8 ms·
The end of Haiti?
- jleyank 17y agoPerhaps it's (finally) time to see the OPEC and other resource-rich countries step up and rebuild Haiti?
- maxklein 17y agoWhy OPEC countries? These are oil producing countries, but very few of them belong to the rich countries in the world. I think that perhaps the richest countries in the world should help rebuild the devastation of one of the poorest countries in the world.
- jfornear 17y agoI think he meant OECD countries.
- sailormoon 17y agoOPEC and other resource-rich countries I think he meant what he typed. There's plenty of OECD countries without significant natural resources.
- brettnak 17y agoHe just had to bring up climate change at the end. Great way to get everyone to miss the point of your post.
- borism 17y agoWhat's wrong with that? (Although I fail to see which island nation will need to be rescued next - actually most likely next humanitarian catastrophe of comparable scale is Bangladesh, in my opinion)
- DaniFong 17y agoIsn't climate change (as a consequence of man-made deforestation) a large part of the problems that face Haiti today? http://svs.gsfc.nasa.gov/vis/a000000/a002600/a002640/ http://svs.gsfc.nasa.gov/vis/a000000/a002600/a002640/
- sailormoon 17y agoThe deforestation depicted in those photos is not the result of climate change, but of ill-advised logging activity.
- pc 17y agoThere's no need to be snide about it.
- sailormoon 17y agoSorry, that was not my intent. I'll edit.
- DaniFong 17y agoYes, I do. What's that got to do with it? My point is that humans can do serious damage to both their own environment and their means for survival, be it on a world or island scale.
- Herring 17y agoGP said deforestation causing climate change, not deforestation caused by climate change.
- sharms 17y agoWhat I haven't seen explained is what exactly needs to be rebuilt? If someone has nothing, and there is an earthquake, exactly how does billions of dollars restore nothing? Or because of this earthquake the world should build their infrastructure for free?
- tptacek 17y agoHospitals, prisons, drinking water distribution, sewage, housing, electricity, police stations, firefighting capability. Is this a trick question? Haiti didn't have nothing; it had a very crappy version of most things. Charge Haiti whatever you'd like to build a basic survivable level of civilization. They'll never pay, but that doesn't matter. The alternative is Somalia in the Carribean.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoI think it is a reasonable question. There are plenty of places without drinking water and sewage infrastructure of any real note. Why then does this earthquake mean that we should fix Haiti's water/sewage. Why not fix Somalia's instead? Given the comments about Haiti's resources it seems it should be quite rich monetarily, certainly enough to pay for the rapid construction of Hospitals and the like. Yes, we'd want to help with skilled workers if sufficient don't exist locally for the timescales sought. I don't think (hope) that the parent is saying we shouldn't help Haiti, just asking why only help them or help them in preference to others that are suffering as much.
- pyre 17y agoWell, the point is that we can't have the attitude that we help everyone or we help no one. In the case of Somalia, there is political turmoil there that could (hopefully) be avoided in Haiti if we help sooner than later.
- philwelch 17y agoThe quick answer to "why not fix Somalia" is "we tried, and they ended up shooting at us, so we left". Oddly enough, we tried fixing Haiti a few times, too. It's not very successful, but they don't seem to shoot at us quite so much.
- philwelch 17y agoAs far as failed states go, this could push Haiti from Haiti level to maybe even Somalia level. So I have to wonder what the repercussions of this could be. Somalia is a "safe" distance away from most of the rich and powerful countries--it's kind of a distant problem that Somalia has no government and even the piracy is kept to a sustainable level. Haiti's a lot closer to home. The US was pushed to action in Haiti in the 1990's, and chances are we'll have to do so again.
- kiba 17y agoThe Somali have customary laws which allow them to operate and grow their economy despite political chaos. However, it would seem to me that that Haitians have no common law system or a customary kind which would permit the growth of an informal economy.
