6 ms·
We already know how to design a program that won't discourage work. It's called a basic income. Everybody gets it regardless of whether they're unemployed, maki
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
We already know how to design a program that won't discourage work. It's called a basic income. Everybody gets it regardless of whether they're unemployed, making minimum wage or Donald Trump. You can't lose the benefit by making more money so there is no even theoretical disincentive to work.
And of course the money comes from taxes which come predominantly from upper income people, so even though the government is writing a check to Donald Trump, it's not half as big as the one he's writing to Uncle Sam, whereas the reverse is true for lower income people.
- kethinov 11y agoI've never understood why this is not a more popular idea. I'm a Bernie-supporting lefty liberal weenie and yet all my hardcore small government libertarian friends agree with me on this one. They tend to characterize basic income as, "I oppose wealth redistribution on principle, but since it's never going away, we might as well have the least shitty version possible." How has this not gotten done?
- jokoon 11y agoIf welfare is having a bad time in term of public opinion, how do you want basic income to have a better public perception?
- acdha 11y agoBasic income is very cheap to administer — removing huge staffs and lengthy, error-prone processes disliked by libertarians and liberals alike – and it avoids the perverse incentives which do things like punish parents for getting a job which pays enough that they lose childcare support but not enough to come out ahead after replacing it. The other big win is that if it doesn't require a visible symbol, you avoid the cognitive trap where someone sees someone using food stamps to buy a steak and spends the next 20 years yelling about how wasteful welfare is (and, of course, never once asking how much it cost per calorie).
- avn2109 11y agoBecause we are not going to call a universal basic income "welfare." Rather, we are going to call it "The America Permanent Fund" and loudly brag about how it's just a copy of the wildly-popular Alaska Permanent fund, that literally nobody has opposed ever.
- notahacker 11y agoI'm going to go out on a limb and say that has less to do with nomenclature and more to do with oil, rather than working Alaskans, paying for the Permanent Fund. Plus there can't be too many people aiming to go through life living solely off the Permanent Fund.
- evanpw 11y agoWell, the libertarians wouldn't support it as an addition to the current welfare state, and the liberals wouldn't support it if it was conditional on dismantling Social Security, Medicare, etc. If we were building something from scratch, we might be able to get to a basic income, but right now, there's too much disagreement about the proper size of the welfare state to make any sweeping changes to its structure.
- Ankaios 11y agoA workable implementation will probably end up somewhere in between—many programs might continue to exist, but the number of people they support would decrease, as would the level of support. If the basic income was set somewhere near the Federal Poverty Level (FPL) for an individual, it would be ~ $1000 / month [1]. (This is just for a rough sense of scale. I don't actually think it's a good idea to specifically aim to match that number, but I suspect we shouldn't go much above it. That's a longer discussion, though.) That wouldn't completely cover Social Security for everyone—the average monthly retirement benefit is ~ $1300 [2]—but it would cover a large chunk. Further, the minimum eligibility level for Medicaid is 133 % of the FPL [3], so if we'd like to maintain our current standards, provision of a roughly FPL basic income won't obviate Medicaid for everyone. (Medicare's qualification criteria are primarily age based, so the number of eligible beneficiaries would be unchanged by the existence of the basic income.) [1] http://aspe.hhs.gov/2015-poverty-guidelines http://aspe.hhs.gov/2015-poverty-guidelines [2] https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/quickfact/stat_snapshot/ https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/quickfact/stat_snapshot/ [3] http://www.medicaid.gov/medicaid-chip-program-information/by-topics/eligibility/eligibility.html http://www.medicaid.gov/medicaid-chip-program-information/by...
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoSo give people a one-time option when the program is introduced to choose either social security or the basic income. And of course for anyone more than a few years from retirement age, the basic income will be the obvious choice because it begins paying immediately, so social security will de facto phase itself out over time. But then you can trivially sell it as "no changes to social security."
- dennisgorelik 11y agoIf basic income was implemented, then it would have to be much smaller, than current welfare payouts (because there would be 15 times more people who collect it). Lefty liberals would not agree with the decrease of the payout for such transition, so there is no transition.
- devit 11y agoBasic income does of course still discourage work: for instance consider the case of someone who would starve without having job but doesn't with basic income. But of course encouraging work is not really the ultimate goal, so this is unrelated to whether basic income is a good idea or not.
- vanderZwan 11y agoYes, and to add to that we could also have a long discussion about what entails "work" in this context.
- evanpw 11y agoThis is exactly the issue of decreasing marginal utility of money. If your income is $0, then the utility you get from an extra $1 is huge, because it keeps you from starving. If you have a $10k / year basic income, then the utility you get from that next dollar is much smaller. But this effect on work is likely to be much smaller than the effect from the high effective tax rates that you get from mean-tested welfare, especially at typical first-world standards of living. I wouldn't say that discouraging work is totally irrelevant either. The reason that first-world standards of living are high is that lots of people are performing (often unpleasant) tasks for complete strangers, in exchange for similar favors from other strangers (i.e., working for money). Decreasing the number of people willing to do that is (all else equal) a bad thing.
