11 ms·
Thinking positively: The genetics of high intelligence
- danieltillett 11y agoI would be very surprised if high intelligence was anything other than the extreme edge of a normal distribution of the human population. For it to be anything other than this it would require people of high intelligence to be a sub-population that did not breed with the rest of humanity.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoYou could make this argument for any trait. However, some traits are the result of a single gene - e.g., sickle cell anemia and the accompanying malaria resistance. Yet some of these traits occur in large populations that are not strongly inbred.
- danieltillett 11y agoOnly single gene traits. Intelligence (however defined) is multi-genetic - there are thousands of genes that contribute to intelligence. Given this the only way that individuals with high intelligence could be anything other than edge of a normal distribution is if they were part of a human sub-population. Edit. I should add that the humans are not completely one population because of genetic isolation and differential selection (especially over the last 10,000 years), but we are almost a single population. Like everything in genetics it gets fuzzy at the edges.
- arethuza 11y ago"there are thousands of genes that contribute to intelligence" And the very definition of "intelligence" is incredibly complex and slippery, which is one of the reasons why I've always found trying to summarise such a complex property into a single numerical value such a silly exercise.
- sanxiyn 11y agoSummarizing a complex property into a single numerical value is very useful and not silly. For example, temperature is a numerical summary of huge number of molecular motions. More on this here: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/08/11/does-the-glasgow-coma-scale-exist-do-comas/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/08/11/does-the-glasgow-coma-s...
- arethuza 11y agoI didn't say that all attempts to summarise a complex system in a single number are silly - just that intelligence is such a multi-faceted and ill-understood area that, in my opinion, evaluating people based on a single number is silly. NB I say that as someone who got a very high IQ test result - which didn't exactly convince me that IQ tests are a good idea....
- themetrician 11y agoWhat is the name of the IQ test you took? Intelligence really isn't "multi-faceted" (read Gardner's own admission that his theory never panned out) and it isn't ill-understood (refer to the Nature or Nurture interview with Nancy Segal on YouTube). There's two reasons people say that. One is, they fared badly on a test and want to dismiss it, and the other is, they fared well on a test and are bashful about it. Also, IQ tests are meant to measure a person's intelligence, not to convince them that IQ tests are "a good idea" - for that you would have to study Psychometrics.
- arethuza 11y ago"it isn't ill-understood" I worked on AI research for a number of years and my strong opinion is that our understanding of general intelligence is, as some wit put it, "pre-Newtonian".
- themetrician 11y agoAI research has nothing whatsoever to do with Psychometrics so you are not qualified to opine.
- cousin_it 11y ago* Geographical isolation for much of history * Social class * Assortative mating
- apalmer 11y agoThis is complete conjecture on your part.
- troels 11y agoOn the other hand - Chimps are significantly less intelligent than humans. So clearly, genetics play a role.
- danieltillett 11y agoOf course genetics plays a role in intelligence (a very important role). In the case of chimps they are not part of the human population so they are not really relevant to any discussion about the genetics of human intelligence.
- medymed 11y agoIf raised in an affluent suburb, they might surprise you.
- gwern 11y agoSpeaking of which, have you seen the _Project Nim_ documentary on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nim_Chimpsky https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nim_Chimpsky ? I would have to say that no, he did not surprise me, and the results were exactly what I would have expected after reading de Waal's _Chimpanzee Politics_.
- medymed 11y agothats ridiculous:-)
- DonaldFisk 11y agoOn many, but not all cognitive tasks: https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn12993-chimps-outperform-humans-at-memory-task/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/dn12993-chimps-outperfo... Of course, genetics probably plays a role in that, too.
- mgraczyk 11y agoSubpopulations can be physically and temporally distributed amongst the greater population. As long as breeding is not statistically independent of intelligence, there will be a tendency for intelligence-related genes to clump together.
- danieltillett 11y agoThis is true, but to get extreme outlier sub-populations for a mulit-gene trait like intelligence would require pretty effective isolation. For any sub-population to be large enough to affect the distribution of intelligence across the human population, yet be able to maintain this isolation, is very unlikely.
- stephengillie 11y agoIt is - a family with low average intelligence can birth occasional individuals with much higher intelligence than their average.
- vixen99 11y ago'would require people of high intelligence to be a sub-population that did not breed with the rest of humanity' - which is increasingly what is happening with people of high ability & potential income of both sexes attending the same universities and mating. This polarization has been documented.
- ansible 11y agoThis polarization has been documented. And seems to produce a higher incidence of autism too, if the anecdotes are to be believed...
- Omniusaspirer 11y agoThat has more to do with parental age than anything else.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 11y agoI hope someone intelligent is working on intelligence reallocation.