- mahmud 17y agoThat's just offensive to Haitians and downright wrong. Somali traditions are the #1 cause of our strife; tribalism. We don't have any "laws", neither written nor verbal. It's all tribal handshakes and the whims of whoever is in charge. If you're referring to Islam, well, that hasn't saved us, or the Iraqis, or Afghanis .. come to think of it, maybe they're better off without a prominent political religious establishment there. Where there is a will for violence and anarchy, the dominant or pre-existing "laws" only become pretexts, never deterrents, or they become marginalized by "circumstances". You have never seen evil until you have seen religion under the Marshall law of the religious, curbed to the side temporarily, until the faithful reach a given objective, promising to resume their piety later when it's more convenient. (a bit meta here, but I am thinking more of Communism than Abrahimic faiths.) Haiti is from the exact same Moor embryo that gave birth to the Dominican Republic, Jamaica, Suriname, and the two Guyanas. Sure, they might not become a world-class economy any time soon, but nationhood is within their collective conscious. Never underestimate the will of a regional minority to rise up: francophone Haitians are in the middle of Spanish and English Caribbean. Give them sometime, they will be back up better and stronger.
- 17y ago
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- pyre 17y agoI'm not sure what the point of these facts are. All you've done is state some information about Indonesia prefaced with a list of resources that Haiti has. Are you claiming that Haiti won't fall apart due to their natural resources or are you claiming that Haiti will fall apart due to substance abuse centered around harvesting their natural resources? How are these related to this article or the disaster itself?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- mahmud 17y agoI am from Somalia, and I have witnessed its decay right to its downfall, including the three days during which the government dispersed and the central bank threw out its stash of local currency in large garbage bins. Haiti will not die. For one, the suffering has been universally afflicted on all Haitians. This will strengthen their bond more than anything. Even if warlords and gangs form their own fiefdoms throughout the country, the humanitarian efforts, whenever they're ready a year or ten from now, can always tap into that shared Haitian identity, forged through an equally-endured hardship. An earthquake has no one to blame. Probably as many Somalis died as in Haiti (though not in one day) but we only have ourselves to blame, and each victim left a blood debt on his killer, which "must" be avenged (or it has been avenged, and now the victim's family are awaiting reprisals)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- sailormoon 17y agoAn earthquake has no one to blame. The event itself does not, it's true. But there certainly is someone to blame for the shoddy construction standards and grievous lack of preparation. The government is entirely accountable for these things.
- cpr 17y agoThere has been no government, in effect, to date, or worse, a corrupt government that was hurting its own people.
- sailormoon 17y agoWell then that's the problem, isn't it? Look, my point is that something could have been done to prepare, and was not. Mahmud's talking like it's a no-fault act of god that's going to bring everyone together in a solidarity of fellow suffering - I'm saying, if I was Haitian and I'd somehow managed to survive this disaster, I'd compare to how other countries deal with this kind of thing and probably be more angry than ever. Update: I am evidently not stating my point very well. I'm not looking for a scapegoat. I'm trying to raise the possibility that these low expectations of government, this disregard for accountability, and this willingness to dismiss gross negligence and incompetence as somehow inherent in these "other" societies are a big part of the problem. "No-one to blame" indeed. Let me tell you what would happen to the mayor of a Japanese town if he let this happen and then just shrugged his shoulders and claimed there was "no-one to blame".
- ars 17y agoHistorically disasters (and wars) have the opposite effect. In the short term it's terrible, but long term a disaster usually spurs rebuilding and economic activity that results in a better situation than what was there before.
- borism 17y agoPretty ridiculous statement in my opinion. Life goes on, disaster or not. There's supposedly always better situation in the future, it is pretty dubious to claim that wars and cataclysms accelerate long term development.
- timwiseman 17y agoThere's supposedly always better situation in the future, it is pretty dubious to claim that wars and cataclysms accelerate long term development. It depends on what you mean. Wars have historically accelerated technology development, at least in the short term. If you mean development more generally, then no probably not. The civilian technology would eventually get developped, if more slowly without the major push of a war. In the process, people and resources are destroyed.
- borism 17y agoOf course I mean human development. Tech development is self accelerating (with main constraint being human developers, who's numbers wars and catastrophes reduce, btw). Conflicts provide some bump, but I would say it's pretty insignificant in the large scheme of things.
- ars 17y agoI didn't say development. I said economic activity.
- chrischen 17y agoPerhaps it's like accelerating your car. You gain more speed faster at the expense of efficiency.
- gills 17y agoThe end of conflating failed states, earthquakes, and AGW?
- flamoot 17y agohttp://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1053831 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1053831 would someone vote for this one time
- LostInTheWoods 17y agoSome countries should be disbanded. Their citizens should be given a passport to the country of their choice along with a 1-way ticket and a small stipend.
