7 ms·
What's wrong with inequality? Serious question. If I work 70 hour weeks and make only a bit more than some guy working 20, why would I bother. Inequality is the
by briandear 11y ago
What's wrong with inequality? Serious question. If I work 70 hour weeks and make only a bit more than some guy working 20, why would I bother. Inequality is the key motivator for success: you want more than the other guy.
- mc32 11y agoI think some kind of BI is inevitable. But like the gov't has stipulations when it sends federal monies to states, I think BI will also bring with it the danger of proscribing behavior. Ie you lose your BI for violations --whatever those may be, political, behavioral, etc.
- facetube 11y agoIt's already here in the US; Wisconsin has proposed both drug-testing welfare recipients – already demonstrated by other states to be a colossal waste of money – and limiting the kinds of food that one can buy using public assistance funds (e.g. an explicit prohibition on using the funds to buy shrimp).
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThat's why people want Unconditional Basic Income. Conditional, with lots of complex conditions, is what we have now as welfare, and while often helpful, it's also very often dehumanizing.
- mc32 11y agoYou're right a d I hope it is unconditional, but I'm not sure it will remain so given the power government interests can wield with this tool. Kind of like healthcare insurance, or any insurance for that matter. They all have incentives to act one way or another.
- circlefavshape 11y ago> What's wrong with inequality? Three word answer: money equals power (hah, I upvoted you by mistake)
- jrmurad 11y ago> money equals power If (legitimately earned) money is how society compensates people for providing things we value, why wouldn't influence (what you call "power"?) come along with it? If you are concerned about "power" being used to violate the rights of people without it, there are systems of law which criminalize such acts without preventing individuals from earning more money (i.e. possibly expanding the "wealth gap").
- clock_tower 11y agoJust remember to emphasize that "legitimately earned." There are two kinds of corrupt societies: ones where people get rich and then seize power, and ones where people seize power and then get rich; and while both are bad, it's _much_ more dangerous to be the second kind (power leads to money) than the first (money leads to power).
- circlefavshape 11y agoI'm concerned about wealthy people having a disproportionate influence on the living conditions and choices available to poor people, and a disproportionate influence on the productive output of society as a whole. The more unequal a society the stronger the incentive to produce things that rich people want rather than things that poor people need
- littletimmy 11y agoSome people like to work for the joy of it. Why must profit be the motive for work?
- hodwik 11y agoBecause most work sucks, and 99% of people would rather be screwing, drinking and watching TV all day long. If you remove the artificial incentives to work, no one will work.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> Because most work sucks, and 99% of people would rather be screwing, drinking and watching TV all day long. That's bullshit view of humanity and frankly, insulting to me as a human being. If you really take a look at "99% of people" you'll see individuals with dreams and passions, most of whom never get to realize them. That nice girl who served you burger and fries in a drive-thru? She wanted to be a pianist, but she had to enter the job market early. She is knitting over the weekend and cares about local problems. That taxi driver who drove you to work probably builds RC planes in the little free time he has, or maybe serves in HOA. If you really, really look at general population, you'll see people with energy to build, create and experiment. Some of them get lucky and find a fulfilling job. Most of them have to try and cram their real work into weekends, if they even have them. And yes, a lot of them come back from work and go straight to drinking and watching TV - because that's the only thing you can do to relax after you spend all your energy on a 8+ hour job and commute. It's a symptom. Yes, if you remove artificial incentives to work, some people will stop working. Maybe a lot. They'll go drinking, spending time with friends, and trying to figure out what they really care about in life, now that they have time. And most will likely get bored after at most a month of drinking and start doing something productive. Because humans in general have the need to build, create and improve. Things will have to be rearranged; some jobs automated, others maybe taken in short shifts out of the sense of social responsibility. But they will get done. Reality is not WALL-E.
- copperx 11y agoThis. If I became a millionaire overnight I would probably take a month off to be supremely lazy. Then I would get back to work in whatever strikes my fancy, probably for VERY long hours.
- thescriptkiddie 11y ago> If I work 70 hour weeks and make only a bit more than some guy working 20, why would I bother. You just answered your own question. In a world with better income equality you wouldn't be getting fucked over so hard you have to work 3 times the number of hours as someone else to make a living wage.
- sliverstorm 11y agoWhat if he wanted to work 3 times harder so that he can afford luxuries? Not everyone is satisfied working just enough to survive and no more.
- s73v3r 11y agoSounds like they need to do something smarter to earn more money, rather than just working longer hours, which is probably having a very negative impact on the work they're doing.
- danharaj 11y agoI am bemused that you think the source of inequality in our current system comes from people working 70 hour weeks versus 20. Sure, the Liberal criticisms of economic inequality are mostly ineffectual because they presume the inequality comes from some incidental source, like poor government policy, rather than the structure of capitalism. The fact is, the vast majority of the inequality in our society is between people who make money because they own lots of capital and people who need to work to survive. I also find the idea that inequality is what motivates success abhorrent, but whatever floats your boat.
- dibujante 11y agoThere's inequality, and there's Inequality. You work 3.5x as much as he does. Should you make 3.5x more money? Probably. That's probably non-controversial. Should you make 35x more money? Maaaaaaybe. Not all work is created equal but that does seem like a big gap. But in today's economy, we're talking about closer to 350x more money. You can rein inequality in from that extreme without abolishing all inequality.
- analyst74 11y agoI agree with you. Inequality is only a problem today, because the poor are suffering. If everyone has basic level of living standard (which probably increases as we approach post-scarcity), inequality would seem much less of a problem.
- greedo 11y agoYou seriously think that it's because the "poor" are "suffering?" If all you do is elevate the base income level, the inequality will still exist, you've just moved the slider on the scale. People will still want/expect/demand more. Witness the demonization of the 1%, listen to the inane demands of the Million Student March, and tell me that there's even a token understanding of inequality in most people's minds. Especially in the US so much "inequality" is a First World problem.
- lmm 11y agoCheap, but serious answer: it makes people unhappy. Maybe it shouldn't, but the reality is that it does.
- pm24601 11y agoSomeone working a minimum wage job 70 hours/week makes less than a tech worker working 20 hours a week. They are doing it for survival not because they have a choice. They also have no time or ability to increase the overall demand in the economy.
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>Inequality is the key motivator for success: you want more than the other guy. If you said in an interview that you want to work for my company (imagining I had one and was in a position to make hiring decisions) just to spite some other person, or that you'd be taking an attitude of spiteful competition at work, I would have to politely grind through the rest of the interview and then recommend we never call you back again.