5 ms·
If the pressure cooker is inferior to boiling water, I wonder if that means the optimal temperature is actually below boiling. Perhaps a sous vide setup could b
by jerf 11y ago
If the pressure cooker is inferior to boiling water, I wonder if that means the optimal temperature is actually below boiling. Perhaps a sous vide setup could be even better. Be a fun experiment for someone to run.
It also occurs to me that there is significant evidence of numerous "cooking myths" that lasted for decades or centuries before falling to the first person to finally put them to the test. Seems like fertile ground for some interesting high school science projects that could get some interesting results.
- mabermoske 11y agoThis is sort of the sous vide experiment. https://youtu.be/vA8YYexlgNs https://youtu.be/vA8YYexlgNs A co-worker sent me that a while back, said it was from the class HarvardX: SPU27x Science & Cooking: From Haute Cuisine to Soft Matter Science Not so much about hard boiled, but cooking a yolk from raw to hard.
- gvb 11y agoOptimum temperature from TFA: Egg white: * At 180 degrees: The main protein in egg whites—ovalbumen—will cross-link and solidify, giving you a totally firm egg white (see the whites of the 7 and 9 minute eggs). Egg yolks, on the other hand, follow a different set of temperatures: * At 145 degrees: They begin to thicken and set up. * At 158 degrees: They become totally firm, but are still bright orange and shiny. ---- A sous vide setup might work, but it probably isn't worth the effort for eggs. You would want to set the temperature to 145..158 degrees, depending on your desired yoke consistency and then drop the egg in boiling water to finish the whites to 180 degrees. TBD is whether the 145 degree sous vide temperature hurts peel-ability (likely) and how long to cook the egg to finish the whites properly without overcooking the yoke.
- jerf 11y ago"You would want to set the temperature to 145..158 degrees, depending on your desired yoke consistency and then drop the egg in boiling water to finish the whites to 180 degrees." I was unclear about what I was thinking. I was thinking using the sous vide hardware to prep water at 200F or 190F and try boiling in that, since trying to maintain that temperature by hand is very hard, or at least, very labor intensive. But my failure to communicate that well produced another interesting strategy from you. And I have to admit I'm more searching for perfection in the abstract sense than interested in changing how I cook them. If perfect turns out to be "individually microwave the egg for 6 seconds, then cook in sous vide bath at 185F for six minutes, then boil for 3 more, then dump in ice bath immediately"... yeah, I'm not going to do that. But I'm intellectually curious.
- gvb 11y agoThe basis of sous vide is to cook the meat to the desired level of "doneness" (directly related to temperature of the inside of the steak) and then sear the outside. Searing the outside is mostly decoupled from the inside cooking because it happens fast and thus only on the very outside layer of the meat. I mapped this strategy directly to eggs, but it probably would work poorly. With a steak, "sear the outside to your preference" is easy. With an egg, "cook the whites without overcooking the yoke" is likely to be difficult. Your suggested method of using the bath to maintain the water temperature would probably work well and probably result in less "rubbery" whites, but probably is overkill compared to maintaining the water temperature at 212 degrees (trivial) and control cooking via time per the article (and tradition). Plus you would have to boil 3,000 eggs to scientifically establish the new cook times. ;-)
- kingnothing 11y agoHere's the Serious Eats guide to sous vide eggs: http://www.seriouseats.com/2013/10/sous-vide-101-all-about-eggs.html http://www.seriouseats.com/2013/10/sous-vide-101-all-about-e... For soft boiled, I've only tried it at 144f for 1 hour, but was a touch softer than I wanted. I think a few degrees higher might fix that. Part of the white was slightly liquid, but it was easy to discard. Peeling was a pain. 165f was good for a hard boiled egg. The texture was softer than normal which I thought was great.
- cillian64 11y agoSous-vide eggs are weeird -- The yolk sets at a lower temperature than the white, so you tend to end up with a set yolk but a jelly-like white. You might be able to find a good compromise temperature, or even a good temperature-time profile with a sophisticated cooker, but boiling and steaming handily cook the white more than the yolk which is usually what people want.
- mizzack 11y agoAccording to Thomas Keller's sous vide book Under Pressure, 144.5F/62.5C is the ideal sous vide temp. He's not the type to be wrong about this.
- mjb 11y agoI highly recommend sousvide (or rather, a temperature controlled water bath) for eggs. For whole eggs, you can get fine-grained control over the texture of both white and yolk (see https://www.chefsteps.com/activities/the-egg-calculator https://www.chefsteps.com/activities/the-egg-calculator), and for scrambled eggs you can control the tenderness very well. Mostly, I just skip the calculator and do in-shell eggs for 40 minutes at 62.5C or 63C. They are soft, have no salmonella concerns, and delicious served on toast or on veggies. The water bath is also a very convenient way to make pasteurized "raw" eggs at home, so you can make raw-egg recipes with very low risk.
- joezydeco 11y agoI like this chart better for sous-vide eggs: http://www.cookingissues.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/eggchart2.jpg http://www.cookingissues.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/02/eggc... It's accurate and has served me well. The only downside of making eggs sous-vide is that it takes forever. If I sleep in on a Sunday morning, set up the water bath, then wait 45 minutes for egg equilbrium, it's almost lunch time...