11 ms·
New Star Trek Series Premieres January 2017
- thehodge 11y agoHopefully this will be a look forward beyond Voyager rather than going back again..
- drunken-serval 11y agoPersonally, I don't see anything wrong with going for an alternate timeline and a modern take on starship design. As long as they don't turn Star Trek into an action franchise, I'm okay with it.
- alexbecker 11y ago> As long as they don't turn Star Trek into an action franchise Oh god, that would be tragic.
- ramblerman 11y agoWell that's pretty much what the last movie was. That being said I thought it was quite good when you didn't think of it as 'star trek'
- aidenn0 11y agoYeah the two new movies were essentially action movies that captured the feel of the TOS characters.
- rhino369 11y agoAll the movies except 1 and 4 were essentially action movies. And 4 was mostly a fish out of water comedy.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoAs much as it's often panned, Insurrection is the most Star Trek of Star Trek movies. It's about the Prime Directive at it's core. The Undiscovered Country is also a great example of a movie about diplomacy. Sure, every movie is going to be action-packed for film screens, but those two I felt stuck to Star Trek's ideals more than the rest, where the movie focused on stopping a specific evil villain.
- rhino369 11y agoIt's been a while since I saw Insurrection and Undiscovered Country, but you could make a similar argument about Star Trek into Darkness. It was about the struggle between a militarized starfleet and a starfleet about discovery and exploration.
- ocdtrekkie 11y agoI honestly just feel Into Darkness is a movie about Khan. I've never felt the new Trek movies put out this discovery and exploration vibe. They certainly haven't attempted to do so as of yet.
- serge2k 11y agoDid they capture the feel? Spock was okay at times. Kirk was okay at times. Scotty was comic relief, with very little of him being a badass
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dangerboysteve 11y agoAs long as it's not based on a truck rest stop like DS9.
- cwyers 11y agoI've seen this said a lot, and I mean... the original Star Trek was a TV series in the late 60s, so in terms of what the effects were capable of on a TV budget and what standards and practices would allow, I think they were as action-oriented as they could be. The original run of Star Trek is filled with as many fistfights, space battles and fights to the death with the Vulcan Lirpa as the budget would allow. Trek was about much more than JUST action (Conscience Of The King is one of my favorite examples of this), but they did a lot of it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Aqwis 11y agoUnless they put it in the alternate timeline, which it doesn't sound like they will given this quote: >The new television series is not related to the upcoming feature film Star Trek Beyond which is scheduled to be distributed by Paramount Pictures in summer 2016. ...they'd have to some serious retconning to place it anywhere before Voyager. Too much existing canon to take into account when writing the scripts.
- cmiles74 11y agoGiven they have the head writer from the last two movies, I can't see them sticking with the old, tired canon. It could be that they need to be clear that they aren't associated with the next film. Different characters, etc.
- Amezarak 11y ago> Given they have the head writer from the last two movies, I can't see them sticking with the old, tired canon What is "tired" about existing canon? What stops people from writing new stories with new characters in the "old" canon? How, for example, was Voyager burdened by the old, tired canon in TNG or DS9? As best I can tell, the only reason they don't do it is because they would prefer to cash in on the popularity of the pre-existing characters and the pre-existing stories without actually having to write as though they exist. Star Trek is a series based on exploration. There are plenty of new worlds and new peoples to see, without throwing away the old canon, while at the same time not relying on it very much. I honestly can't understand why people like the idea of resets and reboots. To me, it just feels lazy and unsatisfying.
