10 ms·
Academia’s Rejection of Diversity
- revelation 11y agoWhat a bizarre line of thinking. A 50/50 split in reasoning isn't "diversity", it's "uncertainty". It is the absence of knowledge. If a researchers "ideology" related to their field wasn't moving in line with results, we would rightly call them biased.
- ch4s3 11y agoThat isn't what the article is saying. It argues that the lack of ideological diversity in social sciences leads to less scrutiny of conventional wisdom. Which it claims is partially responsible for the field's trouble reproducing the results of published research. [edit] I'm just paraphrasing the argument of the article, which I don't necessarily agree with.
- _delirium 11y ago> As such, the field seems to have trouble reproducing the results of published research. I'm skeptical that ideological diversity or lack thereof is at the root of this, since you see it in a lot of "soft science" disciplines of varying political inclinations. Political science, psychology, and economics have fairly different distributions of political viewpoints, and yet none of those fields has a strong track record of reproducibility.
- ch4s3 11y agoI'm not sure I agree either, I was just summarizing what I thought was the thesis of the article.
- oldmanjay 11y agoIf the views are diverse when viewed across all disciplines but a monoculture inside, then you've made an argument in favor of the position you're against.
- _delirium 11y agoThey aren't really a monoculture inside, though. Economics, for example, is pretty politically diverse, with economists ranging from socialist to libertarian in their political preferences, and yet still can't reproduce much.
- revelation 11y agoThen make the argument that these findings are wrong. Don't make the argument that you are surprised the majority of climate scientists "believe" in global warming when that is what results in the field are showing.
- whatshisface 11y agoYou could generate 100% "certainty" about the results of a coin toss if you threw everyone who didn't think it would come up heads out of the room. If you can't convince someone who doesn't already agree, you shouldn't be allowed to claim knowledge, only opinion. (Note: This doesn't mean you aren't right, just that our social mechanism of truth-finding shouldn't trust you implicitly.)
- haberman 11y ago> If you can't convince someone who doesn't already agree, you shouldn't be allowed to claim knowledge, only opinion. What about global warming denial, anti-vax, young-earth creationism, etc? I'm not being snarky, it legitimately troubles me that "can you convince people?" is the best measure of truth we seem to have, because it seems so noisy and unreliable.
- nonbel 11y ago>"What really count are dramatic, unexpected, stunning predictions: a few of them are enough to tilt the balance; where theory lags behind the facts, we are dealing with miserable degenerating research programmes." Imre Lakatos. Science and Pseudoscience. From Imre Lakatos, Philosophical Papers, vol. 1 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1977), 1-7. Written in early 1973 http://crl.ucsd.edu/~ahorowit/lakatos.pdf http://crl.ucsd.edu/~ahorowit/lakatos.pdf
- PaulHoule 11y agoThe problem with retaining conservatives in academia is that they can make too much money from super pacs, crazy billionaires, telecom companies that want you to pay a lot for crappy DSL, etc.
- blisterpeanuts 11y agoI'd love to hear the rest of the list, signified by the "etc." :)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- stupidcar 11y agoThere is a big difference between homogenous, but mostly uncoordinated and unconscious biases held by liberal academics, and the conscious, coordinated and incredibly aggressive campaign by conservative politicians, business interests, activists and academics to attack and discredit any theory or research that conflicts with their world-view. If some innocent conservative academics are facing blowback for being associated with the wrecking tactics of their ideological peers, I'd say it's the least of our problems. The risk that we might literally wind up destroying our civilisation due to the malfeasance of the right weight more heavily on my mind than that some conservative academics struggle to get tenure. If anything, attempting the resolve the latter problem will only exacerbate the first, by helping legitimising the garbage research that conservative academics are paid to produce.
- oldmanjay 11y agoThat you think the only threat to civilization comes from the right shows a bit of bias all on its own. That you can say this in the same paragraph where you essentially condone censuring people for holding views you find unconvincing is just icing on that nasty little cake.
- nemo 11y ago"That you think the only threat to civilization comes from the right" That's not what they said nor is it implied.
- oldmanjay 11y agoIt was directly said that conservatives threaten civilization. I'll admit the "only" was my insertion. The implications of the rest of the comment are clear and I'll stand by my interpretation.
