5 ms·
In the North America analogy Indonesia would be U.S. burning and Mexico and Canada suffering. Indonesia is 4th most populous country in the world (250 million p
by nabla9 11y ago
In the North America analogy Indonesia would be U.S. burning and Mexico and Canada suffering. Indonesia is 4th most populous country in the world (250 million people). Singapore and Malaysia are outmatched in population, GDP and military.
- michaelflux 11y agoAbout being outmatched in GDP and military - you're joking right? Have a look at the figures over the last few decades for Singapore and Indonesia. Singapore is a tiny spec when it comes to size and population, but economically it's in a league of it's own.
- xyzzyz 11y agoSure, per capita GDP of Singapore is vastly higher, but here it's total GDP that's relevant, not per capita. Last I seen, GDP of Indonesia was 3 times that of Singapore.
- coldtea 11y ago>GDP of Indonesia was 3 times that of Singapore. So, like 40-50 times less per capita. Total GDP doesn't matter much when there are size discrepancies that large.
- mikeash 11y agoWhy not? The amount of weapons a country can buy is related to its total GDP, not per capita. The number of soldiers a country can field is related to its total GDP and actually goes up when per-capita GDP is lower, because you don't have to pay them as much.
- AlphaSite 11y agoPer capita it's much larger than Indonesians, yes, but Indonesians total gdp is significantly higher, 300 billion vs 2.8 trilllion.
- adventured 11y agoIndonesia's GDP isn't close to $2.8 trillion. That would give them an economy the size of the UK and France. They have an estimated 2015 GDP per capita of $3,400 per the IMF. They have 250 million people. Their GDP is a lot closer to $850 billion. A $2.8 trillion GDP would require a $11,000 GDP per capita. That's not accurate. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28nominal%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28no... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28nominal%29_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28no...
- jfoster 11y agoGDP per capita versus total GDP. Indonesia is a developing country, but it's big. Singapore is a developed country, but it's small.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hellofunk 11y agoSingapore currently has the most advanced airforce in the world. The size and prowess of its military relative to its size is unmatched anywhere on this planet. Economically, it is at least on par with Hong Kong and Tokyo. Nearly all major companies with a presence in Asia have an office in Singapore, many of them their entire Asian headquarters are in Singapore. I'm not sure I understand your analogy; I think it is the vice-versa of what you mean.
- ptaipale 11y agoSingapore is advanced and rich, but it is small compared to Indonesia. Singapore has larger GDP and military per capita, but in absolute terms, Indonesia is much larger. Its army has four times as many men as Singapore (300,000 vs. 75,000), and Indonesian GDP is 2840 billion USD while Singapore is 453 billion. (edit:typos)
- adventured 11y agoIndonesia's GDP is ~$850 billion, not $2.8 trillion. Singapore is ~$300 billion. Not sure why Indonesia's GDP keeps getting over-estimated by such a dramatic amount in this thread.
- ptaipale 11y ago> Not sure why Indonesia's GDP keeps getting over-estimated by such a dramatic amount in this thread. Sorry, that was just a bit careless looking up of numbers. $850 billion is nominal GDP, $2.8 trillion is the PPP adjusted figure. For Singapore, the nominal and PPP adjusted values are much closer to each other ($300 billion vs. $450 billion).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JPKab 11y agoNot agreeing with the previous statement regarding Singapore's military supremacy, but measuring military effectiveness by number of troops is a hopelessly outdated method. Powerful armies are nothing more than logistics organizations, with 80-90% of members operating supply chains and maintenance to enable the 21st century weapons systems and their elite operators to destroy things. 300,000 guys with assault rifles and crappy Air Force are no match against 75,000 with modern technology and precision munitions.