5 ms·
An interesting factoid: I used to be fine with stuffy environments. Then I started taking a stimulant medication for ADHD. Now I get headaches whenever I'm in a
by derefr 11y ago
An interesting factoid: I used to be fine with stuffy environments. Then I started taking a stimulant medication for ADHD. Now I get headaches whenever I'm in a room with no air circulation (cars with the windows and vents shut are especially bad.) It seems turning my brain on fully requires more oxygen!
It's surprising, though—almost nobody I've ever asked to open a window or somesuch can tell, even when it's pointed out to them, how stuffy the room they're in is. (I don't even know if I myself used to be able to tell; it's a hard thing to remember.) Air quality might be a thing like odor, where you can become inured after spending hours in a room but then it's obvious if you spend some time outdoors and then come back. And yet, bad air seems to "hit me" when I enter a room, in a way it doesn't to most.
Some people, interestingly, get very defensive about the (bad) air quality of a room—even if the weather is perfect outside, and even if they have no allergies or anything similar, they just hate the idea of having a window open. (But, even more interestingly, this seems to be a habitual tic, rather than a physiological desire. One of my friends—who previously kept a horribly stuffy room, and would always ask that I close my own windows because of how "drafty" my apartment is—now keeps his own windows permanently open, after spending just a few weeks at my place.)
- escherplex 11y agoIf by 'stimulant medication for ADHD' you mean one of the nootropics like Piracetam then you probably know these supplements crank up metabolic oxygen utilization through the roof. And, common knowledge, oxygen deficits easily trigger migraines. Plus as a byproduct of normal metabolism you pipe out a metric ton of CO2 per annum (according to James Lovelock material) so constantly replenishing the room's O2 level is probably a good idea. Wouldn't want that average 20 pt IQ boost acquired over three weeks to go to waste would we? :-)
- uhhyeahdude 11y agoI would wager a fair amount that most people diagnosed with ADHD are referring to schedule II substances when they mention stimulant medication. I didn't know that the racetams (or, per your comment, Piracetam at least) have a major effect on oxygen utilization. Thank you for reminding me to look into the world of nootropics again. Straight up stimulants are so taxing. I propose a HAB model as a next step in cubicle drone-tech. Individual airlocks, variable temp, humidity, noise, airflow... And no disco.
- copperx 11y ago> Straight up stimulants are so taxing. This is so true. You become so productive, but at the same time you feel that your body is being overdriven.
- onedev 11y agoYeah for me it was not worth it at all. I was prescribed in High School through College but I stopped taking them in College because I turned into a irritable zombie. No amount of productivity boost is worth the emotional and physical damage that stuff does to you. Also Exercise and Diet helped far more in the long run.
- escherplex 11y agoAs my brother the psychiatrist pointed out the conventional stimulants prescribed for ADHD treatment can have wicked side effects and aren't necessarily effective. In moderate cases some in the field are trying nootropics plus cognitive stimulation therapy (of course that only works if natively there is sufficient functional cognitive hardware to stimulate and the patient wants to focus). Interesting footnote: the brother pointed out that Stephen Hawking is taking some similar cognitive enhancement concoction which includes a synthetic capillary growth stimulating chemical which goes by the name of vinpocetine. If a moderate ADHD patient, the combination of a nootropic (+ choline) and vinpocetine may be something worth testing. For reference, a quick google of oxigenation and nootropics scares up: http://nootriment.com/piracetam/ http://nootriment.com/piracetam/
- derefr 11y ago> vinpocetine Hah, neat, I had just ran into that chemical a few days ago in my own research, for similar reasons. Right now I'm trying diosmin, under a parallel theory: that it protects, increases tone of, and stimulates growth of, lymphatic channels. (Amusingly enough, the main on-label use is for hemorrhoids.) I picked this avenue of research since my own body seems to have a rather sucky lymphatic system: I constantly get fungal infections (but not bacterial/viral ones); I've had middle-ear infections several times in my life, once leading to labyrinthitis; I have a family history of lymphedema and varicose veins; and no matter how well I maintain my oral hygiene and stay hydrated, I still get dental carries and periodontal abscesses. (Also, oddly enough, all my hair grows really fast; and directly atop lymph nodes, I will get ingrown "compound" hairs (pili multigemni). Both sort of suggest an eccrine system trying to expel debris that isn't getting cleared any other way.) So far I can at least say that it unplugs my sinuses (in a different way than a decongestant—gunk ends up in my throat, and my sinuses don't dry out), makes me experience heartburn for the first time since I was a child (probably a bile duct thing), and makes it actually painful to sit with my legs folded under me for more than a few minutes, whereas I used to be able to do that for hours (which was probably a bad thing with a high risk of DVT anyway.) So it's doing something. The experiment I really want to try, though, is to combine the diosmin with N-acetylcholine (or any other metabolically-active glutathione precursor.) From what I understand, glutathione is used up by lymphatic processes (at least both of liver xenometabolism and mucus creation.) I expect, without NAC supplementation, it will appear that my body eventually "habituates" to the diosmin and stops doing anything useful. Edit: one more bonus piece of anecdata—I've gone, on one week of diosmin, from a person who hates being too hot (to the point that I don't enjoy ever getting my face/chest wet in the shower; to the point that I hate drinking coffee/tea just because it's hot) but is fine in the cold (often not bothering to wear a sweater outside in Canadian winter)... to a person who can easily tolerate heat, and gets cold very easily. Very, very bizarre.
