3 ms·
Germany drastically increased its GDP while not growing its population over 40 years. Population expansion is in no way necessary for economic expansion. The p
by adventured 11y ago
Germany drastically increased its GDP while not growing its population over 40 years.
Population expansion is in no way necessary for economic expansion. The people arguing for immigration on the basis of it being required for meaningful economic growth are pushing propaganda, the facts easily prove them wrong.
Productivity gains, new inventions, new processes, stability, science, R&D, sound monetary and fiscal policy - all far more important than merely increasing your population. There's endless proof of this, see: Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Netherlands, Finland, New Zealand.
Or better yet, see: Japan 1974, to 1994. 10% population growth, 1000% economic growth. If population were an integral factor, their growth would have been pathetic over that time.
Japan's growth problem is debt, it's destroying the capital that would otherwise be available for investment and business formation. The collapse of their savings rate has gone in tandem with that, and has further removed capital required for investment to generate productivity gains across an economy. Most of Europe and the US are mirroring that exact outcome, having loaded up on massive amounts of debt, they now find they can't grow beyond extremely low levels. China is in the process of joining that club as well. You can have growth or tons of debt, you can't have both together for long.
- raverbashing 11y agoOh I don't disagree with you on that, increase in productivity is one way of increasing GDP However I don't see this happening in Japan right now. I agree with the debt commentary
- Someone1234 11y agoAnd Germany managed to do it in cooperation with unions (rather than eliminating them, see UK, US).
- eru 11y agoGerman unions are rather different beasts than their UK and US counterparts.
- JamesBarney 11y agoI don't think the case that large debt destroys growth is as open and shut as you seem to imply. You mention debt destroys growth by reducing available capital. This is because the government's borrowing of money increases the demand for capital. The government's increased demand for capital can drive up the price of capital to the point where many private enterprises can't afford it. This is called crowding out. The price to borrow capital is the interest rate. If you look at the problem in Japan and most of the developed world you find remarkably low interest rates. This tells us that we don't have a scarcity of capital and a surplus of opportunities but a glut of capital and a drought of opportunities. We have a large supply of capital and not enough places to use it. If capital was like any other good it would fall to market clearing levels. The problem is that there is an arbitrary price floor on capital. You can't charge anyone less than 0% interest. Which gives you a price floor of a real interest rate of 0% - inflation. This is why so many countries are trying to get inflation. Because if we can get an inflation of 4% we can have a real interest rate of -4% and reduce the price floor on capital.