- astrodust 11y agoThere are a lot of highly intelligent people at all levels of income distribution, so while there might be a polarization effect, it's not to the point of being segregation. Intelligence can help you gain wealth, but if you're never given an opportunity or don't have a lot of drive you'll struggle perpetually.
- drumdance 11y agoIt's happening, but I think it will take quite a few generations for it to become and independent trait of its own.
- danieltillett 11y agoIt would take quite a while for asortive mating to create a new human sub-population, but given the low fertility (through choice) of people with high intelligence such a sub-population can't form.
- lagadu 11y ago> For it to be anything other than this it would require people of high intelligence to be a sub-population that did not breed with the rest of humanity. It is: we call it "social classes". Because intelligence correlates positively with success and because people tend to have children with other people from a similar social stratum, the exact situation you described emerges as a pattern.
- bittercynic 11y agoMy experience doesn't bear this out. Though the few extremely wealthy people I know seem very intelligent, I don't think intelligence correlates with income for the $15K-$200K annual income range. (This is the best proxy I know of for social stratum here in the Bay Area.) I know very intelligent and very stupid people all over this income range, with no obvious pattern.
- Tenhundfeld 11y agoI don't think the question is whether "intelligence correlates positively with success". That may be true but doesn't reveal much about society, IMO. The more interesting question is which correlations are strongest. I can't find a link, but I read a study that came out a few years ago that showed the biggest correlation with financial success was the parents' income levels. That is, controlling for the intelligence of the parents, an average-intelligence person born to wealthy parents was more likely to be financially successful than an above-average-intelligence person born to poor parents. That may also be obvious, but it has more effect on the veracity of the common view of our society being a meritocracy.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> an average-intelligence person born to wealthy parents was more likely to be financially successful than an above-average-intelligence person born to poor parents. > That may also be obvious, but it has more effect on the veracity of the common view of our society being a meritocracy. Why? There's nothing about that that speaks to how much of a meritocracy we are. Parents' financial success directly measures everything that contributes to financial success (rather than, say, a subcomponent); you'd expect it to be highly informative. The result you cite still holds when both children are adopted away. Is that support for the view of society as a meritocracy?
- douche 11y agoAshkenazi Jews would seem to be a well-studied sub-population that tends to possess above-average intelligence. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashkenazi_Jewish_intelligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashkenazi_Jewish_intelligence
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoI notice in that page it compares the number of "full" Ashkenazi Jews in the population, to the number of people who won various academic prizes who had "full or partial" Ashkenazi ancenstry, which seems like a very blatant distortion. On reading slightly further I see someone else has already spotted this and added that disclaimer to the text. Seems like it would be relatively easy to compare like with like here, which makes me suspicious of why it isn't done. Does that mean that the effect disappears when you do that comparison? It's certainly going to be reduced.
- GPGPU 11y agoAs an Ashkenazi Jew, I'd tend to agree. We're also much better looking than other people!
- danieltillett 11y agoEven if it were true that Ashkenazi Jews as a group had above average intelligence, there just are not enough Ashkenazi Jews in the world to have a significant influence on the distribution of human intelligence.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> I would be very surprised if high intelligence was anything other than the extreme edge of a normal distribution of the human population. For it to be anything other than this it would require people of high intelligence to be a sub-population that did not breed with the rest of humanity. Not at all. There could be a specific suite of traits that includes high intelligence, present in some people but not in most. Those people would have high intelligence, but they wouldn't be the extreme of the natural variation of the rest of the population. They would have gotten there by "cheating". This is known to occur right now in human height. Men are taller than women. The difference is so pronounced that the human height distribution is not normal. The tallest humans (except Yao Ming) basically are the extreme of normal variation in men. But they aren't the extreme of normal variation in humans. I hope you'll agree that "men" cannot be characterized as a subpopulation that doesn't breed with the rest of humanity.
- danieltillett 11y agoMen can't be a sub-population by definition since men can breed with men. In regards intelligence both men and woman share the same mean. Given men have only one X chromosome we might expect that they might show a wider distribution in intelligence than women, but the evidence for this is controversial and airing it has a habit of losing you your job.
- thaumasiotes 11y agoI don't see how this is responsive to anything in my comment?
- danieltillett 11y agoI should have written “can’t" not “can" which does rather mess up my response. Actually height is unlike intelligence since there is one gene on the Y chromosome that has a very large influence on height. There are no such genes for intelligence as this study and many others has found.
- apalmer 11y agoYour second sentence is not logically implied by the first sentence. It is not uncommon to have phenotypes that are expressed only rarely although the genes that code for the phenotype are widely dispersed. Many well known genetic diseases fall into this category.
