7 ms·
Why the Web Won't Be Nirvana (1995)
- Nadya 11y agoAmazing how much everything has changed in 20 years as to make nearly every single sentence of this article wrong to a hilarious extent. Thank you for sharing this. It didn't tickle my intellectual curiosity, but it's a nice reminder of how bad humans can be at predicting even short-term changes. :)
- dublinben 11y agoIn aggregate, I'd say the predictions in this article were only half wrong. For as much as we use the Web today, the fundamental interactions discussed here have not changed much.
- bobbyi_settv 11y agoMost people considered Cliff Stoll to be a hilariously wrong luddite in 1995.
- knieveltech 11y agoTrue. And he was roundly vindicated at the time by the dot com implosion.
- mixmastamyk 11y agoRight, I was a bit surprised myself even with your warning. The guy is not always wrong in this piece, but seems to really miss the point, even for '95. Things never ever get totally replaced, but technology and automation tends to take over the default case. His examples of newspapers and salespeople have not completely gone away, but certain have been significantly impacted by online alternatives.
- notahacker 11y agoWhilst it was spectacularly wrong on ecommerce[1], the description of Usenet and the "fawning techno-burble about virtual communities" still sounds suspiciously like the gap between the reality and the fantasy of social today, notwithstanding the greater participation and the decent stab at contextualising the "cacophony" in ways specific to the needs of advertisers and brand-monitors. But apparently he also wrote a book-length version including further predictions about the unlikelihood of computers becoming merged with his telephone, the universal nature of fax machines making them far more practical than email and the practical unlikelihood of Big Brother scenarios. They should probably rerelease it as one of those eBooks he predicted wouldn't take off. [1]even the author now sells stuff over the internet, though I'm willing to bet there's not much of a market for "one sided bottles"
- api 11y agoHe was right about at least once major thing: tele-presence is largely a failure. It's 2015 and most of the Internet industry is concentrated within the Bay Area because people need to be near one another to interact richly. This is a direct demonstration of the failure of the Internet to permit truly rich long range human communication; the very people who build it can't use it to escape their local rent bubble despite strong economic incentive to do so.
- wvenable 11y agoI don't think it's a failure, it's just not ubiquitous. We have huge tele-presense units in most of our offices to facilitate meetings that used to require plane rides and hotels.
- api 11y agoThey also had hypertext in 1969: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY It's a failure in the sense that it's not generally available or in general use. I've also used tele-presence rooms before and they're not that great. Better than Skype or Google Hangouts, but not by much.
- rhino369 11y agoTelepresence in those situations are mostly just replacing vanilla conference calls. Now it's a telephone call with awkward video. Whether society will view that as good enough to replace business trips remains to be seen. Though email and VPN do allow more telework than has ever occurred before.
- sanderjd 11y agoI'm not so sure. I think most of what the article says about education is spot on. We have more efficient replacements for lecturers and (maybe?) textbooks, but not teachers.
- jgrowl 11y agoI feel like hitting a paywall on an article that shows the irrelevancy of the old media is somehow very fitting.
- dublinben 11y agoPDF mirror: http://blogs.sfu.ca/departments/continuingstudies/wiredreporter/wp-content/uploads/2012/12/Clifford-Stoll-Why-Web-Wont-Be-Nirvana-Newsweek-and-The-Daily-Beast.pdf http://blogs.sfu.ca/departments/continuingstudies/wiredrepor...
- jwoah12 11y ago> Yet Nicholas Negroponte, director of the MIT Media Lab, predicts that we'll soon buy books and newspapers straight over the Intenet. Uh, sure. Link to "Get Newsweek on your iPad" directly below the article. I love it.
- n7c3c1 11y agoI wonder what the equivalent of this is today. What are people saying will NEVER happen? Maybe self-driving cars?
- api 11y agoCryptocurrency for real-world mainstream commerce would get my vote. That will NEVER happen. It's only for buying pot, right?
- RexRollman 11y agoMy viewpoint is that things like Bitcoin are little more than cryptographically engineered Monopoly Money. That said, I do believe that eventually, paper money will go away (if for no other reason than to track every purpose for government surveillance).
- gnaritas 11y ago> My viewpoint is that things like Bitcoin are little more than cryptographically engineered Monopoly Money. Exactly like USD and all other first world currencies. Bitcoin is simply the next step in money.
