11 ms·
5K iMac Gets 10-Bit Color
- ctstover 11y agotldr; too much mac universe; I'm assuming 10 bit means 10 bit per channel instead of 8, so what the rest of the world would call perhaps 30 bit over 24 bit?
- X-Istence 11y agoIn the article it shows a screenshot where Apple themselves also call it 30 bit. And the text for the image is as follows: The graphics driver enables 30 bit pixel depth. 10 bit for each RGB color. Image courtesy Mac & I magazine.
- cjensen 11y ago10-bit color and 8-bit color are common idioms in the video industry to refer to 30-bit pixels and 24-bit pixels. It makes more sense in video where one often uses the YCrCb colors space where the color components (Cr Cb) are often sampled at half the rate of the luma components. In this case, 10-bits corresponds to 20-bits per sample point.
- mikeash 11y agoSure looks like a lot of non-Apple uses of this term to me: https://www.google.com/search?q=10-bit%20color%20-apple https://www.google.com/search?q=10-bit%20color%20-apple
- foolrush 11y agoI am wondering why you are getting downvoted when what you said about 30 bit is precisely correct; 10 bit is 10 bits per display plane, which has traditionally been called 30 bit as per AMD[1] and NVidia[2], as supported since 2006. [1] (PDF) https://www.amd.com/Documents/10-Bit.pdf https://www.amd.com/Documents/10-Bit.pdf [2] (PDF) http://www.nvidia.ca/docs/IO/40049/TB-04701-001_v02_new.pdf http://www.nvidia.ca/docs/IO/40049/TB-04701-001_v02_new.pdf
- arm 11y agoHe’s getting downvoted because of the snark. If he read the article, he’d see that even Apple themselves refer to it as 30-bit: https://www.cinema5d.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/iMac-10-bit-color_2.jpg https://www.cinema5d.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/iMac-10-... http://i1.wp.com/www.LSdigi.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/Screen-Shot-2015-10-30-at-05.32.09.png http://i1.wp.com/www.LSdigi.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/S...
- mixmastamyk 11y agoWhy did this support take so long? I remember handling "10 bit" files in SGI in the late 90's, and while most vfx houses are on linux these days, I though mac os was useful also. p.s. I think this was the format: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cineon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cineon
- sjwright 11y agoYou've been able to handle "10 bit" files on Macintosh or Windows since forever. What's new here is native video card driver support for allowing 10 bits per channel (30 bpp) content to be viewed real time through the main display. Let's be very clear here — being able to view 30 bpp is a very, very marginal benefit for most people most of the time, even if they're working on high bit depth material. Far more important has been the substantial improvements in display gamut and accuracy. For content creators the important thing is for this additional bit depth to be captured in the first instance and preserved during manipulation.
- MichaelGG 11y agoIs it very marginal? Shouldn't it reduce banding by a factor of 4 or so? I notice banding a lot on all sorts of content.
- miahi 11y agoThe banding is mostly caused by color compression rather than device support. 99.99% of the content one usually sees is compressed, and many times it's a second compression over something already compressed (I don't know any "uncompressed Youtube" or "raw Instagram").
- Matumio 11y agoIt's possible to notice banding with 8bpc if you look at a color gradient, especially if it wasn't dithered. But if you add proper dithering (over all 3 channels) and you're looking at a natural image (yeah, not a 256-color web-optimized one)... I don't know. Dithering plus higher resolution has pretty much the same effect as a higher bit depth.
- Asbostos 11y agoThat's a great step, but isn't it still not ideal because at 5k resolution, you could still get banding on a continuous gradient covering the screen without dithering?
- sjwright 11y agoTheoretically, yes — 10 bpp increases the number of distinct shades from 256 per channel to 1024. So with a 5K display at 10 bpp, each shade would be repeated for five physical pixels. In reality, no — the differences in brightness between each shade are going to be too subtle to notice. Most sources of egregious banding usually comes from 8 bit source material manipulated or "colour managed" to an 8 bit output product. If the source material was 10+ bits then banding would be far less noticeable, even if the final output is still 8 bits.
- interpol_p 11y agoI find that most significant banding comes from a large gradient that spans between two very similar shades. (E.g., a full screen gradient that goes from grey to slightly-darker-grey). I fear that 10 bpp would hide the banding from you, so that when your users see it on their 8 bpp displays they notice the banding that you didn't see or get a chance to dither out with noise.
- Gracana 11y agoI notice this a lot with web media. Designers have really nice setups, so they don't have any problem designing sites with tiny thin gray text on gray backgrounds with little gray icons etc, not realizing that it looks like indecipherable mush on other people's hardware.