- danieltillett 11y agoIntelligence is like height in that it is multi-genetic (on the order of thousands of genes). Any trait that is determined by thousands of genes is going to show a normal distribution.
- apalmer 11y agoI understand the reasoning behind that... however the whole point of this study was to put this logical assumption under the rigors of actual science... because this is an 'assumption' not a logical 'conclusion'.
- danieltillett 11y agoI just said I would have been surprised if the result was anything other than they found, not that the study was not worth doing. For something as important as intelligence it is worth checking all of our assumptions. This study does support what previous studies have found from when people looked for genes that had a large positive effect on intelligence and failed to find any.
- DonaldFisk 11y agoI don't think there's such a thing as general intelligence. You can be good at some cognitive tasks and poor at other cognitive tasks: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_multiple_intelligences https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_multiple_intelligenc... I also don't think you can separate genetic influences from environmental influences, i.e. one allele might make you do well in one environment and poorly in a different environment. This appears to the case for the 7R allele of the DRD4 gene: http://www.northwestern.edu/newscenter/stories/2008/06/ariaaltribe.html http://www.northwestern.edu/newscenter/stories/2008/06/ariaa... I also don't think any genes actually code for intelligence as it's commonly understood. Intelligence is, basically, knowledge (including knowledge about how to acquire knowledge). Genes affect brain chemistry, which influences intelligence in different ways, within a given environment.
- jessriedel 11y agoThe theory of multiple intelligence you link to is in strong disagreement with the mainstream position of academia. > Intelligence tests and psychometrics have generally found high correlations between different aspects of intelligence, rather than the low correlations which Gardner's theory predicts, supporting the prevailing theory of general intelligence rather than multiple intelligences (MI).[19] The theory has been widely criticized by mainstream psychology for its lack of empirical evidence, and its dependence on subjective judgement.[20]
- drumdance 11y agoHas anyone looked at how these studies correlate with the Big Five personality traits? It seems to me that intelligent people are more conscientious but that could just be my bias.
- moyix 11y agoSome quick Googling turns up: http://www.drtomascp.com/uploads/PersonalityIntelligence_IJSA_2005.pdf http://www.drtomascp.com/uploads/PersonalityIntelligence_IJS... Which seems to provide some (weak) evidence against that: "The hypothesis of a significant correlation between various Big Five personality traits and intelligence test scores was only partially supported. Only Conscientiousness was significantly related to psychometric intelligence, correlating with BRT scores. It is worth noting that the correlation was negative, indicating that higher conscientious participants tended to have lower gf." I'm far from an expert though, so I can't say how good that study is.
- pippy 11y agoInteresting, but tangently related: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Klark_Graham https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Klark_Graham
- sygma 11y agoSaw it on your monthly newsletter today. Thanks for compiling those!
- dgrant 11y agoCan someone explain this for someone like me with no education in biology or psychology?
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoSadly that may be impossible. Metaphors are limited - the understanding gained is always flawed and rarely actionable. A better question is, how much education in biology and psychology is needed to appreciate these findings?
- nitrogen 11y agoThis is an interesting point and reminds me of the difference between technical and verbal understanding: http://www.yudkowsky.net/rational/technical/ http://www.yudkowsky.net/rational/technical/
- jm_l 11y agoFor mentally challenged people, researchers have done an analysis of the distribution of certain genes that are associated with the handicap. They have shown with high likelihood that mental handicap is actually different than just being on the low end of the intelligence distribution. This study tries to answer the question, "is the same true for high intelligence?" The two general theories are the Continuity Hypothesis and Discontinuity Hypothesis. As its name suggests, the Continuity Hypothesis predicts that the high end of the intelligence distribution is continuous; extremely intelligence individuals don't violate the intelligence distribution the way mentally challenged people do. The Discontinuity Hypothesis predicts the opposite. By analyzing the genes of twins and other close family members, the researchers found strong evidence of the Continuity Hypothesis.
- soheil 11y agoI love how you accurately summarized a 10 page paper into a few concise sentences understandable most likely even by those on the low end of the intelligence distribution.
- josephjrobison 11y agoWas hoping that thinking positively would help increase your own intelligence - seems to not be that way?
- munchbunny 11y agoMaybe not your intelligence. But this article is just about intelligence as a trait, not about how to live. The question you ask for yourself is "how do I live well?"
- throwawayaway 11y agoSo time for GATTACA right?
- hyperion2010 11y agoActually not time for GATTACA because you'd have to tweak 1000s of genes not one. Which was the finding of this paper.
- aklemm 11y agoWhat if being retarded and being highly intelligent aren't ends of the same spectrum? High intelligence seems much more situational than being retarded. A retardation is fairly objective and would stand out in almost any scenario, whereas high intelligence can be invisible when the subject isn't taking an IQ test.