6 ms·
Move to the cloud, all fine and everything, as long as you're an US company. Can't speak too detailed because of NDA, but at work we cannot use innovative tool
by mschuster91 11y ago
Move to the cloud, all fine and everything, as long as you're an US company.
Can't speak too detailed because of NDA, but at work we cannot use innovative tools like Google Docs, Google Mail for Business, Dropbox, Office 365 and the likes (and for our privacy-conscious clients, no AWS, only Azure) because the US government can compel the providers to turn over our confidential data to them. We're stuck with Lotus Notes 8.5 and Office 2013 because our IT wants to migrate to Office, but our client NDAs prohibit us from using cloud stuff with their data (again, fears of the clients of US industrial espionage. Snowden actually proved them right).
The NSA and the US government effectively killed their cloud business for non US customers with their spying crap.
- frik 11y agoWhy Azure but no AWS? Has Microsoft a datacenter in your country? Also both are US companies with various sister-companies e.g. in Ireland (EU).
- dogma1138 11y agoMost likely nothing to do with US companies or the "cloud" just specific compliance concerns, the whole sentiment sounds like it came straight of the lips of a circa 2007-8 CTO/CIO of a heavily regulated vertical.
- larkscall 11y agoMost real world work is done in privately owned data centers. Hipster's love for AWS or the like isn't going to change that. Netflix rocks on AWS but that doesn't change the reality of data control concerns for most companies in or outside the US.
- dogma1138 11y agoYes it is, but it doesn't mean that AWS and similar solutions aren't used for development, DR, and other usecases. When a company uses AWS or Azure it doesn't mean 100% of it's infrastructure is invested in it.
- icebraining 11y agoWTF does "hipster" have to do with liking AWS? These lazy insults on HN are just tiring and contribute nothing to a civil discussion. (And no, I don't use AWS, except for S3 as a dumb storage for encrypted backups.)
- mschuster91 11y agoAWS was the only cloud provider which guaranteed in writing that the data would not be exposed to anything/anyone in the US. Bla-bla promises have been given by everyone, but only a formal document can be used to sue for damages in case of violation.
- dogma1138 11y agoThat's more likely to do with the cloud in general or even more likely with platform specific compliance issues rather than anything to do with the US. EU's data protection directive and various local legislation like the DPA don't have an issue with the cloud, but are quite stringent on the fact that the data doesn't leave the EU so you are restricted to EU data centers. Google and Microsoft have services for EU customers that more or less ensure that the data never leaves an EU data center (MSFT guarantees it, google slightly less so) and as far as infrastructure goes most if not all PAAS/IAAS providers have a European data centers. https://aws.amazon.com/compliance/eu-data-protection/ https://aws.amazon.com/compliance/eu-data-protection/ I know for a fact that at the least British, German, Dutch and Italian companies and governmental organizations even in heavily regulated industries like health care and defense use both Azure and AWS for both corporate IT and production (and if we count less regulated verticals such as banking, financial services, and telco then everyone and their mother within the EU uses Azure, AWS, and many other cloud platforms). So no while there is some issues with some US companies and services in regards to privacy especially around the safe harbor rulings there isn't any global or even meaningful resistance to the use of US services providers and software. P.S. Also the fact that you use Lotus Notes and Office 2013 also has very little to do with US phobia, you could've used Exchange just as well, and office 2015 just came out and very few organizations have actually migrated to it. P.S. 2 You've likely already broken your NDA by admitting you signed one or that one exists, as the existence of an NDA is the first thing that is by it. Not to mention that while you didn't gave any technical detail the fact that you've mentioned the restrictions your company and or organization is under is also most likely a breach of any potential NDA as well as organizational opsec protocols.
- mschuster91 11y agoAd PS2: My NDA thankfully covers only client-related matters (which kinda makes sense). The point of why no migration has occurred (or, actually, the migration underway has been paused) is the massive level of uncertainity, which has been fueled even more by the recent EUGH ruling on Facebook.
- bad_user 11y agoThat hasn't been my experience, I don't know from where you're getting your facts from. But I'm involved with two very big German companies and I've heard of many others that are banning US-based services and it's not enough for those services to have servers in the EU. There is no such thing as AWS or Azure, their usage would be unthinkable. Everything happens on their own infrastructure and installing Skype on your computer for example can get you fired. The reason is quite simply fear of industrial espionage and the Snowden leaks made things a lot worse.
- joncp 11y agoSurely you can mitigate that by using encryption at every phase of your operation? That would be a good idea even if the US government were trustworthy. It's also a good idea if you're running everything on-site; if someone were to gain access to your systems, they get nothing.
- mschuster91 11y agoIf you're using stuff like the IoT Hub by MS, you can't use encryption other than HTTPS, and even if you could, deploying a secure encryption solution to IoT devices is a nightmare.
- walshemj 11y agoSo if your working in an industry where security is a real concern you don't use the cloud
- xj9 11y agoYou can use clouds, just not public ones.
- snowwrestler 11y agoI think these types of concerns may eventually be addressed by better and more consistent use of encrypt-in-place in application design. If your data is well encrypted, theoretically it should be safe from the NSA even if they get their hands on the files. Encrypt-in-transit is well along in terms of culture and technology. "SSL everywhere" is something that, I think, most folks believe we can achieve. Google, for example, has said that eventually Chrome will start marking all HTTP connections as insecure. But how many hosted apps being designed today will encrypt all their stored data from the start? I would guess almost none. Even though that is where the smart folks go to steal data: where it's resting. Just sitting there for anyone to grab once they get through the perimeter. What if all data was encrypted at rest by default? It's an idea worth thinking about.
- rifung 11y agoI'm pretty sure most people have thought about doing this; the issue is that with our current technology, the overhead is too large to be practical. At least, that was my understanding in the matter when I was doing some cryptography related research. On the other hand, a lot of research is striving towards that goal. A method for fully homomorphic encryption was very recently discovered, and although it is still way too slow to be practical, the fact that we finally figured out a way to do it after several decades of searching is a huge step.
- taejo 11y agoEven if all data is encrypted at rest, you can still learn a huge amount from access patterns. You need some kind of Oblivious RAM (which could perhaps be better named Oblivious Disk) where the cloud server doesn't even know the metadata (e.g. which disk sector) it's serving, let alone the content. Cryptographers know how to do this in theory, but the overhead is pretty big.
- plg 11y agosounds like an opportunity
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]