4 ms·
This is amazing. Now things like Garman have no real purpose (offline maps was their niche as Google Map's version of the same was terrible). Now who do I need
by Someone1234 11y ago
This is amazing. Now things like Garman have no real purpose (offline maps was their niche as Google Map's version of the same was terrible).
Now who do I need to bribe at Google to get Google Maps to support Mirrorlink so it works with a quarter of a million vehicles? And to give Google Now a fake telephone number?
Google would prefer vehicles implement Android Auto. I'd prefer that too. The reality on the ground is that about a dozen vehicles in the 2016 model year support Android Auto, while four times that support Mirrorlink (a Android Auto/Car Play competitor). That's a lot of vehicles who for their ten-twenty year lifespan won't have Google Maps without MirrorLink app support. So they're stuck using wonderful Android apps like "BringGo" and "Sygic" that are MirrorLink compatible.
As to the Google Now fake phone number issue. Microsoft's Cortana does this, it rocks. A lot of vehicles totally botch Bluetooth. On a $20 Bluetooth Headset you can push and hold the call button and it opens up a audio stream to your smartphone, you say "OK Google" and Google Now works. Unfortunately many vehicles lack this very simple functionality. They outright refuse to open up a blank audio stream over Bluetooth, instead they want a specific phone number to call (that is stored on the vehicle's contact list). With no telephone contact in the directory the vehicle won't even pretend to start a call. Once you ask your vehicle to call someone, it opens up the Android dialer app and "OK Google" does not function (since you're now in a voice call). Cortana's fake number solves this outright, you "call" Cortana, she answers and you conduct your query. Your vehicle cannot know it isn't a real voice call, it is amazing.
PS - No, Tasker does not solve the bluetooth thing. You can intercept the call and start Google Now, but as soon as it hangs up the call the bluetooth cuts out.
- giancarlostoro 11y ago> A lot of vehicles totally botch Bluetooth. I had no idea, I got a 2011 car recently and it plays bluetooth audio and does calling as a separate functionality. I had issues getting it setup at first, but once I did, I haven't really thought of it sense. My only issue is I think Google should let you pick a default music software somehow, when I first started using it, it would open up the stock music player instead of Google Play Music (which is what I use by default). Now I go into my car and it autoplays, but I have to have the app open. Hopefully there will be progress in future versions of Android.
- Someone1234 11y agoThe sad part is that older vehicles used to work correctly. We have a 2014 and a 2016 model year vehicle (by two different vehicle manufacturers, but they both use Fujitsu-manufactured infotainment systems under the brand "Eclipse"); they have voice activated calling. So you have to sync your contacts and then say "Call Bob" for it to call that contact. If you hold the handset up/handset down button it just brings up the contact list on the infotainment unit, if you hit the listen button it just listens for a voice command, unfortunately in either vehicle there is no possible way to just start a pass-through Bluetooth connection, and from forum posts it is unfortunately common. As I said above Microsoft have solved this by giving Cortana a contact and a telephone number. You just hit the voice command button and say "Call Cortana." For many people we're stuck not being able to use Google Now until something changes, and it is unlikely the manufacturer will improve the infotainment system (if history is any indication).
- giancarlostoro 11y agoOdd, whenever I walk into my car it auto pairs and my only issue is when I turn on the car the default app it chooses to play. I'm not aware of my cars radio manufacturer though. Maybe someone should create a device for your particular scenario, bluetooth into a device that has fake numbers that just bluetooth back into your phone? Just power it on when you're on your car. I'm curious how you could do that with a Raspberry Pi come to think of it...
- maxerickson 11y agoThe problem comes up when the car info system implements phone book access: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Bluetooth_profiles#Phone_Book_Access_Profile_.28PBAP.2C_PBA.29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Bluetooth_profiles#Pho... And then tries to act as the dialer (rather than just passing audio to the phone like a headset). With the voice features built into phones now, the car dialer is probably not the better thing to be using. Windows Phone/Cortana have a workaround: http://www.windowsphone.com/en-us/how-to/wp8/cortana/use-cortana-in-my-car http://www.windowsphone.com/en-us/how-to/wp8/cortana/use-cor... So no need for a device, Microsoft has already solved it in software. There's no technical reason that Google and Apple can't copy the feature. I came back to this thread because I just tried to find a way to do this with Siri and failed.
- SiVal 11y agoI think auto makers, gov't agencies with fleets of vehicles, private companies with fleets of vehicles, public transit agencies, etc., should contribute to OpenStreetMaps, which would then let them all incorporate any features they wanted in their navigation systems without ever having to worry about what Google might or might not decide to do or stop doing from one year to the next.
- kobayashi 11y agoThat's a nice idea but I doubt will ever happen
- justinator 11y ago> Now things like Garman have no real purpose (offline maps > was their niche as Google Map's version of the same was terrible). I see you've never used a GPS in the back country for days at a time. Things that are still wonderful about my eTrex 20 [0] is that it's cheap, it takes AA batteries, those AA's can last for 16+ hours continually, and it's not my phone. (phones are great, but I need it to operate as a phone, when I do need it). And yes, I know your phone can do may wonderful things, and I am as grateful for that as you are, but of the few things they still are not getting right is: use in incremental weather. Like: winter outside, in a snowstorm, on a mountain. Or, being dropped onto things, like rocks. They seem to be allergic to those. [0] http://sites.garmin.com/en-US/etrex/ http://sites.garmin.com/en-US/etrex/
- hyperbovine 11y agoIf Garmin's remaining market share consists of extreme edge cases like the one you have outlined, then they are history.
- justinator 11y agoI would wager outdoor enthusiasts were always their primary consumer market. Who do you think bought a GPS 10 years ago?
- scott_karana 11y agoTen years ago, sure. In the intervening period, car GPS was likely their biggest seller. Now, that market is fading again. Sure, they're back to their core audience, but it's a much smaller one than they've become accustomed to.
- whyenot 11y agoThe best thing about the eTrex is that it has a much more accurate GPS than in a phone, at least an iPhone. The worst things about the eTrex are it's utter crap screen, how bulky it is, how expensive it is (they start at $250), the fact you have to spend a significant amount of additional money on maps and map updates, the added bulk due to the fact it uses AA batteries, and the poor battery life (I know this contradicts your experience, but that is MY experience using one 12 hours a day mapping plants). I think for many people buying something like the Gaia GPS app and a waterproof case for their phone will be a much less expensive and more flexible option. If you are worried about running down the battery, buy a rechargeable lithium ion battery with a usb jack and take along your charging cable. If you need more accuracy, get a GPS puck for your phone. Garmin sells one.
- kbart 11y ago"Now things like Garman have no real purpose" Why only now? Offline maps/navigators have been available for years, Google is only catching up.
- drited 11y agoNot sure if you were being sarcastic when you described Sygic as wonderful or not but I use and quite like it when I'm travelling abroad. I think the UI is much nicer than Google Maps and features like the HUD and night driving mode are great. It's not free of course, but IMO it's worth the money if you travel a lot to different countries and just want to have the all loaded up once and not worry about remembering to cache maps each time you travel.