5 ms·
So let me get this straight... RoboVM is acquired by Xamarin, the company behind Mono (the open source c# implementation)... and they therefore go closed source
by scrollaway 11y ago
So let me get this straight... RoboVM is acquired by Xamarin, the company behind Mono (the open source c# implementation)... and they therefore go closed source?
I don't get it.
- hierro 11y agoI don't think Xamarin has open sourced anything that they didn't have to. All tools developed exclusively by Xamarin are closed source (e.g. Xamarin build host, the Mono packager, Xamarin.Insights, Objective Sharpie, etc...).
- carussell 11y agoXamarin contributed several projects to the .NET Foundation. Mono is also permissively licensed, so every contribution Xamarin makes that does up in the open (instead of locked up, which they could do by actually taking advantage of the terms in those permissive licenses) is something "that they didn't have to" do.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- taspeotis 11y agoI don't think Xamarin open source their Visual Studio integration or their Mac OS Build Host. So this would be following in those footsteps: if you want these features, pay for them.
- pionar 11y agoMono is different than Xamarin. Xamarin works on and supports Mono, but it's not their core product. Their core product is the Xamarin Platform, which is what you're talking about.
- johncolanduoni 11y agoXamarin's .NET mobile/mac offerings are closed source. Mono itself fills the role of the OpenJDK does for Java, but it alone is not suitable for running on mobile. Also, Mono is licensed under the LGPL and Xamarin's interpretation of that license precludes using the runtime in a closed-source program without a alternative license from them (which they provide with their paid plans).
- billsix 11y ago> Also, Mono is licensed under the LGPL and Xamarin's interpretation of that license precludes using the runtime in a closed-source program without a alternative license from them Citation? I've never heard anyone interpret the GPL and LGPL as the same. Embedding mono is different than using mono. https://xamarin.com/licensing https://xamarin.com/licensing
- johncolanduoni 11y agoSorry, I meant on mobile (like RoboVM). There is no way to comply with the LGPL on iOS.
- gillianseed 11y ago>Also, Mono is licensed under the LGPL From what I understand lot of code is GPLv2 as well, which would make the project as a whole GPLv2 licensed.
- billsix 11y agoThe project as a whole is not GPLv2. From http://www.mono-project.com/docs/faq/licensing/ http://www.mono-project.com/docs/faq/licensing/ The C# compiler is dual-licensed under the MIT/X11 license and the GNU General Public License (GPL). The tools are released under the terms of the GNU General Public License (GPL). The runtime libraries are under the GNU Library GPL 2.0 (LGPL 2.0). The class libraries are released under the terms of the MIT X11 license.
- 11y ago
- rplnt 11y agoUhm, they only support mono because they simply can't close it and have lots of proprietary libraries built around it. Some they developed on their own, some were bought/licensed from previous Mono maintainers. Xamarin is not a FOSS company by a long shot.
- maccard 11y agotheir official line of reasoning is: RoboVM is a complicated piece of technology that we have worked hard for years to create. Over the past few months, we have seen competitors actively exploiting our good faith by using our open source code to compete with us directly in commercial products. On the flip side, we have received almost no meaningful contributions to our open source code. You can imagine how disappointing this has been to us; we had hoped our initial business model of OSS with proprietary extensions (like our debugger and interface builder integration) would work. But in light of the low contributions and behavior of competitors, we decided to stop automatically releasing changes to the core of RoboVM as open source. tl;dr they weren't receiving any contributions, and people were using their open source code directly against them.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- blumkvist 11y ago@shit HN says, you have work to do!