8 ms·
I strongly feel that my personal computing devices are extensions of my brain. They help me think, contain personal thoughts, notes and pictures, allow me to co
by teekert 11y ago
I strongly feel that my personal computing devices are extensions of my brain. They help me think, contain personal thoughts, notes and pictures, allow me to communicate with people I love and determine who I am even to some degree (i.e. without them I would not be punctual).
I deeply hate the fact that anybody thinks anything on my personal devices belongs to them. I think my devices should fall under the inviolability of the physical body and that decrypting them is akin to forcing me to testify against myself.
I do realize how hypocritical I sound carrying an Android device (Googles customers are the advertisers) but I can be a bit idealistic and pragmatic at the same time, can't I?
- brianwawok 11y agoI can dream of a world both that can deliver targeted advertising where required, but also avoid leaking my personal data... More like facebook style "Male - 40 - Lives in Flordia" would be all that got leaked..
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- laotzu 11y agoThe electric medium of the internet as an extension of the brain is a concept which Marshall McLuhan analyzed back in the 1960s. You might be interested in some of the things he wrote: >My main theme is the extension of the nervous system in the electric age, and thus, the complete break with five thousand years of mechanical technology. This I state over and over again. I do not say whether it is a good or bad thing. To do so would be meaningless and arrogant. >In the electric age, when our central nervous system is technologically extended to involve us in the whole of mankind and to incorporate the whole of mankind in us, we necessarily participate, in depth, in the consequences of our every action. It is no longer possible to adopt the aloof and dissociated role of the literate Westerner. >Instead of tending towards a vast Alexandrian library the world has become a computer, an electronic brain, exactly as an infantile piece of science fiction. And as our senses have gone outside us, Big Brother goes inside. So, unless aware of this dynamic, we shall at once move into a phase of panic terrors, exactly befitting a small world of tribal drums, total interdependence, and superimposed co-existence.
- pdkl95 11y agoBrian O'Blivion: The battle for the mind of North America will be fought in the video arena: the Videodrome. The television screen is the retina of the mind's eye. Therefore, the television screen is part of the physical structure of the brain. Therefore, whatever appears on the television screen emerges as raw experience for those who watch it. Therefore, television is reality, and reality is less than television.
- laotzu 11y ago>The discarnate TV user lives in a world between fantasy and dream, and is in a typically hypnotic state, which is the ultimate form and level of participation. >The inner trip is not the sole prerogative of the LSD traveler; it’s the universal experience of TV watchers. -McLuhan
- pdkl95 11y ago> Television will achieve its apotheosis when it is interactive. > Does TV encourage, or even induce, schizophrenia? Or does it create a separate reality in conjunction with our minds, something that is neither totally our inner life nor totally TV. The networks might call that programming. - Pat Cadigan, from her forward to her short story "Patterns" > Modern cell phones are not just another technological convenience. With all they contain and all they may reveal, they hold for many Americans "the privacies of life." The fact that technologies now allow an individual to carry such information in his hand does not make the information any less worth of the protection for which the Founders fought. - Chief Justice Robers, in the majority opinion of Riley v California
- laotzu 11y agoFor an interesting historical analysis on the subconscious effects of evolving media check out the Gutenberg Galaxy by McLuhan. While your Cadigan quote suggests TV induces schizophrenia, McLuhan asks the same question in regards to literacy and the phonetic alphabet: https://books.google.com/books?id=7K7rKIWaXXIC&pg=PR59&lpg=PR59&dq=marshall+mcluhan+gutenberg+galaxy+schizophrenia&source=bl&ots=-eVrfAUG0Q&sig=LVMj3_SKJtiyoEa3k7vKZFj_oqE&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CCQQ6AEwAWoVChMI0pyanYnjyAIVSKQeCh3ISwwp#v=onepage&q=marshall%20mcluhan%20gutenberg%20galaxy%20schizophrenia&f=false https://books.google.com/books?id=7K7rKIWaXXIC&pg=PR59&lpg=P...
