12 ms·
I'm not following some of this. It's true that the marginal benefits of salary changes for wealthy[1] parents with children in private (US) colleges who also a
by ajross 17y ago
I'm not following some of this. It's true that the marginal benefits of salary changes for wealthy[1] parents with children in private (US) colleges who also are applying for a mortgage payment reduction on homes they can't afford is very small. And for these folks, it may be very tempting to take a part time position[2] instead of working harder.
But needless to say, that's a rather small population. The article is cherry picking this small population[3] of kinda-sorta-unfortunates (they're still making $120k a year!) and using it to argue against a bunch of government programs that provide real benefits to people with a fraction of their income.
Could things be tuned better? Yeah. Benefits programs are filled with this kind of unintended side effect. But to write this kind of blanket argument cautioning against them seems awfully partisan to me. It's a fairly typical right-wing Forbes editorial in journalism clothing.
[1] $120k per year is in the top 10th percentile or thereabouts -- it's at the very edge of what most people would consider "middle class".
[2] NOT simply a lower paying one, as the article implies. A lower paying position is still full time work, after all. The contention that making less is "bad for the economy" isn't really sound. Downward wage pressure in high-paying jobs is a good thing for the export economy and a good thing for profits (companies are paying historically high fractions to their most highly compensated employees).
[3] That is: gate the income to a small range just big enough to be affected by the loss of financial and mortgage aid, but not so big that it dillutes back to the overall tax rate of ~38%. Then pick out only the people who actually need that tuition and mortgage aid: parents with both underwater mortgages and privately-school children in the right 4-year age range. If this isn't cooking the books, I don't know what qualifies.
- wmf 17y agoA lower paying position is still full time work, after all. There's 9-to-5 full time and there's chained-to-your-Blackberry, I'm-going-to-need-you-to-come-in-on-Sunday full time.
- ajross 17y agoEither or both of which might be true of the $60k or $120k position. That's another problem with the article (and your response): it's making the assumption that salary correlates directly with hours worked. Clearly it doesn't, as we all know from experience. There are "easy" six-figure jobs out there, and some folks burning out in $30k office work. The point is that it's a big world with lots and lots of variation. This particular woman has a financial incentive to work less. But to argue that we need to drop (or "reconsider the effects of", as the article euphemizes) assistance programs like financial aid or mortgage relief based on her particular situation is ridiculous.
- lssndrdn 17y agoMy sentiments exactly. Thank you for expressing it so well. If I could upvote your comment more than once I would.
- 100k 17y agoI think ajross hits the nail on the head here. These people are all very well off, comparatively speaking and they're complaining because their kids can't go to private colleges costing $40+K/year. I think the only really valid point the article makes is about the unpredictability of these tax credits. Look at the graph for marginal tax rate for a single parent - it is sort of progressive but the rates are all over the map, rising and falling as income goes up. I'm a strong advocate for progressive taxation as I believe it is essential for fairness but I also think the tax system should be simplified and the number of deductions and credits reduced. Ideally, the IRS would send me a bill at the end of the year and that'd be that.
- gnosis 17y ago"$120k per year is in the top 10th percentile or thereabouts -- it's at the very edge of what most people would consider "middle class"." If 90% of the people are making less, I don't see how it can be considered "middle class".
- plaes 17y agoThat's the new middle class. The ones who thought they are the middle class have to move one step down.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoWhen did middle class become a synonym for a particular range of pay? The majority in the $120k+ USD pay range may be middle class but I'm sure there are working class folk in there too. Consider sportsmen, Beckham and Rooney are very high paid but they're not members of the traditional middle-class. Membership of various classes is a huge quagmire. If you want to refer to people solely on what they are paid then talk about wages and steer clear of notion of class. Edit: not so stupid now.
- ZachPruckowski 17y agoI'd say "Class" can be used to refer to the types of economic problems or challenges facing people, regardless of salary. In this case, if the question is "what's the best way to pay for my daughter going to an Ivy" and not "how on earth can we afford this", they're not middle-class. If mortgage is the topic and "how are we going to ever pay this off" isn't the question, you're not lower-class. I'll certainly agree that the lines are far from clear-cut, but I think it's best defined in a problem-oriented manner. The middle class gets these tax breaks because they can't otherwise afford to send their kids to good schools or own houses, while the upper-class can. They're facing different problems, and so the solutions are tailored differently for them. This causes confusion when you have income-to-SoL disparities in the country ($60k goes further in Kansas than in NYC), so people at different income levels can be facing the same problems.
- pbhjpbhj 17y ago
- ZachPruckowski 17y ago"The article is cherry picking this small population of kinda-sorta-unfortunates (they're still making $120k a year!) and using it to argue against a bunch of government programs that provide real benefits to people with a fraction of their income." It's a regular NYT feature - The Plight of the Not-Quite-Rich-Enough. Sure it sucks for this lady, but 2/3 of the families in this country would be thrilled to have a single wage-earner making $60k. However, Mrs. Not-Quite-Rich-Enough gets NYT articles, and Joe Schmoe, who's struggling to send his kids to college at all, gets ignored. Edit: This is a Forbes article, but it reads just like any of a dozen NYT articles over the last year. It makes more sense in Forbes, because that magazine is targeted at the people in the upper income bracket.