8 ms·
Google Cloud revenue could be bigger than ads
- melted 11y agoThis comes from the same guy who wrote the memo that started Google+. So I'd take it with a boulder sized grain of salt. 3 years in Google is still having trouble putting up the table stakes.
- Oletros 11y agoI thought that the responsible of G¿ was Vic Gundotra. Do you have a link to that memo from Pichai?
- andrewbalitsky 11y agoGoogle tried to compete against Facebook with a "me too" product very late in the game. And now they're doing the same against Amazon. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. What's next? Google Doors operating system? Google ZuneTunes music streaming?
- wodenokoto 11y agoThey also took the entire search market with a me-too web search engine, and a huge chunk of web-mail with a me-too solution. And they do have music streaming and they do have several operating system.
- andrewbalitsky 11y agoThose weren't a "me-too". By all accounts, google search was insanely better than its alternatives (Lycos/AltaVista/Yahoo). Nobody paralled the speed and storage of email in the browser that Gmail did at the time of its launch. Is that "me too"? But you're right, the key here isn't me-too. Android was arguably a me-too iOS. Chrome was arguably me-too Firefox/Safari. So why /did/ the me-too Google+ flop so impressively against Facebook? What did they learn from that failure and the Android/Chrome successes to be able to successfully outperform Amazon in (arguably) it's most important service with a me-too product?
- soylentcola 11y agoNot going to claim this is the authoritative reason for the G+ flop but as far as I can tell from the user perspective, it came down to a few related issues with the basic way social networks work. Probably the easiest way to illustrate is to take the other examples you gave (search, mail, and browser) and compare to G+. If you're a user and you are used to Yahoo or Altavista but you hear about this new Google search, you can easily check out Google search and start comparing how it works relative to your usual experiences. If you like Google search better, you just start using Google search as your primary engine. Done. If you had been user@yahoo.com for years and hear about Gmail, you open a Gmail account, start sending and receiving email as user@gmail.com and if you prefer the new service, you set up forwarding on your user@yahoo.com account and tell friends and family to use the Gmail address. Done. If you had been using Safari and hear about Chrome, you download Chrome and use it for a few days. If you prefer your old Firefox setup you leave Chrome installed or ditch it but if you like Chrome, you just start using Chrome. Done. But social networking isn't the same as email or a browser or a search engine. It's about communication like email but unlike email, you can't just pick whatever social networking service you prefer and use it. For social networking (at least in the typical Friendster/Myspace/Facebook way we usually think of it), you need everyone to be on the same service in order to communicate with them. Switching services is a lot more work than switching a browser or a search engine and there's no relatively easy "patch" like forwarding for email. For a massive amount of people and orgs, Facebook was the first big social network that they invested their time in. It was the first one that really got widespread adoption among people who may not really do much else on the web. It was the one that your mom and your boss and your neighborhood association and your local bartender all joined. And when G+ came along, plenty of people (myself included) checked it out because we like checking out new services and Google has put out several that are at least competitive if not definitive (gmail, search, chrome, maps, etc). I won't speak for everyone but I found it much nicer to use than Facebook. There was no Farmville spam. Sorting the contacts that were displayed on your feed or who saw your posts was much more granular and visual than Facebook. The mobile app was much faster and more attractive. It was already tied to your email, voice/video chat, calendar, and photo/video hosting if you had a Gmail account. At the time, Facebook didn't have a lot of these features. But regardless of whether you liked it or hated it compared to Facebook, it turned out to be irrelevant. Because unlike switching from Yahoo to Gmail or Firefox to Chrome, switching from Facebook to G+ wasn't something that only depended on your interest and relative acceptance of change or effort. Because unless all of your Facebook contacts did the same, it didn't matter which you liked more. The real limit of these kinds of services is that they're not interoperable. And if one (in this case, Facebook) gets a "critical mass" of users who might be resistant to change or switching services, it's nearly impossible to succeed as a competitor. The only real way it could succeed is by offering something other than Facebook (which is what they're going for now I guess) but they will never be able to succeed as a better Facebook even if they build one.
- Johnny555 11y agoIf Google can provide a competitive service at a lower cost, they will gain traction since they are looking for corporate customers, customers that can run the numbers and see real savings from moving to GCE. It was a much different situation with G+ vs FB -- Google was trying to compete for (often irrational) customers and had to convince customers to make the switch to a new social network when they already have a perfect usable social network that costs them nothing that Mom and Dad and the kids are already using so everyone is already there. There's a lot of friction in changing social networks since in order for it to he usable, not only do you need to switch but all of your friends and relatives have to switch too. In comparison, porting code to new API is much easier than getting Aunt Bessie to post her cat pictures on G+ instead of FB. You can compete against a paid product with lower prices, but you can't compete against a free product with more free, you have to show real value, and G+ just doesn't offer that much value over FB for most users.
