3 ms·
This is the downside and the greatest danger with more and more centralized ad networks. Site owners: Market your ads directly or through smaller exchanges, an
by mschuster91 11y ago
This is the downside and the greatest danger with more and more centralized ad networks.
Site owners: Market your ads directly or through smaller exchanges, and host them yourself. This is the only viable long-term option.
- Dylan16807 11y agoA big ad network is fine in theory, just stop using foreign javascript. Or any javascript.
- mschuster91 11y agoThe first iphone jailbreaks went via PNG/JPEG/PDF parser exploits. Disabling javascript does not protect you against a sufficiently malicious enterprise - and I'd label both the three-letter-agencies and the ex-Soviet mafiya as such. Both have been proven to use such tactics.
- seanwilson 11y agoThis would be an argument against using any site that allows user uploaded content, such as this site.
- Dylan16807 11y agoIf you want to be super-paranoid, only accept BMP or TGA with a specific color depth and no compression and validate the header before parsing. Or even accept only raw RGB data, 3 * width * height, and require the size be passed separately. Then convert it to png yourself. You can't prevent exploits from all angles, but you can prevent exploits from some angles.
- itake 11y agoIs it? I hypothesize that smaller exchange have less resources to develop secure systems. While they maybe smaller targets, I think their architecture maybe less robust. Hence why I trust gmail to run my email rather than rolling my own server.
- djent 11y agoAn image that links to the advertiser's product is really all that is needed.
- stevesearer 11y agoMy advertisers are happy with this approach and instead of taking a CPM or CPC billing monthly like a billboard seems to work just fine meaning I'm not incentivized to game clicks or views. This is nice because it makes me want to make good decisions for the user experience (no multi-page image galleries) which I believe will help attract the types of visitors my advertisers want to interact with.
- kevin_thibedeau 11y agoBut then you can't have the dynamic web 2.0 monkey punching experience that the guys in marketing insist on having to keep up with the hottest trends.
- goodside 11y agoJust serve all third-party ad code inside of an IFrame served from a different domain. Even if malicious JS is loaded, it's sandboxed away from any session cookies.
- mmastrac 11y agoYou'll still be serving malware to end users though.
- stevesearer 11y agoWhat you've described is precisely what I do, though I also choose to have only static jpg and png graphics. Keeping ads very relevant is also of importance for me: office furniture ads against office design projects and articles. Selling your own ads takes work for sure, and a different type of work. Instead of technical know how, you need to put in time and energy selling ads and not just sit around waiting for sales to come to you. You also obviously get to keep 100% of the money from the sale which is nice.
- heroh 11y agothis puts you outside the reach of big ad $, which is moving towards programmatic buying and serving retargeting ads. You may be able to link up to a big player, but hosting things yourself will require quite a bit of overhead and they pay off may not be worth it, unless you're getting substantial volume (or appealing to a very targeted audience) btw, traditional display ad CTR is rubbish from an advertisers perspective and we all want to go all in on programmatic + retargeting.
- mahranch 11y ago> this puts you outside the reach of big ad $, which is moving towards programmatic buying and serving retargeting ads. Not if the big ad companies (google's adsense) create a plugin or program that serves the ads up locally instead of making obvious 3rd party calls to their own networks. I suspect they're working on such a plugin as we speak.
- heroh 11y agoI don't think Google's looking to decentralize in any way shape or form. If anything, they want to know more about a viewer and will be actively fighting to prevent decentralization... especially as it'll break a lot of reporting that advertisers expect.
- mahranch 11y ago> I don't think Google's looking to decentralize in any way shape or form. I think google's looking to do what's best for their bottom line. If it becomes more profitable, or even much more profitable to decentralize in that way, they will do it without hesitation. Perhaps they're looking for a way to decentralize their ads, yet still retain the data & meta-data. Basically, have their cake and eat it too.