8 ms·
The New China Syndrome: American business meets its new master
- doctorpangloss 11y agoThe anecdotes on corporate and cultural acquiescence to the Chinese state are not all that convincing. Overall, industrial interdependence and trade is employing way more people than otherwise, in a strictly macroeconomic sense. Normatively, it might result in executives in jail, but fewer people everywhere are starving. Americans aren't killing people all over the world at the same magnitude that they used to—especially not killing Korean, Japanese and Vietnamese people, whom they're now trading with. Surely that's a good thing. But let's examine this accusation that culture has acquiesced. Gravity's trading the real Chinese antagonist for the fake Russian one is pretty damning, but has the author ever watched an episode of South Park? Trey and Matt do not trade in the most friendly opinions. The best point you can make from an example like Gravity is that mainstream cultural products are cowardly. But that isn't really all that surprising. I don't see the author writing a big cautionary tale about how Disney stars don't write enough songs about climate change and cuts to food stamp programs. That self-censorship started long ago, way before there was a Chinese market for American media. Self-censorship and the dumbing down of mainstream media—i.e., endogenous U.S. state and corporate propaganda—is a way bigger threat to our way of life than the organization of Chinese markets ever will be. What about the other corporations, like Walmart, Apple, GM and Rio Tinto, who got their executives jailed for not accommodating Chinese state demands? I can also say: so what? These companies make a bunch of physical junk, they don't make political statements or cultural products. And they make this junk primarily for the benefit of shareholders. Asceticism (in its many forms, like lower demand) is a bigger threat to junk makers than Chinese market controls. Ask Paul Krugman: A slump in global demand put way more American workers on the street than a free trade deal ever has. Germany's savers and domination of the currency union puts way more people on the street than reckless borrowing in a small country like Greece ever has. One man's income is another man's expense. The system by which that exchange happens is sort of irrelevant, depending on where you normatively value people like shareholders in the grand scheme of things. The Chinese state, through blunders, and Western regulators, through austerity, magnified unemployment—they're both equally stupid. You can't blame trade—demand has to come from somewhere, and it seems totally reasonable that demand comes from people outside your national borders. It's something that the Soviet Union never figured out but the Chinese government did. Demand is a more fundamental economy property than the author admits, and it's not obvious how to increase demand while reducing global trade. But the few billions of dollars shareholders miss out on out when the Chinese state strongarms executives? Who gives a shit. The author's blaming the very industrial interdependence that in a macroeconomic sense is keeping millions of people employed, while at the same time kvetching about some bad deals some companies got sometimes. I think he gives Google too much credit for not having business in China. Besides funding the author's think tank, whom exactly are they employing? Which millions of factory workers? At least the junk makers are directly putting money into the pockets of many millions of Walmart and Apple/Foxconn employees. Google's search engine facilities an absolutely colossal amount of commerce that must employ millions of people indirectly. But so does Baidu. It's a Pyrrhic victory for free speech. At the end of the day, Chinese people don't need Google. They need rice on a plate. The alternative world, where American "relies" on "itself" for everything, is not one we want to live in. Billions of people—Chinese people, Indian people, the world's people—stuck in a much worse poverty because they can't make something Americans can buy. The subsequent wars due to poverty. The nationalism and jingoism a closed-trade policy breeds, and the consequences like institutionalized racism, colonization and vindictive foreign policy. That was reality up until the 1970s, just when global economic liberalization started to reach billions of people. If you weren't born among a lucky few prior to that time, you wouldn't want that system. This "Chinese master" worldview is ridiculous.
- danielrhodes 11y agoPerhaps you have missed the point of the article? It is not arguing that there haven't been great benefits to trade, nor is it arguing for strong protectionism. Instead it is arguing that the strategy of easing up trade rules so US corps could go into China, which it was thought would ultimately tame China into becoming a more free and open society, has backfired both figuratively and literally (as was shown with US entertainment). China is now exerting political and cultural control over the US via its corporations, which at least from the perspective of the US, is not a desirable outcome. You can argue that lots of jobs and economic prosperity has been created and this is a fair trade for some independence lost, but most of the benefits have gone to China rather than the US.
