6 ms·
A Seismic Shift in How People Eat
- jkarneges 11y agoWhat I find most interesting about people caring about the content of their food (which is not a new thing, although I can see it is more widespread lately), is the effect it has on capitalism and how consumers make their choices. In the beginning, the best products simply functioned properly. They looked good, tasted good, etc. Is the bread white? Does the paint stick to the wall? At some point we started realizing that what goes into a product turns out to be very important too. Is the bread nutritious? Is the paint lead-free? Does the movie player have DRM? I'd say we are primarily in this phase of consumer awareness, and the nytimes article suggests it has gone mainstream. However I see a third level on the way: People are now starting to care about the impact of products. In other words, what side-effects are there in production and usage. Were animals mistreated when producing this meal? Is the product recyclable upon discard? Did these bananas come from an exploited third-world country? We're still in the early stages of this phase, but I don't see it slowing down. Being a consumer takes so much brainpower...
- skybrian 11y agoIt takes a lot less brainpower when costs are actually included in prices. Instead of everyone deciding on their own which products contribute the most to global warming (and being misled by advertising and getting it wrong most of the time), a carbon tax automatically adjusts the price of each product based on its impact. Then you can make decisions by comparing prices.
- cossatot 11y agoI think a water use tax would also be sensible here, and maybe more straightforward to design and implement.
- tomp 11y ago> Being a consumer takes so much brainpower... Exactly, and this is why I'm a strong supporter of regulation. I'm not even saying that regulation should be obligatory, or all-encompassing; simply that there should be clear and simple ways of branding foods and/or their contents (e.g. "organic" or "free-range" should have a legally-defined meaning, GMOs should be listed in the contents, ...), and consumers should be getting what they expect (e.g. toilet paper of a certain size/height, and common drugs are not harmful) - but of course, if you want something different (e.g. experimental drugs) you should be able to get it, it might just be a little harder (like hedge funds that can only market/sell to "sophisticated" investors).
- tptacek 11y agoYou can do that now: you can create a certification program, sell inspections to acquire the cert, and enforce it through contracts. That companies for the most part don't do this suggests that there isn't really that much market demand for it.
- redblacktree 11y agoThere are a couple of these organizations on whose labels I rely. Non-GMO project: http://www.nongmoproject.org/learn-more/understanding-our-seal/ http://www.nongmoproject.org/learn-more/understanding-our-se... Certified Humane: http://certifiedhumane.org/ http://certifiedhumane.org/
- bad_user 11y agoBeing omnivores our senses help us to distinguish good food from bad. For example we prefer sweet food because sugar in nature is rare, the fruits delivering sugar being a source of carbohydrates, vitamins and other essential nutrients. We avoid bitter plants because that's usually the taste of substances that do us harm. And rotten meat disgusts us. Plus we rely on the wisdom of our ancestors to know what to eat. But the food industry, in all its wisdom has produced foods that (1) lie to our senses, (2) are rich in calories, but poor in nutrients and (3) are so novel that our bodies aren't digesting it properly. Being a consumer is actually easy, if you can read the signs. It's the food industry that's feeding you the lie that nutrition is complicated and needs expert guidance. Does the food come in a package? Does it make health claims? Is the list of ingredients containing substances you don't recognize? Is sucrose or high fructose corn sirup one of those ingredients? Does it come from far away? Is it sold in a super market? All of those are red flags you should watch out for ;-)
- hueving 11y ago>Is the list of ingredients containing substances you don't recognize? This is a bit of a bogus argument. If you had to break down meat into its component chemicals, nobody would understand it then either. We just have a guideline that requires man-made things to list the components which leads to the false argument that seeing lower level chemicals in something means it's bad.
- bad_user 11y agoYes, but my ancestors ate meat from chicken, pigs or cattle, they survived and I'm alive as well. Compared to rats, we don't have to do a trial and error for everything we eat, as culture is part of who we are and we've been eating most of the same meat, vegetables and dishes for hundreds if not thousands of years. You are never going to see meat being broken down to its components on an ingredients label. The only way you're going to see chemicals on such labels is if those chemicals were added by food processors, for various desired effects, like for improved texture, or taste, or for extending shelf life. It's usually bad because, as I said, it's meant to fool your senses. Why do you think sugar or HFCS is in everything these days? It's also bad in the case of health claims and fads because reductionist science is applied.
- siliconc0w 11y agoIt's hard to tell if we're eating better or just being duped in a new way. "Fat free" is bullshit, "Organic" is bullshit, "Gluten Free" is bullshit (unless you actually have celica's).
