8 ms·
Square jumps in market debut
- pkaye 11y agoSo they basically left money on the table?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chimeracoder 11y agoThese days, you "have to" leave money on the table, or your IPO is deemed a "failure" (see: Facebook).
- joeblau 11y agoI was going to ask the same question. This seems like a valid reasoning for why. Facebook seems to have rebounded from that event pretty well with its stock price over $100 right now.
- maxerickson 11y agoI think that isn't fair to IPOs other than Facebook. Facebook was unusual in having the leverage to snub the banks and price strong.
- uptown 11y agoWhat would you rather have ... less money but CNBC and the internet calling you a huge success, or more capital available to run your business but CNBC and today's internet echo chamber calling you a failure. I'd choose the latter.
- vessenes 11y agoFacebook had serious, serious trading problems day one that resulted in a class action lawsuit involving NASDAQ. While it was priced strongly, I don't think it's fair to say it wouldn't have popped without the trading problems. We don't know. It was on its way up when trades started to back up and people freaked out.
- hobo_mark 11y agoBasically yes, you are selling for X something that the market is willing to buy at 1.6X, however someone must have made a lot of money on that spread today.
- joopxiv 11y agoBasically no. If you want to sell for example 100 shares, you need to find a price that you have enough buyers to sell them, in this case they decided on $9. If afterwards there are 5 buyers that want to pay $14 for a share, then the price will go up to $14 based on these 5 shares that are traded. But this absolutely does not mean that you would have found enough buyers for all 100 shares if you initially priced them at $14.
- hobo_mark 11y agoGood point.
- roymurdock 11y agoNot unusual for highly hyped IPOs to "pop". Underwriters and the first tier of investors like to structure IPO pricing this way so they get a guaranteed exit on the initial craze to buy and beat out subsequent buyers. Facebook IPO'd at $38, popped up to $45, closed at $38 on the first day, then plummeted down to $27 a week after the IPO. Now its at $107. Anything can happen.
- jjb123 11y agoI actually don't know the answer to this - but is the situation as straightforward as: "they left money on the table today, but it's in the effort to improve perception and health of the company - and they will be able to sell more down the road with the boost of momentum and health of the stock performance from IPO. At that point, they can capture the value created by an event like today (where they purposefully leave some money on the table) for the move to be net-net positive?
- steven2012 11y agoYes. The investment bankers and mutual fund companies fucked Square for $100M. The difference between this and other IPOs is that Square is undercapitalized at this point and needs the cash, so the 100M would have gone a long way.
- ju-st 11y agoMy impression is that the media event of an IPO is higher valued than the money
- prostoalex 11y agoDon't forget that the first day is reserved for enthusiasts and people highly engaged in speculation with the hopes to get on the "ground floor" of something big. Small float, everybody who matters is still under lock-up. Here's another IPO that went up 56% the first day http://techcrunch.com/2014/12/11/lending-clubs-ipo-pops-56-in-its-first-day-sets-stage-for-hortonworks-and-new-relic-offerings/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/12/11/lending-clubs-ipo-pops-56-i... and Google Finance tells a rather somber "where are they now" story.
- strongcrypto 11y agoFrom what I remember, IPO prices tend to aim about 15% below what the market value should be. It's a big incentive to get the big players (institutional investors) to get in on the IPO and get the stock moving. Pretty sure Square might have offered a deeper discount to make the offering look successful. Regardless of the actual prevalence of that strategy, I don't think we'll have a meaningful narrative about Square's IPO until the market has it for at least a few days.
- noroom 11y agoWhat you remember from where?
- strongcrypto 11y agoFinancial coursework, not anything I can cite but this should work: http://www.crab.rutgers.edu/~yaari/Articles-PDF/IPO-Hauser-Yaari-JLEweb.pdf http://www.crab.rutgers.edu/~yaari/Articles-PDF/IPO-Hauser-Y.... Estimates that this IPO discount is around 18.4% in the US. "The price discount varies over time and across initial public offering (IPO) mechanisms but remains economically significant everywhere. Span- ning 4 decades and 38 countries, Ritter’s (2003) survey of international studies reports a mean first-day return (commonly equated with the offer price discount, or underpricing) ranging from 5.4 percent (Denmark) to 257 percent (China), with a median return of 20.7 percent...[the] U.S. mean return [was] 18.4 percent [from] 1960–2001"
- Bud 11y agoThis is no surprise for anyone who is using Square Cash. Clearly the best product on the market for its purpose.