- fspeech 11y agoIt seems like a simple case of Newton's third law. You can push a small economy around, but it would be naive to believe that you can push against a larger economy without experiencing a reaction.
- bhewes 11y agoFor most of China's Imperial history they had a tributary system. Which I think ended in 1912. It is not really surprising to see it come back in a some form.
- zhte415 11y agoA lot of China's tributary system was money / resources flowing from the center to the outlying areas, to keep them favorable / quell unrest / keep the center stable. China is very geographically islanded (depending on the dynasty, the fee to keep disarray at bay depending on the territory occupied; the many 'great walls' over the centuries basically land-grabs coupled with payments for compliance). But this article is about Ford. Ford is an extremely low-key brand in China. GM is the biggest US brand, but there are far more VWs, Audis and BMWs than GM. Also more BYDs, who despite a reputation for poor material quality are making big pushes in buses, conventional hybrid and electric, and other public transport. BYD will be the name to look out for over the next 15 years.
- bhewes 11y agoInteresting, I did see a lot of Geely and Great Wall Motors autos in Ecuador last time I was there. Thanks for introducing me to BYD.
- chillacy 11y ago> When the United States wielded power over corporations in the postwar era, our overarching goal was — with some notable exceptions — stability, peace, and prosperity. When China wields its power over foreign corporations, the ultimate goal is — always — command and control. That's some narrow-minded thinking. Two different words for the same thing. I'm sure the south american governments who were dismantled in the cold war era by the CIA would see the actions as "command and control" as opposed to peace and stability. Likewise, the chinese government is going to serve the interests of itself.
- kyllo 11y ago"stability, peace, and prosperity" Exactly (the English translations of) the words the Chinese government uses to describe their own goals.
- user_0001 11y agoHas any government ever viewed their own actions any differently? Everyone sees themselves as the good guys, everyone justifies what they do as the right thing from the biggest empires down to the smallest country. American, British, Soviets back through all European empires to Romans and beyond. This whole good vs evil of the current global empire and the war names they give to operations is laughable. Yet they say it with a straight face and it is lapped up by those who get their news solely / mainly from the mass media
- eru 11y ago> Has any government ever viewed their own actions any differently? Yes. There used to be a time when war was seen as more glorious, and not shielded behind euphemisms.
- vinceguidry 11y agoSouth America has a long tradition of interchangeable strongman governments, none of whom had any real interest in advancing the needs of citizens. Plenty of populist autocrats that paid lip service to social advancement, very little actual public service. It's understandable that the US would get a little jaded regarding which regimes to back. I can easily see how a CIA official, tasked with determining how to best advance US interests in the region, but otherwise having a good bit of autonomy, would come to the conclusion that whichever regime was most amenable to the American way of doing things would also be the best steward of the public interest. It's not like they had a bunch of upstanding, self-sacrificing public servants to choose from, and they deliberately chose the wannabe gangbangers to support. And Latin Americans themselves weren't much help either, often eagerly buying into the cults of personality that the strongmen built up. Hence the public fascination with thugs like Che and Escobar. I think you'd find that there's a real, discernible difference between Chinese strong-arming and American interventionism, on both ideological and practical levels.
- danharaj 11y ago> When the United States wielded power over corporations in the postwar era, our overarching goal was — with some notable exceptions — stability, peace, and prosperity. When China wields its power over foreign corporations, the ultimate goal is — always — command and control. What a load of propagandistic garbage. Stability, peace, and prosperity for everyone the US government liked at the terrible, terrible expense of everyone else. It's insulting to my sensibilities. I honestly cannot figure out where to start in dismantling this pile of garbage. How about all of the coups sponsored by the United States to remove threats to the hegemony of U.S. corporations? It's a fun exercise to count them.
- snickerdoodles 11y agoHow about the tens of millions killed by the Red Chinese. You sir, do not make lot of sense here.
- danielrhodes 11y agoAt least in terms of the US maintaining its power, that strategy was apparently more effective than the current strategy now.
