4 ms·
I've been running my own XMPP server for years, with federation enabled. A few years ago, it seemed like the logical successor to AIM and MSN and all those othe
by LeoPanthera 11y ago
I've been running my own XMPP server for years, with federation enabled. A few years ago, it seemed like the logical successor to AIM and MSN and all those other walled garden IM systems. And how easy! My XMPP "name" was the same as my email address. One less thing to put on my business card.
But since then, I have realised a big problem with it - no-one uses it! Today I communicate with the world by iMessage, SMS, Twitter, and email. "Instant messaging" just seems to have died as a concept entirely, replaced by yet more walled gardens like Snapchat.
My XMPP server is being turned off for good, next week.
- jkarneges 11y agoSMS is at least federated. Unfortunately nobody cares about federation anyway: https://medium.com/message/its-kind-of-cheesy-being-green-2c72cc9e5eda https://medium.com/message/its-kind-of-cheesy-being-green-2c... The situation is hopeless.
- stock_toaster 11y agoI ran my own xmpp server for a long time as well. Once gmail stopped federating xmpp (hangouts "upgrade"), most of my contacts just...went dark -- they still showed as online, but they never got messages anymore. The few contacts who also ran their own servers, or used a public one, eventually gave up and stopped using it too, probably because most of their friends were on gmail too. So yeah. I think xmpp is pretty much dead, and google killed it. Oddly, irc still lives on!
- scintill76 11y agoGood to know someone else experienced this. Federation with new Hangouts may not be completely dead -- see my sibling comment if you're interested -- but they crippled it so bad, it may as well be. It's such weird behavior that I almost wonder if it's an accidental regression, as I don't why they'd bother to have it almost-work like that.
- scintill76 11y agoI've also been running my own federated XMPP server for a few years. To my dismay I discovered about a month ago, that a Gmail user on the "new Hangouts UI" never saw me as online. I could send them messages but they just got dumped into an "email"-looking message within Gmail, which I don't think even registered as unread. You'd have to go looking to find it at all. I think they could send me messages, but why would they if I never appear to be online? If the Gmail user reverted to the "old chat", things seemed to work as expected. They're nice enough to let you toggle between them for now, but my friend said only the new interface allows free SMSing or something. Don't take my word too heavily, as this was just what I saw in a quick test with one Gmail account of my own. But I decided if Google is going to basically hellban me, and since almost all of my contacts are on Gmail anyway, I'd just transition to a Gmail account to talk to them. I only have one contact that's not on Gmail, and it's an acquaintance I'll probably not talk to again. Maybe I'll keep the server running just for decentralized geek-cred. At least Google is nice enough to let me use a desktop client, for now. I also noticed Google doesn't seem to support encryption on federated chats. I guess the proper solution is something like OTR anyway, but that was disappointing to see.
- LeoPanthera 11y agoGoogle turned off XMPP federation ages ago, as far as I know.
- takeda 11y agoWhy no one created a transport for hangouts? This is how XMPP conquered msn, aol, yim and others, and could once again become popular. Is communication with hangouts much harder?
- McGlockenshire 11y agoHard isn't the right word - it seems to not currently be officially possible. There is no documented interface for communication with users on Hangouts. Not even XMPP is supposed to work, though I and some other users are still able to use it. The only API available is for building applications that interact with the existing Hangouts UI.
- BostonEnginerd 11y agoKeep it on! I'll talk to you! Let's keep fighting the good fight. I just setup my XMPP server a few months back.
- timdeneau 11y agoThe whole situation is irritating. Federated XMPP is technically the solution. However, it's in the best interest of Google, Apple, Facebook, WhatsApp etc to intentionally fragment chat, at the expense of every internet user. It's short sighted in the long run. I still keep my server on. There are only a handful of contacts left, but it's mostly out of stubbornness. I hope it comes back around eventually.