4 ms·
30 years is a pretty short time horizon to look at. Western meddling as a driver of chaos and authoritarianism in the Middle East stretches back at least a cent
by jacobolus 11y ago
30 years is a pretty short time horizon to look at. Western meddling as a driver of chaos and authoritarianism in the Middle East stretches back at least a century or two.
If Europeans hadn’t drawn completely arbitrary national borders all over the region after the fall of the Ottoman Empire, if Palestine had been left to its Arab inhabitants instead of displacing them in favor of European Jews, if the British and Americans hadn’t put so much emphasis on securing the Suez Canal via support for friendly dictatorships nearby, if the US hadn’t toppled the Iranian democracy under Mosaddegh in 1953 to reinstall the Shah, if Western European, Russian, and American guns hadn’t been handed out on all sides like candy, etc., the region would certainly be far different from now.
But it’s impossible to guess exactly what the effects of some counterfactual foreign policy over the past century would be.
- mc32 11y agoArbitrary borders doesn't explain it all. Africa has just as many arbitrary borders and lots of wars and insurrection happened and continue to happen, but except for north Africa, sub-Saharan Africa doesn't suffer the same kind of chaos and terrorism except for where isil AQ, etc have operatives. So, Africa seems to indicate that terrorism requires a foreign religious aspect in order to take root.
- api 11y agoI'm sure the fact that the Middle East sits on the world's largest deposits of cheap-to-extract high-EROEI and therefore maximally profitable oil has absolutely nothing to do with it. :) The amount of oil in the ground in places like Canada might indeed rival the Middle East, but it's lower-EROEI more expensive oil. The amount of money in the ground is higher in the Middle East than anywhere else. Sub-Saharan Africa does have quite a bit of resource wealth but it doesn't have anywhere near as fat and juicy a prize as the ME does.
- mc32 11y agoSo how does that explain Yemen, or the troubles in the Philippines? Are they overflowing with rich resources? Contrast Mindanao with the rest of the PH.
- api 11y agoMy impression is that at least some of those are satellite conflicts driven by propaganda and actual groups from the Middle East like ISIS. Control of the Middle East and its oil wealth seems like the overall objective behind the various proxy armies and constant "regime change" in the region. I'm not sure why this is such a terribly controversial idea. You have trillions of dollars in assets sitting in the ground under a politically unstable region, so why is it so bizarre to suggest that people are fighting over it? There are people who will shoot you for your wallet, so what will they do for access to world-remaking levels of wealth?
- Phlarp 11y agoYou think middle eastern politics are the driving factors for unrest in the Philippines? Maybe we should start with remedial geography.
- Qwertious 11y agoHey, where do I sign up? None of my geography classes talked about middle-eastern politics or sources of unrest.
- Laforet 11y agoWhy not? Saudi money (not the Saudi government, but they are indirectly responsible) enables and sustains political Islam worldwide. Muslims in South East Asia have been practicising a pretty laid back version of Islam for centuries: No pork, no veils and mingling of opposite gender over a few bottles of booze may be looked down upon, but never a cardinal sin. All of this is changing for the worse because ME has been aggressively exporting their Medina theology for the last two or three decades[0]. [0]: http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/11/09/islam-is-a-religion-of-violence-ayaan-hirsi-ali-debate-islamic-state/ http://foreignpolicy.com/2015/11/09/islam-is-a-religion-of-v...
- lukeschlather 11y agoA sampling of recent chaos in sub-Saharan Africa unrelated to Muslim fundamentalism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rwandan_Genocide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rwandan_Genocide https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burundian_Civil_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burundian_Civil_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007%E2%80%9308_Kenyan_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2007%E2%80%9308_Kenyan_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobutu_Sese_Seko https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mobutu_Sese_Seko
- mc32 11y agoOh, I understand that, I thought it was understood it was about taking these causes abroad to lands unrelated using previous historical injustice as a cause to wreak havoc on unrelated innocents. Say after the us civil war the south went down to Mexico and set off bombs and declared war till all were dixified or dead.
- msbarnett 11y agoThe Klan? The fedayeen? I'm not really sure your criteria even fits ISIS, really. "Historic injustice" isn't their motivation.
- exelius 11y agoArbitrary borders + tribal politics describes pretty much all of it. I mean, we talk about Syria, Afghanistan and Iraq like they are countries, but they're really more like negative space. Africa absolutely suffers the same kind of chaos and terrorism -- we just don't hear about it because it's less densely populated and the people there have darker skin. But Boko Haram is still a huge problem in Nigeria and Islamic fundamentalism in Somalia is a way bigger problem than you would think given the total lack of news coverage (the US launches almost as many drone strikes on eastern Africa as it does in the middle east). Much of sub-saharan Africa is still under de-facto apartheid. Wealthy (often white) land owners are in bed with corrupt government officials who, while black, are more than happy to continue the status quo as long as they get paid. It's very hard to have a cohesive ideology behind your insurgency when there are for-profit death squads operating in the area. But you're right; there is also no great unifying force for the people in the area like there is in the middle east and north Africa.
- mc32 11y agoBokoharam and alshahab are extensions of the problems in north Africa, they are not indigenous to subsaharan Africa. You don't see the dame problems in Mozambique or Angola or Botswana. These places have had their problems but they don't export them and don't fancy taking the rest of the world down with them.
- mleonhard 11y agoWest Africa is full of fighting and has been for thousands of years. The transition to democracy (and stability) is made more difficult by the arbitrary borders drawn by Europeans. For example, Ghana has 71 languages and three major cultural divisions. It should probably be at least 3 countries (including parts of neighboring Ivory Coast and Togo). The square borders do not match where the people live. For example, the Adele people live on the border between Ghana and Togo. They enjoy half the political representation they deserve in both countries.
- forgotpwtomain 11y ago> But it’s impossible to guess exactly what the effects of some counterfactual foreign policy over the past century would be. It's true we can only speculate as to what the results of a different foreign policy might have been - but after years of disastrous foreign policies with all of the same destructive elements - Maybe it's time to build some schools and hospitals instead of bombing another city, sending more guns or eroding more human rights?