5 ms·
They'd obviously rather have more money than less, but why via a tip? What difference would it make if done as a regular delivery fee rather than the bizarre da
by SilasX 11y ago
They'd obviously rather have more money than less, but why via a tip? What difference would it make if done as a regular delivery fee rather than the bizarre dance where someone throws some money at them just because they're in a servile role and happen to be nearby?
I hope it's a better reason than "they'd like to evade taxes". Even the usual justifications about "you can reward more for better service" are hard to apply here: what's the variation? Is it a bonus for not eating the food?
In software, I'd prefer the end customer throw bank notes at me, but I don't equate that with an actual superior model for how software development incentives should work.
- JackFr 11y agoThe tipping model possibly allows the delivery person to capture more of the value than a flat service charge, depending on the shape of the demand curve. That is 3 customers tip 10%, 15% and 20%, for an average 15%. But when you fix the service charge at 15%, the 10% tipper now orders less frequently. That might be made up for by the 20% tipper ordering more, but it depends on the shape of the demand curve.
- SilasX 11y agoBut what's the supply/demand curve for the tip about? What are they getting in this case for tipping more? It sounds like you're just roundaboutly saying "it allows you to take greater advantage of people who don't realize they can tip less", which is also not a good reason. Should I just not tip delivery people at all, since I like to keep money? I'm struggling to see the model that drives your claim. As stated, it would justify "pay what you feel like" for every other good, to some extent.
- JackFr 11y ago> As stated, it would justify "pay what you feel like" for every other good, to some extent. That's true, except in the United States, in the case of delivery people and servers there is an extremely robust societal norm to tip. Such a norm doesn't exist for most other transactions.
- SilasX 11y agoThat's a completely different argument from the one you gave before, and it's a justification for "why to tip, given the system exists", rather than "why this is a good system", which was my original question.
- JackFr 11y agoNo, that was not your question. Your question was "What difference would it make if done as a regular delivery fee rather than [a tip]?", which was precisely the question I tried to answer. That is, you can't aggregate a block of voluntary exchanges and average the price.
- SilasX 11y agoThe question was, why would a system tipping be better than a system of flat, honest fees for delivery. It does not address that to say, within this system, you should do this. You were giving justifications at a system level, which why I said it would imply that other systems should shift to "pay what you feel like", irrespective of which ones currently use it. And it's not an exchange, if one side has nothing to withhold, but a gift.
- moonchrome 11y agoIt's more practical for both of you eg. there's no fixed amount required/it's optional (if you're short on cash for eg.) and the driver gets spendable cash right there - doesn't have to report anything or wait for a paycheck - which matters a lot more when you're doing low paying jobs.
- maxerickson 11y agoThat you can still order when you are short on cash is a great argument against leaving the tip up to the customer (the driver gets screwed on ~100% of those orders). (In USA, the delivery person probably can't get away with reporting nothing to the IRS, they will have to declare some tip income or risk getting chased around)
- moonchrome 11y ago> That you can still order when you are short on cash is a great argument against leaving the tip up to the customer (the driver gets screwed on ~100% of those orders). If you get paid in tips only sure but around here it's minimum wage + tips. No-tip order still pays to your employer - of course it sucks for you but it still keeps the business going. >(In USA, the delivery person probably can't get away with reporting nothing to the IRS, they will have to declare some tip income or risk getting chased around) I meant reporting to the owner and waiting to get the money back trough paycheck.
- Dylan16807 11y agoThe stores already charge delivery fees, and they don't go into the driver's pocket. The table-waiting model of using tips instead of pay sucks, but tipping for delivery can be a lot of money.
- SilasX 11y ago>The stores already charge delivery fees, and they don't go into the driver's pocket. I know. My point was that, to the extent the driver has a legitimate preference, it's for receiving a fixed delivery fee, not for being "yet another person I'm expected to pay under the table". Thus, I'd love for them to say what money amount satisfies my obligation to them, rather then guessing each time how much I'm supposed to secretly give the driver. I'm looking for a model that would make me believe oppositely. Do you have one?
- Dylan16807 11y agoThe problem is that the driver is just not going to get significantly more than minimum wage from their employer. If you could wave a legal wand and cause a fixed $2 per delivery to go into their paycheck, that's fine. But that's not going to happen. Wait-staff in a world without tips can get paid more. I don't think a delivery driver gets paid more.
- JackFr 11y ago> I'd love for them to say what money amount satisfies my obligation to them And yet, it is in the driver's interest to keep this knowledge from you. What they are getting is the minimum you feel comfortable about, which may very well be above what is the minimum they would consider satisfactory. It's not obvious at all that they would prefer a fixed fee.
- SilasX 11y agoRight, I get the idea of people wanting things. That's not enough to validate the want! I'd like to dupe everyone into giving me money for doing nothing, but that's not a valid justification for scamming. The game theory dynamics aren't in dispute. The question is, why do you defend a system that boils down to "they take advantage of people's ignorance", of what they're obligated to pay, and that they're paying more in return for nothing.
- JamesBarney 11y agoI like to think of tipping as more of a generosity tax.