- rayiner 11y agoI disagree. All of the things you say (helping you think, containing personal thoughts, communicating with people) are true of writings on paper. I don't think in 1776 someone would have viewed their personal notebook any differently than you view your Android device. Yet, "papers" have always been considered non-testimonial and subject to search under a warrant. Now maybe that is wrong, and personal papers should always have been protected from search. But that's a different argument.
- otterley 11y agoThe Fourth Amendment requires a warrant, which in this case the Government has. The Amendment protects citizens against warrantless searches or open-ended warrants (i.e. fishing expeditions).
- stevesearer 11y agoSo would this be similar to if some bit of evidence was in an obscure language only one person knew and spoke, and the government is trying to compel that person to do the translation?
- AngrySkillzz 11y agoWhich is definitely applicable in this case. There is more data to be obtained from a person's smartphone than could ever have been obtained from their papers or personal effects; no one in the past could have anticipated recording data on that scale themselves. I would argue that it's a difference in quantity which produces a difference in kind. When the "papers" in question contain e.g. a complete history of your location for the last four years, along with all of your communications to everyone you know, any search of those papers is by definition open-ended.
- wtbob 11y ago> I strongly feel that my personal computing devices are extensions of my brain. You're quite right, but so too are one's personal papers (or they were, anyway, back when people only had paper), and there is a process — the warrant process — for legally obtaining access to those papers. More important, though, it should not be possible for a third party to grant a second party access to your personal devices. If Apple have no way to break into your device without your permission, then you are secure. > I think my devices should fall under the inviolability of the physical body and that decrypting them is akin to forcing me to testify against myself. Agreed — but do note that that right is somewhat more circumscribed than your or I like to imagine. And in this case, they are requiring a third party to decrypt the device, not you.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mtgx 11y agoThat's also why I think the government shouldn't be bypassing the 4th and 5th amendments by going to third-party companies to get your data. I think civil liberties groups should aggressively push for this to be in the new ECPA reform bill. They should make it clear from day one that if this doesn't pass, they will oppose the bill - unlike what they did with the USA Freedom Act, where they compromised, and compromised, and compromised to pass..."something". I should note that Microsoft already supports something like that (warrant directly to the customer), but only for their corporate customers, not for their individual customers (last paragraph before "A new path forward"): http://blogs.microsoft.com/on-the-issues/2015/10/20/the-collapse-of-the-us-eu-safe-harbor-solving-the-new-privacy-rubiks-cube/ http://blogs.microsoft.com/on-the-issues/2015/10/20/the-coll...
- wernerb 11y ago'Nothing was your own except the few cubic centimetres inside your skull. ' (1984 George Orwell)
- patrickmay 11y ago> I deeply hate the fact that anybody thinks anything on my personal devices belongs to them. I think my devices should fall under the inviolability of the physical body and that decrypting them is akin to forcing me to testify against myself. If only that attitude were documented in the most basic law of the U.S., clearly defining the strictly delimited powers of the government. Maybe something like this: "The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." ETA: Yes, I know the government has a warrant in this case. The judge is considering the question of whether that warrant is reasonable.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- a3voices 11y agoI think what he's saying is even warrants shouldn't be allowed to search the contents of your personal devices.
- patrickmay 11y ago> I think what he's saying is even warrants shouldn't be allowed to search the contents of your personal devices. Indeed. I agree that such warrants should be deemed unreasonable. Unless the government can meet the criteria of "describing the place to be searched", going through a phone is more akin to a fishing expedition.
- ams6110 11y agoI think the content of messages, images, etc. on a phone are pretty close to the meaning of "papers" in the quote from the constitution. Not unreasonable to demand in a warrant.
- Natanael_L 11y ago
- kitbrennan 11y agoSomething we forget on Hacker News is that the vast majority of data and information requests are not made to spy on citizens without due cause. The majority of requests are made because someone suspected of a crime (pick any crime: fraud, possession of child pornography, drug dealing) - and they believe there to be evidence on the device. If we prevented legal authorities from accessing data on your phone, then in theory a peadophile would only have to ensure he/she downloads illegal images to their phone to ensure they cannot be caught. --- The reason we have warrants is to ensure there is a second layer to verify that a search is proportionate. Obtaining information from a phone should certainly require a warrant issued by a judge; but it certainly should not be completely unobtainable.
