11 ms·
Stereotype of the Lazy Welfare Recipient: Evidence from Cash Programs Worldwide
- dang 11y agoUrl changed from http://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2015/11/20/9764324/welfare-cash-transfer-work http://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2015/11/20/9764324/we..., which points to this.
- andybak 11y agoI feel that was a mistake. I would prefer a nicely formatted web summary. I generally won't click on PDF links as they tend to be hard to read and usually overly wordy. I am also less likely to read an original paper over a web article unless I'm particularly interested in the topic. I understand the policy for linking to original rather than commentary but there is sometimes value in a 'dumbed-down' summary.
- jimrandomh 11y agoI'll take the other side: I think it's almost always better to link to studies rather than to secondary sources reporting on them. I haven't looked closely at the study or the Vox article yet, but my experience has been that there's a major mismatch between study and the commentary more than half the time and it's always the study that's closer to truth.
- tomrod 11y agoWhy not require a comment to have the study source, and pin that to the top of the comment chain?
- qntmfred 11y agoThe vox link is at the top of the comments now, so potato, potato
- javajosh 11y agoAs an aside, does anybody actually say potato like "potato"?
- goodcanadian 11y agoWell, they say to-mah-to in Australia. However, they also say po-tay-to. I don't know of anywhere that it is pronounced po-tah-to, but I wouldn't rule it out.
- seekingcharlie 11y agoWe also pronounce tune as "choon", which results in a lot of weird looks if you're an Australian in the US.
- gwern 11y agoDoes HN have any such functionality?
- dang 11y agoWe're planning to implement some form of URL grouping. It's an open question what the best UI for that will be.
- jjoonathan 11y agoThe problem isn't dumbed-down summaries, the problem is that the dumbed-down summaries, especially those produced by people other than the original author, are often straight up wrong. Reading just the abstract, or abstract + figure captions, is a good compromise in my book.
- dang 11y agoActually I agree. Url changed back from http://economics.mit.edu/files/10849 http://economics.mit.edu/files/10849. HN generally prefers the best popular article on a specialized paper, with a link to the paper in the comments. An exception is papers on specialized topics the audience here is largely comfortable with, such as computing. I can't remember why we changed this one. It may be that we felt the Vox article was too baity, or perhaps that the HN discussion would be of higher quality if it were fed with vegetables rather than fruit. In any case it was more of an exception than the rule.
- jrcii 11y agoAn anecdotal perspective to bring these conclusions a little closer to home- spend some time in outer borough NYC bodegas, there is a constant stream of people using food stamps to buy cigarettes, alcohol, and marijuana. 100% of people that I've spoken with (dozens?) who live or have lived in these areas have corroborated these observations. As far as I'm concerned, even if these programs were free from abuse, they are payments for votes and programs like SNAP should be abolished -- that's what charities are for. The /only/ difference is that charities permit the liberty of donors whom may manage the fruits of their own labor.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoNYC has a welfare problem, but it's not located in the outer bouroughs. It's in the primary downtown area, where all the banks have congregated. Entire blocks would have been wiped out and gone up for cheap rent in 2009 if everyone else wasn't forced to subsidize their bullshit lifestyles. Open your eyes and look around. Edit: FR balance sheet[0] currently records ~$4.45 trillion in made up, outstanding, welfare payments. Most of that was directly passed through the FR's dependent organizations, commercial and investment banks, and was initiated to save their system from complete implosion. [0] http://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h41/current/h41.htm http://www.federalreserve.gov/releases/h41/current/h41.htm
- yequalsx 11y agoThere are no instances of charity ever providing the basic needs of a nations poor since the advent of the nation state. Charities are much more ibefficient than government at curing starvation, lack of healthcare, etc. Nations that contain large percentages of hungry, homeless, and sick are almost always shitty. Making sure there aren't large numbers of extreme poverty cases makes us all better off.
- ashark 11y agoAFAI am concerned, libertarians are free to replace most of government with charity and other voluntary associations as soon as they find a way around the free rider problem and assorted other coordination problems that isn't 1) government (we already have that!), or 2) obviously worse than government. Good effing luck!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- alecdbrooks 11y agoI haven't personally studied the literature, but this study is in line with what GiveWell has concluded, although they are more certain about cash transfers not being spent on alcohol and tobacco [0] than on it not displacing work [1]. This paper and GiveWell's research are based on some of the same studies, so this study's not exactly surprising or new information, but replication's always nice. [0]: http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/cash-transfers#Alcoholandtobacco http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/cas... [1]: http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/cash-transfers#Whatarethepotentialdownsidesoftheintervention http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/cas...
