6 ms·
Isn't it sad that this has to be said at all? "Hey, not every adherent of a religion supports killing innocent people of a different religion". It'd be like us
by StavrosK 11y ago
Isn't it sad that this has to be said at all? "Hey, not every adherent of a religion supports killing innocent people of a different religion". It'd be like us having to apologize for the Crusades.
Besides, the hits were driven by politics, religion is just a facade.
- huac 11y agoWhereas the Catholic Church has a singular leader (the Pope), there is no equivalent in Islam. That is, currently - historically, Caliphs have been religious and political leaders. ISIS claims to take up that throne now, but...
- bad_user 11y agoNot sure what you mean, but as an Eastern Orthodox I do not recognize the catholic Pope or its authority.
- huac 11y agosure - and the same would be said by a Protestant or pretty much any other denomination of Christianity. my point is - while the Pope can speak for Catholics (and apologize), there is no Muslim equivalent to 'apologize' for terrorist activity. of course, the point is moot, because these terrorist attacks were not taken out by mainstream Muslims. the Crusades were officially backed by the Church and its leaders.
- salex89 11y agoTrue, we do not. However, divisions between Christians in this day and age are not such deep or, let's say, unreasonable like between Muslims, obviously. All recent conflicts that may actually have religious elements (like the old SFRY) are much deeper than plain religion. Same goes for the constant tensions between Russia and western countries, not really much religion there.
- kbart 11y agoIt'd be like us having to apologize for the Crusades. Just a nitpick, but Catholic church did apologize to muslims killed by the crusaders[0]. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_apologies_made_by_Pope_John_Paul_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_apologies_made_by_Pope...
- jacquesm 11y agoIt only took 800 years.
- ousta 11y agoare you serious??? How long did it take for muslims representatives to say sorry about the invasions and conquest that led to the creation of crusades? I have yet to hear an apology.
- jacquesm 11y agoIt doesn't matter to me what the other side of a conflict does, what matters to me is what my side of a conflict does. The fact that we don't descend to the level of our opponents gives us at least a moral edge, and it might even give us a real edge in the longer run. The moral high ground is one that you give up at your peril. Not that the Catholic church in particular has much moral high ground left but at least they did this, good for them.
- ousta 11y agothe thing your kind of people (which is the majority of people in the western world) will never understand is that barbary will always win against democracy. It is by saying sorry, teaching to people that you opressed them, enslaved them, telling them that they are a minority living with less chances and opportunities than a random "white man" well those same people will hate you for this, they will always see you as their enemy -just look at BLM in usa, the riots in french suburbs- and you gave them the tools. Hell I am myself a minority - coming from a muslim country - and get this because I lived in the suburbs of France and saw the global mindset of people there. This is a war of civilisations and way of life. and trust me. the peaceful one, the one that always say sorry for everything is not going to win.
- 20kleagues 11y agoI agree. As much as we would like to believe that most people on the ground would make rational decisions in the face of such atrocities and not blame entire groups, the reality is never that simple. Emotions usually prevail and people end up blaming entire groups just through those groups' 'guilt by association'. The fact that this was said by someone who has faced such horrors on a daily basis before is extremely respectful.
- rmc 11y ago> It'd be like us having to apologize for the Crusades. Or like Americans having to apologise for drone stikes, for Iraq and Afghanistan, and specific attacks like the MSF hospital in Kunduz.
- kbart 11y agoOr like Americans having to apologise for drone stikes, for Iraq and Afghanistan, and specific attacks like the MSF hospital in Kunduz. At least for Kunduz hospital, it has happened too[0]. Not downplaying other mentioned cases, just straightening some facts up. 0. http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/10/07/us-afghanistan-attack-msf-idUSKCN0S10SX20151007 http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/10/07/us-afghanistan-att...
- StavrosK 11y agoWell, those were done by the US government, which the US populace elects, so there is a measure of responsibility.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoAlso, since US is a democracy, it means that the people should be able to influence this behaviour of the government, so there's some responsibility in that it did not happen.
- pluma 11y agoTo be fair, the US has had a reputation of sloppy warfare before 2001. The only difference between now and then is that it's happening to brown people instead of yellow people or black people.
