5 ms·
Ad Blockers Will Change How Ads Are Sold
- jacquesm 11y ago> We know the oldest segment of the internet doesn’t block ads very much. By contrast, the rate will skyrocket for a younger, more tech-savvy crowd. That's so contrary to my own experience, I wonder what evidence they used for that. It's also interesting that they see the 'kind' of ads as a problem, rather than the industry and its way of applying technology as a whole. Ads are a bunch of payload requiring bandwidth (sometimes in short supply), cpu power (and so reduce battery life), waste the recipients time, have been used to spread malware and viruses and are used to track people and build profiles on them. None of those factors have anything at all to do with the content or the format of the ads, and each of those by itself is a very valid reason to install an adblocker, combined the decision is an absolute no-brainer. For a day or so I used chrome (where I normally use firefox but that browser is currently occupied with a rather long running macro) and my chrome install does not have an adblocker. It's absolutely incredible how much worse the situation has gotten since I started using adblockers. The advertising industry is the problem, not the ads themselves and I fail to see how they're going to get us out of this mess short of running into a very solid wall. The fact that the largest advertising company on the planet makes a browser is telling, that may be in the long run the only way ads will survive, by being tied directly to a browser manufacturer which presumably will give them some way to force ads onto your screen. Personally I can't wait for the implosion of the advertising industry, sooner is better. Then we can go back to a web that 'just works' instead of this continuous barrage of commercial junk. If the web were a radio station we'd be listening to 10 second music fragments interrupted with 12 minute advertising blocks.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- geditdk 11y ago>Personally I can't wait for the implosion of the advertising industry, sooner is better. Then we can go back to a web that 'just works' instead of this continuous barrage of commercial junk. 100% agree. Also, pretty sure I'm not the only one who has started boycotting a product only because it's barrage of advertising is annoying.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> Also, pretty sure I'm not the only one who has started boycotting a product only because it's barrage of advertising is annoying. You're not the only one. In my case, I for instance decided to never use Groupon because of a barrage of pink and yellow ads I got once (before someone asks again - I'm pretty pretty sure this was way before I've heard any controversy about Groupon).
- m0nty 11y ago> more than eight out of ten admitted using an ad blocker As if we should feel guilty about it.
- jacquesm 11y agoHey, at least he spread the knowledge to the remaining two. We're a step or two away from getting internet content delivered as one giant .png file with the ads embedded in the page and an oldfashioned clickable map (remember those?) for links and advertising. That's one way of delivering advertising that can't be blocked that I can think of.
- aikah 11y ago> We're a step or two away from getting internet content delivered as one giant .png Well at least it would be a bit more secure ;) but they won't do this. They'll first block users that use ad-blockers then they will just do some sponsored article with brands or just paywall their news sites. Either way it's the end of ad networks as we know them.
- jacquesm 11y ago> They'll first block users that use ad-blockers then they will just do some sponsored article with brands or just paywall their news sites. That requires a website publisher to act against their visitors. Now, some websites will no doubt do this but they're signing their own deathwarrant with a strategy like that. The advertising industry is relatively powerless when it comes to adblocking, the first ad network that blocks access to the pages of the sites it is running on for users of adblockers will surely see a pretty steep drop in the number of websites they're still allowed to serve. So only publishers have that power (and I'm fine with that, if they wish to force me to consume their ads I'm perfectly ok with getting my content elsewhere, it's not as if there is a shortage of content on the internet). Adblockers are forcing a whole class of websites into a variation of the freemium model where the base service is free but only a small percentage is paying because they are still consuming ads. The bigger the ratio between free:paid users the higher the pressure on the remainder to monetize. This will in turn drive some of the remainder towards installing an ad-blocker themselves and so on. This won't end well for the advertising industry, but it is self inflicted wounds for the most part. If advertisers had not structurally overstepped the bounds of the reasonable then adblockers would have never existed in the first place. Sloppy oversight on what ads they allowed to be served up didn't help either. If they really wanted to fix this situation they could simply stop digging the hole any deeper. An actionable plan would look something like this: - immediately stop tracking and profile building, announce this very loudly and stick to it also in the future. - strict oversight on the kind of payloads they allow to be sent out - get rid of the crazy layering of the industry, stick to a simple 3 party model, publisher, advertising agency, consumer (this is a very complex step, agencies do not have the in-house knowledge required to actually serve ads) and take responsibility towards publishers and consumers for the ads served. Lots of people would lose their jobs, lots of websites would likely go under but the industry as a whole would survive. If they can't make a move like this they are in fact milking the cow until it dies and die it will, their actions to date have only accelerated the process. One of the problems that is hard to address is that the advertising industry is in an arms race internally, if one party starts using a new and even more invasive technique to outperform its competitors it gets all the business and this then results in adoption of that technique across the board. And all this to (sarcasm mode on) 'improve your online experience and serve you more relevant content'.
