2 ms·
>"The move has a practical effect: It extends the copyright from Jan. 1, when it is set to expire in most of Europe, to the end of 2050. Copyrights in Europe ge
by pbhjpbhj 11y ago
>"The move has a practical effect: It extends the copyright from Jan. 1, when it is set to expire in most of Europe, to the end of 2050. Copyrights in Europe generally end 70 years after an author’s death. Anne Frank died 70 years ago at Bergen-Belsen, a concentration camp, and Otto Frank died in 1980. Extending the copyright would block others from being able to publish the book without paying royalties or receiving permission." (from nytimes article in OP) //
Mr Frank of course has rights over the work he produced, but anything that Anne wrote will be out of copyright. Works representing the output of multiple persons needn't be treated atomically AFAIA.
As a thought experiment: Something I find curious is what law - other than trespass - would prevent someone from getting hold of the original work and publishing it verbatim, it wouldn't be a copyright infringement; I'm not sure it can truly be considered to theft. The criminal liability for entering and taking photos of a work that is out of copyright should rightly be very minor, the tort of trespass seems to be all that could be sued for.
If this stands the precedent set will surely see editors, typesetters and others claiming co-authorship of works such as out-of-copyright books and causing a further malevolent erosion of the public domain.
- tomphoolery 11y agoWhy wouldn't publishing the book's contents in full under a different name and title be copyright infringement?
- rev_bird 11y agoBecause the original "book," by Anne Frank, would be in the public domain.
- Terr_ 11y agoThen there's no point to their action, because it would still be public domain even after their attempt to steal it.
- dtech 11y agoBecause the copyright on anything that Anne Frank has written will expire this year.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoThe diary itself will be out of copyright, the book "The Diary of Anne Frank" - an edited version of the diary (by excision and addition of preface only, it seems) - will still be in part copyright protected. Except possibly in some regions - I think France has an ongoing right to be named as author/creator of your own works - once copyright expires then you could plagiarise the work without committing a legal wrong; though it would be morally reprehensible IMO.
- bradleyjg 11y agoIf I understand the situation correctly the physical diaries and notebooks are owned by a different organization (The Anne Frank House in Amsterdam) than the owner of the copyrights (Anne Frank Fonds in Basel). And the former are unhappy about this latest development, so that may well happen.