- adventured 11y ago> How about all of the coups sponsored by the United States to remove threats to the hegemony of U.S. corporations? It's a fun exercise to count them. Ok, count them for me. Are you going to say Vietnam? That was France asking the US to get involved to save its colonial possession. Are you going to say Iran? That was the UK asking the US to get involved. Turns out it's an extraordinarily short list.
- user_0001 11y agoYou are correct that global political manoeuvring is rarely a straight forward case of just one country involved. Countries come together when it suits them and oppose each other just as readily. The US does sometimes come under unfair criticism for being the cause of all evil, when the reality is a lot more nuanced, but when you are sitting on top the pile, everyone is gunning for you. However, as the parent comment pointed out, the US has been "involved" in many coups / destabilising existing governments. Do you think the US would help out in French / British coups if it wasn't in their interest?
- hitekker 11y agoI would like to address the theme of "the U.S. is no better than China!" when it comes to trade. It is true that both have countries have manipulated and are currently manipulating levers in greedy self-interests. It is also true that the U.S. is not perfect. Far from it: I'm sure many Russian commenters have some words about the western-bred neoliberal experts who preached "Shock Therapy" to Yeltsin (Spoiler alert: oligarchs). The difference between China and the US, in my opinion, lies in their motivations and how it translates into economic action. The West, like other "enlightened" spheres before it, has had some element of "for the greater good" guiding its vision. One historical example is that instead of colonizing Europe after WW2 (like the Soviets did), the US instituted the Marshall Plan. You can argue that this aid was given in exchange for a degree of suzerainty ( don't bomb NATO! ). Fundamentally, however, those states regained their status as independent actors and were not seen as extensions of the US. Security is very much the heart of the matter here, it's the age-old question of "how much control does the government need over its spheres to feel secure and therefore strong?". Although not always spoken, a country normally ought to be as protectionist over its trade as it is weak in that area of trade. In the U.S., it happened with Japan and Cars as the article points out, and Great Britain and textiles if one goes back even further. With this rationale in mind, Xi Jingping insists that China is still "developing"[1], that China can be excused for so-and-so action to maintain its economy, even though it wields more power than almost all other "developing nations" in the same space put together. What's often overlooked is that it's not just economic (in)securities at play here. China demands the submission of foreign companies because China is politically insecure. Consider a related section from the "X Article": > Easily persuaded of their own doctrinaire "rightness," they insisted on the submission or destruction of all competing power. Outside of the Communist Party, Russian society was to have no rigidity. There were to be no forms of collective human activity or association which would not be dominated by the Party. No other force in Russian society was to be permitted to achieve vitality or integrity. Only the Party was to have structure. All else was to be an amorphous mass. [2] Although China hasn't been at this totalitarian stage for a long while, the concept of "amorphousness", that the only "true" political form is the central power and all else exists in service to it, is one of China's current most debilitating problems. If you don't have multiple organizations each with their own sphere of power, how can you express the multifaceted will of your citizenry (the definition of a functional civil society)? While the Chinese people have to date built many forms [3], the central government is certain to come down hard on any actual power of the forms as fast as they develop. [4]. To summarize: China acts with greater force internally because China's leaders are afraid. Very afraid. First, they don't have the same political mechanisms for dealing with foreign political influences that the U.S. has. In more concrete terms: the last time they allowed for other forms, in the same way the U.S. did and does, came just before their tanks crushed students underfoot in their nice, government square. History in mind, China's leaders have continually resorted to harsh action in all spheres to maintain their form, which they cannot bear to be without. [1] http://foreignpolicy.com/2014/09/25/is-china-still-a-developing-country/ http://foreignpolicy.com/2014/09/25/is-china-still-a-develop... [2] https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/russian-federation/1947-07-01/sources-soviet-conduct https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/russian-federation/1... [3] http://www.economist.com/news/china/21600747-spite-political-clampdown-flourishing-civil-society-taking-hold-beneath-glacier http://www.economist.com/news/china/21600747-spite-political... [4] https://www.hrw.org/news/2015/05/08/dispatches-china-tightens-screws-civil-society https://www.hrw.org/news/2015/05/08/dispatches-china-tighten...