- jacobolus 11y agoWatching the president of the American Enterprise Institute whine about how the partisan hacks he sponsors don’t get respect among intellectuals is pretty amusing. To paraphrase Ben Kenobi, you will never find a more wretched hive of question begging and anti-empirical babble than the AEI. * * * More generally, I reject the claim of the paper he cites (http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X14000430 http://dx.doi.org/10.1017/S0140525X14000430) that changing partisan affiliation among social psychologists is proof that the field has been overrun with leftists, who are driving out all the conservatives via active discrimination, and who have an agenda of proving that conservatives are evil/stupid/lazy/intolerant/.... There are many possible alternative explanations: * Perhaps the social psychologists’ views have remained consistent while the US Republican party has become more radicalized, causing former political moderates to now fall in naturally with the Democratic party. * Perhaps academia as a whole or social psychology as a field has lost status or become less desirable as a career, and folks whose ideological outlook emphasizes money and status have decided to go into industry more than before. * Perhaps the Republican party’s cuts to education funding in general or diversion of funding away from social sciences toward STEM fields (including cutting direct funding for public institutions, cuts to research funding, etc.), attempt to exert governmental bureaucratic control over universities, etc. has changed the minds of formerly conservative-leaning academics away from supporting the GOP. * Perhaps social psychologists or other social scientists have the perception that Republican lawmakers are disregarding the direct lessons of social science and thus framing policies which are “bad” for some reason independent of ideological bias. * Perhaps the easy availability of money at institutions such as the AEI, the Heritage Foundation, etc. has swayed conservative-leaning social scientists to give up on universities and peer-reviewed research, and follow the money to these so-called think tanks. etc.
- pygy_ 11y ago> Perhaps the social psychologists’ views have remained consistent while the US Republican party has become more radicalized, causing former political moderates to now fall in naturally with the Democratic party. That is indeed partly the case, at least as far as the US congress goes. Based on a fivethirtyeight metrics, the average of each group has gradually moved away from the center, but the Republicans did so about twice as fast as the Democrats. I can't find the post where both parties are discussed, but here's one about the Republicans: http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/jeb-bush-president-republican-primary-2016/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/datalab/jeb-bush-president-republ... Relevant graph: https://espnfivethirtyeight.files.wordpress.com/2014/12/silver-datalab-jeb-1.png?w=610&h=916 https://espnfivethirtyeight.files.wordpress.com/2014/12/silv...
- cafebeen 11y agoWhile I agree with the general sentiment, the article makes a pretty poor argument. One one hand, they cite research saying that gender and racial diversity can improve performance and creativity, and then they go on to talk about the lack of political diversity. If want you want is a diversity of ideas (and political views are only ideas, gender and race are not), then academia is full of competing thoughts about nearly every topic. I surely wouldn't want to force a biology department to hire people who deny that evolution occurs...
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoIt's a shame these comments went so far off the rails. The most important diversity is in life experience and problem-solving skills. If your idea of diversity is something that's only skin deep, you deserve what you get. However most voters do not deserve the public education system they are paying for. They're expecting a reasonable, open-minded discussion of ideas. What they're getting is evidenced by the comments here. We're starting to see kids leave academia with 5 and 6-figure college debts with no discernible job skills, no ability to discuss political matters without resort to either threats or stereotypes, and no experience dealing with intellectuals with widely divergent life experiences and problem-solving methods. That's a total and complete fail.
- Torgo 11y agoThe best evidence I have seen for this among friends still in academia is the near-uniform lack of knowledge of, or inability to articulate serious critiques of their own ideas. Almost down to the person, the people I interact with have a "my ideology represents the end of history" mindset. It is getting worse and is not limited to right-left. I recently have seen ruthless attacks against Germaine Greer by campus feminists that don't seem to have an inkling of the history or ideological basis of her school of thought. She's just old, stupid and evil, according to them. Our ideas are unopposed among sane, decent and intelligent people.
- narrator 11y agoIn 19th century Russia, after the unsuccessful attempt at revolution by the Decemberists, the revolutionaries were purged from academia. Thus, the evolution of political though occurred outside of academia in the fiction of popular writers and elsewhere. This eventually led to the development of extreme ideologies that precipitated the development of Bolsheivism. This is probably what will happen here.
- kobayashi 11y agoHigher education is mostly an echo chamber of Leftist thought. This lack of self-awareness and self-critique actually hurts Leftist thought as a whole - rather than the best ideas being sorted to the top, more extreme and largely unscrutinized Leftist theory begets more of the same.