- therealmarv 11y agoAnd why why why I cannot buy an external Apple monitor for my Macbook for getting that? I need to buy a whole Mac to get that :(
- eridius 11y agoBecause Apple still isn't selling 5k monitors. I imagine it will happen eventually.
- Eric_WVGG 11y agolimitations of Thunderbolt 2
- Synaesthesia 11y agoA cinema5D reader reported that he got 10 bit on a Mac Pro with D500 graphics and an Eizo CS230 monitor. So it probably depends on your Mac and monitor but you there's a good chance you can get 10 bit output from you MacBook.
- jacobolus 11y agoGive it some time, and you’ll probably need a new Macbook to get an Apple retina display working. Support for Thunderbolt 3 (which should have enough bandwidth to drive a 5K display at 60 Hz) is coming with Intel Skylake chips, which should be arriving next year. http://blogs.intel.com/technology/2015/06/thunderbolt3/ http://blogs.intel.com/technology/2015/06/thunderbolt3/
- melling 11y agoThunderbolt 3 is USB C. That explains why Apple didn't ship USB C on their new iMacs.
- lazyjones 11y agoIf you have the new "MacBook", it can only drive 4K anyway. You'll likely get 10 bit color with a cheap Dell P2415Q display or similar.
- MichaelGG 11y agoAs much as I dislike Apple, I do appreciate when they push things forward. They've done the opposite for laptop design (bad keyboards, hot chassis) but Retina has probably contributed a bit to other OEMs shipping not-totally-crap panels. Maybe this will push that a bit more? What I'd pay for a X series ThinkPad with a 10-bit "Retina" display...
- LeoPanthera 11y agoI also love Apple, but it's a bit of a stretch to call this "pushing things forward", when 10-bit color has been supported on Windows since Windows 7.
- wyager 11y agoHave any of these devices included 10-bit displays? That's the interesting part.
- trynumber9 11y agoThere's been 10-bit support in AMD graphics cards (since at least 2008). Dell, NEC, Eizo and others have shipped monitors with support. Combine the two off you go. So, yes, PCs have been using 10 bit color for some time.
- MichaelGG 11y agoI thought support was sorta so-so, requiring special apps + driver support. Plus I've not seen any popular PC products shipping with it. If Apple makes this part of their flagship, it might help. Or maybe PC vendors will keep shipping low-res, ugly ass displays.
- FireBeyond 11y agoKinda like support on Apple now - "only with certain models, certain versions of the OS, and only in two apps". I realize this will change, but it's not much different.
- LeoPanthera 11y agoThe "original" article is here, though in German: http://www.heise.de/mac-and-i/meldung/iMacs-lernen-10-Bit-Farbwiedergabe-2854496.html#mobile_detect_force_desktop http://www.heise.de/mac-and-i/meldung/iMacs-lernen-10-Bit-Fa...
- ryandamm 11y agoIn some ways, this is Apple pushing things forward... but in other ways, it's just them catching up. Until this update, there was no way to get 10-bit displays working with Apple products at all, even third-party monitors that were 10-bit capable. The OS simply wouldn't support 10-bit display. I know you could get it in Windows, and almost certainly in Linux with the correct voodoo. My post guys wanted to stay on the Mac platform, so we dealt with 8-bit displays (color wasn't a huge part of our workflow -- but 10 bit would've been nice). But it was one of those head-smacking moments for a platform that was supposedly media-friendly. Note, there's some confusion in the comments so far -- 10 bit is a professional display, and is extremely uncommon. Pro cameras and software can usually handle higher bit depths -- 16 for DSLRs, 10-12+ for pro video cameras -- but you're probably not seeing it unless you've carefully set up your computer. Those bits are still useful: they're the raw material for generating your 8-bit final image, so you don't get banding when adjusting color or exposure. And they're essential for containing a wider range of possible values, letting pro cameras represent a wider dynamic range than is possible in 8 bit systems. And 8 bits is more typical -- it's literally baked into many file formats, like JPEG. Some crappy screens on consumer electronics can't even represent the full 8 bits per channel; 6 bits + dithering is sadly really common, even in screens that advertise themselves as 8/24-bit. Also, color depth can be reported both in bits-per-channel and total bit depth; a 10 bit-per-channel display is 30 bits of color information per RGB pixel, 10 each for red, green, and blue. (Some of the confusion is probably intentional; I had a hardware partner brag about their '15 bit display,' which sounded very weird to me... until I realized it was really 5 bits per channel, which is roughly bad-ATM-screen quality.)