- cmiles74 11y agoI can see where you are coming from and I acknowledge that my comment was cleary meant to denigrate "the canon" of older Star Trek works. You may be right, a new team of writers may be able to author a new show that adheres to these stories and still comes off as fresh and exciting. To my mind, the Voyager series (which I did enjoy) was meant to do what you recommend: use exploration of new worlds as a way to introduce new storylines and, to some degree, to distance the show from the storylines of the past. While I enjoyed that show, I don't think it was entirely successful. Specifically, it didn't appear to generate enough interest to warrrant more films, which seem to be what keeps this series alive. The last series, Enterprise, seemed to be trying to accomplish the same goal by going back into the past, before many of these storylines took place. To my mind, it was wholly unsuccessful. I watched every episode and felt unsatisfied after the majority of them. In my opinion, the failure of the last two series to generate enough interest for more films was a big reason why the "reboot" idea is more attractive.
- roneesh 11y agoAgree, please please please not a prequel! The big joy of Star Trek is speculating about the future, in these times especially I think we could use more optimism about a future we haven't thought of yet, not just a dramatic retcon of stories we already know.
- zo1 11y agoI think they do this very deliberately. Short of making an alternate timeline, they'd have to "play-out" the universe we know as part of TNG/VOY/ENT/DS9. Sure, they could leave it vague and have us all guessing what happened in those intermediate years, but that wouldn't be the StarTrek we know as we'd have no idea how they got to that point. Also, they'd essentially lock themselves into an intermediate storyline that somehow leads to the universe they portray. Hopefully ,if they do decide to make the setting "post" all the other shows by a long stretch of time, they work around some of these pitfalls and come up with a great story and addition to the franchise.
- ck2 11y agoCan't wait to see what it will be like, was entertained by every series so far. Hopefully more like most of the series and less like the new movies.
- seehafer 11y agoYour wish is unlikely to come true, as the new series is being written/produced by the head writer of the last two movies.
- mason240 11y agoAny word on the setting and how the alternate timeline reset of the of 2009 movie fits into the cannon? It seems like there are couple possibilities. 1) They act like the reset in the 2009 movie didn't happen, and the new show is just set sometime after TNG/DS9/Voyager, with the same continuity. 2) Everything is reset and we get a new show set sometime after the reset. I guess there is this: >The new television series is not related to the upcoming feature film Star Trek Beyond which is scheduled to be distributed by Paramount Pictures in summer 2016.
- Gartenioa 11y agoThe reset is just another timeline. I say they open up another timeline. Earth explodes and Vulcan survives.
- smacktoward 11y agoSince the new series is being exec-produced by Alex Kurtzman, who was a producer and co-writer on both the 2009 Star Trek and Star Trek Into Darkness, it seems pretty safe to assume the series will be set in the new timeline/continuity those movies established. I'd read "not related to Star Trek Beyond" more as them saying it won't be tied in any specific way to the plot/characters of that film than that it'll be completely outside the rebooted continuity.
- maxerickson 11y ago"not related" could just mean that the stories do not cross over, it could still be part of that cannon. I would sort of be surprised if they decide to heft all the baggage from TNG et al.
- lghh 11y agoI have always been interested in watching Star Trek, having watched some of Deep Space Nine with my dad and thinking it was okay when I was really young in addition to enjoying the new movies. I figure now is a good time seeing as this is coming out in a little over a year. Any suggestions as to what order I should watch it in or if I should avoid any of the series?
- roneesh 11y agoThere's no order to see it in or order to avoid seeing it in. The writing is strong for each series (though which one is best is debatable). Also every series's episodes largely work as standalone, though Deep Space 9 and Voyager have some overall stories (a war and getting home respectively). My advice is start with Next Generation, it's the best, and most any episode works on it's own. Voyager is my soft spot. Never saw the original, seeing it isn't necessary to enjoy the later ones. Dive in, have fun, my personal suggestion is any episode that deals with time travel or the mischievous life form called Q. You can't go wrong there.
- oqnet 11y agoDS9 needs to watched in sequential order, TOS doesn't, TNG to a certain extent should be watched in order, but doesn't have to be. Some major arch's rely on character points or what has happened with say the borg. Voyager and Enterprise aren't as sequential as DS9 but should be watched in order. There are a significant number of episodes in each you can drop from your watching order, but I couldn't tell you which ones. They both have very low points in my opinion. As for the movies I'm sure there's a watching order. Some of the movies are very meh. If you look online you might find a good order, but if you get really into just watch them in order.