- skwirl 11y agoAre there any studies that reach "negative" conclusions on the impact of welfare systems? I thought surely there must be given how messy real world data is and how widely varied opinion is on the topic. A quick search only revealed more studies reaching similar conclusions to this one and the only articles speaking out against these programs were newspaper opinion pieces.
- rubyfan 11y agoI wonder if at a certain level of development, the bottom is so low that welfare will make life slightly better but sustainable work and pay will sufficiently change the standard of living. Therefore welfare doesn't deter work because incremental standard of living (attainable only by working) is sufficiently divergent from the alternative of relying solely on welfare. I'd also wonder if by contrast in developed countries the standard at the bottom is sufficiently high or the next level up is not sufficiently different enough to encourage working to get there. The Vox article mentions other studies in the US and Canada, particularly negative tax and earned income tax credit. I'm not sure those actually act as welfare or a one time economic stimulus. As a former recipient of earned income tax credit, 1. I definitely didn't plan for that income 2. It didn't change my work incentive (I was already working and low income) 3. I probably spent that refund almost immediately either on paying down a credit card, a car down payment, appliance, etc. Earned income tax Had no effect on my desire to work or to increase my income; the fact that I worked full time and had a low income was incentive enough. The earned income tax was kind of like a bonus on an otherwise hard existence. I suppose what is important here though is the question, do the program's incentivize people to move out of poverty and remove the need for future subsidization? If my hypothesis on upward mobility is correct then government welfare programs don't really do much to move people out of poverty, they are really economic stimulus and you know, keeping people from starving and freezing to death. If we wanted to address the question of deterring work, I'd suspect a lack of upward mobility is enough to deter work toward the bottom.
- evanpw 11y agoThis is the reason a lot of economists think it would be better to implement the earned income tax credit as a wage subsidy rather than a tax credit. Instead of a getting a big lump sum at tax time, you'd get a bigger paycheck: kind of like a negative tax withholding.
- rubyfan 11y agoThat would make sense if it is intended to be welfare. I could honestly say when I was getting a bigger tax refund than what I paid in taxes, I really didn't know what it was or understand why I was getting it and when it would go away. As a once a year thing that I didn't understand, it had little influence on my thinking about work and I certainly didn't think about it as welfare. As a more frequent payout I'm certain I would have gave it more thought and it would have an influence on thinking and behaviors. As a working person I'd likely have considered it welfare and would have given it consideration as my pride and ego would have to grapple with that.
- sevensor 11y agoPerhaps I'm not reading the right sources, but I never see anybody talk about how much work it is to get benefits, at least in the U.S. Once the county welfare office is involved in your life, you have a demanding new boss, always demanding paperwork -- forms, paystubs -- and phone calls to straighten things out when the paperwork goes wrong. It's not like somebody shows up out of the blue and gives you an envelope full of cash every month.
- Mz 11y agoI talk about it once in a while -- when I have time. I am homeless and had food stamps for a time. Then someone in the welfare office dropped the ball and they got cancelled. I reapplied and someone else dropped the ball. I have a compromised immune system. Not only did it take scads of time while getting me nothing, it made me ill to spend half the day in a crowded welfare office waiting room surrounded by poor people, who tend to not be in the best of health. After the second time they dropped the ball, I didn't bother to go back. My income is gradually going up. I would get less help than I used to. I do freelance work, so my income is erratic, which doesn't play nicely with their forms. Etc. I began looking for other solutions. I am sometimes upset that I am not getting the food stamps. My situation is still dicey and it is still a scramble every month to get enough resources to eat every day. But I am not going to go spend all kinds of time trying to chase the few dollars they would give me, getting sick over it, and worrying about the possibility that they will feel I am committing fraud or something because my income is erratic and some months I have enough and some months I don't (or whatever the hell problem they might have with me). So I do sometimes talk about it. But not a whole lot, for various reasons.
- sevensor 11y agoThank you for speaking up! Public assistance in this country is given up so grudgingly, and often so incompetently, as to be actively counterproductive.
- fricken4 11y agoI'm in Canada and a friend of mine was working in a government call centre; her job description could be summarized as 'deny people benefits in 9 minutes or less'. Her role as enforcer of state brutality eventually led to clinical depression and she quit. She couldn't handle turning down people who were more often than not in dire straights.