- bad_user 11y agoHow is organic bullshit?
- msandford 11y agoWell "USDA Certified Organic" doesn't really mean what you would think it means. You'd think it means no pesticides, no herbicides, no fungicides, and no fertilizer. That's precisely what nearly everyone thinks it means. http://lifehacker.com/5941881/what-does-organic-really-mean-and-should-i-buy-it http://lifehacker.com/5941881/what-does-organic-really-mean-... The reality is that "Organic" doesn't mean anywhere near what people think it does, sadly. It's fairly watered down. It's a bummer.
- awjr 11y agoDepends on if the bull eats grass from a pesticide-free pasture ;)
- jarito 11y agoThere is no standard dictating what organic means. Many 'organic' products use processes and methods that most people would not recognize as organic. A consumer buying an organic product has little to no knowledge of whether the producer is being faithful to the concept. Add a huge price markup for organic products and many producers are incentivized to mark products organic even if they really aren't - and many are doing so. There are attempts to standardize, but none have the recognizability needed by the majority of the populace to make them effective.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- goodJobWalrus 11y ago
- latch 11y agoI know it's asking a lot, but I wish people's eating habits were driven more by environmental and humanitarian factors, than what they like or even what's healthy (though I believe none of these are mutually exclusive). I find the current state of things horrifying.
- jonnathanson 11y agoA fairly rushed conclusion... "Making these changes will require a complete reorganization of these companies' fundamental business models and global supply chains, but, ummm, hey, they have the money! Right? The end." If only it were that simple. The government subsidizes corn and soybeans, which is why they're everywhere and in everything. Derivatives from corn and soybeans account for a staggering proportion of the ingredients, 'natural' and 'artificial,' that appear in the staple products offered by most of our biggest food companies. They're also the feed that raises all of our meat. In fact, it's not too much of a stretch to suggest that corn and soybeans are the nation's food supply. They are pretty much the only crops we can grow cheaply at massive mega-scale, and we derive almost all our nutritionally questionable foods from them. Transforming businesses the scale of McDonald's and General Mills will require nothing short of a complete overhaul of our current agricultural economic policy. Best of luck with that... For a more insightful article with a deeper look into the issue, I recommend the recent piece about McDonald's in the New Yorker.
- lotharbot 11y agoThe article made a sudden shift away from "how consumer behavior has changed" and toward "this is what big companies must do", and I don't think it handled that shift very well. Should companies abandon frozen food research? There's not really a compelling argument in this piece for why. There are still large parts of the consumer market that rely on frozen and canned foods because they don't lose as much to spoilage. Research into how to mix "frozen" with "... but still pretty healthy" could actually be a huge step forward for some of these big companies. Because it's not just agricultural and economic policy, it's also consumer lifestyles that aren't necessarily compatible with a "buy everything fresh 3x per week" approach. Some people have trouble getting to the store that often. Some rely on lunch foods that can be prepared in 3 minutes with the microwave at work. Some rely on foods that can go for a long time without spoiling. While a lot of consumers have shifted away from prepared foods, there are still a lot who have reasons not to yet.
- tptacek 11y agoWhat's annoying about this is that the anchor point the article uses to draw the conclusion that big brands have to change their strategy is the market shift towards "perimeter" foods --- produce, deli, dairy, bakery, prepared food --- and the suggestion that this meant consumers were buying more produce and fewer frozen meals. In fact, a giant part of Whole Foods strategy is to get customers to treat them like a high-class version of Boston Market --- which is to say like a counter service family style restaurant. That has less to do with what ingredients customers shop for, and more to do with the fact that people aren't preparing meals at home at all. Later Also: click through to the report they're citing, and then mentally walk a grocery store and ask yourself what isn't a "perimeter" product? Flour, bottled tomato sauce, chips, dry pasta, canned beans, frozen dinners --- but pretty much every home-cooked meal will depend somehow on the produce section, dairy, the deli, or the meat counter.