- snerbles 11y agoFor the original series movies... The Motion Picture (#1) is basically an elongated TOS episode. Doesn't really influence any of the other films. Some enjoy it, some find it dull. The Wrath of Khan, The Search for Spock and The Voyage Home (#2-4) form a trilogy and must be watched in order. The Final Frontier (#5)...I loved it when I was nine. Skippable otherwise. The Undiscovered Country (#6) should be watched after #2 through #4. It and The Wrath of Khan are typically tied for the favorite Trek film.
- eslaught 11y agoWhile we're here, let's also acknowledge some of the fan-funded efforts that have been keeping the spirit alive: http://www.startrekaxanar.com/ http://www.startrekaxanar.com/ http://startrekrenegades.com/ http://startrekrenegades.com/ I, for one, am really looking forward to Axanar as much or even more than these official series.
- Gartenioa 11y agoStar Trek was a professionally produced show. These examples do not 'keep alive' anything. Avoid them.
- zo1 11y agoThey have actors from the "professionally produced" shows. I am perfectly willing to sit through non-blockbuster-budgeted series for a chance to see my favourite actors playing their roles, the ones I grew up watching and had a huge influence on who I am as an adult. Edit. Typo.
- dogma1138 11y agoRenegades was nigh godawful. Prelude to Axanar reminded me of the real-action adverts that big budget games have these days was very HALO 3-eque, not good or bad persay, but it was just a relative short (20min) for their kickstarter so not much to judge it by, the VFX looked professional but very un-Star Trek like which was some what disappointing but unless you have the DS9 effects team that managed to make 3D-CGI look like filmed scaled models or the team behing BSG/Firefly you won't probably get the realistic look either.
- eslaught 11y agoRenegades I won't dispute. But I felt like Prelude was exactly what it set out to be and did quite well for that too. Both are doing remarkably well considering the budgets they've been given (even Renegades). In this day and age we have the privilege to pay for what we want to see, if we feel like it. People love to complain, but seriously, if we aren't willing to pony up the cash for something, why should we expect to studios to produce what we want to see? Even paying for a Netflix subscription will split your money so many different ways that the studios aren't going to be getting that much at the end.
- vanderZwan 11y ago> The brand-new Star Trek will introduce new characters seeking imaginative new worlds and new civilizations, while exploring the dramatic contemporary themes that have been a signature of the franchise since its inception in 1966. Although the series is aimed more at the US than the rest of the world, What if they decided to tackle the current migration issues? Those will only become bigger in the future as climate change will provoke more mass migrations. Aside from being contemporary, the topic is a great source of material for dramatic stories too. EDIT: Could tie in neatly to the Vulcan planet being destroyed in the new timeline.
- ericcumbee 11y agoI'm really hoping its not set in the new timeline. My hope is that it is a continuation of the Post Deep Space Nine/ Dominion War/ Voyager timeline. I would hope they look at whats happened in the books set in that period. The final borg invasion, the rise of the typhon pact, and Dr.Bashir from DS9 becoming sort of a Ed Snowden character.
- moomin 11y ago+1 for any proposal that casts Siddig el Fadil as anything other than a terrorist.
- vanderZwan 11y agoOh that sounds fantastic. Yes, surveillance and privacy is also a Big Theme these days. (I only mentioned the new timeline because a Star Trek centered around the troubles of the migrating remainders of Vulcan civilization is just about the only thing that sounds like an appealing hook in that setting. Like others have mentioned, it's an Space Action Movie timeline, not a cerebral Star Trek timeline)
- serge2k 11y agoHey guys we have loads of aliens who want to migrate, let's use our advanced technology to set them up a series of colonies. Though actually, that would have made a decent episode of tng
- 11y ago
- squeral 11y agoI'm a huge fan and hope it's an alternate timeline that can still stick to some of the original stories. Maybe with refresh ship designs :)
- tantalor 11y ago> available exclusively in the United States on CBS All Access > will also be distributed concurrently for television So, is it on TV or not?