- known 11y agoUnlike in USA, Capex and Opex is low in China;
- thedogeye 11y ago"The turning point came with the triumph of modern libertarianism, with its sophisticated, Orwellian method of hiding corporate power behind the rhetoric of individual liberty" Had me until the part about the "triumph of libertarianism," a system which has never been tried anywhere.
- igravious 11y agoExactly, isn't neo-liberalism the moniker we generally use to describe the set of ideas that cluster around Friedman and his subscribers? As in, neo-liberal policy. Is the author equating "modern libertarianism" with neo-liberalism?
- pron 11y agoLibertarianism was tried in the US during the Gilded Age[1], and failed spectacularly. Power quickly consolidated in the hands of the (unelected) very few, and in a form of modern feudalism, much of the population came to live under the boot of the robber barons and called on the government to save them. That's how the strong American federal government came to be. The US is one of the few places where government regulation actually came about to free people from libertarianism. Somewhat ironically, Ayn Rand came to the US in the aftermath of the backlash, not knowing that all of her ideas had been tried and the mess they caused cleaned up not long prior to her arrival. [1]: Of course, some would say that the US in the Gilded Age wasn't really libertarian, but it was closer to true libertarianism than anyone has ever gotten to true communism. So anyone who says libertarianism hasn't failed because it hasn't been tried must admit the same about communism.
- novalis78 11y ago...you mean the age that propelled a backwater colony to riches and turned it into a global super power?
- pron 11y agoYes, that one, and in the process turned large portions of the population into serfs to the point where they cried for help. No one will deny the great progress the US made in the gilded age, but no one would say it is an age one we'd like to repeat (as its name suggests, it is not generally regarded as a good period in American history; important? certainly; interesting? absolutely; but good? not really). The USSR made tremendous progress during Stalin's various five-year plans, but that, too, is something no one wishes to repeat. Both cases prove that it is possible to make great leaps by enslaving your populace. Of course, we've known that since the Romans. The trick is not to make progress. The trick is to preserve your values while still making progress. Communism and Libertarianism are two ideas that had their chance. They both yielded quick leaps forward but also ruined the lives of millions. Their proponents would claim that neither was really tried in its true form -- and both camps would be absolutely right -- but I think most people have the good sense to trust that any further experiment (of either) would turn out similar enough to previous ones.
- adventured 11y agoChina is no more the new master today, than Japan was in 1992. The exact same things were claimed about Japan back then. Comically, the timing was exactly wrong, just as it is now: this is the end of China's boom, not the beginning.
- jinst8gmi 11y agoThat's a bold prediction to be making.
- josai 11y agoAren't you forgetting the small detail that China is literally ten times the size of Japan? Even if your claim is true, and you don't present any evidence to that effect, the order of magnitude size difference makes it rather a different ball game.
- adventured 11y agoNo, I take that into account. China is ten times larger in population, but that doesn't mean they can grow ten times larger economically. There are limits to both sheer consumption / production within N amount of years in terms of how fast the global economy can grow, and limits in terms of how many resources a nation can realistically consume. For China to be ten times larger, they'd have to figure out how to produce the world's GDP almost twice over. It's impossible, the global economy in real terms is growing at a few points per year, China's growth must inherently move toward that line as it gets larger, just as the US has. It's not hard to find evidence for China's boom being completely over. The best estimates on their actual GDP growth, already have them closer to 2-4% growth, if any growth at all if you go by trade volume / trains / baltic index / copper / construction / concrete etc. Ten years ago they began to shift to massively taking on debt to continue to fake growth. Countries only do that when their organic growth is completely exhausted. It's exactly what Japan did when their bubbles began to unravel, and their money expansion began to implode. When the great recession hit, that was the end of the temporary consumption binge that drove most of China's 2000-2008 growth. Now they're arguably the most indebted nation in world history on a GDP ratio basis, and it's still getting worse, while companies are being artificially floated so banks don't have to own the vast bad loans outstanding, perfectly repeating what Japan did with zombie corporations.
- happyscrappy 11y agoA little off topic but is iMessage encrypted in China? I couldn't find an answer in a quick search.