8 ms·
How was Michael Lewis clueless? He gave a step by step description of how regulation in reaction to previous crises and the money gave rise to HFT and specific
by sjg007 11y ago
How was Michael Lewis clueless? He gave a step by step description of how regulation in reaction to previous crises and the money gave rise to HFT and specifically that Banks get paid by HFTs to submit their orders to specific exchanges. HFT is a game of speed that arbitrages between dark pools and the various public exchanges that ultimately provides no value.
- patio11 11y agoAmong other things, there are times in the book where it is very unclear whether he understands execution of an order against the orderbook is atomic. For example, he posits that someone can, on a single exchange, hit a sentinel order placed by a market maker with a larger order and then have the market maker adjust the prices of orders behind the sentinel, in response to the execution of the sentinel order, prior to the original order hitting the orders behind the sentinel. That can't happen. It might sound plausible, understandably, to someone who has never done concurrent programming and who doesn't understand that e.g. locks are a thing which exists in the world. I am attempting to restrain myself from being too critical here, because that's a higher level of technical knowledge than I would generally expect from a journalist writing for a general audience, but then again this journalist wrote a book-length treatise on how distributed systems and concurrent programming are screwing the American public without successfully demonstrating that he has a handle on either of these topics. For the better-informed and book-length version of this comment, see http://www.amazon.com/Flash-Boys-Insiders-Perspective-High-Frequency-ebook/dp/B00P0QI2M2 http://www.amazon.com/Flash-Boys-Insiders-Perspective-High-F... , which is some of the most devastating technical writing I've ever read.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- bostik 11y ago> he posits that someone can, on a single exchange, hit a sentinel order placed by a market maker with a larger order and then have the market maker adjust the prices of orders behind the sentinel, in response to the execution [..] prior to the original order hitting the orders behind the sentinel. "That can't happen." True, technically. But what you described earlier is close what is called the "Last Look" ability.[0] It's highly unethical, because it provides market makers and large operators a privileged data feed and ability to effectively go back in time. Im simplified terms: if an exchange provides LL, executions against standing orders from privileged parties would be flagged as "pending" for a short window and the privileged party is sent a message of the pending execution. During the time window, they are allowed to respond with a cancel, which will be performed in front of the execution. And if a market maker knows that an execution would result in a bad trade, it will then start issuing cancels for other standing orders too. There's also a kernel of truth in the other part I quoted. I firmly believe that market makers can't adjust prices for their standing orders, but in some exchanges there are order types called "reductions", where the market maker is allowed to adjust the available quantity of a standing order. So instead of issuing a cancel + order, the market maker can simply drop the available amount in their standing order while still keeping the order itself in the book. 0: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-03-03/barclays-last-look-at-currency-trades-said-to-face-u-s-review http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-03-03/barclays-l...
- kasey_junk 11y agoLast Look is a an issue on ForEx markets, but ForEx markets are already extremely dodgy. In many cases, your counterparty in the ForEx markets owns the exchange you are trading on. I've never encountered an equities or futures exchange that allows last look. As for price reductions, some exchanges allow reductions, others model them as cancel + order but allow the new order to take up the priority of the old order (effectively a reduction) and still others model them as reductions, but you still lose priority (effectively a cancel and new order). That is largely immaterial though, because even if you allow reductions, if a large order hits a level it clears fully through that level before anyone can make any reductions. In fact, reductions aren't a problem, increases are because it would allow someone to sit in front of the priority queue until a level is fully cleared. Something that did happen on some exchanges, which is closer to what you are getting at, is that on some exchanges the fill feed is less latent than the market feed. That is you would get notified that an order executed before that order was disseminated on the order book. This would allow you faster insight into the market, so people did use sentinel orders for that, but if a single order was hitting a level enough to clear it those sentinel orders wouldn't help you get out of the way on existing orders at that level, they would get filled as well. But it could be a leading indicator of multi-level sweeps. Largely that wasn't desired functionality on the exchanges side, just a by product of their architectures, but people whose job it is to understand how the exchange behaves, clearly had advantages there over those whose job is not that.
- HiLo 11y agoCan you guys explain what you mean by a sentinel order?