- uhhyeahdude 11y agotl;dr, because it looks like I rambled: I agree, here are some possible underlying causes, people have different perceptions of the material world, people respond poorly to certain types of criticism, and the aging population suffers from this x10000. I am a poor editor, but I mean well. I'm not sure if that is a generally interesting factoid so much as it is interesting as an anecdote; that said, I happen to have a lot of similarly anecdotal support for your observations. Let's say I take medication for "ADHD-PI". If I am being 100% honest, I might change the diagnosis to "easily bored; requires interesting work and regular novelty; try meditation prior to stimulant exposure" . In any case, the meds work, at least they keep me focused for the duration of a particularly tedious task, and allows me to function in normal society with a modicum of normalcy. However, most of the medications Rx'd for ADHD are stimulants, and they are the real deal. Dexedrine and Adderall/Vyvanse are both chemically equivalent to amphetamine sulphate that one might purchase illicitly; they just come in measured doses, from a pharmacy, are legal, and have different fillers/binders and ratio of levo vs dextro isomers contained. Technically, Vyvanse is a pro-drug of dextroamphetamine, converted in vivo at a roughly constant rate. So it's just a new way of doing an XR formulation of speed. Also a new patent to feed off of a drug that's been around forever. The other stimulants commonly prescribed are not amphetamines, but the end result (elevated dopamine and norepinephrine, primarily)- amps are potent DA/NE agonists, while the -phenidate family (Ritalin/Concerta, etc) blocks the reuptake of those catecholamines. There are other drug classes, but they are not in the same ballpark, efficacy-wise. (And this applies to just about any healthy individual fed a mild dose of a powerful stimulant, no diagnosis or disorder required). Reeling myself back in, sorry - (not on meds, tend to get parenthetical and non-linear as they wear off). So, I noticed the same thing you write about with regard to a sudden change in atmospheric sensitivity. I cannot stand to be in an overheated room, or a room without at least a hint of movement in the air. I have also noticed that other people don't seem to care quite as much, or even notice. This makes a lot of sense when you consider the effects of stimulants that flood your brain with chemicals with such intimate ties to one's alertness, attentiveness, and other such qualities of vigilance. They also tend to increase your heart rate, BP (usually minor), sweat production (sweaty skin is hyper-sensitive to air flow), and body temp. On meds, I literally (in the traditional sense) run a little hotter than unmedicated co-workers. And, yeah, people can get defensive about the air quality of their space, whether it's the house or whatever. I try to be sensitive, maybe ask if I could crack a window (hint, hint), but some individuals take these things personally; as if you were commmenting on their breath, BO, or child-rearing capability. It's just human nature, I think. I have spent extensive time working with dementia sufferers, and some of them were NOT OK with any open/unlocked doors or windows. And the houses/rooms they life in are filled with this thick, gluey, slimy "air". I would call it unlivable. They would (if still verbally and cognitively able) call it "normal" or "pleasant". I used to do food drops for meals on wheels in downtown Portland, and I saw the same scene in SRO's throughout the city center and Old Town. For some, who were still mentally intact, the closed windows were an issue of hypervigilance due to past experiences in the past, or because they can cut down on street noise by minimizing sound transmission. I hope this at least supports your assertion re: "habitual tic" vs. materialist/physiological explanations. It is usually a bit of both. For some, it's a deeply rooted habitual behavior, for others it is a manifestation of psychological/neurological/physiological changes associated with aging in general, whether or not the individual is healthy. Context for my observations include caring for dementia patients in close quarters, at length, exhaustive research, regular meetings with the Alzheimer's Association (donate! please! I guarantee someone close to you is burdened with incipient senescence, or caring for a family member who has symptoms), weekly conversations with a respected gerontologist, and, as mentioned, the ADHD experience, and the pharmacological element that can accompany it. As mentioned earlier, it might just be a human trait to take offense at lifestyle criticism, or the perception thereof. I think it is one of those things that transcends cultural, national, racial, gender, whatever differences we have from one another. I am supposed to be really sensitive to this stuff, to have an above average self-awareness when it comes to these issues... But I still get a little pissed when I feel slighted or looked down upon, like someone just farted in the general direction of my ancestors. Alas. Sorry for the rambling post, but nice to look at quirk I don't hear much about. updated because I don't post, and my formatting was way off.
