4 ms·
> Frost thinks we should pay the organizations which own underground coal deposits—specifically, the U.S. government—for the right to never mine it. This is a
by adventured 11y ago
> Frost thinks we should pay the organizations which own underground coal deposits—specifically, the U.S. government—for the right to never mine it.
This is a wildly impractical idea. It's so bad, it hardly deserves any serious consideration.
There is far more coal still in the ground - to go with deposits that are either expected to be there or have not been found yet - than that which we already have operating mines for. If, for example, you remove US coal from the global supply, the only thing it'll accomplish is to lift prices for the rest of the world's miners (bringing their operations back to high levels of profitability, whereas today the global coal industry is in terrible shape), and encourage the creation of new mines all over the planet. In the process of restricting supply, it'll lift coal back to highly profitable as an industry, and it'll fund the creation of new mines.
Unless the plan is to buy all the land on earth of course, so you can guarantee all those untapped coal deposits never come on-line. I'm sure it would only cost a mere few dozen trillion dollars to make a serious dent.
Matt Frost's plan should be renamed: The Coal Industry Restoration Act
- arcseco 11y agoWhen the price of coal rises other forms of fuel become more cost competitive. The net result should be a reduction in coal production as utilities switch to other fuels.
- de_Selby 11y agoThis appears to be the point the parent comment is missing. Making coal economically uncompetitive speeds the adoption of alternative energy sources
- adventured 11y agoIt wouldn't make coal non-competitive, that's the central flaw in the argument. You have to buy the majority of all known coal deposits on earth to accomplish that, and there is far too much land / coal to be purchased to get even remotely close to that. Up to that point, more supply will perpetually come on-line to off-set the price gains, because of the substantial increase in profitability price increases enable. Not to mention that the vast global coal industry that remains - ie those mines not purchased (and there would be vast numbers of those) - will move into high gear and invest into producing more coal, faster, to capture the profits available. It's already very well understood that this is what happens in practice. See: the oil industry. Increase the price of oil from $50 to $200 and see how much supply comes on-line, and the unusual sources it starts coming from (eg tar sands, or two miles below the surface of the ocean).
- iamsohungry 11y agoYes, but there are other ways to raise the price of coal which don't involve bribing coal companies to stop destroying the world. They're destroying the world, how about they pay for it? You could put a massive property tax on coal mining rights, a massive tax on profits from coal, and/or a massive sales tax on coal. Any of those would achieve the same result, but instead of rewarding sociopathic corporations that are literally destroying the world, they'd put that money in public coffers which could be used, for example, to fund renewable energy. I really don't think we need to bribe coal companies to stop killing us. EDIT: And don't even think of playing the "but if we tax them they'll pass that cost on to consumers" card. Driving up the cost of coal by buying mines will also result in them passing that cost on to consumers. All costs are always passed on to consumers: billionaires are billionaires because they're adept at getting other people to pay for things. At least if the money is going into taxes, it can be passed back to the consumers it was taken from in the form of public programs.
- gsibble 11y agoYou really don't seem to have a good grasp on free market economics.
- iamsohungry 11y agoEither present a counterargument or GTFO. Ad-hominem attacks do not contribute to the conversation.
- adventured 11y agoSupply would come on-line to control the price increases, which would completely neutralize any large price spike. We know this is how economics works. We have hundreds of years of commodity market examples to pull from that demonstrate exactly that. The oil industry has provided numerous obvious examples of it in practice in just the last 50 years. This is the flaw at the heart of the plan, that guarantees it can never be feasible. Unless you plan to buy the majority of all coal deposits on earth.
- em3rgent0rdr 11y ago>> "This is a wildly impractical idea. It's so bad, it hardly deserves any serious consideration." But arguably it may be more effective than the political process. >> "and encourage the creation of new mines all over the planet. In the process of restricting supply, it'll lift coal back to highly profitable as an industry, and it'll fund the creation of new mines." If you read the entire article, it mentions that purchasers should consider buying the more harder to mine deposits first, to counter your concern: "Harstad thinks that his coalition should lease or purchase the hardest coal to access: In other words, the coal that’s most expensive to mine. Then, as demand for coal grows and the price rises—and mining companies start to look more more difficult reserves—they’ll find that coal is already locked up."