- red_admiral 11y agoI use uBlock because it does more for my security than my antivirus suite. Fix that problem and we can talk about everything else.
- lotsoflumens 11y agoThey are still in the denial and fight-back stages. He says: "The study should also confirm that people who are ideologically opposed to advertising are a minority compared to the ones who have installed an ad blocker simply because digital promotions and tracking have become unbearable". This shows that they still don't see the big picture - that it's not just in digital media that ads have completely crossed the line, it's everywhere, from TV, radio and print, to billboards, jumbo-trons and corporate names on structures and landmarks. They are still clinging to the idea that they can go back to good times if they just reform some of their practices. This is the end result of one group (publishers) relying on a revenue stream (advertisers) that destroys their own service and credibility. They still don't understand this.
- yoodenvranx 11y ago> They still don't understand this. I am pretty sure that they fully understand it but they can not openly admit it because that would completely destroy their ad revenues forever. Instead they try to get back to the good old days somehow because money from ads is the method which requires the lowest effort on their side.
- velik_m 11y ago"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it!" - Upton Sinclair
- nsns 11y agoIn fact, already in Godard's 1972 film Tout va bien, it is said (quoted from memory): "the Press has signed its own death sentence, when it has decided to rely on ads for its survival."
- lotsoflumens 11y agoThat's interesting. I haven't seen the film, but that is prescient.
- notahacker 11y ago
- evook 11y agoIt's not the website providers business what I do with the bits reaching my network. I choose to display and render what I want, and they choose to deliver what they want. It's not complicated. That is the most fundamental principle of information technology. One decides what to send, another one decides what to receive. If a company dies because of adblockers, let the company die. That's economy.
- wishiknew 11y agoIn the music industry, technology and economy have worked hand in hand to 'let record companies die'. The result is that most projects nowadays are home-made, resulting in a generalized cacophony where it's so hard to find quality content that people are giving up. This is what's going to happen here as well. There is no such thing as a free lunch. Hopefully this will make people go back to real-world local structures, which are going to be profitable again.
- jacquesm 11y ago> resulting in a generalized cacophony where it's so hard to find quality content that people are giving up. I've never had an easier time finding great new music.
- bluejellybean 11y agoI didn't understand this either, the quality and diversity of music has never been better
- wishiknew 11y agoI can understand that somebody being exposed to this idea for the first time would be dubious. If you'd rather hear it from some of the world's top creators, check out presspauseplay.com.
- icebraining 11y ago
- pjc50 11y agoA modern news team should be financially rewarded for its contribution to traffic progression as well audience quality and retention performance Clickbait forever! The only way to end the arms race is to go back to simple display ads: you get a JPG of a fixed size on the article, served from the same webserver. No tracking, no javascript, no flash, no audio, no animation.
- bambax 11y agoI too was extremely surprised by this assertion. It would make more sense if he replaced "traffic progression" by "subscriptions progression"...?
- Fiahil 11y agoThat's a subtle hint to the extended corruption spayed by advertising. Publishers' jargon is centered around CTR, CPM, and traffic, because of their limited understanding of the technology powering their revenue. They grasp at whatever simplified concepts other non-technical persons showed down their throat (like "big data"), to keep their illusion of power and stability. Hopefully it will be over very soon.
- jacquesm 11y agoAnd they optimized for those numbers at the expense of everything else and now they're somewhat surprised there is a counterforce to their optimizations.
- Fiahil 11y agoI have witnessed these "optimizations" taking place in the previous ad-tech-startup I worked at. The story goes like this, everything was (almost) fine, the product worked and it wasn't obtrusive. But, the numbers (CTR, conversions, etc..) were a bit low, and since the revenue of the company were based on these metrics ('cause they are easy to collect and analyse), someone was tasked to find ways to increase them. Of course, this is where everything goes through the door, because the easiest way to increase CTR/conversions is by adopting shady techniques like almost-nude-model or underwear pictures, pop-ups (@#$&%$#!), modals, etc.. I can see multiple reasons why advertising like that is doomed to fail. First is the business model; pricing for performance is not an option. Second is the people; you gotta get rid of the nagging layer of incompetence/ignorance of the ones making decisions. Last, the more business advertisers are losing, the more they are using shady techniques. In the end, better let the whole industry crash hard and fast, so we can build something better after.
