3 ms·
War is Boring has put out numerous hit pieces on the F35. Most of what they write is poorly researched, empty statements without any factual backing, or the equ
by adventured 11y ago
War is Boring has put out numerous hit pieces on the F35. Most of what they write is poorly researched, empty statements without any factual backing, or the equivalent of straw-man arguments.
This is about as sophisticated as their arguments get:
"Can the F-35 really engage, shoot and kill its enemy from long distances? There are reasons to believe it can’t."
The argument attempt they make in that section isn't an argument at all, it's hollow. They say something as though it's factual, without ever backing it up.
For example, that F35 dogfight outcome was with a very early F35, that was carrying a fraction of its final technology package. War is Boring intentionally ignores that completely because they're trying to defraud the reader and spin some propaganda.
http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/07/f-35-project-team-says-dogfight-report-does-not-tell-whole-story/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/07/f-35-p...
From The Joint Program Office for the F-35:
"The F-35's technology is designed to engage, shoot, and kill its enemy from long distances, not necessarily in visual "dogfighting" situations. There have been numerous occasions where a four-ship of F-35s has engaged a four-ship of F-16s in simulated combat scenarios and the F-35s won each of those encounters because of its sensors, weapons, and stealth technology."
- SCAQTony 11y agoYou appear very knowledgeable about the plane but I counter the above with a pentagon report that summarily states (second paragraph) the F-35 circa July 2015 is falling short and it is not operationally effective for military combat. The following paragraphs thereafter contain a "shopping list" of mods the F-35 would need to have to be combat effective. http://www.pogoarchives.org/straus/2015-9-1-DoD-FOIA-ocr.pdf http://www.pogoarchives.org/straus/2015-9-1-DoD-FOIA-ocr.pdf The plane's 400-billion cost is too extravagant and to bring up a point that the 'War is Boring' article made when comparing the inexpensive, 4-speed, Sherman tank versus the Porsche-engine equipped Tiger tank in World War 2, the Tiger was outnumbered by a preponderance of force that was more manageable. An "outdated" F-18e (still in use) can defeat an F-35 in a dog fight and costs about half or $55-million each. (An F35 $100-million-plus) In my opinion the F-18 would be more valuable and effective in regional conflict than an F-35. YMMV