5 ms·
WHY? There are a bunch of legit accounting packages out there. No need to re-invent the wheel or (in this case) clean the parade ground with a toothbrush. Off
by Havoc 11y ago
WHY?
There are a bunch of legit accounting packages out there. No need to re-invent the wheel or (in this case) clean the parade ground with a toothbrush. Off the shelf SME accounting package or if you really need it a proper ERP. Anything else is likely to end in tears.
Unless its for your one man show...in which case go wild with the CLI / Excel custom rolled solutions & sundry DIYs.
Source: Accountant
- fleitz 11y agoBecause if you just spent $50 instead of inventing your own accounting software you might have more than one person working at your business.
- bobbyi_settv 11y ago> Off the shelf SME accounting package Isn't that what this is? For those of us who haven't used this, what makes it less "legit" than competing options?
- Havoc 11y agoCopy and paste answer (got the same question 4x): Is it widely used? Can you get staff with a couple years experience using ledger? Will accounting staff be productive using the interface? Does it cope well with multiple simultaneous users? Is it compatible with other software? Can you get local support? Can you export/import to other packages? Are the fringe case glitches known? All these things matter with finance software, even for fairly small operations.
- e12e 11y agoWith the caveat that I'm not a user of this software (yet), but: > Does it cope well with multiple simultaneous users? If you know of any other software that copes better with simultaneous users than git/modern dvcs+text files I'd be very surprised?
- Havoc 11y agoAgain - thats IT/HN mindset. Who is going to train the accountants to deal with git conflicts? Or are you just going to employ and IT guy that babysits the VCS when you could just spend $100 more to get an accounting package with built in networking? This is all about how this will be practically done in a business context, not whether a hn hacker can throw together a clever hacked solution.
- justinsaccount 11y ago> There are a bunch of legit accounting packages out there What makes ledger not 'legit'?
- Havoc 11y agoCopy & paste (got the same question 3x) Is it widely used? Can you get staff with a couple years experience using ledger? Will accounting staff be productive using the interface? Does it cope well with multiple simultaneous users? Is it compatible with other software? Can you get local support? Can you export/import to other packages? Are the fringe case glitches known? All these things matter with finance software, even for fairly small operations.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> There are a bunch of legit accounting packages out there. How are they more "legit" than ledger? > No need to re-invent the wheel or (in this case) clean the parade ground with a toothbrush. Ledger's been around for a while. Using it is no more "reinventing the wheel" than using any other accounting package.
- Havoc 11y ago>How are they more "legit" than ledger? Is it widely used? Can you get staff with a couple years experience using ledger? Will accounting staff be productive using the interface? Does it cope well with multiple simultaneous users? Is it compatible with other software? Can you get local support? Can you export/import to other packages? Are the fringe case glitches known? All these things matter with finance software, even for fairly small operations.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Is it widely used? Seems to be fairly popular. > Can you get staff with a couple years experience using ledger? It mostly (from the anecdotes I've seen) seems to be used by people who don't have dedicated accounting staff. > Will accounting staff be productive using the interface? See previous answer; the "accounting staff" using it are usually programmers, either independent business persons keeping their own books or using it for personal accounts. They're probably more productive using text-editor + source control + CLI than they would be with a traditional GUI. > Does it cope well with multiple simultaneous users? That's an issue mostly offloaded to the VCS, where needed. > Are the fringe case glitches known? In quality software, known glitches are fixed.
- Havoc 11y ago>either independent business persons keeping their own books or using it for personal accounts. Hence my comment in the initial post that its fine for one man shows. Those can carve their records on stone tablets if they like. Their tax accounting might charge them double for having to deal with the results but thats their problem. >In quality software, known glitches are fixed. Except when you're deal with companies using accounting software. There you frequently see outdated software. At least the commercial packages come with forced updates. Which are a god-send because you sure as hell don't want accounting staff trying to do IT updates...much like ahem you don't want IT staff attempts accounting stuff...like here.
- aidenn0 11y agoComparing ledger to cleaning the parade ground with a toothbrush is misunderstanding the feature set. Similar to comparing it to Excel custom rolled solutions. This is a true double-entry accounting system that happens to have a CLI. It definitely does not have the feature set of a proper ERP, but it can effectively be used in place of an SME accounting package. Out of curiosity, what makes an accounting package "legit" in your eyes? [edit] I see that 3 other comments asked a variation on the "legit" question. At least in my case this is not intended as an attack, but rather actual curiosity about what a professional SME accounting package can do that ledger can't; as far as open-source accounting packages go, ledger has a reputation for being able to produce reports that others can't.
- Havoc 11y ago>not intended as an attack Don't worry. I knew I'd catch grief. I know HN is strong on CLI love and thin on actual accounting experience. ;) >This is a true double-entry accounting system that happens to have a CLI. Double entry has existed in paper format since before the dawn of time. Its not particularly revolutionary (CLI or not) in fact its bare minimum for sanity. Hence my comment that this is barely a step above Excel. >actual curiosity about what a professional SME accounting package Copy paste from other questions: Is it widely used? Can you get staff with a couple years experience using ledger? Will accounting staff be productive using the interface? Does it cope well with multiple simultaneous users? Is it compatible with other software? Can you get local support? Can you export/import to other packages? Are the fringe case glitches known? All these things matter with finance software, even for fairly small operations. >as far as open-source accounting packages go To be honest I wouldn't go for an open source one (as much as I like FOSS etc). Accounting software is really an area where you want to follow the herd (unlike usual HN mindset). Straying from the herd has terrible risk/reward. e.g. Yes you might save $100 on the software by using FOSS, but when the auditors show they take twice as long to deal with the unfamiliar stuff and charge you an extra $2000. Or worse they find a glitch that is new. In the IT world you file a ticket for that. In the accounting world you end up with a massive bill to get outside help to salvage the accounting records. Followed by another massive bill from the auditors attempting to audit said salvaged records. But yeah...you totally saved that $100 on the initial purchase. (Exaggeration obviously, but you get my point). >it can effectively be used in place of an SME accounting package. I'd not attempt it, as per above. Seen way to many horror shows.