5 ms·
Does anyone know of any good systematic studies of the waste / environmental costs of various activities, purchases, etc.? I suspect that e.g. living in a smal
by jacobolus 11y ago
Does anyone know of any good systematic studies of the waste / environmental costs of various activities, purchases, etc.?
I suspect that e.g. living in a smaller house or apartment, driving less and driving a smaller vehicle (more generally, living in an urban area with less pavement and other infrastructure per capita compared to suburbs), better insulating buildings (or constructing them with other passive heating/cooling) and scaling back the temperature control, using less hot water or heating it less, reducing water use on yards/landscaping, reducing use of energy-intensive gadgets (e.g. drying clothes on a line, using a smaller television), consuming less meat and dairy, buying local vegetables in season instead of shipped thousands of miles, and otherwise eating more canned food and recycling the cans, taking local vacations vs. traveling internationally, etc. might have more effect than explicitly trying to optimize only for quantity of personal trash generated.
One problem with our current economy is that our prices do a terrible job at signaling true costs, and the whole system is so complex that any individual person has almost no chance at guessing correctly, if trying to organize their life to reduce external impact. (So much of the price we pay is distorted by some clever company arbitraging international tax differences, cheating regulatory controls, defrauding poor countries and bribing their officials to cover it up, or dumping unlimited toxic shit in places without any oversight.)
It’s like trying to optimize code without a profiler.
As one small example, I’d love to see some kind of systemic analysis of the comparative environmental costs of ordering something online and having it delivered in a truck from a warehouse wrapped in cardboard and then recycling the cardboard vs. driving a single person in a large car to and from a store 10 miles away, including the land and energy costs of keeping inventory in the local stores, employing the cashiers, etc. Personally I little idea what the total impacts are of these two choices.
- Scoundreller 11y agoDirectly, or indirectly, I'd say that the price of a product does a good job of the value of resources expended in getting it to you. This includes: The cost/time of the marketers of the product, the cost/time of its production, the cost/time of whatever services are paid for through taxes on that product, etc. I just wish taxes did a better job of taxing relatively irreversible destruction (like oxidizing 100m old C-C and C-H bonds). If you spend less money, you burn up fewer things in the process, which I think your examples exhibit quite well. Though I'd suggest that flying/trucking food thousands of kilometers means expending less energy than preserving it or risking spoilage. The food may be fresher to boot too.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- keenerd 11y agoPrice is typically a very good indicator. (I use it as well.) The only weakness is that it assumes the "exchange rate" between dollars and resources are equal in all circumstances. This is likely not always the case when the cheaper option is sourced from a country with less pollution or human rights regulations.
- Retric 11y agoI don't think that's a great model as a brentling watch and a Honda civic hardly took the same resources to produce. A new 900sf condo in DC takes few resources compared to a new 20,000 sf house in West Virginia even if there both 500k.
- Scoundreller 11y agoSo what happens with the $15k that gets spent on the watch or the $X00k on the condo? The sellers aren't burying the resources in the ground, they're spending it on other stuff, like jet vacations, a low mpg vehicle, a big home in the country, etc.
- Retric 11y agoThat gets into the fixed pie fallicy, if I buy your house and you buy my house we can have an economic transaction where both sides benifit and no resources are lost. In the watch example it's possible to pay with cash and have the money distroyed after the fact etc. As such taking about potential future resources to be spent is irrelevant when taking about the resources consumed to create something.
- oberstein 11y agoI too would be interested in studies. But I do think environmental cost is factored in to the cost of most things, especially if due to environmental damage it is no longer possible to get a Thing at any price. I think the true cost of a single pencil is well reflected. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R5Gppi-O3a8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R5Gppi-O3a8 The problem with the profiler analogy is that economic costs can open up economic gains, whereas wasting billions of cycles in a dumb loop opens up nothing. If you analyzed the human activities that produce the most environmental cost, the individual contributions would be nothing. Only when you look at economies of scale driven by collections of people do you get to anything remotely resembling significant numbers. And you might think "Let's ban all cars", since that's a somewhat noticeable effect in aggregate, but by doing so you would kill off many other parts of the economy. Depending on the reaction, it could be good or bad for the environment. It could be good if humanity went extinct and the costs we directly produce went to 0 (leaving only the 'natural' costs), but that's not a world I want to live in.
- stevesearer 11y agoOne thing I read about recently is discussion regarding whether building a new "environmentally friendly" building is better for the environment than reusing an older building. "The study concludes that it can take between 10 and 80 years for a new, energy-efficient building to overcome, through more efficient operations, the negative energy and climate change impacts caused in the construction process." [1] Regarding things packaged in cardboard, some office furniture companies offer "blanket-wrapped delivery" for their furniture to help reduce waste as the blankets end up being reused from delivery to delivery. [1] http://switchboard.nrdc.org/blogs/kbenfield/the_green_dividend_from_reusin.html http://switchboard.nrdc.org/blogs/kbenfield/the_green_divide...
- mmanfrin 11y ago10 to 80 years seems pretty reasonable since most are used beyond that point -- and then come along with a bunch of extra benefits like being safer, more precise with HVAC, etc.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]