8 ms·
The future of the postdoc
- DrScump 11y agoFirst posted back in April... original thread comments are here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9334316 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9334316
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dnautics 11y ago12th year as a postdoc? While I don't think the postdoc system is working very well, this example is not the face of failure of the postdoc system. This example is a failure of market signals to overcome an individual's sense of entitlement.
- Estragon 11y agoSense of altruism, more like it. I don't see the sense of entitlement in spending years in low-status, low-paying positions to research Alzheimer's.
- dnautics 11y agoyou stay in a postdoc because you think you're entitled to a professorial position. You could advance to a staff scientist position or move on to industry, or just do something else. If you've spent 12 years doing something, it means you were probably a bad experimentalist, really unlucky, or just bad at 'playing the game'. If you're in science and any one of the three above applies, you should quit. The market was trying to tell her that, she didn't get the message, even when her institution forced her out.
- danieltillett 11y agoThere are no real "staff scientist" positions less competitive that an academic position. In regards industry have a look at how many Ph.D.s have been laid off by the pharmaceutical industry in the last 10 years. Not every field has had the run comp sci has had in the last few years.
- dnautics 11y agoI'm a biochemist so I'm aware. After four years of postdoc, I quit my job and drove for Lyft for a year. Now I contract code. So, I read the writing on the wall. And by the way, staff scientist positions are most definitely not as competitive as professor positions.
- giaour 11y agoMaybe every year she received several rejection letters telling her just how close she came to making it. I remember getting a few "you were one of X finalists so please try again next year" letters; they made it really difficult to move to industry and really easy to think that all would work out in my favor if I just stuck around for another year.
- dnautics 11y agoI have gotten that letter for startup accelerators, but never for an academic professor slot position.
- giaour 11y agoI was in the humanities, and maybe the process is different in the sciences, but 3-5 finalists for each position would always be invited for an on-site interview. Your rejection letter might not spell out that you were a finalist, but it was clear from the interview process.
- danieltillett 11y ago>And by the way, staff scientist positions are most definitely not as competitive as professor positions. I did say real staff scientist positions, not temporary postdoc-like positions or admin jobs. There are relatively few true research jobs that are not fixed term outside of academia (I am excluding industry of course as that is a totally different path).
- johncolanduoni 11y agoWorking hard while getting paid peanuts to have a shot at your goal in not exactly what I'd call entitlement. She obviously didn't expect the position to fall into her lap if she thought it was still worth working for it at year 11. I'm not saying it's rational, but it's not like she threw a tantrum when she got turned down.
- chrisseaton 11y agoWhy does it have to be up-or-out? Not everyone can reach the top. What is wrong with working as a mid-level researcher for your whole career?
- robotresearcher 11y agoThe complaint is that the salaries and roles are very bimodal. You're either a postdoc with very low pay and few responsibilities or a prof with pretty good pay running your own lab. There are few roles in-between. There are some - soft money researchers - but these are not as common as they might be.
- chrisseaton 11y agoThere's a whole structured career ladder between those two roles. I guess it takes most people at least a decade after they finish their last post-doc before they become a professor. During that time you have fellowships, lecturerships, readerships, with increasing pay and responsibilities.
- robotresearcher 11y agoThose are the UK-derived names. In North America those are all referred to informally as 'professor'. Even the lowest, Assistant Professor, is usually expected to run their own lab. Many people don't ever make full Professor. edit: and the jump in pay and responsibility from postdoc to assistant prof is huge - maybe a factor of 2 in pay. The rest is incremental.
- cperciva 11y agoIn December 2014, a committee convened by the US National Academies released a report aimed at highlighting and improving the postdoc’s plight. The committee called for a hike in salaries, from the current recommended starting salary of US$42,840 to $50,000... Hands up, everybody who would love to hire a scientist with a PhD for less than $50k/year.
- danieltillett 11y agoDepends on the scientist. My personal experience is the best postdocs are more than 10x more productive than the average. Some post docs are worth $300,000 per year, while the bottom 20% are worth -$100,000 per year. The real problem is that everyone gets basically the same salary and as an employer you have no ability to pay more to the great postdocs.
- cperciva 11y agoMy point was that outside of academia we would laugh at any company which expected to hire a PhD and pay them under $50k/year.
- danieltillett 11y agoYes I agree, but the PIs don't actually have any control over the pay of their postdocs. When I was a PI I wished I could pay more, but I couldn't.
- p4bl0 11y agoAs a post-doc, I'm not sure people willing to stay in academia care that much about salary. I don't want to be paid a lot, if that was my priority, I would get a job in the industry. What I would like is a stable position where I could engage in mid- to long-term research projects, where I have less pressure and can focus on doing great things even if it means working hard without tangible results for a few years, etc. Salary-wise, I only want to have enough money to not have to worry about it and be able to focus on my research and my life. In many places in the world, $50k/year is largely enough for that.
