6 ms·
The BBC has been a mouthpiece for both the UK and the US government for quite a few years. That's why I've always disliked seeing their articles here, and I'd p
by mtgx 11y ago
The BBC has been a mouthpiece for both the UK and the US government for quite a few years. That's why I've always disliked seeing their articles here, and I'd prefer another source like TheGuardian instead.
Their previous one about UK gov "backtracking" on encryption backdoors was just as bad.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-34691956 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-34691956
Read through it and see how 80% of it is the government's opinion about these things. It barely gives mention to what the civil liberty groups are saying.
Read the last four paragraphs of the article, for instance. They only deal with how much of a headache end to end encryption is for authorities - and leaves it at that. What about what the civil liberty groups say about how it protects security and privacy?
- AlphaSite 11y agoThe guardian is very left leaning as well, a more neutral paper would be better.
- pjc50 11y agoThere are basically no neutral papers in the UK. The Independent sort of tries, and the FT/Economist tend to be accurate with the facts but reflexively probusiness/neoliberal.
- iamwithnail 11y agoThere's no requirement to or expectation that they will be. Papers are not required to present any kind of balance, as long as what they say is broadly true (external pluralism), for a given value of true. The broadcast media (the free-to-air ones) are required to be demonstrably internally pluralistic, to show a variety of sources and viewpoints within their output - and that applies across BBC, ITV, Ch4 and Channel 5, but not Sky News; goes back to when Radio came on stream in the 1930s.
- pjc50 11y agoYes. Americans keep expecting "neutrality", which is hard to define and impossible to achieve.
- jazzyk 11y agoThe Economist is increasingly pro-BIG-business, pro-establishment, rather than fair/free-market (as it used to be).
- marcoperaza 11y agoGood to know that I'm not the only one who's noticed this. It used to be my favorite paper, but I'm disappointed with the direction it's taken lately.
- justincormack 11y agoThe FT is not that neoliberal, it is fairly generally liberal, and generally more left wing than most of its readership by quite a margin, although it is quite varied.
- Loic 11y agoA newspaper cannot be neutral. The real problem with the BBC is that it is officially proud to be neutral but it is not. I way prefer a lot of non neutral papers, where I know before hand their base political/economic/social views. This way I can go and read both sides of the story or if not that important, read just one side knowing that it is a partial view.
- matthewmacleod 11y agoThe BBC is by far the most neutral news source I have ever encountered. It's constantly subject to attack by both the government and the public, to the extent that it's terrified to take a stance on any issue.
- Loic 11y agoThis is what you think and this is the problem because you are not alone at all. I highly recommend you reading this book: "NEWSPEAK in the 21st Century". It is highlighting the fact that the BBC is not neutral for a lot of critical issues. This is why I prefer "opinionated" papers. Sorry for this thread going maybe a bit off-topic, but this a subject I am pretty attached too. Again, I am not saying that the BBC is not doing great work, but just that it is not as neutral as what the opinion think it is. http://www.amazon.co.uk/NEWSPEAK-21st-Century-David-Edwards/dp/0745328938/ http://www.amazon.co.uk/NEWSPEAK-21st-Century-David-Edwards/...
- sdoering 11y agoThanks for the book tip will have a look at it. Having worked in news for some years and seen how (esp. online) news are produced and weighted for priority, it is to say, that it is quite a sad state of affairs. I stopped reading the news, following any news at all. If news do reach me and my interest exceeds a internal threshold, I start investigating the topic further. So having a view from outside my home country might be interesting.
- pjc50 11y agoCowardice is not neutrality. This is how we get global warming denialism given unreasonable amounts of airtime, using the "Views On Shape Of Earth Differ" approach.
- mtgx 11y agoLeft-leaning? So privacy is a left-wing thing?
- jazzyk 11y agoLeft and right are increasingly meaningless labels. These days it is more pro-establishment vs anti-establishment. For example, the most vocal people on privacy are an amalgam of independent thinkers on the "left" (The Guardian, etc) and independent thinkers on the "right" (Ron Paul, etc.) While the "leftist" Hillary Clinton calls Snowden a traitor (so do a lot of "right"-wing people, too).
- justincormack 11y agoAlthough Britain's left wing party, Labour, is pro surveillance, even it seems under Corbyn, who is himself a target.
- matthewmacleod 11y agoStop it – this article is completely fine. It quotes the government, explaining what the plan is. It explains the views of other parties and what they think is wrong with the proposals. It quotes a civil liberties group, who explain why it's bad. This is exactly what news should be. If you want more in-depth analysis or opinions, you should be looking elsewhere.
- noja 11y agoHang on - he has a point, the BBC has become very pro government with its commentary and the way they choose to present information. Particularly above the fold.
- MLR 11y agoI never understand this viewpoint, I read the BBC for online news and the Telegraph at home, it's very easy to see which one is pro government/pro Tory. The BBC is basically going to be gutted by the current government, I don't buy into this world where they're pro government, I find they're fairly neutral while a lot of the people criticising it are almost certainly anti Tory.
- anon1385 11y agoBeing less pro-Tory than the Telegraph is hardly a challenge. The Telegraph is the propaganda arm of the Tory party. As in they literally run press releases from CCHQ as news stories. The BBC should aim for their coverage to reflect facts, not just be a the-truth-is-in-the-middle triangulation of Labour and Tory positions. Their neutrality and balance mostly consists of getting a comment from the Tories and then getting a comment from Labour, with the assumption that doing so will cover all sides of any issue. One of the aims of any decent media organisation should be to challenge the establishment, but when the BBC is constitutionally unable to criticise positions where Labour and Tories both agree then it's unable to fulfil that role.
- forloop 11y ago> The BBC has been a mouthpiece for both the UK and the US government for quite a few years. This is quite well known—at least to people who think about such matters. Strangely, it seems to have been missed by the majority of HN. It's a state sponsored news agency: the BBC are the recipients of a "TV tax" (licence fee, if one watches TV).
- untog 11y agoIt's an organization funded by tax payers. That doesn't automatically mean it is a state mouthpiece. Unfortunately, they have not been very bold in their reporting since the Hutton Inquiry: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hutton_Inquiry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hutton_Inquiry
- teh_klev 11y agoThe BBC is not funded by tax payers. It's funded by the TV License which is not compulsory. If you choose not to watch live broadcast television then you don't pay for a TV license.
- DanBC 11y agoYour definition would mean VAT isn't a tax. Just avoid the luxuries[1] and you avoid the VAT. You have to pay the licence fee even if you never watch any BBC broadcast material. A person who only ever watches ITV would have to pay the licence fee. And non-payment of the licence fee was a criminal offence with fines, and non-payment of the fine sent many people to prison. It feels like a tax. [1] also tampons and sanitary towels, which probably don't feel like a luxury purchase.
- teh_klev 11y agoI hate to "well actually" you Dan :) I was informed by a TV license "officer" that provided you detune BBC channels you can still watch commercial channels. In the same way that I am permitted to listen to BBC radio channels (for which no license is required) via a Sky box. TV licensing have to prove that you're watching on-air BBC broadcasts.