7 ms·
A bit of an off-topic rant, but: I think the author is wrong to dismiss Ian Bogost's article as "as an opportunity to ignore gameplay in order to pontificate o
by the_af 11y ago
A bit of an off-topic rant, but:
I think the author is wrong to dismiss Ian Bogost's article as "as an opportunity to ignore gameplay in order to pontificate on race and show off the Foucault they read in college". The author is probably unfamiliar with Bogost, and also misunderstands that Bogost's article in The Atlantic about Prison Architect isn't a game review. I found the analysis of the game and how it relates to cultural perceptions of imprisonment in America (and the world, really) very interesting.
It's political and it's about games-as-culture. It's not a shopping recommendation, and I think this is what the author of TFA misunderstood.
- tailgate 11y agoGames are sadly just on the cusp of developing a true arts culture - but we have yet to move out of the consumer mentality, where the only value of a game is if you were entertained by it at your most base level. It also doesn't help that a lot of internet commentators can't distinguish between someone criticizing something they like and personal attacks.
- librvf 11y ago> but we have yet to move out of the consumer mentality, where the only value of a game is if you were entertained by it at your most base level. Neither did Mozart.
- Karunamon 11y agoIt also doesn't help that a lot of internet commentators can't distinguish between someone criticizing something they like and personal attacks. It also doesn't help that a lot of critics can't make a criticism along the lines of "I don't like this because X" without injecting an overt or covert "People who like this are X". The former is criticism, the latter is always a personal attack.
- Kalium 11y agoGames are frequently something that most instances of arts culture struggle with - commercial. This means that trying to treat games as artistic artifacts, made of beauty and aesthetics, free of the drudgery of economics, is a misguided thing at best. Games are not generally produced as solely artistic works. The economic aspect is significant. Attempting to discuss and critique games as solely artistic artifacts means missing one of largest influences on any such artifact. It's like discussing architecture without admitting that materials and physics and humans impose limits.
- comrh 11y agoI think there is a massive shift in this though. The rise of indie games, niche crowdfunded games, easier tools to create means people are making games for art and not the AAA paycheck.
- Kalium 11y agoIndie games and crowdfunded games are still generally done with an eye towards the economics. Even today, with all the tools available, you still don't generally get a team of a dozen people working full-time on a game for three years solely as an art piece.
- the_af 11y agoThis isn't it. Mainstream movies are often analyzed and reviewed as art -- whole books written about them! -- even though they are primarily done "with an eye towards the economics". Modern tools can help make (admittedly small) games even by people who aren't programmers and who don't necessarily want to make money. It's been a while, but I remember the early days of the Adventure Game Studio; there were people trying to make something to sell, but also plenty of people writing pretty decent games solely because they wanted to. Also see the awesome Interactive Fiction community.
- Kalium 11y agoAnd I think that such analysis has similar flaws for similar reasons. You cannot hope to understand a thing meaningfully if you choose to ignore huge influences on its creation and creative choices.
- the_af 11y agoThat's a non-standard view of art. I don't know of anyone who uses the term like that; of course an analysis of art must take into consideration its "huge influences". For example, when people review classic movies, they take into consideration what studios were willing to fund; executive meddling; whether the movie bombed at the box office; the political situation at the time; the moral codes of the time; budget limitations that forced directors to be extremely creative; problems between the lead actors; etc.
- wdmeldon 11y agoMy issue with Bogost's article was that he missed one of the core mentalities that went into designing the game: that you are only the architect. The prison industrial complex's main causes aren't rooted in the way prisons are designed and built. > ...but it’s ludicrous to pretend that it makes for a worthwhile study of the 21st-century American prison... But not quite as ludicrous as writing up a profile based on the assumption that it was supposed to be. It's pretentious post modern critique at its worst. Political and cultural criticism is fine, but demanding that things tangentially related to the game's focus be shoehorned in is absolutely ridiculous. I don't see how this is different than criticizing Super Mario Bros. for failing to properly address the realities of life as an working class Italian American.
- the_af 11y agoOh, I'm not arguing that Bogost's article is flawless. I'm just saying that it's wrong to dismiss it simply because he is not interested in reviewing Prison Architect's gameplay. He has something interesting and valuable to say about prisons and how they are depicted in fiction, though in some aspects I agree his article goes too far. Yes, I don't think anyone else (but Bogost) pretends this game is a "worthwhile study" of American prisons; on the other hand, I think he has a point about the absence of race and racism as gameplay elements being very conspicuous in a game about prison. I don't think Super Mario Bros' subject matter is comparable to Prison Architect's, and so I wouldn't expect the same kind of articles written about it.
- searine 11y ago>I'm just saying that it's wrong to dismiss it simply because he is not interested in reviewing Prison Architect's gameplay. No I dismiss it because it is a pretentious circlejerk of an article. Someone needs to confiscate his thesaurus. >I don't think Super Mario Bros' subject matter is comparable to Prison Architect's There are plenty of tropes and power dynamics to analyze in Super Mario Brothers, but that doesn't mean we will derive any value from such analysis. To make something meaningful out of this kind of literary critique you need to consider more than just a single game.
- 11y ago
- zerocrates 11y agoAm I missing something, because if this [1] is the Atlantic article being discussed, it looks like the author is Will Partin, not Ian Bogost. [1] http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2015/10/design-and-punish/409573/ http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2015/10/des...
- the_af 11y agoYes! Thanks for the correction! I'm an idiot. I got confused because this is exactly the kind of article Bogost (who is a game designer/researcher and also writes for The Atlantic) would write. Not that this is a valid excuse, but I read this article some time ago, when it was mentioned in Twitter by Bogost, and somehow got confused and didn't read the byline this time :(