- melted 11y agoI'd compare it to Windows Phone instead: third player coming in very late with a good product. We know how well that worked out. One thing people hate to do the most is learn something new. You have a bunch of engineers who already know ins and outs of AWS. Your stuff _works_. Would you consider moving it elsewhere? I didn't think so. Now consider that there are literally thousands of ISVs offering their stuff there, for whom porting to GCP means hiring more people, increasing complexity of the product (so that it could run everywhere), etc. Why would they pick GCP instead of e.g. Azure, which has _insane_ level of sales access to enterprise accounts?
- Johnny555 11y agoIf I'm spending a million dollars a year and GCE can cut my costs by 30%, I'd consider switching because the cost savings of dedicating a could FTE's for a few months can pay for itself in under a year. I'm a big fan of AWS, but I purposely avoid using too many AWS services that would lead to me being locked in and able to move if I wanted to. Porting deployment scripts to another API isn't too hard, but having to build and support my own replacement to SQS or DynamoDB (and then port my services to the replacement system) adds a lot more to my costs
- jdoliner 11y agoI think there's a pretty big difference here. Social networks have never been a core competency for Google. They invented modern datacenter infrastructure and are still way ahead of everyone else with it.
- jedc 11y agoUrs might have kicked off Google+, but the execution was all Vic, and that's where any blame should be placed.
- melted 11y agoI think you meant to say, "he put Vic in charge of execution so that he's safe when things inevitably go south".
- thoughtpalette 11y agoGoogle App Engine has been a pretty terrible experience in comparison to AWS services.
- secure 11y agoCan you expand on details? Also, why are you comparing App Engine (Platform as a Service) with AWS (Infrastructure as a Service)? Wouldn’t AWS vs. Google Compute Engine be a better comparison?
- vox_mollis 11y agoCan't speak for the parent, but the entire US offering is hosted at a single datacenter, allegedly with 3 zones, but there were a couple times during our evaluation of them when all zones went unavailable. They really need a us-east and a us-west. Not just for availability, but for latency-critical applications, too.
- berns 11y agoThis is not correct. GCE is now (1-Oct) available in the South Carolina data center (us-east).
- vox_mollis 11y agoAh, I stand corrected. Thank you, it's been a while since we gave up on them.
- kid0m4n 11y agoIt single handedly allowed us to build what we did! We tried going to AWS once, and almost got burned with the number of choices available and number of decisions to make.
- Hermel 11y agoYes, app engine does not seem very mature yet. I observed abismal performance of CPU-bound tasks (10 times slower than on my own machine with the same nominal specs). Also, when I tried to unlock the free trial, the whole admin console got locked for a few days to verify my credit card without option to undo anything. Also, I once requested a support call (from the app engine admin page), which I received within seconds, only to find out that the calling employee has never heard of "google app engine" before.
- funkyy 11y agoIf one of those giants could make a user friendly service with proper, clean documentation, then that would be bulls eye. Both AWS and Google are really bad at this and they assume every potential customer have quite good technological knowledge (IT college + 1-2 years work experience type of knowledge) or have all the time in the world to dig in in to countless instructions and specifications. With a first look I am not sure what type of server should I buy to set up a simple website - if such a basic information requires from me to do even simple research - I am out. This is where DigitalOcean and Vultr are profiting the most - publishing tutorials, explaining everything and helping to go step by step through the setup with simple notes and comments.
- niels_olson 11y agoThis. I can use Datalab, and I can interact with everything, but there's clearly dozens of services and options lurking around the VM in the background that make me feel like I'm walking through a minefield.