- jacobolus 11y agoHow much software fully supports the 10-bit Eizo or NEC displays on Windows these days? Do typical GPUs now support 10-bit color, or is it still only expensive workstation GPUs? My impression was that only a few niche applications have bothered (notably, Photoshop has had support for a few years), since 10-bit displays are so rare/expensive, but I’m not an expert. As for Linux, as far as I know the stable version of GIMP still only supports 8 bits/channel color, so displaying at higher bit depth is right out. I guess maybe some specialized video or 3d rendering software could use a 10-bit display? I doubt typical Linux apps support it. * * * Edit: In doing some web sleuthing, there seem to be endless issues with compatibility. (As you’d expect from a new technology that requires upgrading every part of the pipeline for support: applications, operating system, video card drivers, video cards, display interface, and the displays themselves) I see this on a random web forum: “I got an answer from an engineer at Adobe, why Photoshop CC cannot display 10bit/color under Windows 8, 8.1 and 10: There is no OpenGL-path with 10bit/channel like in Windows 7 any more :(” Adobe’s troubleshooting site says “Note: 30-bit display is not functioning correctly with current drivers. We are working to address this issue as soon as possible”
- haberman 11y agoOn the downside, it appears that the newest iMacs still won't do Target Display Mode. This is a bummer -- I like the iMac but hate the idea of having this big beautiful display on your desk that you can't use to give your laptop more screen real estate when you want to.
- DAddYE 11y agoFrom a comment in the article: Hey guys, it appears it’s not just for the 5K iMac, I have tested this on 2013 Mac Pro with an Eizo CS230 monitor and can confirm that you can get 10bit output. http://www.lsdigi.com/2015/10/el-capitan-10bit-display-support/ http://www.lsdigi.com/2015/10/el-capitan-10bit-display-suppo...
- pilif 11y agoYeah - and it also works with last year's 5K imac. (source: I have one)
- finnh 11y agoI also have a 2014 5K imac with El Cap, and my system report shows 30-bit / ARGB2101010 However, when I view the test image from the article's comments (http://www.imagescience.com.au/kb/getattachment.php?data=MTUyfDEwIGJpdCB0ZXN0IHJhbXAuemlw http://www.imagescience.com.au/kb/getattachment.php?data=MTU...) I still see banding. Hmm.
- pilif 11y agoWhat are you viewing it in? It opened in Pixelmator for me where it was showing banding. Then I tried again with preview where it was ok. So the app you use to open the file might not have proper 10bit support
- finnh 11y agoPreview. The banding is pretty odd (the bands have gradients _within_ them, it's weird), and is also displaying artifacts from OS X's default window-transparency settings. Turning those "down" helps, a bit, but there's still banding. I don't see an option to turn it off completely. So I'm not sure where to point the finger.
- carlosEscolano 11y agotest
- handonam 11y agoWould that mean the RGB values change in the future? It would go from 0-F to 0-K wouldn't it? so... #KKK = white? ;(
- huuu 11y agoA lot of software already use normalized RGB. rgb(1.0, 1.0, 1.0) == white
- StavrosK 11y agoAnd the idea is that you specify as many decimals as you need there?
- huuu 11y agoYes but that's an interface problem. Ofcourse you can't provide more decimals than the number of bits used by the float. EDIT: 0.999 * 255 (8 bit) = 255 0.9999 * 255 (8 bit) = 255 0.999 * 4096 (12 bit) = 4092 0.9999 * 4096 (12 bit) = 4096 So for lower color depths the number of decimals isn't that important.
- mojuba 11y agoLook up CSS-color level 4. It supports non-integer arguments for rgb() and rgba() which supposedly solves the problem, though in a bit ugly way, because the total range is still 0..255.
- raverbashing 11y agoHilarious, but no, that's not how it's going to work You get a number in front of ff from 0 to 3, so 3ff is the maximum instead of ff
- pasiaj 11y agoWhen you need that extra push over the cliff...
- adcsd 11y agoMy system info says 32-Bit Color. Is this incorrect? http://imgur.com/PAk8K8e http://imgur.com/PAk8K8e
- jacobolus 11y agoARGB8888 = 8 bits each of alpha, red, green, blue. If you had 10 bits per channel it would say ARGB2101010 http://i.imgur.com/ds1t6HV.png http://i.imgur.com/ds1t6HV.png
- twsted 11y agoThis is really confusing. ARG8888 and it says Pixel depth: 32-bit Color ARG2101010 and it says Pixel depth: 30-bit Color
- Rexxar 11y agoI'm waiting for the first real 32-bit colour monitor, the one that becomes transparent when alpha is set to zero.