- chiefmongoose 11y agoIt is not surprising that a field driven by government funding lacks ideological conservatives.
- hackuser 11y ago(Essential background: The author is head of the leading ideologically conservative think tank, the American Enterprise Institute. For example, IIRC they were behind many of the neo-cons who advocated the Iraq invasion and related policies.) Most importantly, the author desires an ideological war. Like any smart advocate, he makes his case by framing the discussion: What he says assumes there is an ideological contest and, due to the way framing works, nobody questions it; they unconciously accept his framework when responding. But I don't think most people are members of one ideological movement or another. I suspect most people have a nuanced, inconsistent mix of beliefs. Personally, and I know many agree, I think ideology of any kind is the enemy, and I won't accept his presumption that I too am a dogmatic ideologue. . Also, the author seems to desire a sort of affirmative action for conservative ideological ideas: They should be given a place regardless of their merits, simply because they match his ideology. Why don't they (and he) have to pursuade their peers like the advocates of any other idea? It's a loser demanding he should get a trophy too. An aside: Academics are overwhelmingly liberal. People say it is a consequence of bias, but that is not necessarily true. If (broadly speaking) the smartest people are mostly liberal, maybe that tells us something.
- replicatorblog 11y ago"An aside: Academics are overwhelmingly liberal. People say it is a consequence of bias, but that is not necessarily true. If (broadly speaking) the smartest people are mostly liberal, maybe that tells us something." Test the logic of this aside by changing "Academics" to "software engineering" and replacing "Liberal" with "white/asian, straight, males." I don't think it holds up very well.
- hackuser 11y ago> Test the logic of this aside by changing "Academics" to "software engineering" and replacing "Liberal" with "white/asian, straight, males." I don't think it holds up very well. I don't think the analogy applies: Software engineer quality don't vary in quality by gender and race and even if they did, we want to treat people as individuals. We don't want to discrimate based on those factors. But Academia is a meritocracy of ideas; we do want to discriminate strongly against bad ideas. It's not a place where everyone gets a hearing - if it was, students and professors would spend 99% of their time on nonsense, learn little, and make little progress in their fields. For example, I think AEI (his organization) have been climate change deniers. Should their ideas on climate change get an equal hearing in university science departments? What about creationists who think the world was created in the last 10,000 years? What about those who think the world is ending next week?
- thefastlane 11y agothis article reminds me of when creationists say "teach the controversy!"
- burnte 11y agoFirst thing in my mind was "reality has a well known liberal bias."
- replicatorblog 11y agoEveryone dismissing the notion of political diversity being a problem because of the author's institutional affiliation should check out this site: http://heterodoxacademy.org/problems/ http://heterodoxacademy.org/problems/ It's a group of political scientists from a wide range of well respected schools (Harvard, Northwestern, Penn, NYU, Georgetown) making the exact same argument. It's one thing to call into the question the motives of the AEI president, another to make the same argument against Harvard's Steven Pinker.
- threatofrain 11y agoI don't think it's at all easy to recognize where people's political lines are. There are only two parties that can win, Democrat and Republican. This goes to the question of, "What is diversity in this context? More Republicans in academic positions?" I don't think so. I think the fact that people are in the Democratic vs Republican party is related to their views on power (and winnability, but only 2 parties really win) rather than their views on politics. It just so happens right now that the Republican party collects votes with denial of climate change or evolution. The Republican party has made itself hostile to science, in that to back its claims, it has had to say that academia is engaged in a conspiracy to lie, and that academia brainwashes children into being liberal. So regardless of your political beliefs, in terms of your power beliefs, voting Democrat is a good choice for those in academics. If Democrats started advocating for benefits for electricians, I'm sure we'd have more Democrats there. That does not mean that the political beliefs and attitudes of electricians are shifting. Does it surprise anyone that working in the petroleum industry strongly predicts political party? There are also other reasons why the Republican party is quite difficult to support, like their lack of positive regard for secularism. You can't argue with the Texas GOP platform when it's splattered with God and Christian issues. Take a skim through this Texas party platform document published 3 years ago. http://s3.amazonaws.com/texasgop_pre/assets/original/2012Platform_Final.pdf http://s3.amazonaws.com/texasgop_pre/assets/original/2012Pla...