4 ms·
Even if it is working, would that make it ok? What about rape? Should it be criminalized? Is that worth a scientific study from nature? Why is torture in a ci
by rdtsc 11y ago
Even if it is working, would that make it ok?
What about rape? Should it be criminalized? Is that worth a scientific study from nature?
Why is torture in a civilized society not considered like rape. Anyone who suggests, does it, debates about its merrits, should be considered a crazy idiot, ostracized and laughed at. But notice how we as a a society are debating its merits. We have already lost so speak. We lost first when our government engaged in it in large scale. But we lost again when we start excusing and explaining, even if we reach the conclusion "ok, it is not quite working as well".
- raverbashing 11y agoSaying that something is not debatable is exactly the opposite of living in a democracy Excluding hate speech, surely But since you were very fast to call anyone a "crazy idiot" I can see how worried about you are about a "civilised society" instead of your personal opinions
- vacri 11y agoAllowing fringe ideas to dominate discussions so centrally is also exactly the opposite of living in a democracy.
- raverbashing 11y agoI agree, but who determines what is a fringe idea? I don't agree with torture, quite the contrary, but the same discussion could have been constructed in the opposite way and the fringe idea could have been that torture doesn't work (which I'm sure happened in a lot of situations)
- rdtsc 11y ago> but the same discussion could have been constructed in the opposite way and the fringe idea could have been that torture doesn't work (which I'm sure happened in a lot of situations) Could be, but not in this case. This is about torture. I would say living in a civilized society, a society where torture is a despicable criminal act (that is why my original comparison with rape) is more important than living in a democracy. Doing stuff in the name of an ideology (democracy) is a also a problem. There were a lot atrocities and murders and other horrible things also committed in the names ideologies. That is, claiming things like "it's ok to engage in these things, because we live in a democracy and that is what we do in democracy". I would rather not live in a democracy but live in a country where torture is not a debatable topic to discuss for sane people.
- rdtsc 11y agoExactly. To put it another way, I would rather live in a civilized society that doesn't torture or considers it a valid topic for debate, than in a democracy.
- eloisant 11y agoIf it works, some argument can be made about "the suffering of one for the greater good of the many". The common example is the terrorist that knows the location of a bomb that may kill thousands of people. Also torture is made acceptable to some by the idea that only "bad" people are tortured. If torture doesn't work, the argument is much stronger than the humanist one and can appeal even to "us vs them" people. Unfortunately I think the reason many governments torture is not to gather information but to frighten and control the population. Many people will refrain to rebel against authority if they fear being arrested and tortured.
- bluecalm 11y ago>>Even if it is working, would that make it ok? What about rape? Should it be criminalized? Is that worth a scientific study from nature? If raping someone could potentially be used to save a lot of lives then we would have that debate. It doesn't though so. Everyone agrees that torture is bad in itself, the problem arise when not applying it would lead to even worse things happening. If torture works it's immoral to not use it in those situations, that's why there is a debate.
- rdtsc 11y ago> could potentially be used to save a lot of lives then we would have that debate One can conduct various hypothetical experiments of course. Rape is used in uncivilized societies or parts of societies as punishment (by village elders), it is used by brutal violent and primitives countries as a condoned acceptable spoil of war that commanders would turn their eyes away from, or just build a comfortable quarters for it and supply a steady stream of victims (like Japanese did during WWII in China), it increases fear and makes it easier to control people (just like torture) and so on. What would you think of a society that does it and then also starts discussion the merits of that in a scientific journal. Instead of treating like a topic for lunatics and crazy people we are treating it like we are discussing the results of a chemical reaction, that is what I am talking about, sane people finding excuses and studying torture as a valid topic.