- Terr_ 11y ago> An interesting factoid: A factoid is, formally speaking, not a small fact, but instead something that appears to be a fact but may be false. Similar to how an android is not really a man, and a spheroid is not really a sphere. That said, I love the self-referential truth of: "Saying 'a factoid is a small fact' is a factoid." It works whichever definition you believe in :)
- achow 11y agoFactoid is both - Truth & Not-a-truth. But in todays world it usually (actually overwhelmingly) means an interesting piece of trivia. From Wikipedia: [Factoid] The term was coined originally in 1973 to mean a "piece of information that becomes accepted as a fact even though it’s not actually true, or an invented fact believed to be true because it appears in print." Since then, the term has evolved from its original meaning, in common usage, and has assumed other meanings, particularly being used to describe a brief or trivial item of news or information.
- derefr 11y agoYup, that's actually how I was using it. A fact extrapolated from sample-of-one anecdata is a factoid more-often-than-not. ;)
- AceyMan 11y agoTFA is about buildings and working environments, but I have been suffering through these same environmental aspects on my bus commute recently. I have a short (35 min avg.) ride with no transfers from my place to the Los Angeles office. The past few months my transit operators have been really inconsistent in the use of the AC on the bus and it's killing me. When I step onto a bus and the wave of warm, moist air hits me I will nearly freak out[0]. I can't help but snap at the operator, "Will ya' turn on the dang AC, please... it's hot in here!". How can 20-40 people just sit there like that and not feel it, or say something about it? With West LA (my area) having such a temperate climate, I suspect the bus operators -- who sit by their own window, and have the boarding door open constantly, providing circulation -- don't seem to know how bad it is in the back. And while it may be 18c or so outside, as you HN folks know, the human body puts out a great deal of heat. I did a little BOTEC the other day, and 40 people on the bus puts out about the same heat as 2 1/2 conventional (open) gas fireplaces (~4kw). I don't care if the windows are open or if its 15c outside -- it's going to get warm in the bus with 4kw of heat burning inside, and that doesn't take into account CO2 levels or water vapor (humidity) increases, which I don't have good maths for. -- [0] TBH, most day's I am titrating some ADD (CII) meds, but I'm sensitive to these conditions even when I'm rolling my normal cognative/CNS self. (I'm from SEUS originally, so maybe I'm hyper tuned to muggy, stuffy air...). edited for layout
- derefr 11y agoOne hypothesis I have myself, is that it could be possible for ADHD to be developmentally "caused" by venous/lymphatic insufficiency. In est, the brain notices early on that it can't drain waste amines from the neural cleft through the glymphatic system (because it's underdeveloped), and downregulates their production to compensate. If that were to be true, then you'd expect to see a high correlation between people who have ADHD, and people who are very sensitive to heat. Blood would be pooling toward their extremeties—though not necessarily to the point of causing edema—and keeping them warm, but also making it easier for the environment to overheat/overcool their blood, somewhat similarly to people with third-degree burns. It would also suggest that people with ADHD would feel positively about any medication that causes a parasympathetic response, pushing blood toward their core—caffeine being a primary example.