- phphphph 11y agoNo. The way our mind works, associations need to be strengthened for permanence (which is an extra-weird process because it can apparently modify memories). More importantly, he needs to get this off his chest. You find people to talk to in the msot unlikely places. Both language as encoding of thought and transmission are lossy. Rule of thumb: A sentence contains four different things: what I mean, what I say, what you hear and what you understand. Putting things into words already is an important part of how we for ourselves deal with the incomprehensible, the disturbing and revolting. Finding agreement, or at least getting feedback form others that our words form a comprehensible sentiment, heck - just knowing that we ended up with a gramatically well-formed sentence comforts us that the abyss between you and me, between you and everyone else can be bridged. tl;dr: it's great that it can be said.
- Luc 11y ago> Besides, the hits were driven by politics, religion is just a facade. I wonder how can you call the main motivation of these jihadists 'just a facade'?
- StavrosK 11y agoBecause if their motivation was to spread Islam, there are better ways to do it.
- Luc 11y agoBut, but... they're an apocalyptic cult establishing a caliphate... Never mind.
- pluma 11y agoHow does "it's about religion" imply "they're trying to spread their religion"? It's about cultural dominance. It doesn't have to make heretics convert, it just has to make them scared of heresy. Terrorist attacks aren't about defeating the enemy, they're about terrorizing the enemy and inciting them to make the wrong decisions -- like mistreating peaceful Muslims and thereby supporting the Islamists' propaganda that this is a jihad in defence of Islam. The easiest way to gain sympathy is to portray yourself as the victim and your attacks as righteous self-defence.
- slowmotiony 11y agoYes, suicide bombers shouting "Allah akhbar" is definitely political, nothing to do with religion at all.
- atmosx 11y agoThe roots of this mess are political: France wanted Assad ousted at every cost, a policy that suited the US too since Assad was in business with Russia. That's why the ISIS was allowed to grow and receive funding. I know shocking isn't it? Now that France knows that the ISIS, retards as they are, are not easy to control. France will have to decide: Either you leave Syria to the Russians or you leave the ISIS be and hope your intelligence will be able to prevent terrorists. It's crystal clear that the population there wants and supports Assad. Obama's on the G20 made clear that the US are not going to change policy on the ISIS, which basically means that they will keep them restrained on one side, but continue to support them indirectly on the other. Putin of course offered his support in destroying ISIS, he for sure wants ISIS out of the picture, dead and buried. Turkey is playing a double-game, supporting the ISIS indirectly while condemning it's activities. It's a mess, but it's our mess. Someone should ask Hollande: "What is the reason the French military was there in the first place?" and the answer will be to enforce Liberté, égalité, fraternité. Some people really believe that. Truth is we should be apologizing to this old fella from Syria (the OP) because he is a victim of Western imperialism as much as we (Europeans) are.
- wfn 11y agoVery well put.
- realityking 11y ago> It's crystal clear that the population there wants and supports Assad. Do you have a source on that? From what I've read there are plenty of opposition groups still fighting Assad (and ISIS).
- ocean3 11y agoWhy are France interested in ousting Assad?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> It'd be like us having to apologize for the Crusades. Though It's probably something Western Christians should still bear in mind when talking to or about muslims.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- calibraxis 11y ago> Besides, the hits were driven by politics, religion is just a facade. Politics, markets and religion are greatly overlapping concepts! For example, an anthropologist points out that markets and major religions formed at the same time, and are frenemies. "Nowadays, the work of destroying such ways of life is still often done by missionaries–representatives of those very world religions that originally sprang up in reaction to the market long ago. Missionaries, of course, are out to save souls; but they rarely interpret this to mean their role is simply to teach people to accept God and be more altruistic. Almost invariably, they end up trying to convince people to be more selfish and more altruistic at the same time. On the one hand, they set out to teach the “natives” proper work discipline, and try to get them involved with buying and rolling products on the market, so as to better their material lot. At the same time, they explain to them that ultimately, material things are unimportant, and lecture on the value of the higher things, such as selfless devotion to others." (Originally from Harper’s Magazine, reprinted here: https://libcom.org/library/army-altruists-alienated-right-do-good https://libcom.org/library/army-altruists-alienated-right-do...) Note these inversions: - ISIS is Muslim. Sharia law economics is free market. (Adam Smith apparently cribbed many of his most famous arguments from medieval Persan free market theorists. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_economics#Markets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Islamic_economics#Markets) - The US is capitalist. It's among the most fundamentalist religious. (About 40% believe Earth was created less than 10k years ago.) So-called "economics" and religion are duals. Very hard for those enmeshed in them to see.
- calibraxis 11y agoExcuse me for this absurd comment; I have a cold and there was really no point for it.