- google15 11y agoBasic income is a special case of negative income tax. The current welfare system resembles a negative income tax that has a very high marginal tax rate on low income earners (because welfare is means-tested). But because budgets have to balance, the current system has the advantage that it can have lower marginal tax rates on higher income earners. Whether it makes sense to impose an especially high marginal tax rate on poorer people (and a lower marginal tax rate on richer people) is a complex question. But to claim that basic income solves the problem of incentives is wrong. Basic income just moves the disincentive effect to a different segment of workers.
- skybrian 11y agoMaybe, but at what level does the disincentive effect become significant for high-income workers? It seems like at the highest levels of income, spending money is just a way of signalling and keeping score. Also, there are some taxes where the disincentive effect is beneficial. Basic income funded by a carbon tax seems like a good combination.
- google15 11y agoIt's a complex issue. But it's something that needs to be made explicit in any discussion, not swept under the rug. I'm not saying I'm able to resolve this issue myself, but I think that basic income advocates need to be challenged whenever they use misleading argumentation, even if they are ultimately correct. At any income level you can make arguments why their work output would be more/less sensitive to taxation. We are talking about a difference in a difference (how much one group changes their work in response to tax, vs another) and not absolutes, which complicates matters. E.g. poor people need the money more, so maybe they are less responsive to marginal tax rates. Also, there are some taxes where the disincentive effect is beneficial. Basic income funded by a carbon tax seems like a good combination. Pollution taxes are a good idea for their own sake, but they will only cover a tiny percentage of basic income or welfare.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> But because budgets have to balance, the current system has the advantage that it can have lower marginal tax rates on higher income earners. That isn't a very strong argument. Assuming the basic income and associated taxation is calculated to approximate the same level of redistribution of wealth as the existing welfare system, the amount a person making a given level of income would have to have their taxes increased by in order to balance the budget is only equal to the amount they themselves would receive from the basic income but would not have qualified for in a means tested welfare system. For high income earners that amount is negligible because the basic income constitutes such a small proportion of their total income, and even then it has no effect on their effective tax rate (i.e. net transfers with the government; taxes paid less basic income), only that small change to the marginal rate needed to keep the effective rate the same. And in particular what is really happening is that the disincentive (which is created by any taxation for any purpose) is being spread more evenly throughout the population, which all else equal can be expected to have less effect on behaviour than concentrating the effect on a subgroup which will then be much more compelled to react to it. Moreover, how the taxes are collected is separate from the basic income. If we find that it is for some strange reason better to charge a higher marginal rate to lower income people than higher income people then we can have a basic income and yet still do that.
- rhino369 11y agoBasic income also reduces incentives to work for people who aren't currently on welfare. Me and most of my family would probably just move to rural Wisconsin and fish, snowmobile, netflix and play video games for the rest of our lives. Unless the basic income isn't enough to live on, which would mean more welfare would be needed for those who can't work or can't find a job.
- Crusoe123 11y agoI very much doubt you could afford a snowmobile on such income, you would still need supplemental income to be able to afford most of those things you're talkng about. So if anything maybe some people who now work full time, would work part time. And those who currently work but can barely scrape by would actually be able to live decently which IMO would have a tremendous effect on people's productivity.
- skybrian 11y agoThis is binary thinking. On the margin, a small basic income (not enough to live on) would still have a lot of small effects. For example, a couple might find it more affordable to get by without both people working, if they could almost afford it before. Or, people might be more willing to take a lower income job like teaching. It also makes rural areas with a lower cost of living somewhat more desirable, if you can find a job.
- dllthomas 11y ago"It also makes rural areas with a lower cost of living somewhat more desirable, if you can find a job." Or if you've saved almost enough, otherwise.
- 11thEarlOfMar 11y agoHere's a theory for you... 1. Better income for adults means lower crime rates. A minimum wage job qt $7.25 plus $1,000/month grosses $27,080. 2. A Basic Income improves the outcome of children in poor families. Two minimum wage-earning parents plus $1,000/month per adult yields $54,160: Reduces divorce rate, reduces domestic violence, enables residence in a better neighborhood and attendance to better schools. 3. An improved outcome for children also means lower crime rates. 4. Lower crime rates improve real estate values. Anecdotally, from 1998 to 2006, East Palo Alto median home prices increased from $190,000 to $650,000 (342%). Over the same time period, the total crimes reported dropped from 550 to 350 (was over 900 in 1988) [0]. (note that the median home price has not further increased since 2006). 5. There are about 3,600 detached single housing units. [1]. With a little arithmetic, the total increase in the value of the real estate owned by those owners was $1,656,000,000. 6. A basic income of $1,000 per month for East Palo Alto over those 8 years would have cost $1,824,000,000.[1] 7. Property tax receipts increased somewhat. The county gets 1% annually, but due to prop 13, that will take a long while to fully materialize. 8. Sales tax receipts would likely increase as the population would have $228,000,000 more to spend each year. So, if it is true that a basic income would reduce crime and lower crime rates improve real estate prices, then part of the economic analysis of a basic income needs to factor that in. [0] https://www.law.berkeley.edu/files/EPA_Main_Report_Final.pdf https://www.law.berkeley.edu/files/EPA_Main_Report_Final.pdf [1] http://www.bayareacensus.ca.gov/cities/EastPaloAlto.htm http://www.bayareacensus.ca.gov/cities/EastPaloAlto.htm Mods, please add 'anecdotally' to the spell check dictionary