- nandhp 11y agoFor the concurrent distribution, I believe they are referring only to international distribution. For example, House of Cards was broadcast on traditional TV channels in countries that did not have Netflix (like Australia, New Zealand, and India).
- ewzimm 11y agoThey state in the press release that it will premiere on TV then move to their steaming service.
- metasean 11y ago> The new series will blast off with a special preview broadcast on the CBS Television Network. The premiere episode and all subsequent first-run episodes will then be available exclusively in the United States on CBS All Access > will also be distributed concurrently for television and multiple platforms around the world by CBS Studios International. - CBS Television Network first, then - United States - exclusively CBS All Access - International, except United States - multiple other platforms
- dogma1138 11y agoKinda worried that this will be a "web-only" series, Star Trek needs quite a good production to work well, The budget for a TNG episode was 2M$ which was pretty unheard off back then and is even considered expensive these days (GOT which is currently the most expensive running show has about 6M per episode and when you count the fact that TNG had 24-25 episodes per season the overall season budget was almost the same). I'm really hoping that the web production will be more akin to Netflix or Amazon Studios quality and budget rather than the usual network webseries tie in. Also anyone has any ideas about the cast? there was a very long standing rumor / pre-production "Captain Worf" show that was supposed to happen but never did, I really hope that this won't be in the rebooted universe because it was well kinda meh. Enterprise wasn't great (4th season was amazing tho), if this will be of the same quality as TNG/DS9 or even "mom we got stuck in the holodeck again" Voyager this would truly blow my mind, but as of now I am pessimistic beyond hope until I can see the cast, writers, and canonical premise.
- exelius 11y agoSci Fi shows are expensive to make period - which is why there aren't usually a lot of them on TV. Just think about it: for a normal sitcom or drama, costumes can be bought off the rack and shots can be done on location or on a sound stage with easily-sourced furniture / decoration / etc. Everything on a Sci Fi (or fantasy) show has to be custom-made; from the costumes to the wall decorations to the light fixtures to the furniture. Custom making these things isn't easy, because they first have to be designed so they look like they "fit" stylistically, then built. A show like Star Trek will also have extensive makeup / prosthetics to depict the many different races. Besides, Star Trek is an active franchise with two recent, very successful movies. No studio exec would ruin a franchise like that with a half-assed, underproduced web series. Because you can't do Sci Fi cheaply without becoming B-movie quality, this show will have to have at a minimum Stargate Atlantis levels of production value. They may just be putting it on the web because the Star Trek demographic doesn't watch network TV and the web is a better way to reach the core audience for the show.
- baldfat 11y ago> Sci Fi shows are expensive to make period So never saw the Dr. Who series int he 1970s and 1980s :) Personally I loved the campy Dr Whos a lot. BBC - "Your almost Out of Budget and you have 3 part series to finish" Producer - "No problem we will put a trash can over that guy and tape up a few trash bags, throw some kids paint on it and there is our new monster." "We will also call the gravel pit see if we can use it as a location during there lunch breaks."
- oldmanjay 11y agoThey'd better just blow out the stops, go like 4000 years in the future and start imagining some out there stuff. I don't need people in makeup and masks fondling iPads and acting all utopian cause Roddenberry said so.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoI guess there are lots of other franchises to watch. I don't know why they'd butcher this one because some folks have tired of it.
- maxerickson 11y agoThere's not other franchises that get Star Trek money and some room to make mistakes. I watch way too much TV but am finally getting sick of it, the commercial requirements end up favoring safe stuff.