- Squarel 11y agoIndeed. I don't see anti-immigration people and Christians being asked to apologize for Breivik, nor all catholic priests being asked to distance themselves from the catholic scandal of the last decade.
- Mikeb85 11y ago> all catholic priests being asked to distance themselves from the catholic scandal of the last decade. Catholics absolutely take heat for the various scandals over the years. It's just easier for most of them to distance themselves since few actually practice the faith...
- ptaipale 11y ago"I don't see anti-immigration people and Christians being asked to apologize for Breivik" Seriously, you don't? I've seen lots of comments where this and that politician or Christian leader is required to apologize "for their involvement" in the Breivik mass murder, which is nuts. All they've done is doubt whether the removal of border controls in Europe is a good idea. That's supposed to be enough for a guilt-by-association to Breivik's crimes as "incitement".
- jules 11y agoUp until a few weeks ago I used to think that religion is just a facade, but I no longer think that is true. Religion is the center of their beliefs, and a very important factor that drives their actions. When the Boston bomber says "Know you are fighting men who look into the barrel of your gun and see heaven, how can you compete with that?" he is not lying. This is what these people truly believe. They think the metaphysics of this universe works as follows. You walk into a theatre full of people with an assault rifle and start shooting people. This ensures your place in heaven next to God. Then you press the button on your suicide vest to teleport into heaven. Imagine that you were living in the Matrix but instead of a telephone, death is what lets you out of the Matrix. Furthermore, outside of the Matrix there is somebody who has been keeping score and this makes the difference between eternal bliss or eternal torture. The robots that run the Matrix have really engineered the world that way. This is what these people believe, or at least a medieval version of it. Another example is the Heaven's Gate suicide cult. Instead of being based on Islam they were based on Christianity. They though that Jesus was an alien and you can reach their UFO (= heaven) by committing suicide. And they did.
- seren 11y agoI believe it is a bit more complex. From the point of view of the bomber this is certainly true. But there are also people using their gullibility. I have read multiple times that Isis has amongst its member ex Baathist officer from Saddam, Ba'ath party which was at least originally more secular and left-leaning. I am pretty sure that some of these people are not that into the religious aspect, except as a recruiting and propaganda tool. The way I see it is that using the "Islam" brand is great way to have funds and international support/appeal. In the same way, in the sixties, you had plenty of nationalist movements all over the world that were claiming to be Communist. Sure it was also the hand of Moscow at work, but for local people, that was also a great way to secure some funding/weapons/etc from USSR. Also some of the bomber have allegedly married in Syria, possibly with children, I am not sure what would happen to their family if they defected.
- jules 11y agoThere are certainly multiple things at play here. I think the three main ones are: 1. Religion 2. Politics 3. Personal gain For instance the politics around hating the west and hating Israel, and personal gain in sex deprived young men getting to rape women in Syria and getting a salary that's 5x as much as the average Syrian. These three parts are intertwined and can't be separated from each other. Most media focuses solely on #2, but a theory built solely around #2 does not explain the behaviour of ISIS very well, whereas a theory built around all 3 aspects fits the data very well. As for the idea that high ranking members of ISIS do not truly believe in the ideology, and they are just manipulating everyone for personal gain, it is possible but I consider it unlikely. The leader of the Heaven's Gate suicide cult also committed suicide himself along with the others. And George Bush is himself a true Christian believer. I consider it unlikely that ISIS is an exception. It is interesting that the only people equipped to intuitively understand the sincerity of the metaphysical beliefs of a suicide bomber are those who are or were in a cult or fundamentalist religion. For instance Megan Phelps-Roper who left the Westboro Baptist Church does understand this.
- gotchange 11y agoWell, literal Islam is unfortunately a political ideology masquerading as a religion. You can't separate the politics from the "spirituals" in literal Islam. The more you're drawn to the literal flavor of religion, the more you are corrupted by the ideological views of the founder of Islam and his early followers and disciples i.e. the expansionism, imperialism, triumphalism ...etc Does this mean that there's no good Muslims out there? Of course not, there's plenty of them but the underlying problem is that the contemporary mainstream Sunni Islam has shifted from left to right by the early 70s thanks to the increasing influence of the Saudi petrodollar and the relentless exporting of the wahabist cultural product to predominantly Sunni Muslim countries and thus hard-line teachings of Sunni Islam became the norm and dominated the public sphere and one of its poisonous fruits sadly infected Paris over the weekend.