4 ms·
How much software fully supports the 10-bit Eizo or NEC displays on Windows these days? Do typical GPUs now support 10-bit color, or is it still only expensive
by jacobolus 11y ago
How much software fully supports the 10-bit Eizo or NEC displays on Windows these days? Do typical GPUs now support 10-bit color, or is it still only expensive workstation GPUs?
My impression was that only a few niche applications have bothered (notably, Photoshop has had support for a few years), since 10-bit displays are so rare/expensive, but I’m not an expert.
As for Linux, as far as I know the stable version of GIMP still only supports 8 bits/channel color, so displaying at higher bit depth is right out. I guess maybe some specialized video or 3d rendering software could use a 10-bit display? I doubt typical Linux apps support it.
* * *
Edit: In doing some web sleuthing, there seem to be endless issues with compatibility. (As you’d expect from a new technology that requires upgrading every part of the pipeline for support: applications, operating system, video card drivers, video cards, display interface, and the displays themselves)
I see this on a random web forum: “I got an answer from an engineer at Adobe, why Photoshop CC cannot display 10bit/color under Windows 8, 8.1 and 10: There is no OpenGL-path with 10bit/channel like in Windows 7 any more :(”
Adobe’s troubleshooting site says “Note: 30-bit display is not functioning correctly with current drivers. We are working to address this issue as soon as possible”
- nitrogen 11y agoLinux is a first class platform for many of the atypical apps that would benefit from higher bit depths.
- jacobolus 11y agoI’m seeing a lot of web discussions like this: https://devtalk.nvidia.com/default/topic/771081/30-bit-depth-with-linux-driver-does-not-produce-30-bit-output-on-monitor/ https://devtalk.nvidia.com/default/topic/771081/30-bit-depth... Can you find an example of someone talking about using 10 bits/channel color displays on Linux in practice, and having it behave properly? What kind of work are they using it for? (Maybe my google-fu is deficient, but all I can find are people complaining about compatibility problems and Nvidia marketing materials.)
- berkut 11y agoCompositing and grading for VFX/film. Most high-end VFX studios use Linux.
- gglitch 11y agoWith what software?
- modfodder 11y agoDavinci Resolve is what Company 3 uses (The Martian, Spectre, Jurassic World, etc). It's available on Mac and Linux, but the big shops use the Linux version as they can expand it allowing for more real time nodes. Baselight is another major platform for color grading that runs on Linux.
- photoGrant 11y agoResolve, Nuke, Flame, etc
- mminer 11y agoI worked for a company that performed stereoscopic conversion for Hollywood films. Their primary tool was NUKE [1] running on Linux. It's also available for Mac and Windows, but because NUKE encompassed their entire workflow, the underlying OS wasn't especially important. [1] http://www.thefoundry.co.uk/products/nuke/ http://www.thefoundry.co.uk/products/nuke/
- dtf 11y agoLinux workstations have been the preferred platform for high-end finishing applications like NUKE, Flame and Baselight for years. Generally it's NVIDIA hardware on Red Hat.
- nitrogen 11y agoIf there's one problem this thread makes me want to solve it's the undiscoverability of the unknown. 99.9+% of software is stuff most of us have never heard of, but we don't know what to search for because we don't know how to know what we don't already know. 99% of business opportunities we might have are invisible to us because we don't know how or where to look. 99+% of the dating population is out of reach of each other because of path dependence problems -- their lives simply won't ever intersect. If I had my own startup accelerator, tonight (and only tonight ;-) ) this would be my RFS#1. Solve the knowledge bootstrapping problem. Google clearly failed to link 30-bit to VFX.
- kuschku 11y agoKrita, a KDE project competing with GIMP, supports a lot more colorspaces than GIMP. Also, next to all KDE apps support it. 8 bit? 16 bit? 10 bit? CMYK? YPbPr? XYZ? Krita has them all.
- MichaelGG 11y agoA funny note: During Longhorn (PDC 2003), some MS devs indicated that the color pipeline for everything in Windows was moving to a 128-bit pixel struct. Some floating point part, I think. Course that never shipped but it sounds cool. I think Carmack mentioned that in some extreme-but-possible cases, 64-bit isn't enough to represent the results correctly.
- ryandamm 11y agoI have to assume that's 128-bit precision in 3D rendering -- partly because it's Carmack, but largely because 64-bit color would be... well beyond human perceptual limits. This StackExchange post claims ~2.4 million colors for the limit of human color vision; it cites CIE color science: http://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/10208/how-many-colors-and-shades-can-the-human-eye-distinguish-in-a-single-scene http://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/10208/how-many-colo.... 64 bit per channel color would produce ~2e19 different colors; if it's 64 bits per channel it would produce some even-more absurd number like ~8e57. (Besides the ridiculous numbers, I assume those numbers are per-channel, because it's not divisible by 3.) And yes, higher bit precision is really important for drawing 3D graphics. Look at the price premium you pay for Nvidia's Quadro cards, which can process in higher bit precision than your stock cards... they're typically 5-10x a consumer card: http://www.nvidia.com/object/quadro.html http://www.nvidia.com/object/quadro.html Mostly advertised for high end CAD or VFX, where bit precision errors can result in odd display artifacts or incorrect rendering.
- MichaelGG 11y agoI think the context was that after doing multiple layers of texture mapping on a 3D object, a 128-bit color space wasn't enough to be fully accurate. I'll see if I can find what I'm most likely miss misremembering. Thanks for the SE link. 2.4M can't be right or we wouldn't be able to see banding all over the place right? The link says including luminosity, it might be up to 100M. So 24 bit wouldn't cut it but 30 would?
- ryandamm 11y agoLike all things perceptual, an exact answer is maddeningly difficult to pin down (individual to individual variation, subjective issues like ambient light, etc). Even at 10-bit you could in theory see banding if your color discrimination were good enough, I think. It depends on the material... but the 10-bit displays I've seen look awfully, awfully good. (And the ability to represent more dynamic range starts to matter -- you have to have a wide scale to show off the bit depth, too. A monitor I saw at NAB this year has two backlights and can show off a lot more light... campfires glowed, headlights looked like they were bright, very real... that's the real direction for displays, I think.)