- PudgePacket 11y agoSo you'd actually see through the monitor to the internals our out the other side? That would be interesting :)
- 9point6 11y agoI wonder why it's not ARG10101010 for 10-bit RGB + Alpha Surely it's not actually 2 bit Alpha in ARG2101010
- makomk 11y agoThe alpha part of the framebuffer isn't actually used because monitors don't support an alpha channel, it's just convenient to pad everything out to 32 bits anyway.
- Keyframe 11y agoI was hoping for a push to 10-bit monitors for awhile. First step would be for nvidia to unlock 10-bit output on their geforce series and then for monitor manufacturers to lower the prices / introduce 10-bit panels... Not to mention standardize on a port for 10-bits.
- shurcooL 11y ago10-bit color. Retina-level DPI. 120 Hz refresh rate. External display. Pick... two?
- shurcooL 11y agoWell, I know the first thing I'm checking when I get to work in the morning.
- alkonaut 11y agoInteresting. Do API:s support 10 or 12 bit colors? Is it limited to "low level" rendering, similar to when you render a region of screen using a 3D hw device, while the rest of the screen is being drawn at 8bpp using the graphics API:s of the OS? I guess my question is: Has OS X always had graphics API:s that uses floats instead of rgb bytes for everything?
- 0x0 11y agoAt least iOS uses CGFloats for argb components in its UIColor class: https://developer.apple.com/library/ios/documentation/UIKit/Reference/UIColor_Class/#//apple_ref/occ/clm/UIColor/colorWithRed:green:blue:alpha https://developer.apple.com/library/ios/documentation/UIKit/...: Going beyond 8bit would be awesome; if you have large gradients and don't use dither, you get really heavy banding. Imagine a gradient on a web page background. If your screen is 1024 pixels high, thats 4 rows of pixels of the same color even if your gradient is going from 0 to 255 on a channel. If your range is smaller (dark gray to lighter gray), it gets even worse. Even older APIs could draw benefit of this, for example a CSS gradient specifying #rrggbb...#rrggbb with 8bits/channel could be rendered with more than 8 bits per channel to avoid banding.
- MrBra 11y agoAnyone care to explain in brief to someone who reading 10 bit color still thinks "hey, weren't we at 32bit color already?"...
- Monory 11y agoWe are currently at 24-bit colour palettes - 8 for each colour. 32-bit is used for ARGB, with alpha-channel, so it's still 8 bit per channel. This, however, moves us to 30-bit palette, which is nice.
- crusso 11y agoWhat I don't understand is why 8 bit color isn't enough. Back when 8 bit color was released (yes, I'm old), we were told that it provided way more colors than the human eye could discern - 24 million as opposed to the 10 million that the human eye could discern. What changed? Is 10 bit color smoke and mirrors or is it something that only a smaller fraction of the population can appreciate?
- rplst8 11y agoIt's not smoke and mirrors. It's akin to the audio world where the final product (an CD or MP3) is mastered in 16 bit audio, but is mixed and edited at a higher bit depth, often 32 bit. In the color world, most of ones job is about mapping what a sensor captures (most modern DSLRs are 12-16 bits per channel) onto the reduced palette offered by 8 bit color. Actually, most cheap displays are 6 bit color with some fancy techniques to help fool our eyes. Research banding and dithering with respect to color to get a better idea of the subject.
- mtw 11y agoFor seeing pictures and watching videos, 8 bit is good. Its when you start manipulating images that it doesn't work out. For example, you have a nice sunset picture but its dark and you can't see the people in front. As a result, you try to increase saturation, contrast and exposure. The people's faces are still dark so you try to change the exposure more aggressively. That's when the picture breaks down. The sky sunset becomes pixelated, maybe the skin becomes white etc. If you use a 8-bit display you wouldn't know if it's because of the effects or because of the 8bit monitor. With a 10-bit display, if it looks crap, at least you know its from the picture you took. This might look an extreme example bit it happens often for photographers and videographers. It can also happen for consumers if they try to check a picture which lots of minimal variations if the same color in the same picture. A good example is a picture of a white sky. It can appear pixelated in a few parts
- post_break 11y ago10 bit color, 5400rpm laptop hard drive. 2 steps forward right?
- lallysingh 11y agoWait, seriously? Dude.
- post_break 11y agoSorry I was wrong, the 5200 laptop drive is in the 21.5" 4k iMac.
- xyproto 11y agoI think it's misleading that the title says "10-bit" instead of "30-bit". 8-bit graphics is normally 256 different colors (at least for DOS era programming). 24-bit graphics is 8-bits per RGB channel.