4 ms·
> They reportedly received threats and piles of attention over both panels, and they didn't want to deal with that. What, exactly, did they think would happen
by MBCook 11y ago
> They reportedly received threats and piles of attention over both panels, and they didn't want to deal with that.
What, exactly, did they think would happen when they stepped into GG?
> They allowed both panels to sign up in the name of neutrality and diversity of ideas.
That's bullshit. When one group is infamous for dragging the other through the trash, issuing death threats, bomb threats, etc. there is no 'neutrality' to be found.
> And I guess people from both sides made sure neither could have nice things.
Again, bullshit. One side is know for getting death threats for existing, the other for sending death threats. One side is clearly to blame.
> (SXSW didn't blame anyone, but that's my guess.)
Clearly.
Now I know that the anti-GG people I know of have been VERY critical of SXSW for giving GG a panel in the first place. I know they've been campaigning and complaining. I'm sure they've expressed disappointment and probably personally boycotted the events.
But I seriously doubt the anti-GG people sent death threats.
On the other hand I can easily see the pro-GGers waning they would send them if their panel was cancelled, or the anti-GG panel wasn't cancelled, or because of some other perceived issue (such as one getting a better time slot or bigger room).
And now that SXSW was cowered to the hate mob, I imagine they'll get threats for for cancelling the pro-GG panel and letting the anti-GG people 'win' (despite losing their own panel too).
It's clear which side I'm on. I'm not trying to hide that I think GG is ruining my hobby. I'd say they're setting our image back 20-30 years but I don't remember death threats over NES games.
If SXSW wanted to be 'neutral' and stay out of it they could have. I don't understand how they went forward with scheduling the panels and didn't see all this coming. It's so predictable and sadly status-quo.
- striking 11y ago> I seriously doubt > the hate mob I've looked for evidence for which "side" did the harassment. SXSW didn't make specific who was part of the "hate mob". That's why I guessed it was both sides. > On the other hand I can easily see the pro-GGers On the other hand, you sound biased (as far as text can provide "sound"), without any specific data to back it up. If you know something I don't, I'd be glad to hear it. EDIT: I'm not picking a side here, and I'd be willing to defend either in a debate. I really hope I don't sound condescending, and apologize if I do.
- MBCook 11y agoAs I said, it's clear I'm anti-GG. Biased is defined as 'unfairly prejudiced' against someone. After watching people driven out of their homes and numerous death threats and doxxings I don't think my view of GG is 'unfairly prejudiced'. SXSW hasn't said who is at fault and I imagine plenty of anti-GG people were... 'less than cordial'... about their thoughts. But since one side of this 'debate' is know for issuing death threats I'm willing to make a firm guess on who is at fault. > I'm not picking a side here, and I'd be willing to defend either in a debate. At a certain point, when there is enough evidence, 'neutrality' in the face of a hate group isn't neutral. Perhaps you don't know anything about GG and this is (more or less) the first you've heard of it. Because I know of it I tend to assume others in tech know of it (it's made the national news after all, multiple times). So when I continue to see people couching things as a 'debate' and 'being neutral' to me it looks a lot like the people still 'asking' for 'debate' on the 'possibility' of climate change (or the dangers of vaccination, or the possibility of fake moon landings). They say that but clearly they've picked a side.
- eertami 11y ago>But I seriously doubt the anti-GG people sent death threats. No true scotsman
- MBCook 11y agoI said I seriously doubt. No true Scotsman would be if someone clearly anti-GG was proven to send a death threat and I redefined them to not be anti-GG for some reason. We haven't reached that point yet in my argument. I'd have to be proven wrong first. Since the reason I'm anti-GG is the harassment and threats (don't agree with their ideas but I think they'd be ignorable without the problematic behavior), I wouldn't want to see someone on my side do the same. But they could.
- thoughtmonkey 11y agoThe unfortunate truth is that Gamergate has been harassed, you just likely haven't heard it. For example, there were bomb threats at several of their meetups, and a panel they had at a Society of Professional Journalism conference had to be evacuated because of several bomb threats.
- MBCook 11y agoHmm. Now that you mention I may have heard about the SPJ one. I won't make any further comment about those threats. I have no info about them, all my thoughts on the possibility are heavy on bias (could be right, but clearly bias).
- 13thLetter 11y ago> But I seriously doubt the anti-GG people sent death threats. Anti-GG have in fact called in bomb threats against pro-GG meetings multiple times, so that doesn't follow. Look, it's clear you feel strongly about this, but when you dismiss the misdeeds of people on your "side" you are doing exactly the same thing you're condemning on the other "side." It's better to take a civil attitude towards everyone. Discussion is good, threats and hyperbole are not. Gaming would be better off without the trolls and frothers on both sides of this mess.