- yeukhon 11y agoThe introductory could be done better, I agree. I think a full tutorial with code sample + lab account will help people to accelerate (I am slowly building up some code sample myself to train people internally). I suggest to AWS they need to slow down on making new products, and instead focus on enhancing the existing products. Some of the products lack of critical features, and in some cases their APIs are not complete. TODO TODO. Kind of embarrassing. I can understand why they don't do that. Several reasons, 1) they assume people who are looking to build infrastructure in their cloud platform have some experience, if not, extensive experience with operation and building infrastructure. Second, there is a whole support model they sell. Lastly, they have partners to do training. IMO, AWS has done good job presenting intro materials to experienced operation folks in their reInvent videos. I can go on to defend why I think the entry barrier exists, or how AWS can do better. Here is my only tip to any new AWS customers: your mileage is different so don' start plugging in a dozen AWS native services into your architecture just because everyone is using it. Start simple. In our case, we are forced to use two ELBs in front of our nginx and our router service, which eventually routes the requests to our app server. That's a lot of web servers passing traffic. There should be a native offering of Nginx and Apache IMO. ELB is garbage (I say this with a love and hate passion) if you want to replace Nginx / Apache entirely. Anyway, IMO, the major take away of building a cloud infrastructure is "instance is cheap to recycle [if you have the right tool]." > This is where DigitalOcean and Vultr are profiting the most - publishing tutorials, Are you referring to https://www.digitalocean.com/community/tutorials/ https://www.digitalocean.com/community/tutorials/ ? I find them useful, but some of the community tutorials are suggesting (maybe just me) wrong approach. I don't think DO is the first one, I remember browsing Linode content quite often back in the days. Anyway, I think the gap is filled by developing a PaaS such as Herkou, on top of IaaS (AWS, GCE, Azure). Of course, you can build one yourself.
- cenal 11y agoGoogle should just buy Digital Ocean and build their cloud around that. I know it's not on the same level of sophistication as their existing offerings but who cares? It's so affordable and easy to get up and running with that it's easily the best acquisition target for them.
- powera 11y agoWhat would this get Google other than some good publicity on Hacker News? Do they have a customer base that would use other Google Cloud offerings?
- nodesocket 11y agoKnow your market! DigitalOcean users are not likely to pay Google Compute prices, and understand the power of the platform.
- Johnny555 11y agoWho cares about the level of sophistication? Customers do. DO has a nice product for relatively unsophisticated users that just want to build a website. But when you want to move a large application that spans hundreds or even thousands of servers and scales up and down to meet demand, you're not going to run it on an unsophisticated provider. You're going to want a provider with rich service API's and enough capacity to let you scale your infrastructure as needed. Most of DO's customers are not in the target market for AWS or GCE - while those users provide decent revenue from a small amount of compute resources, Google and Amazon are looking for the larger corporate customers that are willing to purchase thousands of compute units and terabytes (or petabytes) of storage.
- bossx 11y agoHave you used Google Cloud developer console recently? I would argue it's as simple as DO, and maybe even easier.
- eitally 11y agoI think it's way more impactful for them to hire Diane Greene to run their cloud & infrastructure business units that it would be to make any external tech purchase.
- powera 11y agoFirst of all, "cloud computing" is going to be a very low-margin business compared to ads. So comparing revenues doesn't mean very much. Second, pretty much every Google business other than ads could be described as "running on Google cloud" for some definition of Google cloud. Apart from App Engine (which is a completely separate starting point than the rest of GCE and is really more of a solution to Google internal tools than to enterprise customers), the initial cloud offering can roughly be described as "what is the MVP that can run both websearch and gmail". As they gain customers, they gain features. (note: I used to work on Google App Engine [and Cloud])
- blfr 11y agoNot to go all corporate but cloud offering has a lot of synergy with other Google projects. They already have this huge infrastructure, and bought a lot of fibre when it was cheap. Standardizing and renting it out only makes sense.
- nypar 11y ago>(...) there are some announcements coming up that will "remove any doubt." I guess in the next few months, it will be interesting to see how they compare to low cost competitors like "Backblaze B2". https://www.backblaze.com/b2/cloud-storage.html https://www.backblaze.com/b2/cloud-storage.html https://www.backblaze.com/blog/b2-cloud-storage-frequent-questions/ https://www.backblaze.com/blog/b2-cloud-storage-frequent-que...
- jo909 11y agoBackup/archive storage is a use case where storing your data far away from any processing power does not matter. Far away in the sense of bandwidth, latency and transfer costs. For (nearly) everything else, the opposite is true. Google Cloud stands out in the PaaS-world because of their excellent internal network. While an excellent offer in their own domain, Backblaze B2 is not comparable at all.
- nypar 11y agoThanks for the explanations. Much appreciated.
- entropyneur 11y ago> That means that Google can offer ever-increasing lowered prices to customers Hmm, maybe things have changed since, but last I checked their offerings were more expensive than any of the main competitors by a nontrivial margin.
- vgt 11y agoGoogle has been the price leader in compute and storage for at least 2 years. Here's an example: http://www.rightscale.com/blog/cloud-cost-analysis/google-vs-aws-pricing-google-cuts-are-first-2015 http://www.rightscale.com/blog/cloud-cost-analysis/google-vs...
- pvg 11y ago[...] despite a later start, Android has become the single most popular operating system in the world. "I hope we're going to be the Android of that story," Hölzle said. This seems like a strange wish given that Apple is making almost all of the money in that market. Surely their goal can't be 'the most popular but not particularly profitable cloud offering'.