- yc1010 11y agoThey had the PADDs on star trek more than decades before tablets where released, yet another example of star trek being ahead of its time as for your "Utopian" comment, in the last few decades we have entered the era of plenty, the main problem encountered by startups we see here in HN is not that they are not innovative its that their products/services get drowned out in a sea of plenty Given a few hundred years and plentiful+cheap energy it is not beyond the realm of imagination to imagine replicators, hell on a recent cruise i nicknamed then soda vending machines "the replicator" because the thing could spit out hundreds of different drinks with a few taps. So a world of the future would be fairly "socialist" as machines and cheap energy allow people to devote their times towards science, exploration, art etc, we are already seeing this happening today and further mechanization and robotics will only speed up the trend
- oldmanjay 11y agoI'll grant them 15 years ahead of the iPad, but the show was supposed to be hundreds of years advanced. My utopian thoughts aren't really around the economics. Star trek humans are all pure of motive and work to do the right thing in all circumstances, modulo plot-necessitated black hats. I'd prefer a bit more humanity there. Humans are far more complex than the black-and-white morality plays star trek tends to be. If they make a show that has "wrath of Khan" level pathos to the characters, I'm in. If it's action schlock or morality plays, the star trek brand isn't enough to attract me, particularly if the technology alternates between "stupidly unreal" and banal.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jbob2000 11y agoI'm skeptical. TV shows in general have taken a turn for the worse lately, with the best series not even really airing on cable. Here's to hoping it's not just another cobbled-together excuse for showing you an ad every 10 minutes.
- myth_buster 11y agoI like what Steven Moffat did with the Doctor Who series, so perhaps a good team could revive the series.
- unixhero 11y agoThey have most definitely not. There's just a higher signal to noise ratio. You have * Fargo * Boardwalk Empire * Mr Robot * Suits * True Detective These are stellar shows with high production qualities. There's generally no ads on web streaming during the show.
- serge2k 11y agoTv is fantastic right now. Network tv sucks
- valm- 11y agoIt appears we will all need to pay CBS %5.99 a month to watch this.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoYes, CBS has this weird notion that you will pay $5.99 a month AND watch commercials that you can't skip. I get that they "think" its like this now, they get paid by the cable company for their channel (the $5.99) and they send them content with commercials (which they have sold), but the new world is NetFlix which charges monthly, but has now commercials.
- enlightenedfool 11y agoI would just wait for it on putlocker
- maxerickson 11y agoThe broadcast networks have been in the process of expanding that fee: http://www.thestreet.com/story/13181362/1/cbss-tough-stance-on-programming-fees-may-be-paying-off.html http://www.thestreet.com/story/13181362/1/cbss-tough-stance-... Given the quality of digital broadcast and tendency for it to overlap cable service areas, it's pretty ridiculous that they manage to get anything. It wouldn't be so hard for a consumer friendly TV to transparently switch between sources (well, except for the cable companies making sure not to put consumer friendly features in their now required boxes).
- toxican 11y agoIt's not a weird notion, considering it works fairly well for Hulu. Even their "commercial-free" tier features commercials on select episodes because "reasons"
- ChuckMcM 11y agoPerhaps 'weird' is the wrong word, I think ultimately it is an unsupportable position. It seems irrational to me in the face of alternatives (Amazon, NetFlix) with higher customer satisfaction.
- munificent 11y ago99% press release trying to demonstrate the economic viability of CBS All Access. 1% about Star Trek.