- borism 17y agoAll countries should be disbanded. Thank you very much for your exceptionalism.
- _ck_ 17y agoHow about we send a "surge" of 30,000 aid workers? Or does that only work if we are declaring war on people?
- tennisman120 17y agoThis earthquake can be noting but good for Haiti. People saw and heard there were problems and poverty here, but did nothing. Now due to the earthquake, people see and and millions of dollars are pouring and and will continue too. It is going to spur growth and economic activity. like ars said, bad initially, but great in the long run.
- timwiseman 17y agoThis MAY end up being good the economy of Haiti in the long run, but it is a huge tragedy in a human scale. Also, remember that for it to help their economy, that humanitarian aid has to stick around for the rebuilding. If everyone makes a huge push to help right now, but then stops as soon as all the bodies are collected, it will not help.
- kingkawn 17y agonothing but good? seriously?
- adharmad 17y agoBroken window fallacy
- timwiseman 17y agoThis does not apply in this case because it is bringing in resources from outside of the country. The broken window fallacy only applies in a relatively closed system. Of course, even if this DOES improve the economy (and I am not saying it will, just that it does not violate the broken window fallacy if it does) this was a horrible tragedy with an enormous deathtoll.
- adharmad 17y agoAgreed..it does not seem to be broken window fallacy....sloppy on my part.
- WalkingDead 17y ago
- patrickgzill 17y agoDoes the Dominican Republic want Haiti? I don't think so considering how hard they are on Haitians who try to go to the DR part of the island. Will the USA take on Haiti and make it a second Puerto Rico? I don't think so; for one, it would be expensive; two, all the Haitians would move to the USA as soon as they could; and there are probably other reasons as well. So my analysis shows that Haiti will remain a barely functioning country as it was before and it will not "end". After all, Bangladesh has it bad every year due to the extensive flooding and naturally occurring arsenic in the groundwater; but they still exist.
- datums 17y agoPuerto Rico was invaded by the United States. Haiti has great sadness in it's history. A large portion of their population is > 19 yrs old. There's a well known problem of child sex slaves in Haiti.
- yardie 17y agoI think you mean <.
- drinian 17y agoUnfortunately, the other two recent American protectorates, Iraq and Afghanistan, have had mixed results. Iraq seems to be doing better because it had pre-existing infrastructure. Afghanistan might be a better analogy. At least it's geographically far smaller, and easy to support from the continental US. There are currently several thousand US troops in Haiti performing aid activities; I would bet that we could get a UN mandate if so desired.
- Alex3917 17y agoDid anyone else hear the NPR special on Haiti the day before the earthquake? They were saying how even though the country was extremely poor, investors were lining up to put in money to train workers and start companies, in part because of Clinton. They were saying how this was probably Haiti's last chance, and if anything else went wrong it would probably be the end of the country. Then this.
- roundsquare 17y agoPotentially relevant TED talk: http://www.ted.com/talks/paul_collier_s_new_rules_for_rebuilding_a_broken_nation.html http://www.ted.com/talks/paul_collier_s_new_rules_for_rebuil...
- gphil 17y agoGiven the fact that even before the quake, Haiti was a hotbed of gang activity, and now that many more of its criminals have escaped from prison, I can't help but worry that all of this aid money being handed over is going to ultimately fall into the wrong hands.
- 1gor 17y agoThe concluding remark about 'climate refugees' is out of place in this otherwise very important discussion about failed states. Climate change and its perceived influence on the mankind is a very controversial subject, and today most of people's suffering from poverty and misgovernment has nothing to do with it. Advancing your own pet theories using a real-life tragedy as a prop is a bad taste.
- sukuriant 17y agoAgreed, and I quarreled with that statement briefly. What I think the author is trying to say is that soon, there will be climate refugees, and when that happens, we'll need to know what to do with them, and we can use this event as an example on how the world should handle it. It wasn't necessary in the argument, and yes, he was pushing his theories, but it may not have been so completely insulting as: "climate changed caused an earthquake!"
- borism 17y agoClimate change and its perceived influence on the mankind is a very controversial subject, and today most of people's suffering from poverty and misgovernment has nothing to do with it. The fact that a lot of people today suffer from poverty and misgovernment is indeed not entirely due to climate change (although there is dutch disease/resource curse: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse) However it is not hard to realize that those suffering right now will suffer even more were climate change effects as severe as some scientist predict, is it?