11 ms·
While the west complains about immigration and the issues arising from it, here's the other side of the problem. Japan has not grown significantly in the past
by raverbashing 11y ago
While the west complains about immigration and the issues arising from it, here's the other side of the problem.
Japan has not grown significantly in the past 20 years and it won't grow again. http://www.tradingeconomics.com/japan/gdp http://www.tradingeconomics.com/japan/gdp
- anon4 11y agoEndless growth is impossible.
- anti-shill 11y agoand some forms of growth are akin to cancer
- vlehto 11y agoGenerally "Physical growth" and "GDP growth" are not really similar. A number can grow infinitely. Tree or human population can not. GDP approximates perceived value prodced by society. In capitalism, saying GDP cannot grow anymore is essentially saying humans don't want anything you can buy with money to be better in any perceivable way. Give average guy huge amount of money, if he burns it for shits and giggles, then GDP cannot grow anymore.
- orthecreedence 11y ago> Generally "Physical growth" and "GDP growth" are not really similar. No, two different things. But just the same, neither can grow infinitely. > A number can grow infinitely. Especially if it's a measure of a scale that's constantly adjusting itself. Your explanation of economic growth sounds like how American capitalists justify the existence of growth economies. Economic growth cannot be infinite, just like physical growth. Economic growth depends on resources just like any other kind of growth. When the resources run out, the everything stops. You can't math your way out of that. The only way to sustain our current economic burn at our current (and growing) population is to move off-planet.
- ingas 11y ago> Economic growth depends on resources That's a point from ... long past. Dollar, yen, euro, bitcoin(!) have no direct relation to resources. So, I agree with your opponent that economic growth is not limited in principle.
- will_pseudonym 11y agoReal economic growth (NB: inflation adjusted) cannot grow infinitely. In fact, growth of the value of the currencies you've listed points instead to the finite nature of resources, since they have no intrinsic value, except as a measure of exchange for other goods and services. Supply of resources being constricted means that fiat currencies will go up over time. That doesn't mean that economic growth is infinite.
- orthecreedence 11y ago> Dollar, yen, euro, bitcoin(!) have no direct relation to resources. Made up numbers (ie the value of the dollar, bitcoin, etc) need to be reconciled at some point. The value doesn't come from nowhere. If the bitcoin value GOES UP it's because people are putting money into it. The price doesn't go down when people buy it, it goes up. That's a currency exchange, it's not creating value from nothing. That's what I'm referring to as a "resource." Not just iron or silicon. The entire 2008 crash happened because people were trying to create massive amounts of value from nothing. The idea that any system needs resources to grow isn't an opinion, it's a universal constant.
- vlehto 11y agoThere is nothing American about it. Global sum of all GDP's has grown for all recorded history. Even if inflation adjusted. If you mean that GPD can't grow "infinitely" as infinitely high value, then I agree. If you claim it can't grow for infinitely long time, well at some point sun is going to swallow earth or heath death happens, I agree again. If you claim that GDP doesn't necessarily grow exponentially, I agree again. I'd say the last one is even likely. But my point was that there is no known inherent phenomena, that would force economic growth to end in the timescale of human life. End of oil could be it, or it could be offset with different energy sources, different types of consumption and more energy efficiency.
- adventured 11y agoGermany drastically increased its GDP while not growing its population over 40 years. Population expansion is in no way necessary for economic expansion. The people arguing for immigration on the basis of it being required for meaningful economic growth are pushing propaganda, the facts easily prove them wrong. Productivity gains, new inventions, new processes, stability, science, R&D, sound monetary and fiscal policy - all far more important than merely increasing your population. There's endless proof of this, see: Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Netherlands, Finland, New Zealand. Or better yet, see: Japan 1974, to 1994. 10% population growth, 1000% economic growth. If population were an integral factor, their growth would have been pathetic over that time. Japan's growth problem is debt, it's destroying the capital that would otherwise be available for investment and business formation. The collapse of their savings rate has gone in tandem with that, and has further removed capital required for investment to generate productivity gains across an economy. Most of Europe and the US are mirroring that exact outcome, having loaded up on massive amounts of debt, they now find they can't grow beyond extremely low levels. China is in the process of joining that club as well. You can have growth or tons of debt, you can't have both together for long.