- danso 11y agoI was a big Trekkie when I was younger...but I'm surprised at how poorly the show has held up when rewatching on Netflix. I think what spoiled me was the revamped Battlestar Galactica. It's not the dated special effects that bother me, it's the way the utopia of Star Trek's future and technology began to provide way too many plot crutches. By the end of TNG, it seemed like every crisis resolution involved reversing the polarity of some piece of equipment or weapon at the last minute. DS9 was my favorite series up until the latter seasons, where again, fancy technobabble would save the day over well-written plots. I never watched much of Voyager or Enterprise...but it seemed the technobabble only increased, with time travel being thrown in for variety. With Voyager, the absurdity of tech continued from the beginning...IIRC, even though Voyager was banished in the middle of nowhere with purportedly limited resources, some technicality about how the holodeck worked allowed them to basically use the holodeck all the time, as if it ran on magic and dreams (which is basically what the holodeck stood for in all the new series). Even the utopian future of no-currency was rendered a bit absurd with DS9 and the introduction of Ferengi as main characters, and constant mentions of "gold-press latinum" BSG spoiled me because it showed, credibly that a space-faring future is unlikely to be clean and sanitized. I think one of my favorite aspects of BSG were the mundane ones, such as how having everyone spread out on different ships hampered logistics and communications. In Star Trek, of course, this was solved with instant communication devices, though the impact of instant communication in TNG-and-on seems rather limited compared to what we experience in the Internet-age. Since the OP states that the new series shares the same writers as the rebooted movies, I'm assuming that the altered timeline will be adopted by the new TV series? The reboot Star Trek films were flashy and entertaining in the way that modern action films are entertaining...but they took up the technology-as-deus-ex-machina to the next level...Scotty created a teleportation device that rendered starship travel moot and, of course, life-giving Tribbles.
- DanBC 11y ago> By the end of TNG, it seemed like every crisis resolution involved reversing the polarity of some piece of equipment or weapon at the last minute. some tech the tech solution that works one week is ignored the next week. http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2009/10/why_i_hate_star_trek.html http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2009/10/why_i_ha... > former Star Trek writer and creator of the re-imagined Battlestar Galactica Ron Moore revealed the secret formula to writing for Trek. > He described how the writers would just insert "tech" into the scripts whenever they needed to resolve a story or plot line, then they'd have consultants fill in the appropriate words (aka technobabble) later. > "It became the solution to so many plot lines and so many stories," Moore said. "It was so mechanical that we had science consultants who would just come up with the words for us and we'd just write 'tech' in the script. You know, Picard would say 'Commander La Forge, tech the tech to the warp drive.' I'm serious. If you look at those scripts, you'll see that." > Moore then went on to describe how a typical script might read before the science consultants did their thing: > La Forge: "Captain, the tech is overteching." > Picard: "Well, route the auxiliary tech to the tech, Mr. La Forge." > La Forge: "No, Captain. Captain, I've tried to tech the tech, and it won't work." > Picard: "Well, then we're doomed." > "And then Data pops up and says, 'Captain, there is a theory that if you tech the other tech ... '" Moore said. "It's a rhythm and it's a structure, and the words are meaningless. It's not about anything except just sort of going through this dance of how they tech their way out of it."
- ajeet_dhaliwal 11y agoHopefully this would be based after the end the war with the Dominion at the end of Deep Space Nine. Enterprise and the new movies have made me tired of Star Trek, not interested in prequels and origin stories any longer.
- tsunamifury 11y agoTwo Words: Starfleet Academy. It would be perfect to introduce a new crew and follow them through the Academy years. They could either do the backstories of existing characters to introduce new ones. You can combine the fun of Hogwarts-eque school, with younger drama, and still throw in lots of science and adventures.
- ck2 11y agoDidn't they do Starfleet with the Bakula series?
- qbrass 11y agoEnterprise was set before Starfleet existed, where nobody knew what they were really doing. The idea was for the crew to make the mistakes that set the precedent for future Starfleet's regulations.
- cpeterso 11y agoI'm binge-watching DS9 (for the second time ;) and I have been thinking a series about Nog's time at Starfleet Academy would be fun.
- luckystarr 11y agoI'm surprised nobody mentioned Star Trek Continues http://www.startrekcontinues.com/ http://www.startrekcontinues.com/ yet. It's financed by donations and has imho very good acting and dramaturgy. James Doohan's son Chris even impersonates Scotty. (Stays in the family, I guess...).
