3 ms·
This article has all the hallmarks of poor science: 1) very small study size 2) very short study period 3) self reported consumption 4) marginal p-values 5) hig
by dekhn 11y ago
This article has all the hallmarks of poor science:
1) very small study size
2) very short study period
3) self reported consumption
4) marginal p-values
5) highly biased first author.
- thrownaway2424 11y agoAgreed on 1-4 but you lost me at #5. Explain?
- dekhn 11y agoYou should always consider the bias of the author of a paper when evaluating it. THe author has a vested interest in seeing an outcome. Many authors permit their bias to allow themselves to overanalyze a poorly designed study. Lustig has a history of doing this, for example he published papers previously where the evidence led to a different conclusion; in particular, he selectively analyzed his data to support his conclusion, but direct analysis showed the opposite.
- awolf 11y ago>for example he published papers previously where the evidence led to a different conclusion I did not know this. Could you share the papers you're talking about?
- dekhn 11y agohttp://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0057873 http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.... read the paper carefully.
- ibejoeb 11y agoI'm curious what the consensus is around Lustig and his work. He seems to have impeccable credentials in medicine and nutrition. He seems forthright with the science, but I don't have the requisite biochemistry skills to evaluate it myself. I'm don't know if he's biased or just right. I'm happy to hear a refutation of his arguments. For those unfamiliar, here's the talk the probably gave rise his noteriety: https://youtu.be/dBnniua6-oM https://youtu.be/dBnniua6-oM. It's long, but it's interesting.
- pointeroffact 11y agothe extremely poor quality of this study and the irresponsible PR campaign that has accompanied it is enough reason not to take him seriously.
- hindenburg 11y agoI completely agree. I'm surprised that the HN community, which so often points out poor science in other articles, in this case seems to include a lot of people posting personal anecdotes about their diets. For those people, I think it's very nice that you had a good experience dieting. Your story isn't science however, and the rest of us aren't going to learn anything generalizable from it. Perhaps you should be posting to a reddit support group?
- dekhn 11y agoDid you mean to reply to another comment? I didn't say anything about dieting.