- Arnt 11y agoThere's something strange about this. We're at a point where ad blockers are used by a majority of the first parts of the audiences. The article and the talks it references all seem to be about how to slow down or halt the adoption of ad blockers so it won't get that to that point. But we have reached that point already.
- mattlutze 11y agoI don't think we can safely suggest a majority of media consumers on the internet are using ad blockers. As the author states, we should be wary of most stated statistics on blocker usage. Neither the 25% nor 90% numbers he gives represent the global internet user base broadly enough for such an assertion.
- jacquesm 11y ago> I don't think we can safely suggest a majority of media consumers on the internet are using ad blockers. Yet.
- Arnt 11y agoMy statement wasn't about the world, only about the existence of such demographic groups. I was thinking about groups such as "urban young German laptop owners".
- mattlutze 11y ago> We're at a point where ad blockers are used by a majority of the first parts of the audiences. Ok. I guess if that meant urban young German laptop owners I was misinterpreting. Audiences of content, in general, really aren't yet close to being a majority ad block users. Of course, the trend will continue if media companies continue as they are or become more belligerent. I don't think it's a stretch to imagine a browser manufacturer partnering with / buying an ad blocker to install as default. Then we'll certainly see these majorities.
- lifeformed 11y agoI wish I could just directly pay web content creators the equivalent ad revenue that my pageviews would generate.
- amelius 11y agoI always wondered why Google didn't build a micropayment system for that. But then again, that might blow up in their face.
- hamax 11y agoThey're testing it: https://www.google.com/contributor/welcome/ https://www.google.com/contributor/welcome/
- jacquesm 11y agoI don't want to pay google. I want to pay the publisher directly. All this will do is give google even more power over publishers which is the last thing we need.
- soared 11y agoMore power? The already use countless google products, AdSense being where they currently serve ads from. Publishers don't lose power. Google relies on publishers for revenue, I don't see them purposefully hurting a publisher.
- paublyrne 11y agoYes, well if things continue as they are hopefully this will become a reality by necessity.
- beej71 11y agoPatreon.com does exactly that. There must be others, as well, but Patreon gets mentioned a lot on the science channels on YouTube.
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoIt's interesting how problem-solving paradigms can lead somebody to places they probably wouldn't go otherwise. "... In a wide study to be conducted globally in the coming months, Google will try to ascertain what exactly motivates a web user to install an ad blocker..." I have many friends who train people. We agree on some things and disagree on others. What I find among some of my trainer friends is that if I disagree with them, the problem must be that I haven't been "trained" enough. They use training to change the world. If the world doesn't look like it's supposed to, then time to do some more training. Google are data folks. If their business model doesn't work any more? Must gather more data. Why do people install ad blockers? If we could only identify the top 3 drivers, then make some kind of short-term trade with them to prevent this behavior (The kid of short-term trade that looks good in the beginning but sucks for the user later on.)? We can fix this. We must be careful that we don't approach problems already knowing what the solution is. This is especially tough in an established and crazy profitable industry. If your tool is to give people free stuff while collecting data to present them with ads, when presented with a problem, odds are that your solution is going to involve giving people free stuff while collecting data to present them with ads.
- jacquesm 11y agoIt's called 'institutional blindness' and the advertising industry will go down in history as the poster child for that particular affliction. Now let's hope they don't take a whole raft of publishers with them.
- soared 11y agoThe assumption that Google is aiming solely for a short-term trade is absurd. A competent business like Google very much goes for long term solutions, especially when Adwords drives their revenue.
- jacquesm 11y agoInteresting. This article is now on page 3 of HN, apparently flagged to death.
- robin_reala 11y agoThere’s a filter based on the total number of votes and the ratio of comments to votes, which I think this just tripped. It’s designed to reduce the occurrence of front-page ‘flame wars’.
- jacquesm 11y agoYou were correct.
- sfk 11y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10532611 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10532611 In this case the flagging is ridiculous and the moderators should ban the company IPs that the flags came from.
- sfk 11y agoThis thread dropped from number 3 to number 97 in 3 minutes right after I made the Google comment. Censorship at its finest.
- corin_ 11y agoA comment on that page: Publishers cannot blame advertisers 100% for this situation. As an advertiser, I tried several times to offer, less intrusive ads in exchange for lower CPM. Publishers never, not even once, would be willing to reduce their price by even a penny in exchange for friendlier ads. I think without any irony.