4 ms·
I am surprised by this line, Alternatively, the treaty can also take effect if it’s ratified by half the countries representing 85 per cent of the zone’s econom
by btilly 11y ago
I am surprised by this line, Alternatively, the treaty can also take effect if it’s ratified by half the countries representing 85 per cent of the zone’s economy. Is this something that the negotiators really had the power to agree and bind their countries to???
The US constitution is very clear that the negotiators lack that power. However the question can't come up because the USA is about 16% of the world economy, so you can't get to the 85% of the economy figure without the USA.
But Canadian law is not entirely dissimilar. Specifically Canada may have signed it, but according to http://www.parl.gc.ca/content/lop/researchpublications/2008-45-e.htm#a5 http://www.parl.gc.ca/content/lop/researchpublications/2008-..., Canada is not bound by the agreement until it is ratified. And even then it does not have any force in Canadian domestic law until Parliament has passed specific bills to implement it. So Canada shouldn't be bound by this, and the negotiators were in the wrong to promise what they had no authority to promise.
I'm sure that the US and Canada are not the only two countries where the negotiators did not rightly have power to bind their countries to that term. So why is this term considered binding rather than being pointed to as a clear example of overreach??
- dragonwriter 11y ago> I am surprised by this line, Alternatively, the treaty can also take effect if it’s ratified by half the countries representing 85 per cent of the zone’s economy. Is this something that the negotiators really had the power to agree and bind their countries to??? Of course the negotiators don't, only the ratifying authorities have the power to bind, but that's true of all of the rest of the treaty (and every treaty) as well: note that, in that case, in comes into effect between those who ratified it. So, only for those for whom those with the power to bind the country did so (including agreeing to that condition for it going into effect.) NOTE: This type of minimum threshold clause is common in agreements (many multilateral treaties have something like it.) The idea being that the prospective parties don't think that the restrictions are worthwhile unless there is a sufficiently-large group joining the arrangement.
- btilly 11y agoThat sounds very reasonable. OK, TPP doesn't. But that term does.
- burke 11y ago(IANAL and I haven't even read the document) My interpretation of that has been to safeguard against a smaller country or two dropping out: For example, if NZ bailed at the last minute, the agreement would still hold between the other 11 countries to whatever extent is applicable. However, if some critical mass of countries all drop out, the whole agreement is invalidated. In this sense, the negotiators didn't bind their countries to anything; they just set some terms regarding what does and does not invalidate the entire agreement.
- morgante 11y agoOf course it doesn't bind people who haven't ratified it yet. Rather, that clause is to make clear that the agreement will become binding for those who have ratified it once 85% have ratified (preventing a holdout from slowing down the majority). Notably, a similar protocol was used for the adoption of the US Constitution (see Article VII).
- adventured 11y agoThe US is 23% of global GDP per the IMF's 2015 projections, which take into account the rather significant shift in currencies globally in the last year. Going by 2014 IMF numbers, the US was 22%. The World Bank and UN both have similar figures.