- p4bl0 11y agoThere is one thing that is not mentioned in the article: very-short term post-docs. For instance, I just started my first post-doc after having defended my PhD, but my contract only lasts for one year. This is not atypical, at least in France and in computer science, to have one-year post-doc. And since you can't do a post-doc at the same lab where you did your PhD, it means that in the course of one year you have to: 1- get to know a new domain or at least a new subject, 2- become proficient in this new domain or subject to the point you can publish something in a good peer-reviewed journal or conference, 3- apply for competitive faculty positions and/or another post-doc position (in which case, rinse and repeat, unless you get to extend your current post-doc for one more year, but that depends on external fundings that you have no control or effect on). Of course 3 requires 2 which requires 1, which means that you only have something like a bit more than half a year to complete 1 and 2, otherwise your applications for your next position will seem weak ("you didn't do anything this year?"). It is really a horrible feeling to be urged to do science. Especially when you just finished your PhD, you have lots of ideas that you want to explore and being so short-sighted (one year term is really peanuts in science) is an atrocious feeling.
- chrisseaton 11y agoSurely you'd be hired for a post-doc because your doctoral work was relevant to the project they were hiring for?
- p4bl0 11y agoIn general yes (not so much in my particular case though), but even then entering a new research project, even if it is close to the one you were working on before still take some non negligible time. But you are right, the time to complete step 1 from my comment may vary a lot and might be short in some cases I guess. In my particular case, I did my PhD on "cryptographic implementation security against physical (side-channel and fault injection) attacks", and my post-doc is on "privacy as control". I chose to apply for this post-doc rather than take one of the few that were offered to me on my PhD topic, because it also interests me scientifically a lot, plus it interests me politically. On the one hand it may have been a bold (or stupid? we'll see that later :)) move career-wise, but on the other hand it was a good time to change topic, as it may be harder to do later when you are even more specialized. And that is not specific to me.
- omginternets 11y agoFull disclosure: I'm a last year Ph.D student in cognitive neuroscience, and I'm neck-deep in post-doc applications... I think a large part of the issue has to do with government policy as it relates to science. I notice that many politicians reason in terms of "producing more science" as if it were a commodity good that should be produced and exported en masse. The problem, then, is that the current academic system actively encourages people to pursue academic careers without disclosing the reality of the situation. They push masses of people through undergrad, then grad school, then post-docs, until the end of the line whereupon most people hit a huge brick wall. I'm all for promoting research in STEM fields, but simply upping the quota of Ph.Ds won't cut it. As far as the U.S. is concerned, I think this has more to do with turning a blind eye to the dismal state of public education than anything else. It enables politicians to say "we trained 200% more scientists", while conveniently omitting the following truths: 1. Virtually none of them will be employed in the sciences at a level that warrants a doctorate. 2. For all the chest-puffing we do, we still get humiliated by the rest of the civilized world in terms of education. 3. Those people actually employed in research positions in American universities are majority foreign.
- gaius 11y agoactively encourages people to pursue academic careers without disclosing the reality of the situation Sure, but everyone including a freshman undergrad is an adult and the odds of ever becoming a tenured professor are public knowledge. No-one can realistically complain that they just didn't know.
- omginternets 11y agoThe point isn't that they're unaware. The point is that it's irresponsible to push people towards academic careers without attempting to separate those who are interested in science from those who are also good candidates for tenured positions. I've always known that the academic market is saturated. I still don't know what it actually takes, in practice, to penetrate. I contend that this guidance failure stems from a policy that aims to inflate certain non-informative statistics. More to your point, however, I think you over-estimate the quality of the information going around. Every college professor will tell you it's difficult, but they'll also guide you based on their experience from 30 years ago.
- nonbel 11y agoI found a major problem is that many people graduating with PhDs in biomed suffer from the misconception that rejecting the null hypothesis somehow allows them to conclude their favored explanation is the correct one. This is a widespread, top-to-bottom, worldwide error. I was trained to think this in grad school, surrounded by people who thought it, and have read innumerable papers by those who pretty much explicitly write that down and publish it. Since rejecting the null hypothesis is much easier than coming up with and deciding between multiple research hypotheses, these people appear to be much more productive (when measured in publication output) than those who try to do it right. I tried, and no longer believe it is possible to do a good job in the current academic environment. It is just not possible to compete with people who only reject a null hypotheses and skip everything else, not according to the metrics being used to assess performance. It's a race to the bottom.
- nonbel 11y agoThere is another problem with this null hypothesis focus as well. The literature simply does not include the information required to really develop and test quantitative models (do a good job). Instead, nearly every claim is of the form "A makes B higher/lower". But this is not the type of information we need, it is near useless! Here is an example of someone trying to figure out whats going on, but being unable to really check. The information required to constrain the parameter values is not being reported in the literature: >"Although the signals that transduce the external cues to the GTPase network are becoming clear (21), most of the chemical parameters remain unknown. Because many of the reaction coefficients in Fig. 1 B are also unknown, we allocated a number of possible parameter sets to qualitatively analyze the kinetics of these reactions." http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1366631/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1366631/ Here is another, we don't even know how many cells are in the human body to within 8 orders of magnitude, let alone how quickly they are supposed to be dividing (which is related to mutation rates), etc. How can you expect a cure for cancer in the absence fundamental quantitative data like this: >"First, we noticed that these data were typically mentioned in the literature without citing a reference; second, we observed wide ranges among data reported by different sources, ranging from 10^12–10^20." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23829164 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23829164