- natrius 11y agoIt seems unlikely that they'll be able to transfer money for free indefinitely. Their competitors hold on to balances for a reason: it's the only way to build a sustainable business on top of free money transfers.
- ethanbond 11y agoSquare Cash uses the refund rails, no? And aren't those actually free (albeit an exploit of the transfer system)?
- glass_of_water 11y agoSquare Cash recently introduced the ability to send money w/ your credit card (before it was just debit). Square takes 3% of those transactions. Also, I think they charge 1.9% for non-personal use when sending money w/ a debit card.
- xux 11y agoThe product and IPO price have literally zero correlation.
- wslh 11y agoIt is weird that I can't find neither the SQ symbol or SQUARE in Google Finances but it is available on Yahoo.
- jonknee 11y agoNot that surprising, IPO days are weird for that sort of thing. It will show up here: http://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ASQ http://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ASQ
- mcpherrinm 11y agoIn my experience, stocks never show up immediately after IPO on google finance. I always end up using Yahoo to watch the price for the first few days.
- jonknee 11y agoIt's really a shame that Google has abandoned Google Finance. Seems like a pretty low-cost high-reward vertical for them (advertising to people who care about financial markets is lucrative).
- Grazester 11y agoHad the same issue with Ferrari's IPO for half the day on Google Finance
- tedmiston 11y agoI have the same issue with most IPOs on Robinhood too.
- marcusestes 11y agoThe financial press has spent the last two weeks lambasting them for a valuation that was essentially a down round from their last private financing. I'm sure they were aiming for a small pop, but 60% does make it look like they left money on the table and that they might have taken some of the heat off the criticism around the discounted valuation. They just needed to get the deal done (http://avc.com/2015/11/getting-the-deal-done/_ http://avc.com/2015/11/getting-the-deal-done/_.
- tosseraccount 11y agoHow much of the stock is publicly available? What is the corporate structure, i.e. is this a one share, one vote set up?
- ksherlock 11y ago"We have two classes of authorized common stock: the Class A common stock offered hereby and Class B common stock. The rights of the holders of Class A common stock and Class B common stock are identical, except with respect to voting and conversion rights. Each share of Class A common stock is entitled to one vote. Each share of Class B common stock is entitled to ten votes and is convertible at any time into one share of Class A common stock." "After the completion of this offering, our existing stockholders will continue to hold all of our issued and outstanding Class B common stock and will hold approximately % of the combined voting power of our common stock. As a result of their ownership, they will be able to control any action requiring the general approval of our stockholders, including the election of our board of directors, the adoption of certain amendments to our certificate of incorporation and bylaws, the approval of any merger or sale of substantially all of our assets, and certain provisions that impact their rights and privileges as Class B common stockholders. See “Description of Capital Stock.”"
- chollida1 11y agoA couple of interesting things about the IPO. A Lot more the trades happening are tagged as coming from trade reporting facilities, which means they were crossed/filled by internalizes, than is normal. This usually means retail flow( regular folks) using E-Trade, Ameritrade, Interactive Broker, Scott Trade, etc to buy/sell shares. These firms get paid to send their orders to HFT firms who fill the orders internally(ie not on an exchange) and then use trade reporting facilities to notify the markets of these orders. Also supporting this thesis is the number of small and odd lot trades. So you could argue that main street likes Square more than Wall street. With the market down and Match.com's IPO popping less, this is a very good opening for them. Having said that, the real test for most new stocks is 6 months out when they've had 2 reporting quarters, options start to trade and short interest numbers( a measure of how many people want to short the company) start to have some validity. Question to anyone more informed than me...... Do squares late series investor's liquidation preference kick in at the IPO opening price or the vwap price through the day? If it's the former, then the late stage investors are going to get a great double dip of getting a huge increase in shares due to the ipo price being below their strike and get the benefit of this pop. Maybe late stage investors aren't as dumb as people around here have been claiming lately?
- roymurdock 11y ago> A Lot more the trades happening are tagged as coming from trade reporting facilities Where are you getting your data - a Bloomberg terminal?