- rhino369 11y agoIt's not a next step because the US dollar is monopoly money forced on you by the government. Also it's supply is controlled to keep the value steady. Bitcoin has nobody forcing you into using it and nobody controls the price. Bitcoins are just bits on a ledger that maybe someone will buy from you tomorrow, maybe. Even in the niche roles where bitcoin is superior to bank accounts, credit cards, and cash, there is nothing beyond momentum keeping people from switching to another type of cyptocurrency. That's why it's monopoly money.
- empath75 11y agoI wouldn't discount network effects. I think a lot of people are going to build more and more services on top of the bitcoin blockchain rather than creating their own blockchain, just because it's convenient in terms of adoption and development and so on. And once those services are there, it's going to be hard to migrate them off. And that will eventually create some sustainable value to the coins. As to what that value will be, I have no fucking idea. I don't imagine that it will be a major currency. But it'll always have some use cases, imo. I mean your argument is essentially like saying: TCP/IP is just a protocol and anybody can switch to a different protocol any time. Well, sure. But they haven't. And they won't unless it breaks completely.
- leejoramo 11y agoAlas, this Cliff Stoll's essay doesn't hold up well. If you haven't read Stoll's The Cuckoo's Egg, you really should. It recounts online life in the 1980's and Stoll's own real involvement in uncovering an online espionage ring. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cuckoo%27s_Egg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cuckoo%27s_Egg
- jsnk 11y agoI welcome these kind of bold predictions, and unfortunately we see this less and less nowadays. Perhaps it's because it's easier to get called out than before with all the claims you make online nowadays being pretty much be set in stone. Anyways, I would enjoy reading bold predictions about the future that's falsifiable rather than wishy-washy useless articles titled "7 reasons why Uber is winning." or "Why less users are joining Twitter."
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoWell, Stoll was correct about the governmental aspect at least. Of course, his experiences pursuing Markus Hess made that quite evident, I'd assume.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoPriceless! Cliff would not doubt have a good laugh at what he got wrong. I was involved in a discussion this weekend that had a similar tone around people becoming too future aware. Specifically when you know a lot about the underlying technology (as Cliff does (and did) about networking) you tend to extrapolate what you know, but when you don't know anything about the underlying technology you tend to extrapolate your imagination. People can imagine wondrous things. And when they tell an engineer to go build it, that engineer starts working backward from what would have to be true in order to have that amazing capability, and starts working on the pre-cursors. Of all the things he got wrong I think there is a lot of resonance in the online education thing. I've done a few Coursera and MIT-X courses and while it could be my previous experience clouding my expectation, I personally learn better when the teacher is in the room and I can ask questions as they arise. Too often I start trying to answer a question to get clarity and get distracted into a whole new train of thought. That makes the learning process much slower and less satisfying for me.
- scott_s 11y agoAgreed on education, in that what we currently have is not a replacement for a human teacher. But I think he still missed how valuable the internet now is for research of all levels, from the kind of research that gets published in academic journals, to the kind a 10-year-old does to learn about dinosaurs.
- ricksplat 11y agoAgree on education - it's not just the teacher, it's also about being part of an actual class - the social dimension if you will - you learn as much from your classmates as you do from your teachers and indeed as many opportunities arise through the network you develop there too. Another benefit is that being part of a herd forces you to keep moving briskly through the material without getting to stuck on any one thing. There is a lot to be said too for the social support that is available when you have direct access to teachers and classmates. Doing any challenging course of learning is sufficiently taxing in this regard. I do see many online and distance learning approaches trying to tackle some of these confounding "emotional" aspects to education but I don't think they're quite there yet.
- SilasX 11y agoSemi-OT: Kind of an odd metaphor to use, the year after the band Nirvana "ended" with the death of the lead. The web won't end with a shock to its head? I see this problem a lot: even if you know what a metaphor refers to, it can be unclear how its use is intended: arms-length transaction: so wait, within arms length, or beyond arms length? (The term is used for the latter.) sanguine: sang ... blood? So you feel bloody about this? What does that have to do with optimism? (I know, the four humors thing, but it's still weird.)
- dragonwriter 11y ago> arms-length transaction: so wait, within arms length, or beyond arms length? (The term is used for the latter.) Actually, its usually used to mean at arms-length, neither closer nor farther: maintaining a distance that is close enough for the contact necessary to perform the transaction, but no closer.
- zeckalpha 11y agoNirvana was a thing before the band.