- MichaelGG 11y agoIn this case, a sentinel order exploits the speed differences between different data feeds. So if an exchange sends data on executed trades out slowly, but notifies traders of their own trades in a fast way, then you place a small order so you can see market activity faster than the general activity feed.
- 11y ago
- MichaelGG 11y agoHis examples are just flat-out wonky. For instance, his key opener is a trader that is shocked to find out that when he buys tens of thousands of shares, the price, gasp, moves. Or another one, where the price moves before the guy hits enter. So either he's saying HFT's have trojan'd traders' workstations or ...? Instead of investigating this, he just writes more "ooh spooky" lines. At one point, he spins regulations requiring customer orders use the best price as a bad thing. Basically, you get the feeling from his book that he'd feel better if we went back to specialists on the floor with quotes in 1/8th, doing stuff you can understand as a human. That somehow, all this tech is bad. Hell he even makes fun of colocation - not adding multiple third-party providers of fibre to a connection to make it faster and less likely to break is obviously evil because... well he says it so ominously it must be true! He doesn't say HFT provides no value. He says everything's a huge conspiracy (involving, apparently, everyone) and HFT is stealing money. He fails to realise there's risk. Instead he makes it out like HFTs can just buy so fast that money falls out (that if they buy at one price, the only possible outcome is a sale at a higher price, that the market can never move in the other direction). He even gives them magical capabilities, implying that they can determine total order sizes from a single trade.
- harmegido 11y agoThat part about Brad Katsuyama in the beginning made me so angry. Here's a 'hero' trader making literally millions of dollars per year, and he has no idea how the stock market actually works. It would be like UPS getting pissed off at Fedex for using this crazy contraption called the airplane to get freight overseas faster.
- gammarator 11y ago> where the price moves before the guy hits enter. Can you give a page # reference for this? In the scene I recall, the price is stable on all exchanges for minutes--until they hit enter on very small order to BATS, at which point the prices increase on the exchanges further away.
- MichaelGG 11y ago“I hadn’t even hit Execute,” says the hedge fund president. “I hadn’t done anything but put in a ticker symbol and a quantity to buy. And the market popped.” From location 142/505. And this is supposed to be the guy in charge of a $9B fund. The next page continues to state that all the big players (like Vanguard) have no clue how markets work. As if these evil HFT wizards live in another dimension where you can't just, I dunno, interview them. Or hire them. Or buy their companies. The lulz never stop. Next paragraph has an amazing quote about colocation "What the fuck??!! That's got to be illegal!" I guess if you act incredulous, insulted, upset, and bewildered, any mundane thing can turn into a sinister conspiracy. The sad part is that people are taking this book seriously, and politicians even seem to be "addressing" it as a campaigning point? Sigh.
- harryh 11y agoHFT (the automation of human market makers) has provided enormous value by reducing bid/ask spreads by at least a factor of 10x.
- dantiberian 11y agoWas it HFT or the move to electronic trading that reduced the bid/ask spread by 10x?
- justinjlynn 11y agoCertainly electronic trading. I've found this to be an excellent article deflating HFT benefit myths: http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4594.html http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4594.html
- MichaelGG 11y agoThe article is a bit suspicious. It talks about Thor, which timed orders to different exchanges so they'd arrive simultaneously. This is because a market maker would notice a large order on one exchange, and raise his price. This is totally and utterly expected - why should a market maker take undue risk? Increase the latency - suppose a user submitted a large buy order to Exchange1, waited an hour, then sent it to Exchange2. Is it not reasonable that the price would go up? So why is it suddenly so controversial when it happens on shorter timeframes? Why should RBC be able to make big trades and not have to deal with price impact? Why should market makers be left holding the bag? Now whether or not HFT adds more value seems debatable. But it seems to be a fairly harmless result that naturally arises.
- mrchicity 11y agoHFT has been around for a while longer than Reg NMS: http://www.bizjournals.com/kansascity/stories/2005/01/17/smallb1.html http://www.bizjournals.com/kansascity/stories/2005/01/17/sma... describes an major player doing something that sounds similar to modern HFT in Jan 2005, presumably they'd been trading that way for a while.
- 11y ago