- grotsnot 11y agoIt might help your case to pick an example other than trotting out the old paedo boogeyman. I can see the point you're making, but there's a red flag for "THINK OF THE CHILDREN!" fear-mongering.
- kitbrennan 11y agoIt's a pertinent example because we think of peodophiles making photos - which is something phones are very good at. However, it doesn't require much of an imagination to think of other scenarios: * Keeping records of drug sales on a phone. * Messaging a hitman to carry out a murder. * Recording days and times of homes being empty in preparation for a break in.
- beambot 11y agoDon't particularly care for the example.... but going with your example: Assume the peadophile has photographic memory (or even just an active imagination). If we had the capability of reading out wetware memories from their biological brain (eg. via neural stimulation & recording), would those be searchable with warrants too?
- kitbrennan 11y agoI'm not saying there isn't a line to be drawn - obviously given your example most people would shrink away from the idea of using someones thoughts to convict (literal thought-crime). It's a question of where we draw the line. If we don't allow a judge to issue a search warrant for a phone where there is reasonable suspicion of illegal activity - why should we allow a judge to issue a warrant to search a car/property/paper-work? Of course that completely oversteps the line in the other direction though. Conviction rates for many crimes would drop through the floor if the legal authorities have no way of obtaining evidence. Given how powerful smart phones have become and you come run a criminal enterprise solely through your phone, it is reasonable to expect that the police with a proper warrant would be able to inspect your phone.
- bad_user 11y ago> Googles customers are the advertisers I see this repeated over and over again, but that's simply not true. The problem is that people treat such relationships as if it's a zero sum game. But to make an analogy and please bear with me, if you look in nature at a natural food-chain, the relationship between the carnivore and the herbivore and then between the herbivore and the grass that it eats is not zero-sum at all, being actually a synergetic relationship, continuously creating value (in nature this means life). It's a wonderful relationship, with the grass storing sun energy into calories that can be consumed. And the carnivore wouldn't survive without that grass, as no grass means no herbivores left to be eaten. And the herbivores themselves depend on the existence of a natural enemy, otherwise they'd breed too much and quickly deplete their food source. Now skipping over the cultural taboos we have over the relationship between hunter and pray, there's something to be said about the synergies in a food-chain that apply to economic systems just as well. You can say that Google's customers are the advertisers and by that implying that its users are actually the product that they are selling. But the truth is more complex than that. Because users are not produced on an assembly line, like Apple is producing its hardware. Users have a mind of their own and can install ad-blockers or can switch to other products and services if you piss them off. For these reasons users are not a commodity. And so the fact is that users along with advertisers are Google's customers, being in a synergetic relationship. Of course, if money change hands that's even better and note Google's forays into the subscription based model, along with Google Apps or YouTube Red. And by your logic, Apple's customers are the carriers and the app developers, which is actually true but note that the interests of the carriers and of app developers can also be in conflict with the interests of Apple's users. Have you noticed that your carrier can disable your right to create a Wifi hotspot with your iPhone? Because I did. Back to Google, their genius is that they recognized this synergy and played in the interests of everybody. Well, at least in the times of Eric Schmidt. It all went downhill when Vic Gundotra led the Google+ effort. I don't know what's this tendency to hire management from Microsoft, but along with the likes of Stephen Elop I'm seeing a pattern. Anyway, lately I've been dissatisfied with Gmail's support for standards, so I decided that I don't want to encourage a monoculture and switched to FastMail. I hope they'll return to their strategy from the days of Eric Schmidt, because if trust is lost amongst us techies, then it's really hard to regain it - see Microsoft - and us techies are quite an influential bunch.
- n0us 11y agoDavid Chalmers, a famous philosopher of mind among other things, shares your idea in a fairly influential paper. http://consc.net/papers/extended.html http://consc.net/papers/extended.html