- tptacek 11y ago1. The changes in the lede of this article --- no more artificial colors, no antibiotics in poultry, emulsifiers with friendlier names --- are marginal. Many of them, like the food colorings, are probably there to satisfy a market demand in the first place (not for the additives, but for the shelf-stable properties they impart on the food) --- if the market would rather have white cheese rather than radioactive orange, why spend the extra 0.5c per package to make them orange? By and large, these aren't "seismic" changes. Marked changes in macronutrient content would be, but that mostly hasn't happened. Great example: shifts from high-fructose corn syrup to "natural" sweeteners (an almost entirely cosmetic change that puts minimal disruption on the supply chain), or to "gluten free" products. 2. One seemingly enduring and significant change in the food industry is the move away from "liquid calories". Low-fat, Atkins, Paleo, juice cleanse, whatever: regardless of the fad, the conclusion that sweetened soft drinks are practically toxic has probably stuck. "Americans are drinking less soda" makes for a less sexy lede, though. 3. The major shift I see isn't in how people eat, but rather in how the same stuff we've always eaten is marketed to us. Maybe it's gotten easier to handle distribution logistics, or to bring new products to market, but there are a zillion more brands. Where in 1980 we might have had one or two category-killing brands for any given snack, frozen meal, or beverage, we now have 100 different brands --- most of them owned by one of a few major companies. But again, that's got less to do with "how people eat" and more to do with market segmentation: given a roughly stable COGS for, say, microwaveable frozen dinner entrees, customers today get to choose based on things like loyalty to childhood favorite brands, or "organic" labeling, or "low-carb", or "ancient grains". Multiply serving size by calories/fats/carbs/proteins/fiber per serving, though, and my guess is that it mostly doesn't matter which one you choose. 4. If that (3) is the case, it doesn't really much matter that consumers are shunning iconic American food brands. They're substituting them for niche brands that are now or soon will be owned by PepsiCo or Kraft. Any discussion of how Americans buy food they prepare at home probably has to include a discussion of Whole Foods, which has in the last decade gone from a specialty store to one of the largest grocery store chains in the country. But look around at a WFM next time you visit, and notice what percentage of the store is allocated to produce, dairy, and meat, and what percentage is allocated to frozen meals, snacks, and prepared foods. The biggest difference between a WFM and a Safeway isn't the size of the produce section (many "conventional" grocers have bigger produce sections), but rather the size of the prepared foods section, where you can stop in and buy a pizza, a pre-cooked chicken, or a deli of potato salad.
- goodJobWalrus 11y agoIt will be interesting to see whether (or when) this will be followed by a decrease in obesity rates.
- ars 11y ago"freshly prepared meals with locally sourced vegetables and grains" I will never understand this obsession with "local". Local is not safer, local does not embody less CO2 (it actually has more), it does not mean more nutritious, it does not mean less pesticides. Pretty much the only argument that ever made even a bit of sense to me is cultivating a relationship with the farmer - but what difference does that make when you buy the food from a chain restaurant (as described in the quote above), or even a grocery store? Is this author just trying to load up the article with as many buzzwords as possible? I noticed they didn't mentioned "organic".
- tptacek 11y agoIt doesn't necessarily mean more nutritious or fewer pesticides, but if you are optimizing for attributes like that, your best bets are going to end up being a local producer. Not all local is good, but the best producers usually are.
- ars 11y ago> Not all local is good, but the best producers usually are. Wait, so you are saying, if I live far away from the farm the exact same produce suddenly tastes worse?
- tptacek 11y agoYes. It's not the exact same produce. The very best produce doesn't travel at all. If you live in a major US city, go to one of the top restaurants in it sometime for dinner, and ask your server a lot of questions about where the vegetables come from. Chances are they don't come from big purveyors; most will come from farms with names you can write down, and probably buy direct from --- but not from your supermarket, and definitely not from a supplier anywhere more than 150 miles away. Sometimes these are gold-speaker-cable kinds of differences, and sometimes they're real differences that you'd have to train your palate to detect (and so why would you want to do that?), but sometimes they are huge differences, products you simply have to live in the region and buy at the right time of year to get.
- 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 11y agoMcDonalds needs to do more than use antibiotic-free chicken. The back of the house for its 36,000 restaurants currently looks like a mini-factory serving fried frozen patties and french fries. It needs to look more like a kitchen serving freshly prepared meals with locally sourced vegetables and grains — and it still needs to taste great and be affordable. I would have to disagree. Nobody has ever gone to McDonald's for healthy food. McDonald's growth was fueled by its reputation for quick service, clean (usually) restaurants, tasty food, consistency (a Big Mac is a Big Mac in New York or California) and low price. IMHO McDonald's needs to dump about half of its menu. Focus on basic, good-tasting fast food, and making it fast again. Bring back the beef tallow for frying, those french fries tasted great. Chasing the organic, vegan, whole-grains market is a losing strategy. The McDonald's customer is not part of the market segment that cares about any of that.