4 ms·
How about this month with a market survey? ;) http://www.edn.com/electronics-blogs/embedded-insights/4440832/8-bit-isn-t-dying--it-s-growing http://www.edn.com
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
How about this month with a market survey? ;)
http://www.edn.com/electronics-blogs/embedded-insights/4440832/8-bit-isn-t-dying--it-s-growing http://www.edn.com/electronics-blogs/embedded-insights/44408...
Interesting details on how 8-bit companies are doing that from John Donovan the year before:
https://www.digikey.com/en/articles/techzone/2014/feb/is-there-a-future-for-8-bit-mcus https://www.digikey.com/en/articles/techzone/2014/feb/is-the...
We'd need a price list for the other thing. Can you get 32's with decent memory & low watts for a few bucks a CPU in low volume? Aside from that, you still think they're dead and useless with the new articles?
I'll add that many chips from old nodes survived for decades due to stability. The new process nodes have all kinds of issues and break faster. So, there is that to consider if the application is long-term, safety-critical, or security-critical. Many in high assurance design stayed with old stuff (esp on SOI) because manufacturing bugs were less and interference/wear issues are lower.
- Sanddancer 11y agoYes, the tiny Freescale, Cypress, etc can be obtained for less than a dollar in a reasonable quantity [1]. The microcontroller market is changing pretty rapidly of late, with the number of products getting more and more broad. For your high reliability stuff, you'd probably want to look at the cortex-r series, which is built for the type of use cases you describe. [1] http://bit.ly/1NbLYov http://bit.ly/1NbLYov redirects to digikey search.
- nickpsecurity 11y agoAppreciate the confirmation. Outside embedded, one use for these people aren't appreciating is offloading interrupts or security checks of I/O devices. Along with sensors/mgmt stuff you can trust more. Cost being so low let's one do physical partitioning of domains instead of software. Also, thanks for the mention of Cortex-R as I hadn't heard of it. A quick glance at their description looks good. About $8 on low end to $50 on high-end. Getting quite cheap indeed for what 8-bits would be required for. Way cheaper than the old champ (RCA 1802 MCU) is today ($150 w/ 1k units). http://www.intersil.com/content/intersil/en/products/space-and-harsh-environment/harsh-environment/microprocessors-and-peripherals/CDP1802A.html?part=t&_charset_=UTF-8#overview http://www.intersil.com/content/intersil/en/products/space-a... Ok. So, I'll probably not have to go to 8-bit or drop large $$$ if I take-on certain projects. Good to know. Dirt cheap chips with large ecosystem, lock-step, real-time, and MPU's... it's like the golden era in tech for embedded start-ups, eh? :)
- sitkack 11y agoThe charts on the EDN article are flipped, 8 bit usage is dropping. Time is from right to left. ;) My argument is that the economic cost of production between 8 and 32 bit MCUs is negligible. There is a _need_ for market segmentation, etc. But the cost of the package makes up for the cost in gates. It really is a wash. Much of what we still see in 8 bit designs is because of (no insult intended) 8 bit designers. I love me some 8 bit RISC, but AVR is having to fully embrace ARM even when it has its own AVR32 ISA. I don't think they are dead and useless, but they are definitely on the out for most designs. Totally agree on old stable designs. Engineering tolerances are "better" now. Something to be said for the Brooklyn Bridge and DC3s. Cheap and low volume? Yes. http://www.mouser.com/Semiconductors/Embedded-Processors-Controllers/Microcontrollers-MCU/ARM-Microcontrollers-MCU/_/N-a85pc?Rl=a85pcZgjdhrcZ1ynznd2Z1yrfw5rSGT&Ns=Pricing%7c0 http://www.mouser.com/Semiconductors/Embedded-Processors-Con...
- nickpsecurity 11y ago"The charts on the EDN article are flipped, 8 bit usage is dropping. Time is from right to left. ;)" I saw that. They still had almost 10% of a huge market, though. My point was Ganssle's points of them not gone for most cost-sensitive markets seemed still accurate. "My argument is that the economic cost of production between 8 and 32 bit MCUs is negligible. There is a _need_ for market segmentation, etc. But the cost of the package makes up for the cost in gates." That does seem to be true. Especially package vs gates. "I don't think they are dead and useless, but they are definitely on the out for most designs." I won't argue there. 32-bit space has improved significantly on cost and efficiency. Dropping down process nodes helped a lot, there. ;)