- raverbashing 11y agoOh I don't disagree with you on that, increase in productivity is one way of increasing GDP However I don't see this happening in Japan right now. I agree with the debt commentary
- Someone1234 11y agoAnd Germany managed to do it in cooperation with unions (rather than eliminating them, see UK, US).
- eru 11y agoGerman unions are rather different beasts than their UK and US counterparts.
- JamesBarney 11y agoI don't think the case that large debt destroys growth is as open and shut as you seem to imply. You mention debt destroys growth by reducing available capital. This is because the government's borrowing of money increases the demand for capital. The government's increased demand for capital can drive up the price of capital to the point where many private enterprises can't afford it. This is called crowding out. The price to borrow capital is the interest rate. If you look at the problem in Japan and most of the developed world you find remarkably low interest rates. This tells us that we don't have a scarcity of capital and a surplus of opportunities but a glut of capital and a drought of opportunities. We have a large supply of capital and not enough places to use it. If capital was like any other good it would fall to market clearing levels. The problem is that there is an arbitrary price floor on capital. You can't charge anyone less than 0% interest. Which gives you a price floor of a real interest rate of 0% - inflation. This is why so many countries are trying to get inflation. Because if we can get an inflation of 4% we can have a real interest rate of -4% and reduce the price floor on capital.
- saiya-jin 11y agowell, they tend to be a bit racist, xenophobic (just ask koreans how they are treated) and super-closed to foreigners
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- moistgorilla 11y agoNo terrorist attacks either.
- nova 11y agoI think Japan will manage. Not sure about Europe.
- Aoyagi 11y agoThe other side is stable economy and conserved cultural values, it would seem.
- nova 11y agoAnd an enviable level of social trust.
- blisterpeanuts 11y ago>Japan has not grown significantly in the past 20 years and it won't grow again. You mean, Japan won't grow again this year? Or ever? Interestingly, back in the 1980s, we Americans thought Japan was going to take over in every market: automotive manufacturing, high tech and consumer electronics, software, even space travel eventually. They were buying up iconic American properties like Rockefeller Center, and Japanese culture was all the rage. Then something strange happened in the '90s: the Internet. Suddenly the Americans (and some Europeans) roared back into first place and left Japan just idling by the side of the road. It was a remarkable turnaround. By the same token, I would expect Japan eventually to bounce back from its current doldrums. China is a huge challenge to Japanese manufacturers, but they are still incredibly clever and innovative. Their aging population may do a number on that innovation, though; a new baby boom is probably their best hope.
- raverbashing 11y agoYes, Japan will grow again if it finds a way to expand productivity in one sector. You're right about Japan getting behind after the internet. I guess their way of working is not compatible with the velocity demanded by this new field. Can you imagine Salaryman getting the latest on the new Angular.js version? (or even JS for that matter?)
- gotchange 11y agoI think that the Plaza Accord had its toll on the Japanese economy and only benefited the Americans and Europeans. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plaza_Accord https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plaza_Accord
- eru 11y agoDid it help the Germans?
- crdoconnor 11y ago>Interestingly, back in the 1980s, we Americans thought Japan was going to take over in every market: automotive manufacturing, high tech and consumer electronics, software, even space travel eventually. They were buying up iconic American properties like Rockefeller Center, and Japanese culture was all the rage. > >Then something strange happened in the '90s: the Internet. The Internet had nothing to do with it. Japan was simply in the midst of a titanic property bubble which subsequently popped: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_asset_price_bubble https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Japanese_asset_price_bubble
- splouk 11y agoTo add to this discussion, the pyramid scheme of constant population growth to pay for the elderly is not going to be sustainable forever in first world countries. Maybe Japan is intelligently embracing these 'growing pains' (by which I mean the pain resulting from a shrinking population, which the west will have to face at some point) now, by investing in robots and automation. I think they are getting a head start in a race against ageing that we will all (all of us with birthrates below 2.1, that is) have to compete in at some point.
- chvid 11y agoFor my own country Denmark, if you adjust GDP for population growth (which is due to immigration) and inflation, we did not have any growth for the past two decades. However we did successfully create a housing boom/bubble, while the Japanese are deflating theirs. Also as others have mentioned GDP can be an amazingly stupid measure where crime or an poorly organised health care system give higher output while harm. Japan is a wealthy country.
- foldablechair 11y agoJapan has been in a debt-deflation cycle for a quarter century and the west is headed the same direction. http://i.imgur.com/PQ6HNay.png http://i.imgur.com/PQ6HNay.png