- im_dario 11y agoInteresting study. It is kind of a reinforcement to the progressive policymakers' point of view that cash programs work and even there will be people who cheats the system, they will be whatever the system you choose. I feel curious about what conclusions would obtain from a similar study in European countries, which are well-known by their welfare programs.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoWe already know how to design a program that won't discourage work. It's called a basic income. Everybody gets it regardless of whether they're unemployed, making minimum wage or Donald Trump. You can't lose the benefit by making more money so there is no even theoretical disincentive to work. And of course the money comes from taxes which come predominantly from upper income people, so even though the government is writing a check to Donald Trump, it's not half as big as the one he's writing to Uncle Sam, whereas the reverse is true for lower income people.
- kethinov 11y agoI've never understood why this is not a more popular idea. I'm a Bernie-supporting lefty liberal weenie and yet all my hardcore small government libertarian friends agree with me on this one. They tend to characterize basic income as, "I oppose wealth redistribution on principle, but since it's never going away, we might as well have the least shitty version possible." How has this not gotten done?
- jokoon 11y agoIf welfare is having a bad time in term of public opinion, how do you want basic income to have a better public perception?
- acdha 11y agoBasic income is very cheap to administer — removing huge staffs and lengthy, error-prone processes disliked by libertarians and liberals alike – and it avoids the perverse incentives which do things like punish parents for getting a job which pays enough that they lose childcare support but not enough to come out ahead after replacing it. The other big win is that if it doesn't require a visible symbol, you avoid the cognitive trap where someone sees someone using food stamps to buy a steak and spends the next 20 years yelling about how wasteful welfare is (and, of course, never once asking how much it cost per calorie).
- avn2109 11y agoBecause we are not going to call a universal basic income "welfare." Rather, we are going to call it "The America Permanent Fund" and loudly brag about how it's just a copy of the wildly-popular Alaska Permanent fund, that literally nobody has opposed ever.
- evanpw 11y agoThe thing that discourages work is (mostly) not the cash grant itself, but the high effective marginal tax rate you get from phasing it out as the recipient earns more. The negative income tax and the earned income tax credit (which is almost the same thing) should actually encourage work among those with low incomes, because the more you earn, the larger the credit.
- talloaktrees 11y agoHere's the conclusion: V. CONCLUSION In recent years, there has been a large growth in safety net programs across the developing world. If anything, we might expect this trend to increase as countries become richer: Chetty and Looney (2006) show that social insurance as a fraction of GDP rises as countries get richer, suggesting an that safety nets may be increasingly important as countries grow. 18 As safety nets have increased, so has the debate about whether they simply discourage work, enabling a “lazy poor.” Aggregating evidence from randomized evaluations of seven cash transfer programs, we find no effects of transfers on work behavior, either for men or women. Moreover, a 2014 review of transfer programs worldwide by Evans and Popova also show no evidence—despite claims in the policy debate—that the transfers induce increases in spending on temptation goods, such alcohol and tobacco. Thus, on net, the available evidence implies cash transfer programs do not induce the “bad” behaviors that are often attributed to them in the policy space.
- Aoyagi 11y agoI personally know two people who abuse the welfare system and a study whose name starts with "Debunking the Stereotype" sounds like it's throwing any objectivity out of the window right at the beginning - not to mention they analyse data only from six third world countries. Inapplicable to richer countries with generous welfare benefits.
- nedwin 11y agoAre you suggesting your study of two people trumps this study?
- notahacker 11y agoTo be fair, systematic data on experimental transfer programmes aimed at the extreme poor in developing countries is no better than random anecdotes for confirming or debunking stereotypes of lazy welfare recipients in developed countries with well-established welfare states. This study tells you a fair bit about extreme poverty relief schemes and precisely nothing about how the welfare state affects or doesn't affect people's behaviour in Western Europe and the USA. Lack of negative behavioural effect from conditional handouts as low as $4 per household per month really doesn't tell you much about the effect of subsidies designed to permit an at least borderline-adequate Western standard of living. They're trying to fix different issues with different sized budgets.
- yiri 11y agoI don't think he's suggested anything of the sort; tried to discredit the study, yes, but he hasn't characterised his anecdote as a "study" much less an authoritative one.
- vanderZwan 11y ago> I personally know two people who abuse the welfare system So? You performed what Daniel Kahneman has called "question substitution": replacing a difficult to answer question - "do welfare plans encourage exploitation" - with a simpler one: "are there people who exploit welfare systems". > sounds like it's throwing any objectivity out of the window right at the beginning Says the person who draws conclusions based on anecdotal evidence. My money is on the study with data, not the random internet person who actively looks for arguments supporting their existing beliefs.