- chollida1 11y agoYes Bloomberg terminal, along with multiple data feeds and my own analysis tools.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoHow much overhang? (wondering if this a Groupon like thing where the number of shares floated was so small that any demand would have a big upswing, or if the upswing was based on a reasonable fraction of the shares outstanding.)
- stanfordkid 11y agoThey didn't per-se leave money on the table. The 60% pop is for shares that are actively trading. The actively traded amount is much much less than the amount that was taken in by institutional investors that would agree to hold the stock for an extended period of time.
- cowsandmilk 11y agoSide question on this: Are there ever efforts to have varying lock-up periods for different institutional investors? So there is a multi-stage gradual introduction of more actively traded shares?
- zwily 11y agoThe bankers typically grant IPO shares to a good mix of long-term and short-term holders.
- prostoalex 11y agoYes, for example, FB http://www.thestreet.com/story/11666479/1/heres-the-rest-of-facebooks-lock-up-schedule.html http://www.thestreet.com/story/11666479/1/heres-the-rest-of-...
- mikeash 11y agoThis seems to be a pretty common thing. Why don't IPOs use some sort of auction structure to discover the right price at the time of the IPO, rather than setting a price up-front and trying to figure out the optimal number ahead of time?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ryw90 11y agoGoogle used a Dutch auction in their IPO. But then again they are pretty obsessed with auctions. There is some research on auctions for IPOs, e.g. http://www.nber.org/papers/w16214 http://www.nber.org/papers/w16214, that suggests they are too complex for investors.
- evanpw 11y agoAnd Google still had a 15% first-day pop, which is just about the normal size for a traditional bank-run IPO.
- chillydawg 11y agoIt absolutely it not normal. If there was ALWAYS a 15% pop, then IPO prices would be 15% higher.
- remarkEon 11y ago
- cheknyc 11y agoa good sign for the market
- gchokov 11y agoBig shorting coming.
- yggydrasily 11y agoYahoo finance says the market cap is only $340M, but all the articles leading up to today said their valuation was going to be $2.5-3B. Did they really only IPO less than 20% of the total company and keep the rest private?
- joshu 11y agoThat isn't how it works. They create some new shares and sell them. The rest of the shares are held by the current owners.
- btilly 11y agoThe proper conclusion is that Square raised a lot less money than it could have raised, and investment bankers are very happy with the cream they are skimming off the top for their friends. A pop makes for a good headline. But really it is a terrible deal.
- adventured 11y agoThat's not necessarily accurate if the pop today is being caused by average public investors. As someone else noted, it would mean main street likes the stock more than Wall Street.
- btilly 11y agoHow not accurate? The half about investment bankers and their friends being happy is guaranteed to be accurate because they bought low and now get to sell high. As for the other half, it is theoretically the job of Wall St to figure out what main street will like. However Wall St makes money by being bad at that job. Is there any wonder that they are consistently terrible at it?
- chillydawg 11y agoIt's highly unlikely that retail investment made up a significant portion of the traded volume today. I'd be amazed if it was more than 0.5% and thus its impact on price would be very small.
- evanpw 11y agoThe investment bank's fee is a percentage of the proceeds (typically around 7%), so you're saying that they gave up millions of dollars as a favor to their "friends". I think it's more likely some combination of: a) they screwed up (60% is too high); b) they have to balance making as much money as possible (=> high price), and not ripping off the investors they hope will participate in future IPOs (=> low price); and c) current shareholders want a healthy secondary market and a good collection of longer-term shareholders, even if that means getting paid somewhat less for the ~5% of the company they just sold off.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vskr 11y agoIt is truly amazing how bankers always get away with this kind of incompetent non-sense. Every single time a stock sees a "jump", it is because those "analysts" did a poor job in evaluating stock price. And company going IPO is leaving money on the table, which is stolen by those greedy (too polite a term for bankers) bankers.
- remarkEon 11y ago-> It is truly amazing how bankers always get away with this kind of incompetent non-sense. -> And company going IPO is leaving money on the table, which is stolen by those greedy (too polite a term for bankers) bankers. Well, it appears both these statements can't be true. Bankers can't both be so stupid so as to leave such amazing amount of money on the table...and then also be so smart that they reap the rewards of significant underpricing.
- randomsearch 11y agoI gotta ask, why will Square succeed in a market that is surely going to be controlled by device (phone/watch) manufacturers?