- beat 11y agoI, for one, am optimistic. Even though the JJ Abrams reboot movies sucked, he's not the only one who can do the work. There are hordes of people in Hollywood who grew up on Star Trek, love it properly, and want to bring back the spirit of exploration and optimism and the ensemble cast work that make the older series so compelling. I think the world needs a new Star Trek - one that isn't just shiny effects, but holds true to the sense of hope and courage that I loved and still love. And I know it can be done. On the plus side, the quality of ensemble-cast science fiction tv writing has exploded over the past 15-20 years, starting with how Babylon 5 and Buffy the Vampire Slayer built season and multi-season story arcs that depended on character growth. I would love to see the sort of rich, passionate writing that made Firefly, Walking Dead, and other shows so effective applied to Star Trek! And I'm a little biased toward the development of web-only series - some friends of mine are doing Cartoon Network's first web-only series, and I'm really hoping it succeeds spectacularly and points a new direction for CN. Fixed timeslots in general are a dated way of doing shows now. Timeshifting is the norm. So yeah, hope for a bright future. And screw the Prime Directive.
- codezero 11y agoWhat did you dislike about the reboot films? I really liked them, I thought they were cast well, and were over-all pretty good. edit: others in the comments have noted that the reboots are basically just action sequences with none of the underlying social themes that made Star Trek significant in the first place.
- untog 11y agoThey're fine movies (and I think people sometimes forget that Trek movies are, on average, not great), but they're not particularly "trek"-y, aside from reusing the broad strokes of some historical characters. And personally, I have zero interest in seeing Captain Kirk again. I feel like it was a backwards step to take a broad universe and refocus on the original iconic characters. There are a lot of stories to be told, the Borg are still one of the most fascinating sci-fi creations in years, etc. etc. Basically my objection is that they don't really "boldly go" anywhere, they just retread.
- 11y ago
- wiremine 11y agoI'm a bit disappointed how pessimistic this thread is. They're bringing Star Trek back! There are 1000 reasons it might fail, but it's GREAT to see them trying. The ideals are timeless.
- acheron 11y ago"CBS All Access"? Nobody wants to buy individual streaming services from every studio/network. Stop trying to make it happen. Just sign a deal with Netflix or Amazon[1] and accept you missed the boat. [1] And really Amazon is only acceptable because it's free.[2] [2] Given that having Prime is pretty much non-negotiable anyway.
- rhino369 11y agoNetflix and Amazon don't seem to be interested in becoming the Comcast or direct tv of the Internet. The amount of content Netflix and Amazon can create is limited. They cannot pay for every tv show for 100-120 bucks a year. Look at what a mature company like HBO produces for 180 a year. 3-5 hour long prestige dramas. 5-8 half hour comedies. Some low expense reality tv like Bill Mayer or Real Sports. Netflix may be able to scale better, if they get 80% of households they can go cheaper. But they aren't going to be q total replacement for all media. And you don't want them too. One company with control over all media would be a disaster.
- beloch 11y agoTrek at it's best: 1. Isn't afraid of being slow, talky, and philosophical (Sorry J.J.). TNG had many excellent episodes specifically because it was willing to risk being "boring", while DS9 evolved Trek into the homogeneous "action" formula that has dominated Voyager, most of Enterprise, and the recent movies. 2. Is a force for idealism. The captains of Star Trek are paragons of humanity, and are supposed to find the high ground when tackling murky issues. The original series featured the first on-screen interracial kiss. TNG dove into many thorny ethical issues. While TNG took a hard stance against torture, Enterprise portrayed it as a useful tool. 3. Boldy goes to new places. Star Trek (2009) did nothing new geographically, but at least it went off the reservation by destroying a storied and beloved Trek locale. Not everyone liked that, but at least it was daring. Into Darkness (2013) aped Khan badly, completely missing out on what made the original character and movie special. In general, the Trek movie franchise has been chasing Khan for too long, and needs to focus on other aspects of Trek. 4. Is smart about technology, and self consistent. Nerds pay attention to this stuff. Khan beaming directly from Earth to the Klingon homeworld functionally obliterated the vastness of space in the rebooted Trek universe. Trek doesn't need to blow previously imagined sci-fi tech out of all proportion to be interesting. It's strength, historically, has been inventing new technologies and examining their impact on humans. Is there anything in the new Trek movies that, in a few decades, we're going to be saying, "Hey, Trek predicted this!". 5. Doesn't solve everything by modifying the deflector dish. (Corollary to 4) Voyager, I'm looking at you. All of the series occasionally penned "tech" into their scripts to lazily magic their way out of situations. At some point this became standard practice and as much a part of the formula as always having at least a few minutes of "action trek", no matter how inappropriate it was to the episode. This is a crutch that should be used as sparingly as possible. 6. Features interesting, well-developed alien cultures. The original series may have debuted the Klingons, but it was TNG that fleshed them out into a living, breathing culture. TNG debuted the Cardassians and Bajorans, but DS9 benefited greatly from exploring the cultures of both these races. The formula of Voyager forced a return to shallow portrayals of "species of the week", and the show suffered greatly as a result.
