3 ms·
OK, I think we all can agree that programmers almost never begin a project with the intention of causing harm. All the examples cited involved situations where
by joe_the_user 11y ago
OK,
I think we all can agree that programmers almost never begin a project with the intention of causing harm. All the examples cited involved situations where immense pressure applied by higher-up impel a programmer to knuckle-under and agree to such approaches.
The solution that is offered seems very specific to now - we take the fall guy who caved in to one sort of incentive and we put an opposite incentive on him to force a different behavior (btw without removing the first incentive). How fucked-up is that?
Obviously, the better, saner solution is removing the existing perverse incentives, giving software engineers more leverage in decisions, punishing high-ups if they don't give software engineers autonomy to make decisions. And heck, execute the CEOs when the bridges collapse. The bucks should stop with them, right?
- hlieberman 11y agoThe problem becomes... what if the CEO is unaware of it? Volkswagen, for example. It is highly unlikely in my mind that some engineer somewhere in the trenches decided, in desperation, to add in a few lines of code to make sure the engine passed emissions tests. But, do I think the CEO of Volkswagen signed off on adding the code? No. There's a diffusion of responsibility that makes it hard to point to any given person after the fact. How can we arm people - software engineers, but product designers, project managers, QA engineers, CEOs, and the welders on the assembly line can say, "Hold on, stop, this isn't right!"?
- joe_the_user 11y agoI think that shows the limits of the punishment after the fact approach. The point is to demand that companies create an atmosphere where professionals have some autonomy to make decisions based on their expertise rather than the good of the company. Unfortunately, the trend is things going the other way for virtually all professionals, not simply almost-professionals like programmers.