- simonh 11y agoSure, the analogy isn't very strong, but from Google's point of view Android is a big success. They want their hosting service to also be a big success, it's just that the metrics for success are very different. Google's strategy with Android is not to make money off it directly. It's to ensure that there is always an open mobile platform with Google services and a decent browser that has a strong market presence. They're actually doing very well at that. But the mission statement for cloud services will be different and presumably include making a profit.
- pvg 11y ago'Google makes money from Android indirectly' is a sensible point but it's not obvious how something similar applies to their cloud services. Or why the emphasis is particularly on revenue. It sounds like there might be something missing or confusingly oversimplified in the Business Insider summary.
- 0xFFC 11y agoYour point sensible , but I think that is wishful thinking we are seeing from google . Comparing android success and thinking same think will happen , for me it sounds like wishful thinking. (android was great opportunity. other competitors was so busy , Nokia,Microsoft, market needed an alternative for apple proprietary product ,and google was in best position and they pushed it greatly , even though android design itself was not the best.but they did it very well.) Imagine Oracle is going to push cloud as hard as possible - and they have fuckload of money/resource - (Because they know , their survival depends on cloud business in long term), when you consider big names like Amazon,Oracle,Microsoft are pushing cloud as hard as possible - again because all of them know this is the one of the most important and key technology of future world - , that kind of thinking does not sound very rational.If you don't have best plan , you are going to have hard time . It sounds like google don't have plan and don't want to focus on cloud as much as possible.
- CodingGuy 11y agoIf Google Cloud would offer much cheaper outgoing traffic than AWS, I would switch immediately. 10 cent/GB is like modern highway robbery...
- redwood 11y agoDoes anyone other that Google use GCE for production workloads? I never meet people who are. My sense is they're a distant #3. Maybe they don't have the storage issues Azure does? Or maybe they're worse. Who knows. AWS has indicated that the network is the bottleneck growing faster at a slower rate than everything else which has huge implications for anything network attached. There is tremendous IP required to be competitive in the space and admittedly Google may well have built that capability for its own services. still the number one thing holding Google back has got to be the fundamental lack of knowing how to be an enterprise oriented business. I suppose that can be learned just as Microsoft is learning to be a cloud business. my final concern is their branding seems komplex I don't like Google "compute engine" as it doesn't flow off the tongue nor does the acronym. Google Cloud does but it's confused if they want to call Google Cloud compute and Google Cloud docs and email all cloud offerings... admittedly Microsoft blurs these lines too. Only AWS can claim to be be the clear compute cloud winner and not need to hide cloud usage numbers in SaaS offerings also sold
- us0r 11y ago>Maybe they don't have the storage issues Azure does? What storage issues does Azure have?
- coleca 11y agoI've been using both GCP and AWS for awhile now and think they both have their strengths and weaknesses. AWS has an amazing breadth and depth to their offering that GCP can't match. GCP has some very nice little features though such as how easy it is to use their system with the gcloud CLI vs AWS' CLI. The GCP offerings feel as though they were planned out and have some overarching standards whereas the AWS offerings feel as though disparate teams designed them and they tried to standardize them together after the fact. But GCP has some big gaps esp when it comes to the network and their firewall vs AWS' far superior security groups. Google has no way to chain rules together right now which can make configuring a pain. Google also feels as though it was really meant for everyone to be super user to take advantage of their web console vs AWS where the amount of ways to segment access is dizzying.
- eitally 11y agoAgreed 100%. I give it a year, though, and I think Google will sort a lot of those things. Just judging from all the press lately -- a lot of which seems "solicited", based around PR pieces -- it seems clear they're taking GCP very seriously now.
- coleca 11y agoYes. It's fascinating to watch these companies evolve. A few years ago AWS was all about price reductions. Now, they are focused on large enterprises and most of their R&D is on features that appeal to that set. Google seemed to be built by engineers for engineers, but now they are starting to really polish the edges around their offering (for example their new redesigned web console that was release a week ago or so). The other advantage Google has is simple no-nonsense pricing. The longer you run a machine, the bigger discount you get. That's pretty much the extent of their pricing schema vs Amazon with their whole reserved instances and you never really know if you're getting the best deal without breaking out Excel and doing some analysis.
- 0xFFC 11y agoI am curious what is Oracle going to do , what do you think ? They are going to as harsh as possible in cloud.Do you think they can take on AWS ? (reading comments in HN is one of my best resource)
- liveoneggs 11y agoYou pay google (ads) to get traffic to your website, where you also pay google (cloud) to serve it- good for business!