- seehafer 11y agoOne addition in terms of how Trek becomes great, from a behind-the-camera perspective: 7. Results from a tension between competing visions between writers and creators. Examples: TNG was campy and unwatchable, mostly, until Michael Piller took over as head writer in the third season and started focusing on characters and more traditional drama. Piller had an inclination to be too soap opera-y but was held in check by Roddenberry's presence and later, spirit. DS9 was the result of the tension between Ira Steven Behr and Berman aided by Ronald D Moore, and worked well until it became the all-war-all-the-time series. Voyager is the result of Berman, Braga and Jeri Taylor running wild without any counteracting force. Enterprise is the same (minus Taylor).
- gdubs 11y agoCurrently re-watching the Next Generation on Netflix. The remastering is wonderful; you can really see the film-level quality in things like Geordi's visor, etc. What I miss most about the Star Trek universe is its optimism; particularly during The Next Generation days. Sci-fi has largely mirrored the militarism of the past decade. If the new series brings back some of that optimism, I'd be excited.
- erickhill 11y agoIt sickens me that a post with this much activity and interest was modded out of existence. Boo, Hacker News Mod, whoever you are. Boo. Lighten up.
- logfromblammo 11y agoStar Trek is a franchise that was slowly being crushed by the mass of its own canon--five television series, ten feature films, books, comics, video games, and a devoted fanbase will do that. That is likely why the Abrams films rebooted the universe--restarting from the Captain Pike era--with a big enough change to justifiably say it changes everything that the previous continuity ever did. And that is rather fortunate, because if they had made first contact in 2016 rather than 1996, people might conceivably be throwing money into the Facebook, Reddit, and Twitter interfaces to the Borg-net, rather than foolishly engaging in any futile resistance. The cube-ships would be ruthlessly harvesting our most shareable lolcat videos, and everyone would be walking around in identical jeans-and-hoodies outfits and calling everything "amazing". A reboot is really the only way to restore the franchise to its original mission to simplify today's social issues and frame them up against the backdrop of a more progressive starfaring society, so that people can get some perspective on those things that might otherwise be too close to home in a somewhat entertaining way. For instance, given the South China Sea situation, I would guess that at some point, the new Star Trek series would introduce some alien species as proxies for China, Vietnam, Philippines, Malaysia, Japan, and maybe even Brunei, and the China-aliens would be constructing artificial dwarf planets out of hazardous nebulae using unlicensed Genesis devices, and using them as bases to harass passing scientific and mercantile traffic. Then some of the people watching would obsess over details and completely miss the broader point.
- fapjacks 11y agoOh, no. Kurtzman ran Hawaii 5-O and Scorpion, two of the worst shows ever produced in the history of television. This thing is going to blow hard.
- anotherevan 11y agoIt's a shame that they would be very unlikely to option New Frontier by Peter David. He created some great characters there (although I think the latter books have gotten a bit screwy). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Trek:_New_Frontier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Trek:_New_Frontier